1/110
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Name | Mastery | Learn | Test | Matching | Spaced |
---|
No study sessions yet.
social process theories
study of the operations of social institutions, such as family, peer groups, and school
crime is a result of learning norms, values, and behaviors
social learning can involve both the actual techniques of crime and the psychological aspects of criminality
most people refrain from criminal activity and few of those who do commit crimes remain persistent chronic offenders in adulthood
socialization
human development and learning, primarily in the family, secondary in institutions
if our relationships are positive and supportive, we will be able to succeed within the rules of society
if our relationships are dysfunctional and destructive, conventional success is more difficult
parental efficacy
the ability of parents to be supportive of their children and control them effectively in non coercive ways
delinquency is reduced when parents provide the type of structure that integrates children into families while giving them the ability to assert their individuality and regulate their own behavior
effects of abuse on children
children who grew up in homes where parents are physically or sexually abusive, harshly physically disciplined, are prone to later antisocial behavior
effects of abuse are long-term
children whose parents are harsh, angry and irritable are likely to behave the same way
stigmatize
to create a label that taints a person’s identity, changing them in the eyes of others
relationship between school and criminality
children who do poorly in school and feel alienated are the most likely to engage in criminality
classroom-based emotional support is important for high risk children and lowers criminality
social learning theory
people learn the techniques and attitudes of crime from observation
either directly from criminal peers or indirectly in the media
rewarded interactions are copied, and punished interactions are avoided
people are born good and learn to be bad
control theory
looks at how society controls, manages, and restrains behavior
maintains that crime occurs when the forces that bind people are weakened or broken
people are born bad and must be controlled to be good
labeling theory
society creates deviance through the designation of individual behavior as deviant
people become criminals when they are labeled as such and they accept those labels as a personal identity
whether people are good or bad, their actions are controlled by the reaction of others
differential association theory
Edwin H. Sutherland
criminal acts are related to exposure to an excess amount of antisocial attitudes and values
criminality stemmed from neither individual traits nor socio-economic position; rather it is a function of a learning process that could affect anyone
principles of differential association
crime is learned in the same manner as any other behavior
crime is learned in interaction with other persons
learning crime occurs within intimate personal groups
learning crime include techniques, and supporting motives, rationalizations, and attitudes
the reaction to social rules is not uniform
a criminal perceives more benefits to violating the law when acquaintances have definitions that are favorable toward criminality
learning definitions favorable to criminality produces illegal behavior
testing differential association
friendship patterns of delinquent youths, recent friendships have more of an effect than older friendships
longitudinal analysis
differential reinforcement theory
crime is learned behavior, combining differential association with learning
people do not learn to be all deviant or all conforming, rather they strike a balance between the two
direct conditioning occurs when behavior is either rewarded or punished during interaction with others
differential association involves learning from direct or indirect interaction with others
cognitive definitions are attitudes that are favorable or unfavorable toward a behavior and can either stimulate or extinguish that behavior
behavior is reinforced when positive rewards are gained or when punishment is avoided
main influence on behavior comes from groups that control individuals reinforcement and punishment such as peer and friendship groups, schools, church
neutralization theory
offenders drift into periods of crime by neutralizing conventional values
most delinquents and criminals actually hold conventional values and attitudes but master techniques that enable them to neutralize those values and drift between illegitimate and conventional behavior
subterranean values
drift
techniques of neutralization
subterranean values
immorality is entrenched in the culture but is otherwise publicly condemned
people commonly hold both subterranean and conventional values- few people are all good or all bad
drift
youth move in and out of delinquency and have both conventional and deviant values
techniques of neutralization
a strategy of cognitive dissonance used by deviants to counteract moral constraints
offenders develop a distinct set of justifications for law violating behavior
criminality is the result of the neutralization of accepted social values
offenders process of developing a distinct set of justifications for law-violating behavior
they voice a sense of guilt over their illegal acts
they often respect and admire honest law abiding persons
they draw a line between those whom they can victimize and those they cannot
they are not immune to the demands of conformity, participating in the same social functions as law abiding people
Skyes and Matza’s techniques of neutralization
deny responsibility- illegality it was not their fault but due to forces beyond their control
deny injury- the harm is neutralized by denying the wrongfulness of an act
deny the victim- the victim of crime had it coming and so doesn’t deserve sympathy
condemn the condemners- the world is corrupt so it is unfair to condemn misconduct
appeal to higher loyalties- justify illegality as an expression of loyalty to one’s peers
addition to Skyes and Matza’s by Minor, Klockars, and Coleman
the defense of necessity- something is morally wrong, but okay if it is necessary
the metaphor of the ledger- the balance of good qualities make up for the bad
the denial of the laws necessity- the law itself is not fair or just
the claim that everybody else is doing it- the criticism of being singled out
