ap seminar tmp

Establish Argument 3

Establish Argument 3

The presentation conveys the argument for the team’s solution or resolution using evidence that is not well selected for the situation.

Establishing Argument 4

The presentation conveys the convincing argument for the team’s solution or resolution through strategic selection of supporting evidence

Understand and Analyze Context (Evaluate Solutions) 2

The presentation describes pros and/or cons of potential options related to the topic

OR

The presentation describes limitations or implications of the solution proposed by the team, but in an inconsistent, illogical, overly broad, or otherwise unconvincing manner

Understand and Analyze Context (Evaluate Solutions) 3

The presentation explains the pros and/or cons of potential options and situates the team’s proposed solution in conversation with them

AND

The presentation evaluates the solution proposed by the team by thoroughly explaining its limitations or implications

Engage Audience (Performance) 3

At times, some presenters (ie more than one) effectively engage the audience. As a team the presenters demonstrate uneven delivery or performance techniques

Engage Audience (Performance) 4

All presenters effectively engage the audience through strategic intentional use of performance techniques most of the time

Engage Audience (Design) 2

The presentation design demonstrates am understanding of media and design elements but does not enhance the team’s message, or does so inconsistently

Engage Audience (Design) 4

Overall, the design clearly guides viewers through the presentation and demonstrates strategic selection of media and design elements that help clarify the argument for the team’s solution

Collaborate Reflect 2

Two or more of the responses in the oral defense support their answers with some relevant evidence specific to the team’s project

Collaborate Reflect 3

All responses in the oral defense articulate detailed answers to the question asked and support those answers with relevant evidence specific to collaboration on this project

AND

The answers in the oral defense taken together with the presentation demonstrate roughly equal participation from all team members