1/34
Thinking
Thinking is the active mental process of manipulating internal ideas, images, and concepts to understand, reason, solve problems, and create knowledge. It encompasses a wide range of cognitive activities such as paying attention, learning, remembering, forming concepts, making judgments, and forming plans to achieve goals.
“Going beyond the information given” (Bruner, 1957)
“A complex and high-level ‘skill’ that ‘fill(s) up gaps in the evidence’” (Bartlett, 1958, p. 20)
“A process of searching through a problem space” (Newell & Simon, 1972)
“ [What we do] when we are in doubt about how to act, what to believe, or what to desire” (Baron, 2000, p. 6)
“System 2” (Kahneman, 2011)
Problem Space
Problem space is a mental representation of all possible states, actions, and solutions relevant to a given problem, consisting of an initial state, operators (transformations), and a goal state.
Problem-solving involves searching through this mental space to find a path from the initial state to the goal state, often using heuristics or algorithms to navigate the space effectively.
The complexity and accuracy of a person's problem space can significantly influence their ability to solve problems, especially for complex or unfamiliar tasks.
Heuristics
Heuristics are mental shortcuts or "rules of thumb," that people use to make quick, efficient decisions, solve problems, and form judgments, especially under conditions of uncertainty or limited time. While these shortcuts reduce mental effort and cognitive load, leading to quick "good enough" outcomes, they can also result in systematic errors, biases, and sub-optimal decisions.
Rules of Thumb: These are generalized strategies derived from past experiences that provide serviceable results without extensive analysis.
The Dual-Process Model
System 1 & System 2
System 1 refers to fast, intuitive, and automatic thinking, while System 2 involves slow, deliberate, and analytical thought.
System 1 relies on heuristics, intuition, emotions, and pattern recognition to make quick judgments, often leading to fast but potentially flawed judgments.
System 2 engages in conscious, effortful, logical reasoning to handle complex problems and correct the errors of System 1. System 2 engages in conscious reasoning, careful consideration, and evaluation of information.
System 1 and System 2 don't operate in isolation; they work together and often influence each other. System 1 can provide a quick answer that System 2 then examines for accuracy. A key function of System 2 is to override or correct the potentially flawed intuitions generated by System 1, leading to more rational decisions.
Psychologist Daniel Kahneman popularized this dual-process model of thinking in his book Thinking, Fast and Slow.
Focused Thinking and Unfocused Thinking
Focused thinking is a concentrated, conscious state used for analytical problem-solving and absorbing/learning specific information. It helps with precision and existing knowledge. Focused thinking characteristics include intense concentration, step-by-step reasoning, and the ability to apply existing knowledge and skills, often used for tasks requiring precision, such as learning a new skill, following a procedure, or solving structured problems with clear solutions.
Unfocused thinking, also referred to as diffused thinking, is a relaxed, often subconscious mode that allows the mind to wander, make broad connections, and foster creativity and innovation. It enables new insights and connections. Unfocused thinking characteristics include a relaxed, broad, and often subconscious state that allows the mind to wander and make connections across different knowledge domains, often used for complex problems, generating creative ideas, finding new solutions, and developing a broader understanding.
Problem
Well-Defined Problem & Ill-Defined Problem
A problem is a goal-oriented situation where there is an initial state and a desired goal state, but no clear or immediately apparent way to get from the start to the finish. This definition includes three core components: the goal (what you want to achieve), the initial state (what you have), and operators (the tools or rules you can use to reach the goal).
Well-defined problems have clear initial states, goals, and operators (rules or methods), leading to a specific and often singular solution. There's a finite set of rules or actions that can be applied to transform the problem state, and the desired end state is specific and unambiguous. For example, solving a math equation or a chess game with defined rules.
Ill-defined problems are ambiguous, with unclear initial states and goals, indefinite operators, and multiple potential solutions, requiring creative and flexible thinking to navigate. The steps or methods to solve the problem are not obvious and may be numerous or nonexistent, and there is often no single "right" answer, and solutions can be open to interpretation. For example, deciding on a career, writing a short story, or dealing with complex personal relationships.
Well-defined problems are easier to study in lab scenarios; for that reason, it is generally assumed that solving ill-defined problems works in similar ways as well-defined problems.