the claim of entitlement- the individual feels they are entitled to the gains of crime
white collar neutralization
white collar deviance is more important because of the relative power such people have
appeal to higher loyalties and denial of injury were the reasons such criminals cited most often for their crimes
financial desperation, frustration at a lack of advancement, and the feeling that everyone else was doing it were also found to be reasons
testing neutralization theory
would show that a person neutralized their moral beliefs before drifting into criminality, unless rationalizations can also be after the fact
possible criminals and noncriminals have different moral values and that neutralizing them is therefore unnecessary
validity of the model depends on research showing that all people share similar moral values and must neutralize them in order to engage in criminal behavior
institutionalized youths excuse deviant behaviors to a significantly greater degree than the general population does
almost anyone who criminal acts has learned to rationalize their guilt
social control theories
assumes that all people have the potential to violate the law and that modern society resents many activities for illegal activity
control theorists argue that people obey the law because behavior and passions are controlled by internal and external forces
commitment to conformity
commitment to conformity
a positive orientation to society’s rules, where the individual internalizes those rules
might believe that if they are caught in criminal activity it will hurt a parent or jeopardize their chance at university
a persons behavior is controlled by attachment and commitment to conventional institutions, individuals, and processes
self concept and crime
early control theory speculated that low self control was a product of weak self esteem
delinquents have weak ego ideals and lacked personal controls
poor self concept= more likely to be a criminal
self rejection
self rejection
the consequence of being labeled whereby the negative stigma is internalized
containment theory
containments insulate youths from crime, and include a strong self-concept and a positive support from others
a strong self image can counteract: internal pushes, external pressures, and external pulls
all people perceive inducements to crime, some are better able to resist them
elements of the social bond
attachment: a person’s sensitivity to and interest in others, without which a person loses their ability to relate coherently to others
commitment: involves the time, energy, and effort expanded in conventional lines of action such as getting a education and saving money for the future
involvement: in conventional activities leaves little time for illegal behavior
belief: involves the extent to which the individual believes in conventional norms
labelling theory
explains career formation in terms of destructive social interactions and encounters
roots in symbolic interaction theory
people are assigned a variety of symbolic labels in their interaction with others such as mental disorder, difficult patient, or even victim
negative levels stigmatize people and weaken their self-image
a devalued status can cause permanent harm when conferred by a significant other
institutions such as police, the courts, and correctional agencies produce stigmas that are so harmful to the very people they’re trying to help which ends up amplifying criminal behavior
crime and labeling theory
killing can mean different things, the same things have been switching between legal illegal for all history (abortions, homosexuality, etc) whats important is who does the labeling
differential enforcement
the law is differentially applied, benefiting those who hold economic and social power and penalizing the powerless
members of minority groups and people living in poverty are more likely to be prosecuted for criminal offenses and receive harsher punishments when convicted
law is differentially applied to favor the powerful members of society who direct its content and penalizes people whose actions represent a threat to those in control
social distance
power differences between labeller and labellee, typically related to race, class, and ethnicity
consequences of labeling
the creation of stigma
the effect on self-image
master status
dramatization of evil
master status
an identity that overrides others, such as drug-dealer, a more important status than citizen
dramatization of evil
the reaction to deviance sets up a feedback effect that the individual internalizes
primary deviance
deviant acts that go unsanctioned and that do not redefine the self-image of the offender
involves norm violations that have little influence on the actor and can be quickly forgotten
secondary deviance
when the deviant acts are sanctioned, the label becomes a basis for identity and more deviance
occurs when a deviant event comes to the attention to those who apply a negative label
if successful, secondary deviance involves re-socialization into a deviant role
retrospective reading
the reassessment of a person’s past to fit a current generalized label
both self and other do this reading and re-evaluation
general theory of deviance
begins with the assumption that people who cannot conform to a social group standards face negative sanctions
those exposed to negative social sanctions experience self-rejection and poorer self-images
some acts are defiant, showing contempt for the source of the negative labels, while others are planned to distance the target from further contact with the source of criticism
imposing social sanctions on adolescents leafs to self-rejection, deviant peer associations, and eventual deviance amplification
differential social control
self evaluation reflect actual perceived appraisals made by others
labeled youths may join with similarly outcast delinquent peers, who facilitate their behavior
this effect amounts to a self-fulfilling prophecy, and the process has been linked to delinquent behavior and other problems, including depression
reflective role-taking
youth delinquents give an inner voice to their perceptions of how significant others feel
when these groups are dysfunctional, such as when parents use drugs, they encourage rather than control antisocial behavior
reflected appraisal
youth’s evaluation is based on their perceptions of how others evaluate them
reflected appraisal as a rule violator has significant effect on delinquency
focuses more on social control and symbolic interaction
is labeling theory valid?
