* Pro-lifers made a website called “Nuremberg Files”
* This website contained addresses, pictures, and other information about clinics and doctors who performed abortions
* These doctors would be assaulted or killed, and the website would be updated to cross out their name or gray it out
* Planned parenthood sued because it was a safety threat
* In 1999, a federal jury sided with Planned Parenthood
* The ACLA appealed it on grounds of First Amendment because the site only *implied* for violence, as opposed to explicitly inciting it
* ACLA was found to be correct unanimously
* In 2002 a circuit court voted six to five to barre the original sites content by arguing they’re advocating violence
* So while advocating for violence is protected, threatening a person is not
* Conclusion is that political hyperbole is protected under the First Amendment, but not true threats
* So ACLA could not do this, and Planned Parenthood won