The U.S. Constitution arose out of important historical and philosophical ideas and preferences regarding popular sovereignty and limited government. Compromises were made during the Constitutional Convention and ratification debates, and these compromises have frequently been the source of conflict in U.S. politics over the proper balance between individual freedom, social order, and equality of opportunity.
democracy
a government under the direct or representative rule of the people of its jurisdiction
republic
a form of government in which the people elect, or choose, their leaders
republicanism
theory that emphasizes participation of citizens for the common good of the community
stresses public rights and obligations of the people in support of the community
is more rooted in the political + civic ideas of classical antiquity
european enlightenment put forward republican ideas
needs of the community considered superior to the claims of the individual
liberalism
based on the constitutionally guaranteed rights of individuals being the primary concern
personal/individual > public/community
popular sovereignty
people are the source of government power
natural rights
Initial list: life, liberty, property
changed after the passing of the declaration of independence
God given rights that the government can’t take away
Revolutionary for the time, because people believed that natural rights were given by the government
limited government
the government is limited in what it can do
In order to not violate rights, they have limited power
social contract theory
An implicit agreement among the people in a society to give up some freedoms in order to maintain social order
Purpose of the government is to make & enforce rules that protect the peoples rights
Government cannot improperly violate the peoples rights in the name of social order
If the government does violate rights, the people have the right to dissolve the government
state of nature
Ideal of what what humans look/interact like in a state of nature (before the government)
Everyone is equally free, all born equal, all born free, all born with certain natural rights
John Locke
person behind most of the philosophy of the revolution war
What does a just government look like?
limited government
natural rights
popular sovereignty
social contract
state of nature
labor theory of property
majority
when comparing two options (such as bills or candidates), the option preferred by more than half of the voters should win.
supermajority
a specified proportion of votes in excess of a simple majority, as required by a legislature or other body to pass certain types of measure.
Articles of Confederation
strengths
treaty of Paris (1783)
Northwest ordinance/land ordinance
kept the states together
federal aid to education (NW Ordinance)
Weakness
no separate executive
one vote per state
no federal courts
9 states required to pass legislation (2/3)
13 states required to amend
no power to tax
couldn’t draft troops
no standard national currency (States had their own as well)
inability to repay french loans
British retention of forts in the northwest
no regulation of interstate commerce
Spain’s denial of right of deposit at New Orleans
boundary disputes between states
little trade with Britain
members often failed to attend congress
inability to protect settlers from Indian attacks
Barbary pirates raided shipping
States taxed each other’s goods
Structure
9 states required to pass legislation (⅔)
13 states required to amend
One vote per state
No federal courts
No separate executive
No power to tax
No standard national currency (sts had own as well)
Shays Rebellion
under the AOC —> the country was in debt and the national government had no way to raise money to repay this debt
the responsibility fell to the states who passed new taxes to try and raise money to meet these obligations
A group of farmers and American Revolution war veterans in Massachusetts became increasingly angry at their state government
faced higher taxes they couldn’t pay, loss of property, and even the possibility of debtor’s prison
this group under shay’s leadership called for an end to the heavy burdens as well as demanding debt relief
1787 —> the rebellion march into an armory and the government’s militia put down the rebellion
caused the founding fathers to realize that a stronger government was needed
led to the adoption of the Constitution
Connecticut Compromise/Great Compromise
proportional representation in the House of Representatives and equal representation in the senate
Was a compromise between: small states and large states
Compromised by: (bicameral legislature 2 houses)
Senate → equal number of senators (2 per state)
Chosen by state legislatures
Changed by the 17th amendment → 1913
Elected by popular vote
House of Representatives → based on population
Popular vote
three-fifths compromise
⅗ slaves were counted to determine a state’s total population for legislative representation
Also applied to taxation
States were taxed on the number of population
Was a compromise between: the non-slave and slave states
Slave Trade compromise
it prohibited regulation changes to the slave trade for 20 years and it protected the interests of slave owners
Congress can’t touch the international slave trade for 20 years
But after 20 years, the international slave trade is abolished
Was a compromise between: north and southern states
Electoral College
Was a compromise between: the election of the president by a vote in congress and the election of the president by a popular vote of the qualified citizens
Depending on how many electoral votes are in each state that determines the next president of the U.S.