its inability to specify the conditions that must exist before an act or an individual is labeled deviant
fails to explain crime rates
ignores the onset of deviance as well as the decision to forgo a deviant career
argues that some crimes are universally sanctioned
developmental criminology
an approach that examines change in a criminal career over the life course
the view that criminality is stable over one’s life is being challenged
integrated theories
divided into three groups on the basis of their views of human development and change: multifactor theories, latent trait theories, and life-course theories
multifactor theories
integrating individual factors and concepts into complex explanations of criminality
combine variables that have been used in structural, socialization, conflict, choice, and trait theories
explains criminal career formation and desistance
a model based on the concept of traits may explain the flow of crime over the life cycle by looking at characteristics that control the inclination to commit crimes
stresses the influence of changing interpersonal and structural factors
latent traits
conditions present at birth that lead some people to become crime prone over their life course
those who carry these latent traits are in danger of becoming career criminals, regardless of personal characteristics
because latent traits are stable, fluctuations in offending over time reflect criminal opportunities and not the propensity to commit crime
integrates concepts usually associated with trait theories with those of rational choice theories
assumes that change occurs not in people but in their criminal opportunties
life course theory
criminal offending patterns change over time, influenced by conditions or events
some career criminals may desist from crime, while others escalate their rate of involvement
some may specialize or become generalists
some are influenced by family matters, financial needs, or changes in lifestyle
stresses the influence of changing interpersonal and structural factors
common ground between multifactor, latent, and life course
the criminal career is a passage along which people travel, and their journey is influenced by events and circumstances such as
structural factors: income and status
socialization factors: family and peer relations
biological factors: size and strength
psychological factors: intelligence and personality
opportunity factors: free time, inadequate protection, easily stolen merchandise
the social development model (SDM)
the attempt to integrate social control, social learning, and structural models of crime
community level risk factors make some people susceptible to developing antisocial behaviors
as a child matures, pre-existing risk factors are either reinforced or neutralized through socialization
provides an accurate picture of the onset of continuation of violent and antisocial behavior for both early onset offenders who engage in antisocial acts in childhood and for later-onset offenders
also predicts the onset and continuation of delinquency and drug abuse, where both social learning and control bonding predict gang membership
pro social bonds
bonds develop within family life that provide pro-social bonds opportunities and feedback
childrens antisocial behavior arises from interaction with antisocial peers over the life course
elliotts integrated theory
adolescents who live in social disorganized areas (A) who are improperly socialized (B) face a significant risk of perceiving strain (C) which leads to weakened bonds with conventional group, activities, and norms (D) weak conventional bonds and high levels of perceived strain lead some youths to reject conventional social values (E) and seek out deviant peer groups (F) from these delinquent associations come positive reinforcements and role model for deviance (G) attachment to delinquent groups, when combined with weak bonding to conventional groups and norms, leads to a high level of delinquent behavior and drug abuse (H)
combines the features of strain, social learning, and control theories into a single theoretical model
integrated structural marxist theory
integrated approach looks at a person’s influence within relations of material production
crime is a result of family relationships marked by conflict and despair and is influenced by the quality of a person’s work experience
wage earners who occupy inferior positions are more likely to experience negative relationships with supervisors and employers
creates strain and alienation in families, juveniles in families become alienated from parents
negative social relations at home and school result in strain, which is reinforced by alienated peers and results in patterns of violent behavior or economic crime
the glueck research
conducted longitudinal studies to research the life cycle of delinquent careers so as to determine the factors that predicted persistent offending using interviews and records
research focused on early onset of delinquency as the harbinger of a criminal career
most important factor related to personal and social factors was found to be the nature of family relations, such as quality of discipline and emotional ties with parents
four best way to achieve reductions in criminality
join the military
get a job
change your environment
change your neighborhood
four critical cognitive transformations as key to the healing process
a basic openness to change
exposure to a positive development
a willingness to establish a replacement self to substitute for the older identity
a transformation in the way the actor views the deviant lifestyle
