Oral Health Promotion: Final Exam (Work in progress)🚧

taking action to represent your own interests - speaking up for yourself

self advocacy

taking action to represent one or two individuals or a small group i.e. like advocating for a patient

individual advocacy

Aims to inform and influence decision-makers. Used to influence those who have the formal power to make the change.

policy advocacy

taking action to change policies or laws to contribute to health of people and the overall the population

public health advocacy

influencing people

-especially policymakers

-as they develop, review or revise laws and regulations that impact oral health.

oral health advocacy

What are the 5 current issues of dentistry at the federal level?

funding of NIDCR, Opioids, Federal student loan, Higher Education Act, medicare

What are state/local issues in Dentistry? (5)

Opioids, medicaid dental services, midlevel providers, community water fluoridation, COVID19 repsonses

Process of a bill:

-Anyone can write a bill but a legislature needs to file and sponsor the bill

-Advocators can work with legislatures to craft bills to address concerning issues

Bill drafting

Process of a bill:

-A legislator introduces a bill in the body of which he or she is a member

-After a bill has been introduced, a short description of the bill is read aloud to the chamber so that all members are aware of the bill and its subject (aka first reading). The presiding officer assigns the bill to a committee during the first reading of the bill

Bill introduction

t/f: in some states, bills are assigned to several committees

true

Process of a bill:

debate and vote

floor action

Process of a bill:

Steps from intro to floor action are repeated

Second Chamber

Process of a bill:

formed when two chambers disagree on the final version of the bill and they work to create a compromised legislation that will pass in both chambers

Conference Committee Process

Process of a bill:

They can sign/veto/allow the bill to become a law without signature

Governor's action

If each chamber passes a different version of the bill, a conference committee is formed to work out the differences

-Bill cannot be sent to the governor until each chamber passes an identical version of the bill

Conference Committee

In most states, a______ can sign a bill into law, allow a bill to become law without their signature or veto the bill

governor

Bill returned to Legislature for possible override

Vetoed

is an abbreviation for five elements that help identify core messages of an advocacy campaign effort

PEARS

-Urging policymakers to adopt a specific "solution" requires that advocates first identify a problem or challenge that exists in their community, state or country

-The problem should answer this question: What is happening or not happening that your audience cares about?

Problem

-Saying there is a problem is one thing; proving it is another

-The problem may not be as self-evident to policymakers as advocates think it is

-Share facts or data that demonstrate this problem exists and reveal its impact.

-Evidence can also be helpful to build confidence in your solution

Evidence

-What are advocates asking the audience to do?

-The answer to this question should be specific

-The action probably will vary based on whether the audience is composed of decision-makers or influencers

-Advocates will ask decision-makers to make the right choice, but they will encourage influencers to make their voices heard by signing a petition, emailing decision-makers, or taking other steps.

Action

-advocates should play devil's advocate by thinking of the skeptics in their audience

-What might they say to dispute or dismiss your messages?

-Try to anticipate and overcome their skepticism by offering responses that are grounded in the facts.

Reality Check

-This is different from the Action

-The Solution identifies what will change if the Action is taken

-If policymakers or people take the desired action, what impact will it have?

-How will it change things for the better?

-Advocates should consider tailoring the solution to different audiences because they may define "the better" differently.

Solution

-mid-level oral health professionals

-Scope of practice between that of hygienist and dentist

-provide basic preventive & restorative treatment to children and adults

-Different education requirements and scope of practice depending on the state.

Dental therapist

-insurance for poor/low income households

-costs shared jointly by federal and state governments and

-there’s dental treatment for children while adults vary by state.

Medicaid

-insurance for people 65+ regardless of financial means

-cost covered by federal gov

-mostly no dental benefits

Medicare

Introducing a bill before the session starts

Pre-filling

The last day a member of a legislative body is permitted to introduce legislation

Bill Introduction deadlines

The last day a chamber may act on a bill that originated in that chamber

Crossover deadlines

Placing a limit on the number of bills a member of a legislative body may introduce

Bill Introduction Limits

Legislation that did not pass during the first year of a legislative session will be alive when the legislature reconvenes the next year

Carryover

Some states require a legislature to adjourn by a specific calendar date, while others place a limit on the number of days a legislative body is allowed to meet in a calendar year this is referred to as restriction on _______

