Topic 1: Philosophical Issues and Questions

studied byStudied by 3 people
0.0(0)
Get a hint
Hint

what are the strengths of the cosmological argument (experience)

1 / 82

83 Terms

1

what are the strengths of the cosmological argument (experience)

It is based on our experiences (a posteriori) and it is logical to believe that the universe had a first cause because everything else in the universe does (cause and effect).

New cards
2

what are the strengths of the cosmological argument (composition)

Dismissing infinite regress prevents fallacy of composition

New cards
3

what are the strengths of the cosmological argument (argument)

Universal argument as it is not focused on one faith’s god

New cards
4

what are the weaknesses of the cosmological argument (Inductive arguments)

are only probable not exactly certain

New cards
5

what are the weaknesses of the cosmological argument (evidence)

Some philosophers (eg. Hume) don’t believe that there is enough empirical evidence to suggest that the universe had a starting point

New cards
6

what are the weaknesses of the cosmological argument (questions)

Raises the question of what God was doing before creating the universe (infinite regress) and who created God

New cards
7

what does Leibniz's sufficient reason

Argument states that nothing can take place without there being sufficient reason for it to take place. Ie. everything must have a total explanation

New cards
8

what is the impact of sufficient reason on the universe

For the universe (which is contingent) to have sufficient reason it must be dependent on something which is necessary (self-explanatory)

New cards
9

what does God as sufficient reason suggest about God/ the necessary cause

Everything in the universe is contingent so this necessary cause must be external, which is possible to be God

New cards
10

what does the Kalam argument argue

Argues that whatever begins to exist has a cause. The universe began to exist which means it had a cause and that cause was likely God.

New cards
11

what type of argument is the kalam argument

Deductive argument (argues from the general, aka whatever begins to exist, to the particular, aka the universe).

New cards
12

how does the kalam argument link to other forms of the cosmological argument

Gives sufficient reason to the universe and links to a first cause like Aquinas says in his 2nd way

New cards
13

what is Aquinas' 1st way

states that there is an unmoved prime mover as infinite regress isn’t possible. We understand this to be God

New cards
14

what is Aquinas' 2nd way

states that there is an uncaused first cause that started the chain of cause and effect to prevent infinite regress. We understand this first cause to be God

New cards
15

what is Aquinas' 3rd way

The universe is contingent (dependent) and once there was nothing, which nothing can come from. Therefore there must have been a necessary being that began the universe. We understand this to be God

New cards
16

What does Hume argue against the cosmological argument (experience)

Hume argues that we have no direct experience to the creation of the universe so we cannot speak meaningfully about it

New cards
17

What does Hume argue against the cosmological argument (sufficient reason)

Hume thought that sufficient reason was pointless as it is like looking for something that cannot be found

New cards
18

What does Hume argue against the cosmological argument (cause)

Even if the universe did begin it doesn’t mean that something caused it to do so

New cards
19

What are the strengths of Hume's argument about the cosmological argument(Aquinas)

Aquinas’ arguments may fall into fallacy of composition (if this is true then…)

New cards
20

What are the strengths of Hume's argument about the cosmological argument (experience)

We didn’t experience the beginning of the universe and therefore don’t have very much empirical evidence for it

New cards
21

What are the strengths of Hume's argument about the cosmological argument (external)

We can’t experience an external necessary being as there are no necessary beings within our contingent universe.

New cards
22

What are the weaknesses of Hume's argument about the cosmological argument (science)

Clashes with the Big Bang theory, a scientific theory stating that there was a first cause to the universe

New cards
23

What are the weaknesses of Hume's argument about the cosmological argument (evidence)

There are things we experience within the universe (such as red shift) that can act as empirical evidence for the universe having a beginning

New cards
24

What are the weaknesses of Hume's argument about the cosmological argument (Kalam)

Clashes with the Kalam argument which states that everything that begins to exist has a cause as nothing can come from nothing

New cards
25

What did Kant argue about the cosmological argument (knowledge)

Argues that our knowledge of the world is limited to what we experience as space and time and it is not possible to speculate on what may exist independently outside space and time as we know it

New cards
26

What did Kant argue about the cosmological argument (language)

Denying that the necessary being God exists doesn’t create a contradiction so this cannot be a necessary proposition so the concept of necessity cannot be applied to God.