process is complete when the actor no longer sees their past life and behaviors has personally relevant
Multisystemic therapy (MST)
home based treatment for juveniles addresses the relationships among family, peers, school, and community
targets chronic violent and substance-abusing juveniles who are high risk
aim is to empower parents with the skills and resources needed to help their children cope
conflict theorists view on crime
the outcome of class struggle
conflict promotes crime by creating a social atmosphere in which the law is a mechanism for controlling dissatisfied members of society while maintaining the position of the powerful
explains why crimes of the wealthy are sanctioned much more leniently than lower class crimes
reject the notion that law is designed to maintain a tranquil and fair society and that criminals are simply violent and predatory people
conflict can be functional when it results in positive social change
conflict has been a significant element of the human condition since the dawn of time, shaping human behavior and culture
conflict theory
criminal behavior is caused by economic inequality and law defined by those in power
productive forces and productive relations
production has 2 components
productive forces: which include technology, energy sources, and material resources
relations of production: which exist among the people producing goods and services
marx view on crime
crime as the product of law enforcement policies akin to a labelling process
saw a connection between criminality and inequality
working people committed crime because their choice was between a slow death by starvation or a speedy one at the hands of law
the only crimes available to the poor are the severely sanctioned street crime
willem bonger
believed that society is divided into have and have-nots, on the basis of system of production in force
every society has a ruling class and an inferior class
almost no act is punished unless it heeds the interests of the dominant ruling class
the legal system discriminates against people who are poor by defending the actions of people who are wealthy
ralf dahrendorf
society is organized into imperatively coordinated associations (those who possess authority and use it for social domination and those who lack authority and are dominated)
unified conflict theory of human behavior
every society is at every point subject to processes of change
every society displays at every point dissent and conflict
every element in a society renders a contribution to its disintegration and change
every society is based on the coercion of some of its members by others
unified conflict theory of human behavior
every society is at every point subject to processes of change
every society displays at every point dissent and conflict
every element in a society renders a contribution to its disintegration and change
every society is based on the coercion of some of its members by others
george vold
argued that laws are created by politically oriented groups seeking the government’s assistance to help them defend their rights and protect their interests
if a group can marshal enough support, a law will be created to hamper and curb the interests of some opposition group
every stage of the process is marked by conflict, criminal acts are. a consequence of direct contact between forces struggling to control society
modern conflict theory
criminologists began to view the justice system as a mechanism for controlling the lower class and maintaining the status quo
labelling theorists rejected the simplistic notion that crime is morally wrong and studied the interactions among crime, the criminal, the victim, and social control agencies
identifying the “real” crime in society such as profiteering, sexism and racism
evaluating how the criminal law is used as a mechanism of social control
objectives of conflict criminology
describe how control over the political and economic systems affects the administration of criminal justice
show how definitions of crime favor those who control the justice system
to show how justice in society is skewed so that those who deserve to be punished the most are actually punished the least while those whose crimes are relatively minor and committed out of economic necessity receive stricter sanctions
social reality of crime
quinney’s conflict theory on the relationship between society and crime
conflict exists between social groups the people who hold power will create laws to benefit themselves
criminal definitions are based on factors such as: changing social conditions, emerging interests, increasing demands that political, economic, and religious interests be protected, changing conceptions of public interest
propositions of the social reality of crime
crime is a definition of human conduct created by politically authorized agents
criminal definitions describe behaviors that conflict with the interest of those that have the power to shape public policy
criminal definitions are applied by those that have the power to shape the enforcement and administration of criminal law
behavior is structured in segmentally organized society in relation to criminal definitions, and persons engage in actions that have relative probabilities of being defined as criminal
conceptions of crime are constructed and diffused in society by various means of communication
the social reality of crime entails constructing criminal conceptions, applying criminal definitions, and developing of behavior to criminal definitions
norm resistance
the interaction between authorities and subjects produces open conflict