"Legislative Days" Vs. "Calendar Days"

where it restricts the consecutive number of years a member can be in one chamber of the legislature; it is not unusual to see a member of the legislature bounce between chambers after reaching the consecutive term limit

consecutive term limit

prohibits a member from running for an office they've held after they have served a specified number of years. Presiding officers (usually known as the President of the Senate or Speaker of the house/assembly) are the most powerful members of a legislative body

lifetime term limit

should answer the question "what is happening or not happening that your audience cares about?"

problem

Share facts or data that demonstrates this problem exists and reveal its impact

Evidence

Ask decision makers to make the right choice and encourage influencers to make their voices heard by signing a petition/emailing/taking other steps

Action

Play devil's advocate by thinking of the skeptics and thinking what they may say

Reality Check

Identifies what will change if action is taken

Solution

t/f: Data comes from a wide variety of sources such as the CDC, national survey of children's health, the national health interview survey, medical expenditure panel survey, census data, etc.

true

-strategy that puts issues in the appropriate context

-occurs when a person or group presents an issue in a way that makes an audience more likely to support or oppose a particular position. Considers the beliefs and attitudes of the audience

framing

Which of the following should NOT be considered in traditional media?

a.Developing a Media List: should include the names, media outlets and contact info for key reports/editors and other media

b. Designating a spokesperson for media interviews: someone should be chosen as the person who will be quoted/handle interviews

c. Creating talking points for your spokesperson: should consist of 3-4 key messages

d. Choosing the right time to reach out to news media: think carefully before deciding when or if to send an email or press release to media list

e. Building a relationship: building a relationship with reports and editors is crucial; one of the best ways is to send an email thanking a reporter for a story and suggesting a related story for a future article

f. Using letters to the editor to raise the profile of an issue: good way to raise awareness of an issue

ALL SHOULD BE CONSIDERED

What are the 3 state branches and what do they consist of?

-Legislative branch consisting of a State Legislature

-Executive branch consisting of a governor

-Judicial branch consisting of a court system

Amendment says that "Any powers not given to the federal government, but not denied to the states" belong to the state

-One of these powers reserved for the states is the right for the states to establish their own system of state government

10th Amendment

Are these DO's or DONT's of Lobbying?

-Dress professionally

-Introduce yourself

-Confirm appointment prior to meeting

-Introduce your organization and the highlights of the legislation you're lobbying

-Share a personal anecdote to relate why the bill is important to you

-Admit when you don't have an answer + offer to follow up

-Directly ask that the legislator co-sponsor the bill

-Say "thank you" for the opportunity

DOs

Are these DOs or DONTs of lobbying?

-Wear casual clothes

-Get discouraged if meeting with a staffer

-Arrive too early for your appointment

-Stray off topic

-Come to meeting unprepared

-Forget to reiterate the reason for your visit

-Discuss campaign contributions during the meeting

DONTs

Students engage in activities where the emphasis is on service for the sake of the beneficiary or recipient (client, partner)

volunteerism

Students engage in community service activities with intentional academic and learning goals and opportunities for reflection that connect to their academic disciplines

service-learning

Students engage in activities to enhance their own vocational or career development

Internship

Students work in a discipline-based venue in place of an in-class course experience

Practicuum

Students engage in activities to meet actual community needs as an integrated aspect of the curriculum

Community Service

Students engage in actively addressing mutually defined community needs as a collaboration between community partners, faculty, and students) as a vehicle for achieving academic goals and course objectives

Community-Based Learning

What are the four core elements of successful learning programs?

-academic link

-sustained community partnership development

-orientation to community

-guided reflection

Theoretical framework for International engagement

-an ethical framework that explains that you should not commit any wrong act, even if the consequence is good

-holds the principle that individuals know what is best for them and no one else should act in any way that compromises their agency

autonomy

These are all recommendations for:

1. Require-trip knowledge of cultural, historical, and social issues

2. Recipient community identifies its own needs

3.Define clear objectives and use established outcomes measures

4. Require at least minimum proficiency in the local language

5. Manageable group size

6. Faculty supervision during the provision of care

7. Allow limited tourism activities

8. Establish clear standards for student behavior

9. Emphasis on sustainability and continuity of program.

international healthcare service learning activities

What theoretical framework is this?

