Source paper

What is the message of source A?

1 para: The message of source A is… ; 2/3 pieces of ev; explain big picture POV

Why was source A published in year X? Use details from the source and your own knowledge.

1 para: Source A was published in year X bc…; 2/3 pieces of ev; contextual knowledge; what is author trying to achieve

How far does source B support source A?

3 para: agree, disagree, conclusion. No eval of prov. Inference as well as quotation

Does source D mean that source C is unreliable? Explain using sources and OK

3 paras: compare content, compare provenance, conc.

How far does A prove B wrong? Source + OK

3 paras: how far on basis of content, how far on basis of prov, judgement (usually not completely proven wrong)

Do you think these two cartoons were published for the same reason? Use sources and OK

3 paras: Explain purpose of A (content+prov), explain purpose of B (content+prov), conc do they have a common purpose

Are you surprised by the cartoonist’s attitude towards X in source B? Sources + OK

3 paras: Surprised by B (content, prov, consider OK+source A), not surprised by B (“”), conc how surprised

Study A and B. Which is more useful as evidence about X? Sources + OK

3 paras: utility of X (useful for what? Consider content+prov), utility of Y (“”), conc (more useful for dif aspects)

How far do you trust this source? Sources + OK

3 paras: ways in which u do trust (content+prov), don’t trust (“), conc

Study all of the sources… how far do these sources provide convincing evidence that “”?

4 paras: INTRO - outline two groups of agree + disagree sources

P1 - Explain how agree sources support statement. Use prov to briefly explain whether u trust them. Choose 1-2 sources that have juicy prov to explain.

P2 - “” for disagree. Explain 1 or 2 provs, do u trust them

CONC: Overall which one is more convincing

What to do if running out of time for the 9-marker

Cover both sides. You can dump some sources. 2 sources per side gets at least 6 marks