Intentional torts

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/19

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

20 Terms

1
New cards

Stephens v Myers [1830] 4 C&P 349

  • C was acting as a chairman in a parish meeting.

  • Sat 6 people away from the defendant on a table.

  • Defendant was aggressive and motion was passed that he turned to be out of the meeting.

  • After that the D threatened the C but was restrained by the person in between them.

  • Claimants action was assault = court held that an assault had been committed.

  • Restrainment was irrelevant.

  • Apprehension of immediate and unlawful force is sufficient as assault.


2
New cards

Tuberville v Savage [1669] I Mod 3

  • D blinded by the C by poking his sword in the Cs eye.

  • Hand had been placed on the sword = could be assault but this was negated by the accompanying words which made it clear he would not inflict immediate and unlawful force on the claimant themselves.


3
New cards

Thomas v National Union of Miners (South Wales Area) [1986] ch20

  • Miners were bussed into work through an angry picket line.

  • People in the picket line made violent threatening gestures to the people in the bus.

  • It was held there was no assault on the basis the threats could not be carried out because the mine workers were protected by protective shields placed on the bus and the presence of police.


4
New cards

R v ‘Ireland; R v ‘burstow (1998) Ac 147

  • Appellant made 3 large phone calls to women and remained silent when they answered.

  • Psychiatrists examined the women and said they suffered psychological damage.

  • Second appellant directed harassing conduct towards women with whom he had previously had a social relationship.

  • For 8 months made silent phone calls to her.

  • Distributed offensive cards in the street where she lived.

  • Sent her many notes.

  • Appeared at home and place of work.

  • Took photos of her.

  • She suffered from depression as a result.

    • One question for the HOLs was; whether the making of a series of silent phone calls could amount to assault?

    • They held: yes, silent caller may cause the victim to apprehend immediate and unlawful personal violence as the nature of the act is uncertain of his or her actions.


5
New cards

Falange v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [1969] 1 QB 439

  • Defendant was instructed by a policeman to park his car in order for the policeman to ask him questions.

  • Defendant drove car onto the policemans foot.

  • The defendant declined after being askesd several times to do so to remove the vehicle from his foot.

    • Q was there a battery? failure to rectify situation = batter? yes.

    • Convicted of criminal offence.


6
New cards

Livingstone v Ministry of Defence [1984] NI 356 NICA

Transferred intetntion:

  • Soldier fired a baton band at a rioter but missed and hit the claimant.

    • Intention to hit the rioter was transferred to the claminate who was able to establish a claimant battery unless the force could be justified.


7
New cards

Collins v Wilcock

  • Interference with a persons body will only be lawful if consented to however, there is a broad exception on the basis that certain forms of contact are unavailable and therefore acceptable


8
New cards

Wilson v Pringle (1987) QB 237

  • Claimant and defendant were both school boys.

  • C was injured when D pulled Cs bag from his shoulder.

  • D claimed his actions were horse play and that no injury was intended.

  • C argued the intention to cause injury was irrelevant, only had to be intentional application of force.

    • Case went to the COA: Q was what did the C have to prove?

    • A) Intentional touching or contact in one form or another of the C by the D.

    • B) That the touching was hostile.

    • Q was how do you prove hostility?

      • (Does NOT have to be hostile to amount to battery).


9
New cards

Re F; F v West Berkshire Health Authority (1990) 2AC 1

  • Consent to a surgical operation where the patient was suffering a serious mental disability.

  • Surgical treatment without the consent of someone legally entitled to give consent on his or her behalf or other legal authority (court) is battery.

  • Intention must be proved, intended to commit the act that amounts to battery, intention to injure is not necessary.


10
New cards

Chatteron v Gerson (1981) 1 QB 432

  • Claimant had operation to relieve pain, did not work and worsened issue by causing additoinal loss of sensation.

  • Sued the surgeon in both trespassand negligence.

  • Both claims failed

  • she argued she consented to the operation yet she wasnt given a proper explanation of the risks which materialised into the loss of sensation.

  • Courts held claimant was explained broadly in terms of the procedure- which was consented.

    • (sufficient in 1981- not anymore)


11
New cards

R v Billinghurst (1978) Crim LR 553 (criminal and civil case)

  • Off the ball punching in a rugby match.

  • D was convicted of the crime of assault.

  • D argued that this was a physical game and one could expect this to happen during the game.

    • When you consent to sport you consent to the rules of the game! Not being punched of the ball.

SPORT

12
New cards

R v Brown (1993) 2 WLR 556 (Criminal and civil proceedings)

  • Sex activities conducted in private between a consented couple.

  • Acts caused significant injuries.

  • Case went to HOL where convictions for assault, ABH and malicious wounding were upheld.

    • Defence was consent yet majority in HOLDs (2/3) held the defence did not apply where injury was caused in the course of these sado acts and it wasnt in the publics interest to encourage this.


13
New cards

Cockroft v Smith (1705) 2 SALK 64

Claimant was a clerk of the court and during scuffle the claimant attened to poke the defendant in the eye.