A community is given a well without being asked whether they need one. The high-tech well breaks down and is reduced to a meeting point. Had community partners been consulted, the project’s success would have been higher – “we don’t need a well, we need farm tools” or “a well would be great, but we can’t maintain a high-tech one.”

Autonomy

What theoretical framework is this?

A UBC student is learning in an different region. Community partners have expressed that it is inappropriate for male gynecologists to practice on women. Gynecologic projects be most successful if the community partners beliefs are respected, and the staff is exclusively female.

Autonomy

What theoretical framework is this?

Instead of the UBC students flying down to Mexico to construct homes, a community partner suggests that she fly to Vancouver to deliver several lectures to the entire UBC community about poverty and homelessness in Mexico. This suggestion replaces the original intention of the project to give the opportunity to unemployed Mexicans to construct homes with the funds. It would be argued that projects which place emphasis on community partner preferences are the most successful.

Autonomy

What theoretical framework is this?

An undergraduate student decides that they would like to go to Africa over the summer because they have heard (falsely) that it increases your chance of getting into professional school. When they arrive, they find there is little that they can help with and find themselves wishing they had waiting until they developed a skill before going abroad.

Autonomy

What theoretical framework is this?

A master’s student is planning on doing research in Cambodia and contacts a community partner to ask about what training she might need. The community partner assures her that it is essential that she learns Khmer before conducting research, so she postpones her trip by a year to learn the language.

Autonomy

What theoretical framework is this?

While giving money or gift to vulnerable communities, it is important to consider if the gift will be sustainable or if it will just promote a dependency relationship

Ethics of Care

-the theory that is centered around the interdependence of all individuals

-Considers the fact that certain communities and people are more vulnerable than others

ethics of care

What theoretical framework is this?

When designing an ISL project for Rwanda, you would have to take into account the local cultural, historical context of the genocide, and language barriers. This would be very different from designing an ISL project for Afghanistan, where you would take into account the needs and wants influenced by Islamic culture

Ethics of Care

What theoretical framework is this?

When designing a health related ISL project for India, consider the goal of having the local community achieving an equal amount of benefit as the ISL project designer.

Ethics of Care

What theoretical framework is this?

If you are going on an educated related ISL project to Guatemala, it is better to go with the motivation of learning something from the local community and a sincere desire to help, rather than with the motivation of padding your resume. In the former case, you would be more likely to learn more about the culture and consider the local context do your job more sincerely; in the latter case, you wouldn’t care as much about focusing on the details that make the experience collaborative and sincere.

Ethics of Care

What theoretical framework is this?

On a health care project to Haiti, in a rural area with little to no infrastructure, it is best to send a volunteer who has the necessary skill to operate a project with minimum technical equipment.

Ethics of Care

What theoretical framework is this?

You may be working on a project involving sexual education for youth. This may be unacceptable to some locals and thus long-term community investment is threatened.

Ethics Pluralism

What theoretical framework is this?

the idea that there are many theories about what is right and wrong and what may be incompatible with your own personal norms

Ethical pluralism

What theoretical framework is this?

-the movement that aims to establish equal right and legal protection for women

-advocates for women’s rights and gender equality, but theories are NOT restricted to women’s issues

Feminism

What theoretical framework is this?

if you are project leader it is important for you to establish a respectful and trustful relationship with each member of your team, regardless of their title or role. This relationship includes everyone’s contribution. Since your project involves consulting the community and collaborating with them having reciprocal and balanced relationship is essential.

Feminism

What theoretical framework is this?

If you are working in a community where the parents are very involved in their children’s personal lives regardless of the children’s age, you need to respect and accept this cultural practice even though it is different from your own culture. This is necessary in establishing and maintaining a trustful relationship with the local community and engaging in your work. Your acceptance of their culture allows for you and the community to be on the same level and have a balanced relationship.

Feminism

What theoretical framework is this?

In designing and implementing a project you need to establish a relationship with the community and seek their advice and understanding in coming up with the project’s goals and format. When the project involves the community at every step it is able to sustain for long-term after your departure

Feminism

What theoretical framework is this?