Generate-And-Test
The generate-and-test method is a problem-solving strategy where a system generates potential solutions and then evaluates each one until an acceptable solution is found. This method, however, loses its effectiveness when there are many possibilities (e.g., trying all possible combinations in a lock).
Means-End Analysis
Means-end analysis (MEA) is a problem-solving strategy where a person breaks down a large problem into smaller, manageable sub-goals by comparing the current state to the desired end state, identifying the differences, and determining the steps (means) needed to achieve each sub-goal and ultimately the final goal.
This method involves repeatedly assessing the gap between the current situation and the ultimate goal, creating intermediate goals, and taking actions to reduce that gap, making it a systematic way to tackle complex challenges.
It starts with a goal, then analyzes the current starting point, and creating steps (the means) towards reaching the goal (desired end point); generating a plan to solve the problem.
Working Backward
Working backward is a problem-solving heuristic where one starts from the desired end goal and works backward through the necessary steps to reach the starting point.
This strategy involves visualizing the solved problem and then reversing the process to discover how to achieve it, often making complex problems more manageable and efficient to solve.
Working backwards does not usually involve making a move and seeing what happens. It is most effective when the backward path is unique.
Similar to means-end analysis, working backwards attempts to reduce the difference between the current state and the goal state, and often includes subgoals.
An example of working backward is the Towers of Hanoi problem.
The Towers of Hanoi Problem
The Towers of Hanoi problem is a classic puzzle used to assess and study executive functions, particularly problem-solving, planning, working memory, and self-monitoring.
The task involves moving a stack of disks of different sizes from one peg to another, one at a time, following specific rules (larger disks cannot be placed on smaller ones).

Backtracking
Backtracking is a problem-solving strategy that involves returning to a previous decision point and trying a different alternative path after encountering a dead end or an incorrect solution.
It's a systematic, trial-and-error method to build solutions incrementally by abandoning incorrect paths and exploring new ones until a valid solution is found.
This process relies on memory to remember past choices and uses it to make new ones, similar to navigating a maze.
One makes provisional assumptions about a problem’s solution. Then, keep track of when and which assumptions were made, in case one has to “undo” them (keeping track of “choice” points).
Provisional Assumptions
Provisional assumptions are temporary, often unconscious, beliefs or suppositions that the mind uses to quickly interpret and make sense of information. These cognitive shortcuts, or heuristics, allow for rapid decision-making and problem-solving without needing to fully analyze every detail of a situation.
Provisional assumptions are not based on complete evidence and are understood to be flexible and revisable as new information becomes available. They are the mental "best guesses" that the brain makes to navigate the world efficiently.
Reasoning By Analogy
Reasoning by analogy is a cognitive process/problem-solving technique of applying knowledge from a familiar situation (the source domain) to understand or solve a problem in a new situation (the target domain) by recognizing deep relational similarities (patterns) between the two.
It involves mapping corresponding elements and their relations from the source to the target, allowing for inferences and the formation of abstract categories based on shared structures, thereby simplifying complexity and fostering creative solutions.
To be successful with this problem-solving technique, people must successfully move beyond the details and focus on the relevant structures of the problem/find the patterns.
Block to Problem-Solving
A block to problem-solving is any mental obstacle that prevents a person from finding an effective solution to a problem.
An example of a block to problem-solving is mental sets.
Mental Set
A mental set is a type of block to problem-solving that occurs when an individual repeatedly uses the same procedure, even when a better, alternative procedure exists. It is a very rigid way of thinking.
A mental set is a cognitive framework or ingrained pattern of thinking that leads an individual to rely on previously successful strategies and methods when approaching new problems, even if those methods are no longer effective. This tendency to persist with familiar solutions can be beneficial for efficiency, but often impedes creativity and makes it difficult to perceive alternative, more appropriate solutions for novel challenges.
Humans are cognitive misers; it wastes less energy to repeat an already known pattern than to create a new path to obtain the desired outcome.
Functional Fixedness
Functional fixedness is a type of mental set where an individual is unwilling to think of other functions for a common object.
Functional fixedness is a cognitive bias where a person has difficulty seeing an object’s potential for alternative uses beyond its traditional or intended function. This mental block hinders divergent thinking and creative problem-solving, making it challenging to find novel solutions because one's perception of the object's role becomes too rigid.
Incomplete Problem Representation
Incomplete problem representation is a type of mental set.