New cards
27

what are some strengths of Kant's arguments about the cosmological argument (Hume)

Hume makes very similar points (especially on necessity)

New cards
28

what are some strengths of Kant's arguments about the cosmological argument (evidence)

Depends on empirical evidence being used, trying to make the cosmological arguments more a posteriori

New cards
29

What is Paley's use of analogy in the design argument

watchmaker analogy to compare it to God as the universe is intricate like a watch and therefore it should be assumed that there is a designer

New cards
30

What is Paley's Argument from purpose

watch has been put together to fulfill a purpose and therefore contains evidence of a designer- everything in nature seems to have been designed to fulfill a purpose therefore there is evidence of a creator

New cards
31

What is Paley's Argument from regularity

regularity of watch (regular mechanical movements) can be compared to regularity of the universe which leads us to infer an designer

New cards
32

What are the strengths of the design argument (observation)

We can observe the complexity of the universe- empirical evidence- relates well to our own experiences of the universe

New cards
33

What are the strengths of the design argument (God)

Reinforces the idea that God is involved in the history of the universe and is omniscient, omnipotent and omnibenevolent

New cards
34

What are the strengths of the design argument (purpose)

Gives the universe a purpose- as opposed to it just having a blind nature moving in a random direction

New cards
35

What are the weaknesses of the design argument (conclusion)

Only leads to a probable conclusion

New cards
36

What are the weaknesses of the design argument (Robert Hambourger)

Analogous design arguments constrain and reduce nature as they suggests that nature is like man made objects

New cards
37

What does Hume state about the design argument (houses)

that we have experienced houses being built but not the universe so we cannot speculate

New cards
38

What does Hume state about the design argument (universe)

The universe is unique and we cannot make assumptions on it- the universe is an organic entity meanwhile a watch is a machine- the analogy doesn’t quite work when the things are so different.

New cards
39

What does Hume state about the design argument (designer)

Suggests that there may have been more than one designer- leading into polytheism. Also the designer isn’t specifically omnipotent/ omnibenevolent

New cards
40

What are the strengths of Hume's arguments on the design argument (knowledge)

Prevents us from going too far outside of the scope of our knowledge

New cards
41

What are the strengths of Hume's arguments on the design argument (status)

The universe is given a higher status than it is in the design argument- moving away from analogy allows the universe to be understood and appreciated as a separate organic entity

New cards
42

What are the strengths of Hume's arguments on the design argument (polytheism)

Allows for more faiths, makes the design argument more universal, can be applied to polytheism

New cards
43

What does Swinburne highlight surrounding the design argument

Sheer size of the universe and its complexity are so evident that there must have been a designer

New cards
44

What does Swinburne say about human intelligence in reference to the design argument

Human intelligence, consciousness and questioning is all due to God’s decision to create us with free will

New cards
45

what are the Regularities of co-presence

things tend to turn up in orderly patterns. Nature is the one which creates this, acting as a human-making machine, which is where we learn to make machines- evolution requires particular natural laws to take place to have created this complex world

New cards
46

what are the Regularities of succession

basis of temporal order- - laws of nature are so absolute that one thing always follows another in a predictable order

New cards
47

How does the anthropic principle link to the big bang

Human life as we know it began with the big bang- physical, astronomical and thermal features of change. The best explanation for how well everything is stable to sustain life is that the universe was fine-tuned for human life

New cards
48

what does F.R. Tennant say

the possibility of these events happening by pure chance is so low that there must have been a guiding hand

New cards
49

what is the goldilocks principle

The conditions for the creation had to be just right

New cards
50

What is the Weak form of the anthropic principle

because we are here, the universe must have the properties necessary to sustain life as if it didn’t we wouldn’t be here

New cards
51

What is the Strong form of the anthropic principle

necessary for universe to have the properties it does- it was intelligently constructed and could not have been any other way

New cards
52

What is the issue with the weak form of the anthropic principle

doesn’t explain why the universe is as it is, just states that it has to be that way- unsatisfying

New cards
53

What does Dawkins suggest

Organisms are always evolving to changing environments

New cards
54

How does evolution differ from the design argument

Paley said organisms would suit their environment and were designed that way, but Darwin pointed out that they were evolving to fit the environment they were in

New cards
55

How does evolution go against anthropomorphism

humans became the dominant specifies by developing a larger forebrain, not through any special acts of God’s design

New cards
56

What type of argument is the ontological argument

A priori argument- based on an idea of God, not on empirical evidence. Defining God means that he exists

New cards
57

What is aseity

God contains within himself the means of his existence and so his existence is necessary

New cards
58

What is Anselm's 1st proof

God can be defined as a being than which nothing greater can be conceived- even if non- believers have a definition of God, it suggests that God at least exists in the mind. But this wouldn’t make God nothing which greater can be conceived therefore he must exist in reality too