Be honest with yourself about why you are going abroad to volunteer. Is it the experience you will earn? Is it the exposure to a different culture and language? Do you need some time to escape from your everyday activities? Are you going to improve your resume? Do you want to help? Are you going to achieve your feminist goals? It is important for you to keep your motivations in mind as you begin your work with the community.

Feminism

-an ethical framework that maintains that you should never commit any wrong act

=Says you should act fairly and treat similar situated individuals in a similar manner

justice

What theoretical framework is this?

Even if women in an Islamic country want to be treated by only women doctors, allocating resources equally would require hiring both men and women, which may result in equitable access for the community

Justice

What theoretical framework is this?

Go Global is engaged with community partners in many resource-poor, under-resourced settings. While distribution within the partnering community must be fair, more funding may be spent in Uganda as opposed to in Canada

Justice

What theoretical framework is this?

If a project is being funded by a company, then volunteers may be pressured to distribute goods or services based on the company’s preferences and not equitably

Justice

What theoretical framework is this?

Only a trained doctor will be able to distribute his/her medical services equitably, as s/he will be able to diagnose all the patients in an equally professional manner

Justice

What theoretical framework is this?

-Requires an intention to avoid needless harm or injury that can arise through acts of commission or omission

Non-maleficence

What theoretical framework is this?

refers to actions that promote the well-being of others. The duty of professionals should be to benefit a party, as well as to take positive steps to prevent and to remove harm from the party

Beneficence

What theoretical framework is this?

A short-term health-promotion project may be appropriate when aiding an already established project (eg. supporting a local educator) that has asked for help in pre-identified areas. However, this project may be ineffective and possibly damaging when the service providers are interacting firsthand with communities, they know little about.

Non maleficence/Beneficence

What theoretical framework is this?

A volunteer gives toothbrushes and toothpaste to a rural community and educates them about dental health. However, the toothpaste is quickly used up and the community has no access to commute to town to purchase toothpaste so they burn their plastic toothbrushes along with the rest of their garbage in the backyard creating harmful fumes

Non maleficence/Beneficence

What theoretical framework is this?

Students want to experience living among the community members in a local community. However, it may not always be appropriate to ask locals to open their homes to strangers from abroad and it may create an unfavorable power dynamic.

Non maleficence/Beneficence

What theoretical framework is this?

A 1st year medical student who wishes to get hands-on experience goes to Nicaragua and begins to diagnose and treat patients in an understaffed urban clinic with little supervision

Non maleficence/Beneficence

What theoretical framework is this?

A group of science students wishes to address the health needs of the community and concludes that the primary school in the community needs a washroom. They soon begin building the lavatory but is unsuccessful in finishing because they run into various logistical and mechanical obstacles due to their limited experience in construction and plumbing. The project is left unfinished before the volunteers’ leaves.

Non maleficence/Beneficence

What is a worldwide problem discussed in module 6?

Access to basic oral health services

According to WHO, what is the oral health provider ratio in developed countries vs. Africa?

Developed countries: 1:2000

Africa: 1:150,000

-conditions where people are born, grow, live, work and age and the fundamental drivers of these conditions

-Has direct and indirect outcomes on oral health

social determinants of health

compound neighborhoods , higher crimes, transportation accessibility, no clean water

urban areas

farming, transportation difficulties, no clean water

rural areas

Level of influence:

Policy, Laws, Agencies, Oral Health Funding

Federal and State

Level of influence:

Institutions like dental offices, professional societies, dental schools, advocacy groups

Organizational

Level of influence:

Home, families, schools, caregivers, community support, access to care

Interpersonal

-5+ years of training

-provides all services

-work independently

dentist

-3 years of training

-limited scope (no prosthetics, endodontic or complex oral surgery)

-can work independently but under direction of dentist

dental therapist

Who is the BACKBONE of oral health health in Zambia?

Dental therapists

What are three ethical considerations in terms of Effective project design?

weight of authority, the volunteer effect, burden of hosting

What is the main point of this diagram?

Placing more efforts into prevention, you will decrease the amount of specialist oral care needed by dentist and costs

What are the 5 primary Oral Health care principles?

1. Equity

2. Intersectional Approach

3. Prevention

4. Community participation

5. Appropriate technology

Primary Oral Health care principle states: oral health services should reach all people

equity