Intentional Torts: Business Torts
3
Learning Outcomes
After completing this chapter, you should be able to:
Explain the basic elements of several intentional torts focused on interference with business and contracts.
Explain the elements and differences between the various torts focused on false statements.
Understand how these torts may be used to remedy wrongs associated with business and economic interests.
34
Introduction
The torts described in this chapter are more commonly pleaded by businesses in circumstances involving harm to their economic interests. This chapter begins by covering torts that apply where the defendant makes a false statement, then goes on to describe torts that are relevant where there has been an improper interference with a person’s business or contractual interests.
Deceit
Deceit, also known as “civil fraud,” is a tort with a well-known counterpart in criminal law.1 As such, a person who commits fraud may face criminal prosecution as well as a civil lawsuit since a criminal prosecution does not provide financial compensation to the victim of the fraud.
A defendant commits deceit where:
The defendant makes a false representation.
The defendant knows or believes the representation was false, or is reckless as to its truth.
The defendant intends the plaintiff to act, and the plaintiff does act, on the representation. Essentially, the plaintiff relies on the defendant’s statement.
The plaintiff suffers a loss.2
For example, assume that you’ve just opened a retail clothing store. To increase business among parents of school-aged children, your supplier offers discounts to retailers who advertise to parents through online ads and whose sales of children’s clothes make up a certain percentage of their sales. Despite the fact that you do not advertise to parents nor sell much in the way in children’s clothes, you tell your supplier that you meet all the conditions for the discount, knowing this to be false. You are thus given the discount, which saves you thousands of dollars.
In this case, you may have committed deceit, as you knowingly lied to the wholesaler to receive a discount that would not otherwise have applied in your situation. The wholesaler acted on your lie, gave you the discount, and earned less than that to which it was entitled.
Deceit may also be committed if someone states a “half-truth” that is misleading because it leaves out important information.3 For example, consider a situation where you are purchasing property from someone who told you that they were unaware of any restrictions on the use of property. While the seller may not have actually known of any restrictions, they may have been deceitful in failing to tell you that they never checked the deed or zoning. Deceit may also occur where a statement was true when it was made but became false due to a change in circumstances.4
deceit
a tort involving a false representation that is relied on by another person, causing them to suffer a loss
35
The tort of deceit overlaps with the contractual defect of fraudulent misrepresentation, with which it shares a similar test. Fraudulent misrepresentation is essentially a deception intended to induce the plaintiff into entering into a contract. Since fraudulent misrepresentation is a contractual defect, the available remedies, including recission of the contract, are different than those of deceit.5 Fraudulent misrepresentation is covered in Chapter 14.
FACT SCENARIO
You are an author who develops a series of kids’ books featuring what becomes a very popular character known as Clara Beara (a cute, furry bear who likes to ice skate). XYZ Inc, a TV production company, wants to licence the Clara character for a new TV show. You eventually sign a contract with XYZ that gives them permission to use your intellectual property from the books, including the characters and storylines, in return for a royalty of 25 percent of the show’s profit.
Things go well for a couple of years, and you receive annual payments for your portion of the profits. Last year, for example, XYZ earned a profit of $1 million on the Clara Beara TV series, which entitled you to a payment of $250,000. However, you have recently learned that XYZ underreported its profits for the last year so as to reduce the amount it paid you. In fact, the Clara Beara TV series actually made $5 million last year. Thus, you should have received $1.25 million in royalties.
Do you have an action in deceit?
Defamation
The tort of defamation is intended to protect against unjustified assaults to a person’s reputation.6 Defamation involves making a false statement about someone that “tends to lower [that] person in the estimation of right-thinking members of society.”7
To prove defamation, a plaintiff must establish three elements:8
That the defendant’s words would tend to “lower the plaintiff’s reputation in the eyes of a reasonable person.”9
That the words referred to the plaintiff. This means the words must be specific enough to support a reasonable inference that they referred to the plaintiff. It is not defamation to spread untrue rumours about dishonest politicians generally, but a comment about “dishonest city councillors from the west end who oppose expansion of the downtown subway system and drive a giant black 2011 Cadillac Escalade” could be defamation if a particular councillor fits this description.10
defamation
a false statement about someone that lowers their reputation
36
That the words were published. Publication means that the words are communicated, and specifically that the words are “both sent in a comprehensible form, and received and understood” by someone other than the plaintiff.11 As such, an otherwise defamatory statement made only to the plaintiff is not defamation.