  • In response the defendant bit off the claimants finger

  • Lord Justice Holt concluded the force used was unreasonable.

SELF-DEFENCE MUST BE REASONABLE AND PROPORTIONATE.



14
New cards

Ashley v Chief constable of Sussex Police [2008] UKHL 25

  • Ashley had been fatally shot by the police during an armed raid.

  • Claimant= son and father of the deceased brought actions against the chief constable alleging amongst other things in negligence, assault and battery.

  • Chief constable conceded liability for negligence and for all compensatory damages flowing from then shooting itself.

  • Issue= was the defence of SD available?

  • where the assailant held the honest and genuine belief that he was in danger even though such belief was unreasonable.

  • Constable argued that the criteria for SD in civil law should be the same as in criminal law.


15
New cards

Leigh v Gladstone (1909) 26 TLR 130

  • C was a suffraget in prison on a hunger strike.

  • Forcibly fed in prison by staff.

  • Argued battery.

  • Held: act of prison staff was lawful on the basis they use the minimum necessary force to save her life otherwise she’d have starved to death in custody.

Necessity: force used is the minimum necessary force used to preserve life.


16
New cards

Imprisonment

The complete restriction of claimants freedom of movement without lawful excuse.


R v Governor of Brockhill Prison, ex party Evans (No.2) [2001]

  • If a prisoner is detained for a longer period sanctioned by the law they can argue false imprisonment.

Bird v Jones 1845

  • Reasonable means of escape → no claim for imprisonment.

  • Boat race on Thames.

  • D fenced off part of the bridge to view the race.

  • C was in the habit of crossing the bridge and climbed over the fence, insisting on taking his normal route.

  • Stopped by the D and told to go back the other way.

  • Alternative route was available = no false imprisonment


Meeting v Graham-White Aviation Co Ltd (1919)

  • C was employee of the D who suspected him of stealing paint.

  • C was not aware of suspicions.

  • Was asked to go with two police officers to the company office.

  • Without his knowledge the officers remained outside of the office.

  • Once he realised he sued for false imprisonment.

  • Contended no false imprisonment as the C could leave at any time as he was unaware of the officers outside.

  • COA disagreed and held that the Tort could be committed even tho the C was not aware he was being detained at the present time.


Robinson v Balmain New Ferry Company Ltd (1910)

  • C paid D to enter a wharf to board a ferry.

  • Changed his mind and tried to go back.

  • Paid further money to exit → condition to enter a wharf.

  • Held to be no imprisonment.


Here v Weardale Steel, coal and coke Co Ltd (1915)

  • Shortly after commencement of shift a coal miner declined to continue working on the grounds they believed it was unsafe and asked to be released.

  • His employers employers refused to send the lift down for him.

  • Employers sued the worker for breach of contract.

  • Worker counter-claimed in respect of his detention.

  • Held he went to the pit under the agreed conditions of the contract, he had no right to call upon his employers to make use of special machinery at their cost to neigh him to the surface when he pleased.


17
New cards

Wilkinson v Downton [1897]

Doctrine

  • As a practical joke the D falsely told C her husband had been involved in an accident and suffered two broken legs.

  • As a result the C suffered vomiting and her hair turned white.

  • She also suffered nervous shock.

  • Action could not be brought in trespass as there was no contact or physical force.

  • Courts didn’t recognise liability for negligence in nervous shock at the time.

  • Courts held a tort has been committed but doesn’t fall under the existing categories.

Suffered intentional infliction onto their mental state the rule applies.


18
New cards

Janvier v Sweeny [1919]

  • Private detective pretended to be a police officer and threatened the C that she was in danger of an arrest for associating with a German spy (her finance) as a result the C suffered psychiatric harm and was awarded compensation on the basis of the rule of Wilkinson v Downton.



19
New cards

Wainwright v Home Office [2003]

  • Mother and son visited a prison.

  • They were subjected to an unnecessarily embarrassing strip search in contravention to the prison rules.

  • Mother was unable to recover in the basis she suffered from emotional distress and not from a recognised psychiatric illness emotional distress did not suffice.

  • Son who had learning difficulties was diagnosed with post traumatic stress disorder.

    • HOL did not allow a remedy as they held the officer did not intend to cause harm.


20
New cards

O v A [2015]

Three elements; A conduct element, a mental element and a consequence element.

  • C was a well known pianist and author who had written an auto biography.

  • D suffered horrific sexual abuse as a child and wrote about it in graphic detail in the book.

  • The Ds ex-wide attempted to prevent the D from publishing on the basis their son would suffer psychological harm and publishing would amount to the intentional infliction of harm (w v D)

    • SC noted that the Tort required words of conduct directed at the C fr which their was no justification or lawful excuse.

    • On the facts of freedom of expression the D had the right to publish it.

    • In relation to the intention requirement: the court confirmed it was necessary to prove intention to cause psychological damage.

    • It was sufficient to prove the D intended to cause ere emotional distress so long as the result of the conduct was a recognised psychiatric illness