Tube 1, the control, should remain orange - no photosynthesis or respiration should have occurred therefore CO2 concentration remains normal
Tube 2, in foil, should turn from orange to yellow - no light, therefore no photosynthesis should have taken place, therefore only respiration occurred, producing CO2 and increasing CO2 concentration in the tube
Tube 3, in gauze, should have remained orange - a little photosynthesis and respiration should have occurred, therefore roughly equal amounts of CO2 will be taken up and produced by the leaf, so the CO2 concentration in the tube won't change much
Tube 4, uncovered, should have turned from orange to purple - there will be some respiration, but photosynthesis at a far greater rate, therefore there would be a net uptake of CO2 by the leaf, lowering CO2 concentration in the tube