Species are a group of organisms because different species may have different criteria for determining whether they are from the same species or just two different species that may have similar characteristics. Generally, a species is a group of organisms that can interbreed and produce fertile offspring, but there are certain exceptions.
FOUR SPECIES CONCEPTS
Biological Species concept
This concept is used by taxonomists
Those species that can interbreed and produce viable offspring
Can be used to define diploid, sexually reproducing organisms
It relies on reproductive isolation - when 2 populations cannot interbreed, they are not from the same species
States that no gene flow occurs between two populations if reproductive isolation occurs because they cannot reproduce together
It uses multiple lines of evidence.
There are two types of reproductive isolation
Pre zygotic
Temporal
Habitat
Behavioral
Gametic behavior
Mechanical
Post zygotic
Hybrid viability
Hybrid sterility
Disadvantages
Can't be found in fossils
Difficult to apply - geographic barriers
Determining the boundaries of a species can be difficult, as genetic and morphological data can vary within and between populations.
Lack of consensus: There is often a lack of consensus among researchers on the appropriate criteria for defining a species, which can lead to inconsistencies in species designations.
Can be subjective: The interpretation of genetic and morphological data can be subjective, leading to different conclusions about species boundaries.
May not reflect ecological or functional differences: The phylogenetic species concept does not necessarily reflect ecological or functional differences between groups of organisms, which can be important in some contexts.
2. Morphospecies Concept
The morphological species concept defines a species based on physical characteristics such as anatomical features, size, shape, coloration, and other observable traits
Morphological differences between individuals of the same/different species
Fossil identification
Helpful with extinct/extant species
Can be applied to extinct AND living organisms
Helpful when genetic data is unavailable
Disadvantages
Cannot identify cryptic species
Limit of variation between populations - characteristics can vary within populations, making it difficult to determine if individuals belong to the same or different species.
the physical features used to distinguish between species can also overlap, leading to ambiguity in species identification.
May not reflect genetic differences
3. Ecological species concept
Organisms that have the same resources, environmental tolerances and face the same predators
Identifies species based on their role in the environment
Ecological niche, behaviour, and interactions with other species
Can be used to identify bacterial, archaea, or organisms that reproduce asexually
Reflects ecological interactions
Useful for conservation research and efforts
Can reveal cryptic species
Disadvantages
Not useful if one does now know anything about the role of the organism
Difficult to apply - ecological interactions can be hard be complex
Ecological differences may not reflect genetic differences and differences species can occupy similar ecological niches
Limited to organisms - cant apply to bacteria and viruses as they do not have well defined ecological niches
May not reflect historical relationships
4. Phylogenetic species concept
Evolutionary history of populations based on the
DARWIN - stated that all species are related by common ancestry
All species form a MONOPHYLETIC group, or clade
They are identified by synapomorphies at genetic, mental or structural levels
According to this concept, species are a group of organisms that are bound by ancestors based on their morphological and genetic traits and lineage
Widely applicable
Reflects evolutionary history
Can be applied to all organisms
Disadvantages
Can be difficult to apply - incomplete data on lineages, etc
Limited data
May not reflect functional differences