R - Rutherford B. Hayes; D - Samuel Tilden; Rutherford B. Hayes had 165 votes and Samuel Tildon had 184; The required amount of votes is 185; there were 20 votes left if Tilden won one state he would win; 15-person commission, within the people there, are 7 Dem. and 7 Rep. and 1 Ind.; Democrats gave the independent person a new position so he goes to their side, but instead, he leaves and his replacement is a republican; Rutherford won; 82% voter turnout