New cards
59

What is Anselm's 2nd proof

it is greater to be necessary than contingent, therefore God is necessary

New cards
60

What are the strengths of the ontological argument (a priori)

A priori arguments means there is no need for empirical evidence (we don’t have proper empirical evidence for God)

New cards
61

What are the strengths of the ontological argument (reason)

Logical chain of reasoning

New cards
62

What are the strengths of the ontological argument (instinct)

Fits with universal religious instinct and begins discussions on religious language (God as an analytic term)

New cards
63

What are the weaknesses of the ontological argument (a priori)

a priori arguments are difficult forms of logic to comprehend

New cards
64

What are the weaknesses of the ontological argument (Kant)

Kant said that existence isn’t a quality that can define God into existence

New cards
65

What are the weaknesses of the ontological argument (Aquinas)

we don’t know God’s essence therefore we cannot say he exists. We also don’t know what the correct definition of God is (and one hasn’t been agreed upon)

New cards
66

What are the weaknesses of the ontological argument (Hume)

it is not possible to apply an a priori argument to an a posteriori universe

New cards
67

What is Descartes' ontological argument

God is the supremely perfect being, who contains all perfections, existence is a supreme perfection therefore God must exist

New cards
68

What does Descartes suggest about the idea of God

clear and distinct (cannot be doubted) and this idea includes existence therefore he must exist

New cards
69

What does Descartes say about God's existence

A triangle will always have three angles and a mountain will always come with the idea of a valley, to say that God doesn’t exists is a contradiction- God’s existence is a necessary predicate

New cards
70

What are the strengths of Descartes' ontological argument (Anselm)

Simpler than Anselm’s argument as he does not attempt to claim that God exists in the understanding so it is not vulnerable to the accusation of confusing the concept of God with God himself

New cards
71

What are the strengths of Descartes' ontological argument (many religions)

God is characterised as a supremely perfect being- which is a statement that is agreed upon in many religions

New cards
72

What does Aquinas say about God's essence

If we knew God’s essence we would know he existed- but we do not know God’s essence

New cards
73

What does Aquinas say about the definition of God

No agreed definition of God and if there was one we wouldn’t know if it was correct or not

New cards
74

How does Aquinas disagree with Descartes' definition of God

God is not innate or natural (disagreement with Descartes) God is more of an external, timeless being therefore not of our nature

New cards
75

What does Hume say about the type of argument that the ontological argument is

it is not possible to apply an a priori argument to an a posteriori universe

New cards
76

What does Hume say about existence

We cannot treat existence as a predicate as it doesn’t change the definition of the subject

New cards
77

What does Hume say about the statement 'God exists'

not an analytic term as God doesn’t contain the idea of existence like the statement a bachelor is an unmarried man does. The statement is synthetic

New cards
78

What does Kant say about existence as a necessary property

Even if existence is a necessary property of God, that doesn’t mean he exists

New cards
79

What does Kant say about the existence of God

God necessarily exists may be true by definition (subject and predicate are inseparable) but it may not exists in reality like how unicorns are horned horses but that doesn't mean that they exist

New cards
80

What does Kant say about existence as a predicate

Saying something exists doesn’t tell us about the object- predicates describe the subject which existence doesn’t do

New cards
81

What does Russell say about existence as a predicate

Existence cannot be a predicate as it would create a syllogism- like saying that Eeyore exists since dokeys exist and eeyore is a donkey

New cards
82

What does Russell say about intension (I don't understand this xx)

Defining something is to define an intension (internal concept) so properties must be attributed to the subject by it. However existence only acts as an extension to the intension

New cards
83

What does Russell classify 'existence' as

Existence acts more as a existential quantifier than a predicate (corresponds to the subject)

New cards

Explore top notes

note Note
studied byStudied by 5 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 637 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 9 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 4637 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 82 people
... ago
5.0(2)
note Note
studied byStudied by 92 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 109 people
... ago
5.0(3)
note Note
studied byStudied by 635 people
... ago
5.0(3)

Explore top flashcards

flashcards Flashcard (65)
studied byStudied by 59 people
... ago
5.0(2)
flashcards Flashcard (206)
studied byStudied by 11 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (120)
studied byStudied by 16 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (87)
studied byStudied by 74 people
... ago
4.5(2)
flashcards Flashcard (57)
studied byStudied by 70 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (102)
studied byStudied by 7 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (24)
studied byStudied by 23 people
... ago
4.9(8)
flashcards Flashcard (51)
studied byStudied by 2 people
... ago
5.0(1)
robot