both authorities and subjects are committed to opposing cultural norms, people with group support will be resistant to authority or change, assessing the strengths and weaknesses of opponents helps avoid conflict with authorities
dangerous classes
being single, young, urban, male, and ethnic can result in harsher treatments in the criminal justice system
correctionalist
simply correcting behavior rather than seeing its cause, such as in economic relations
fundamentals of marxist criminology
mostly ignore formal theory
crime and criminal justice must be viewed in a historical, social, and economic context
part of the radical agenda is to make the public aware that crimes of power are just as much as crimes of burglary and robbery
criminals are products of society and its economic system
criminality is a function of the social and economic organization of society
to control crime and reduce criminality, one must end the social conditions that promote crimesurp
surplus value
labor produces wealth that exceeds their wages; that wealth goes to the capitalist class as profits
surplus value has been increased through globalization as production shifts to regions of the world with lower wages and fewer restrictions
instrumental marxism
the law is designed to advance the interests of particular groups or organizations
law is shaped by the economic, social, and political interests of the ruling class
views the criminal law and criminal justice system solely as instruments for controlling the poor; the state is the tool of the capitalist
society is based on an advanced capitalist economy
the state is organized to serve the interests of the dominant economic class
the law is a state instrument that maintains the existing social and economic order
crime control occurs through institutions established and administered by the elite
contradictions in capitalism require that the lower classes remain oppressed by the law
the collapse of capitalism and creation of a socialist society will solve crimes
marx view on privilege
linked crime to differentials in privilege- rights of life, liberty, and happiness; traits of intelligence, sensitivity, and humanity; material goods of monetary wealth, luxuries, and land
how violence and coercion are used are the main factors determining which social groups gets to define and hold privilege
structural marxism
maintains the overall capitalist system, not just the rights of few
disagrees with the view that the relationship between law and capitalism always works for people who are rich and against people who are poor
law is designed to keep the capitalist system operating efficiently and anyone who rocks the boat will be sanctioned
law defines any person who disturbs or hinders capitalist modes of appropriating the product of human labor, process of socialization, capitalist ideology, etc into question as deviant
ways of dealing with those oppose operation of capitalism (instrumental marxism)
normalize formerly illegal acts
conversion - co-opting deviants by making them part of the system
containment involves segregating deviants into isolated geographic areas so they can be easily controlled
supports some criminal enterprises, such as organized crime through money laundering
critique of marxist criminology
the old tradition of helping the underdog
capitalism is blamed for every human vibe and for predatory and personal crime
overlooks the distinctions between people in different classes
suspects even those practices and freedoms that most people cherish as the cornerstones of democracy
left realism
crime is a problem experienced by the poor, and crime prevention strategies would help
basic principles of left realism
crime is a symbol of the antisocial nature of capitalism
the relationship with the public determines the efficacy of policing
the relationship between the victim and offender determines the impact of crime
the relationship between the state and the offender is a major factor in recidivism
relative deprivation leads to discontent, lack of solutions leads to crime
local crime surveys provide the best measure of crime in any one area
anti crime strategies should be short term and avoid crime control solutions
pre-emptive deterrence
community organization efforts can reduce crime before it is necessary to use police force
aim to reduce the number of marginalized youth
marxist feminism
capitalism is based on private property, male domination, and the exploitation of women
gender inequality stems from unequal power of men and women in a capitalist society
origin of gender differences can be traced to the development of private property and male domination of the laws of inheritance
women are controlled be capitalism and are economically and biologically controlled by men: double marginality
capitalism renders women powerless, they are forced to commit less serious, nonviolent, self destructive crimes, such as drug abuse
radical feminism
the view that female crime is caused by male patriarchy and the subordination and control of women by men
sexual and physical exploitation of young girls may cause the girls to run away or abuse substances, both of which are labeled as deviant behavior
the female criminal herself is a victim
many girls involved in delinquency, crime, and violence have themselves been the victims in their youth and later as adults
power control theory
crime and delinquency rates are a function of class position (power) and family functions (control)
radical feminist model
uses class and gender differences to explain the onset of criminality
paternalistic families: male siblings exhibit more delinquent behaviors
