evaluating psychotherapies, biomedical therapies and preventing psychological disorders
90% clients say that
psychotherapy is effective
critics skepticism on client’s views on psychotherapy effectiveness
time entered therapy usually time of crisis and time usually heals people, placebo effect that therapy will heal you, be nice to therapist, want to believe time and $ was worth it aka effort justification
effort justification
being prone to selective and biased recall and to making judgements that confirm our beliefs
therapists believe they are successful because
they are vulnerable to confirmation bias and illusory correlation
meta-analysis
a procedure for statistically combining results of many different research studies
using meta analysis results show that
no therapy one will often improve but with therapy a person will be more likely to improve, quicker, and less likely to relapse
no therapy is the best the most important thing is to effective therapy
is having a specific problem
cognitive and cognitive-behavioral therapies effectively treat
anxiety, PTSD, insomnia and depression
behavioral conditioning therapies effectively treat
specific behavior problems such as bedwetting. phobias, and compulsions
psychodynamic therapies effectively treat
depression and anxiety
non directive/client-centered therapy effectively treat
mild to moderate depression
evidence-based practice
clinical decision making that integrates the best available research with clinical expertise and patient characteristics/preferences
EMDR eye movement desensitization and reprocessing
does seem to work but could just be due to exposure therapy of repetitively recall memory and reconsolidate them in safe and reassuring context and placebo effect
light exposure therapy
does seem to help those with a seasonal pattern in their depression symptoms by activating brain regions that influence arousal and hormones
all psychotherapies work by giving people
hope, a new perspective, an empathetic trusting caring relationship
therapeutic alliance
a bond of trust and mutual understanding between a therapist and client who work together constructively to overcome clients problems
therapy can be less effective if client and therapist do not match in
cultural beliefs (like individualism, focus on personal desires/identities and collectivism, focus on group goals, harmony, social/family responsibilities)
religion and gender
emotional bond between therapist and client is
an important factor
biomedical treatments
can change brain chemistry with drugs or brain circuit with electrical simulations/magnetic pulses/psychosurgery or influence responses with lifestyle changes
changing the way we think and behave is
a brain changing experience
therapeutic lifestyle change is
a biomedical therapy because it influences how brain responds
mind and body are a unit so
affect one you will affect the other
exercise, nutrition, relationships. recreation, relaxation, religious/spiritual engagement
affect mental health
people can find relief in depression symptoms by
aerobic exercise, adequate sleep, light exposure, social engagement, reduce rumination, and better nutrition
psychopharmacology
the study of the effects of drugs on mind and behavior
widely used and helps people get out of hospitals
to test drug effectiveness in psychopharmacology
double blind procedures are used
antipsychotic drugs
drugs used to treat schizophrenia and other severe though disorders
antipsychotic drugs decrease symptoms of schizophrenia by
dampening responsiveness to irrelevant stimuli and block dopamine activity
antipsychotic drugs side effects
tardive dyskinesia (involuntary muscle movements), tremors, and increased risk of obesity/diabetes
antianxiety drugs
drugs used to control anxiety and agitation
antianxiety drugs decrease symptoms of PTSD and OCD by
depressing central nervous system
antianxiety drugs side effects
don’t resolve root of problem, very addictive, and withdrawal symptoms occur without drugs
antidepressant drugs
drugs that are used to treat depression and anxiety disorders like PTSD and OCD
antidepressant drugs reduce depression by
increasing availability of serotonin and norepinephrine
some antidepressant drugs are
selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and these are used to treat many disorders
some use antidepressant drugs that work bottom up along with
CBT that works top-down to treat depression
mood stabilizing drugs
depakote and lithium are types that treat bipolar disorder
electroconvulsive therapy ECT
biomedical therapy for severely depressed patients in which a brief electric current is sent through the brain of anesthetized patient
ECT is used as
last resort and is effective (no one really knows why it works) but relapse possible
transcranial direct current
mild current to scalp that has probable efficacy
repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation rTMS
the application of repeated pulses of magnetic energy to the brain to stimulate or suppress brain activity
rTMS may cause cells to