An incomplete problem representation is a flawed mental model of a problem that omits or misinterprets critical information. This prevents a person from accurately understanding the problem's current state, its goal state, and the available operators (rules or moves) to reach the solution.
An incomplete or incorrect representation can lead to an impasse, where a person becomes stuck and cannot find a solution. This is often the case with "insight problems," which are specifically designed to mislead the solver into an incorrect initial representation
Cognitive Miser
A cognitive miser is an individual who prefers to use mental shortcuts (heuristics) to make decisions and solve problems, rather than engaging in more complex and effortful thinking. This tendency highlights the brain's drive for cognitive economy; simplifying complex situations by focusing on a few salient pieces of information to reduce mental effort. All humans are cognitive misers by nature.
Problem Space
Imagine every possible state of affairs within a problem corresponds to a node in a mental graph. The entire set of nodes occupies some mental area, and this area, together with the graph, is the problem space.
A problem space is a layout of all possibilities. The more an individual searches, meaning the more they expand their problem space, the easier it is to overcome mental blocks.
A problem space is all possible moves from the initial state and all possible replies to each move until the goal is reached. Some possible choices lead to dead ends, yet they are still part of the problem space. Other choices lead to the end goal; a path is a series of moves that lead to the goal.
A problem space is the mental representation of a problem, including its initial state, goal state, all possible intermediate states, and the operators (actions) that can transform one state into another. It serves as the mental "arena" in which a problem-solver searches for a path from the start to the solution, often using strategies called heuristics to make the search more efficient.

Incubation Effect
The incubation effect is a cognitive phenomenon where stepping away from a problem for a period of time allows the unconscious mind to continue working on it, leading to sudden insights or solutions upon returning to the problem. This break allows for the forgetting of initially fixated incorrect ideas and facilitates the formation of new, creative connections, ultimately improving problem-solving ability.
Cueing Effect
A cueing effect describes how an external stimulus (a cue) can influence a person's attention, perception, or memory, leading to faster or more efficient processing of information and/or new insights. Examples include faster reaction times when a visual cue directs attention to a target (Posner cueing), quicker visual search for objects in familiar spatial arrangements (contextual cueing), and a heightened response to a target in the direction a person is looking (gaze cueing).
Insight
An insight is the sudden, non-analytical comprehension of a solution to a problem, often accompanied by an "aha!" moment, and is characterized by a sudden restructuring of the problem that reveals an unconventional but correct path forward.
Critical Thinking
Critical thinking is defined as an active, disciplined, and intellectual process of analyzing, evaluating, and synthesizing information to form reasoned judgments and guide beliefs and actions, rather than accepting ideas at face value. It involves using cognitive skills to question assumptions, consider alternative explanations, examine evidence, and avoid biases.
Critical thinking requires a good knowledge base, the willingness to raise objections to one’s own and others’ ideas, the construction of examples and counterexamples with respect to one’s and others’ conclusions, and the understanding of fundamental issues alongside essential structures.
Decision-Making
Decision-making is the complex cognitive process of selecting a course of action from several alternatives by evaluating potential outcomes and considering various internal and external factors, including reasoning, emotion, and biases. This process involves recognizing a problem, gathering information, generating options, and assessing their consequences to arrive at a chosen action.
Uncertainty
Uncertainty is a lack of precise knowledge or clear understanding of something, such as future outcomes, the truth or falsity of a statement, or a situation's true alternative. It signifies a state of knowing that you don't know, often influencing thoughts, feelings, and actions by triggering a need to predict, adapt, or make decisions under conditions of ambiguity.
Cognitive Overload
Cognitive overload occurs when the volume of information or complexity of tasks presented exceeds a person's working memory capacity, leading to a reduction in focus, performance, and decision-making ability; the information available overwhelms the cognitive processing available.
Phases of Decision-Making
Decision-making tasks can be divided into five categories (phases). There may or may not be a set order to the tasks, and the performance of one task can overlap with the performance of another, while some tasks can be skipped.
These categories are:
Setting Goals / Revising Goals
Gathering Information (investigating possible options and their consequences)
Structuring the Decision / Decision Structuring (organizing and managing all the information acquired)
Making a Final Choice (select a path out of all available options)
Evaluating (evaluating one’s entire decision-making process to improve it for future predicaments)
Systematic Error / Cognitive Bias
A systematic error, or cognitive bias, is a consistent, repeatable flaw in thinking that distorts perception, interpretation, and judgment, leading to faulty conclusions or decisions. These biases cause a deviation from accurate thought processes and can be influenced by factors like memory, attention, or the interpretation of evidence, leading to systematic inaccuracies in reasoning or problem-solving.