Compromised by: the founding fathers
Amendment Process
propose
⅔ of both houses of congress
⅔ of states calls on congress to call for a national convention
ratify - formally approve (puts in effect)
¾ state legislatures
¾ state conventions
separation of powers
the division of government responsibilities into distinct branches to limit any one branch from exercising the core functions of another.
checks and balances
HoR → impeach the president (majority)
Senate → holds the impeachment trial (⅔)
HoR → chooses the president if no candidate receives a majority in the electoral college
voting by delegation
each of the states get one vote and vote for one person
the person with the majority will be president (ballot for each state → ⅔ majority)
senate → chooses the VP if no candidate receives a majority in the electoral college
president vetoes a bill → vetoed bill can be overridden by congress (can pass the act by ⅔ vote in both the house and senate)
senate → must approve appointments to head departments of the executive branch and ambassadors (majority)
senate → approves treaties (⅔)
congress → approves the relationship of the VP if the person resigns (majority in the house and senate)
congress → power to declare war (majority)
congress → has the power to tax and appropriate funds (majority)
president → must deliver a state of the union address to congress
Impeachment
a charge of misconduct made against the holder of public office
compare the House and Senate
Senate
trial of impeachment charges ⅔
override a presidential veto ⅔
confirming deputy heads, ambassadors, and federal judges (include SCOTUS) majority
approve treaties ⅔
declare war maj.
tax maj.
appropriate funds maj.
House of Representives
impeach - bring charges majority
confirming deputy heads, ambassadors, and federal judges (include SCOTUS) majority
approve treaties ⅔
declare war maj.
tax maj.
appropriate funds maj.
federalism
division of power between the national government and the state government
factions
a party or group (as within a government) that is often contentious or self-seeking
judicial review
can declare a law unconstitutional then the law isn’t valid (null and void)
Marbury v. Madison
established for the first time that federal courts had the power to overturn an act of Congress on the ground that it violated the U.S. Constitution.
enumerated powers
the powers granted to the Federal government, and specifically Congress
tax, borrow money, regulate interstate commerce, naturalization, coin money, establish lower courts, declare war, raise army and navy
implied powers
powers Congress exercises that the Constitution does not explicitly define, but are necessary and proper to execute the powers.
elastic clause/necessary and proper clause
congress
pass laws to carry out, execute, enumerated powers
supremacy clause
it makes the Constitution and all laws on treaties approved by Congress in exercising its enumerated powers the supreme law of the land
commerce clause
gives Congress broad power to regulate interstate commerce and restricts states from impairing interstate commerce.
take care clause
president must take care that the laws are faithfully executed
Federalist Papers
a collection of essays written by John Jay, James Madison, and Alexander Hamilton in 1788. The essays urged the ratification of the United States Constitution, which had been debated and drafted at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787
arguments of Federalists and Anti-federalists
Federalists → Supported the new Constitution.
antifederalists → Opposed the new Constitution.
Antifederalists → Believed that the Constitution gave too much power to the central government.
Antifederalists → The nation was too large to adequately represent the interests of the people in a distant central government.
Federalists → A large republic is better because yes, many factions will inevitably develop, but in a large republic there are enough of them that they will check the power of each other.
federalist → The states are represented in the Senate (originally, state legislators selected the Senators (from that state), so they shouldn’t fear the central government.
antifederalists → This new government doesn’t protect individual liberties.
antifederalist → The new government won’t represent the interests of small states and more rural areas.
federalists → Each branch of the central government can check the power of the other two branches ensuring that no one branch will become too powerful.
anti federalists → States are better able to represent the people because they are smaller and closer to the people.
federalist → The people are directly represented in the House of Representatives.
anti federalists → The Supremacy Clause and the Necessary and Proper Clause make the central government far too powerful over the states and will render the states powerless.
anti federalists → The President and the Executive branch generally are given far too much power and it would be easy to fall into despotism. How is this President any different from the king?
Federalists →A strong executive is needed to carry out the laws of the legislative branch.
antifederalists → There is no effective limit on Congress’ power to tax.
antifederalists → If the federal government has the power to tax, then states will be unable to raise much of their own revenue from taxation. Citizens only have so many resources.
federalists → The Constitution doesn’t give the federal government the power to control the press, for instance, so why do we need to specifically protect a right that Congress doesn’t have any power over? The same can be said for other individual liberties. A Bill of Rights is not needed and could actually lead some to argue that Congress has more powers than those enumerated (listed) in Article I of the Constitution.
federalists → A stronger national government is necessary to facilitate interstate trade, manage foreign affairs, and provide for a national defense. But the national government can’t become too powerful because the powers of Congress are specifically limited to those enumerated (listed) in Article I of the Constitution.
antifederalists → The national government will overtake the state governments.
federalists → The President is elected by a college of electors, it is not a hereditary title and in no way resembles a monarchy.
Bill of Rights
1st amendment
Freedom of Religion, Speech, Press, Assembly, and Petition
10th amendment
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
Declaration of Independence
to explain the colonists' right to revolution
Constitution of the U.S.
the fundamental law of the U.S. federal system of government and a landmark document of the Western world.
Articles of Confederation
the original constitution of the US, ratified in 1781, which was replaced by the US Constitution in 1789.