form new circuits through long-term potentiation
deep brain stimulations
calms overactive brain region, a neural hub that links frontal lobe to limbic system, linked with negative emotions
psychosurgery
surgery that removes/destroys brain tissue in an effort to change behavior
lobotomy
a psychosurgical procedure once used to calm uncontrollably emotional or violent patients by cutting nerves connecting frontal love to emotional controlling centers in the inner brain
brain surgery is
irreversible the last resort and rarely used today to change behaviors
the goal is to treat
the person and the source of the mental health issue
preventative mental health programs are based on the idea that many psychological diseases could be prevented by changing oppressive, esteem-destroying environment
into more benevolent nurturing environments that foster growth, self-confidence, resilience, and alleviate demoralizing situations
resilience
the personal strength that helps most people cope with stress and recover from adversity and trauma
posttraumatic growth
positive psychological changes as a result of struggling with extremely challenging circumstances and life crises
posttraumatic growth can lead to positive things like
increasing appreciation for life and meaningful relationships
suffering can beget
new sensitivity and strength
modern psychotherapy: psychodynamic theory
presumed problem: unconscious conflicts from childhood experiences
therapy aim: reduce anxiety through self-insight
therapy technique: interpret patients’ memories and feelings
modern psychotherapy: client-centered theory (a humanistic theory)
presumed problem: barriers to self-understanding and self-acceptance
therapy aim: enable growth via unconditional positive regard. acceptance, genuineness, and empathy
therapy technique: listen actively and reflect clients’ feelings
modern psychotherapy: behavior
presumed problem: dysfunctional behaviors
therapy aim: learn adaptive behaviors and extinguish problem ones
therapy technique: use classical conditioning via exposure therapy or aversion therapy or operant conditioning via token economy
modern psychotherapy: cognitive
presumed problem: negative, self-defeating thinking
therapy aim: promote healthier thinking and self-talk
therapy technique: train people to dispute negative thoughts and attributions
modern psychotherapy: cognitive-behavioral
presumed problem: self-harmful thoughts and behaviors
therapy aim: promote healthier thinking and adaptive behaviors
therapy technique: train people to counter self-harmful thoughts and to act out their new ways of thinking
modern psychotherapy: group and family
presumed problem: stressful relationships
therapy aim: heal relationships
therapy technique: develop an understanding of family and other social systems, explore roles, and improve communications
therapist: clinical psychologists
therapist description: most are psychologists with Ph.D or Psy.D supplemented by a supervised internship and often post-doctoral training. 1/2 work in agencies/institutions and 1/2 in private practice
therapist: psychiatrists
therapist description: psychiatrists and physicians who specialize in treatment of psychological disorders. Not all have had extensive training in psychotherapy but as M.D.s or D.O.s they can prescribe medications. Thus they tend to see those with the most serious problems. Many have their own private practice
therapist: clinical/psychiatric social worker
therapist description: a 2-year master of social work graduate program plus postgraduate supervision prepares some social workers to offer psychotherapy mostly to people with everyday personal and family problems. 1/2 have earned the national association of social workers’ designation of clinical social worker
therapist: counselors
therapist description: marriage and family counselors specialize in problems arising from family relations. clergy provide counseling to countless people. abuse counselors work with substance abusers and with spouse/child abusers and their victims. mental health and other counselors may be required to have a 2-year master’s degree
biomedical therapy: therapeutic lifestyle change
presumed problem: stress and unhealthy lifestyle
therapy aim: restore healthy biological state
therapy technique: alter lifestyle through adequate exercise, sleep, nutrition, and other changes
biomedical therapy: drug therapies
presumed problem: neurotransmitter malfunction
therapy aim: control symptoms of psychological disorder
therapy technique: alter brain chemistry through drugs
biomedical therapy: brain stimulation
presumed problem: depression (ECT is only used for severe, treatment-resistant depression)
therapy aim: alleviate depression, especially when it is unresponsive to drugs or other forms of therapy
therapy technique: stimulate brain through electroconvulsive shock, mild electrical stimulation, magnetic impulses, or deep-brain stimulation
biomedical therapy: psychosurgery
presumed problem: brain malfunction
therapy aim: relieve severe disorders
therapy technique: remove or destroy brain tissue