Cognitive Illusion
A cognitive illusion is a systematic, involuntary error in thinking, judgment, or memory that occurs when the brain interprets information based on prior assumptions, resulting in a perception or conclusion that differs from objective reality. Unlike visual illusions that can be seen, cognitive illusions involve mental processing and often go unnoticed, revealing the brain's reliance on mental shortcuts (heuristics) and ingrained thinking patterns, known as biases.
Availability Heuristic / Retrieval Fluency Effect
Ross and Sicoly (1979)
The availability heuristic is a mental shortcut where people judge the likelihood of an event based on how easily examples come to mind, rather than on actual facts or logic. This cognitive bias often leads to errors in judgment because easily recalled events, such as those highly publicized or dramatic, are not necessarily the most common or probable. For example, particular words, committees, or decision paths are more easily remembered, computed, or thought of, making them stand out more in one’s mind; consequently, they are deemed/assumed by the individual to be more frequent or probable.
Example: Ross and Sicoly (1979) surveyed 37 married couples (husbands and wives were surveyed separately and independently). The participants were asked to estimate the extent of their responsibility for various household activities, meaning, who they believed did more chores, them or their partner? On average, for 16 out of the 20 activities, both husbands and wives believed they were the ones who performed the chore most often. When asked to explain their answers, participants were able to remember more instances of when they performed the activity than their partner. This is an example of the availability heuristic because it is easier for us to remember events that occurred to us than when they happened to someone else (and we simply observed it). Similarly, we are not present every time someone else does a chore, so we just assume we do them more because we can recall more instances of us doing them.
Representativeness Heuristic
The representativeness heuristic is a mental shortcut where people judge the likelihood of an event by comparing it to existing prototypes, stereotypes, or categories in their minds. People are more likely to believe something is true or belongs to a category if it strongly resembles a typical or stereotypical example, often leading to errors in judgment by ignoring statistical base rates or other relevant information.
The Law of Small Numbers
The law of small numbers is the common cognitive bias of incorrectly believing that small samples of data are highly representative of the larger population they come from, leading to overgeneralizations and misinterpretations. It's a fundamental misunderstanding of statistics, as random chance has a much larger impact in small samples, making them more prone to outliers and less likely to reflect the true characteristics of the population than larger samples.
Gambler's Fallacy
The gambler's fallacy is the mistaken belief that past independent events influence future independent events; for example, believing a coin is "due" to land on tails after several consecutive heads, even though each flip has a 50% chance regardless of prior outcomes. This cognitive error stems from a misunderstanding of randomness, often linked to the representativeness heuristic and the law of small numbers, where people incorrectly assume small samples of data should perfectly mirror the ideal proportions of a larger population.
Framing Effect
Kahneman and Tversky (1981)
The framing effect is a cognitive bias where people's decisions are influenced by how information is presented rather than just the information itself. This bias highlights that the presentation of choices as gains versus losses can dramatically affect risk tolerance and choices, demonstrating how the mind processes information to reach a decision.
Example: Kahneman and Tversky (1981) conducted an experiment, known as the Asian Disease Problem, where participants were separated into two groups and asked to choose between two options:
Group 1 / Gain Frame options:
Program A: 200 people will be saved.
Program B: There is a one-third chance that 600 people will be saved and a two-thirds chance that no one will be saved.
Group 2 / Loss Frame options:
Program C: 400 people will die.
Program D: There is a one-third chance that no one will die and a two-thirds chance that 600 people will die.
Results: In the gain frame, most people chose Program A, the guaranteed saving of 200 lives. In the loss frame, most people chose Program B, the risky gamble, because they were unwilling to accept the certainty of 400 deaths. This shows that the same outcome is perceived differently when framed in terms of gains versus losses, leading to different decision-making processes.
Anchoring
Anchoring is a mental shortcut where a person relies too heavily on the first piece of information they receive (the "anchor") when making a decision. This initial information becomes a reference point, and subsequent judgments are made by adjusting from that anchor, often insufficiently, leading to biased outcomes.