egalitarian families: daughters law-violating behaviors mirror that of her brothers
implies that middle class youth of both sexes will have higher crime rates than their lower-class peers
deconstructionism
the analysis of language to see how racism or sexism become institutionalized
semiotics
language is a set of signs that describe the world by conveying shared meanings
restorative justice
mediation as an alternative to the court system to heal personal injury and community
emphasizes a holistic response to crime
the needs of victims, offenders, and communities can only be met in smaller, less formal, and more cohesive social groups
three principles of restorative justice
community ownership of conflict (including crime)
material and symbolic reparation for victims and the community
social reintegration of the offender
peacemaking criminology
a restorative approach that stresses mediation and conflict resolution to end crime
believes that the main purpose of criminology is to promote a just and peaceful society
promotes idea that mutual aid rather than coercive punishment is key to a harmonious society
summary of Unsettled Times: Indigenous Incarceration and Links
high rates of indigenous incarceration reflect how colonialistic structures and logics persist today, colonial logics made invisible a construction of the colonized as inferior that subordinated their welfare to the colonizer
to manage colonies, penitentiaries would be erected in more populated areas within 5-7 years of joining the federation, racial themes of pathology and contamination (colonial logic) in penal administration to segregate populations
labor in the penitentiary was instrumental, abuse and punishment in residential schools, and prevention of indigenous mobility through pass system
post-war era shifted colonialism from overt domination to a cultural model of acknowledgement while the same colonizing relationship that subordinates Indigenous interests to the state was retained
new knowledge around the “native criminal”, negative stereo types and rapid prison growth causing increasing rates of indigenous incarceration
penal advances and expansion acting in tandem with the receding of formal colonization practices, the prison took over as the new expression of colonialism
modern colonialism
extracted tribute, goods, and wealth from the countries that it conquered and consisted of a restructuring of local economies, markets and governance
4 main products of modern colonialism
the racialization of relations between colonizers and colonized, as well as sex, class, and age, among others
the formation of a new capitalist system of exploitation that included slavery, servitude, and simple commodity production
eurocentrism as the new mode of production and control, with subjectivity developed within the experience of the colonizer
the establishment of the nation-state as anew system of control and collective authority
epistemic violence
a repressive ordering that has become such a pervasive part of our modern ontological fabric and psyche that we hail to recognize its patterns or challenge its structures
politics of recognition
the now expansive range of recognition-based models of liberal pluralism that seek to reconcile Indigenous assertions of nationhood with settler state sovereignty
methods within Unsettled Times: Indigenous Incarceration and Links
The policing of modern logics within the penitentiary was achieved through a micro-regulation over labor and economics, moral instruction and schooling, and the health of the body
Medical practitioners were interested in solving the “Indian problem” by constructing malnutrition as evidence of laziness and apathy
Indigenous mobility was restricted through a pass system whereby Indian agent authorization and regular reporting to the police chief was required to travel off-reserve
Recommended Native programming including community liaison, after-care support, legal advocacy, less policing, reduced jail sentences for liquor offenses, the expansion of existing criminal justice services, the hiring of native people in the system, the elimination of residential schools, and addressing treaty and land rights
summary of crime, media, culture - modern serial killers
serial killing usually has individualized focus on the aetiology (the cause, set of causes, or manner of causation of disease or condition) and biography of particular offenders, serial killers are distinctively modern
several distinctively modern phoneme, including anonymity, rationality, and the mass media, provide the key institutional frameworks, motivations, and opportunity structures characteristics of contemporary forms of serial killings
Murderers embrace and reproduce the wider cultural codings that have devalued, stigmatized, and marginalized specific groups reflecting back and acting upon modernity’s distinctive valuations
mass media and its effects on serial killers
Mass media is a vital component of serial killing, fosters a culture of celebrity (like Ted Bundy), provides a symbiotic relationship (opportunities to capture public's attention by capitalizing on the themes of serial killing while giving the serial killer attention)
Anonymity and its affects on serial killers
Increased social anonymity is a fundamental precondition for the rise of serial murderers because strangers are candidates for potential victimization, pre-modern villages people knew each other
rationalization and its affects on serial killers
The rational strategizing about murder can one of the most integral and pleasurable aspects of killing itself, modern subjects are involved in an elaborate process of role playing