There are two types of defamation: libel, which involves making a defamatory statement by publishing or broadcasting it, and slander, which involves making an oral defamatory statement. Notably, defamatory words in a newspaper or broadcast are deemed to be published even in the absence of proof that anyone actually received the communication.12 Further, in a claim for defamation, the plaintiff is not required to prove that the defendant intended to harm the plaintiff, and proving the elements above will generally result in a presumption that the words were false and, in the case of libel, damaging.13 In regard to slander, special damages must be proven except in specific circumstances.
As outlined in Chapter 4, there are a number of defences to defamation, including:
justification (the defendant’s statements were true),
absolute privilege (the statements were made in circumstances that the law protects from claims of defamation),
qualified privilege (occasions where the defendant had a duty to make the statement and made it in good faith),
fair comment (the statement was an opinion made on a matter of public interest), and
responsible communication (the statement was on a matter of public interest and made responsibly).
The Criminal Code also contains provisions regarding “defamatory libel.”14
FACT SCENARIO
This scenario is taken from Hee Creations Group Ltd v Chow, 2018 BCSC 260
The plaintiff, a wedding services business, claimed that the defendants defamed it in a number of social media posts. The posts were partly a result of the defendants’ unhappiness with the pre-wedding photographs the plaintiff had taken. The social media posts suggested that the plaintiff, among other things, was deceitful, engaged in dishonesty and bait-and-switch practices, and destroyed evidence. As a result, the plaintiff’s business suffered as new business dried up. While the statements at issue were untrue, there was no direct evidence that they were read by a third party in British Columbia.
Based on what you know from the facts above, do you think the plaintiff has a case for defamation?
While you have yet to learn about defences to defamation, based on what you know so far, do you think it’s fair that someone can sue over a social media post? Do you think this unduly affects your freedom to express yourself?
libel
a defamatory statement that is published or broadcast
slander
an oral defamatory statement
special damages
damages that are known and described at the time of trial
37
Injurious Falsehood and Slander of Title
While defamation is focused on false statements that harm a person’s reputation, injurious falsehood, sometimes referred to as “malicious falsehood,” is typically focused on false statements that harm a person’s products or services.
The basic formula for injurious falsehood is as follows:
The defendant published a false statement that reflects negatively on the plaintiff’s business, property, or title to property. Unlike defamation, the statement is not presumed to be false, and the plaintiff must prove both publication and falsity.15
The statement is calculated to induce others not to deal with the plaintiff.
The statement is made maliciously.
The plaintiff suffered special damages, such as loss of business.16 This requirement to prove actual damages has been waived by statute in certain circumstances.17
As an example, consider the case of two competing manufacturers of acne cream. In a bid to increase its own market share, one manufacturer uses social media to disseminate false claims that the other manufacturer’s product causes undesirable side effects such as rashes and hair loss. As a result of the claims, sales of the competitor manufacturer’s acne cream decrease, leading to financial losses. This conduct may constitute injurious falsehood.
Slander of title, meanwhile, is a form of injurious falsehood concerned with false statements in respect of the plaintiff’s real property. Specifically, in a case of slander of title, the false statements result in the plaintiff being unable to sell the property or receiving a lower price on sale.18 Examples of slander of title include improperly registering a lien or caution on the title of a property19 and claiming that the plaintiff’s house was haunted.20
Passing Off
Whereas injurious falsehood typically involves the defendant alleging fault with the plaintiff’s goods or services, the tort of passing off is the highest form of flattery. Passing off occurs when a defendant attempts to benefit from the plaintiff’s goodwill or reputation by bringing to market goods of its own that are confusingly similar to those of the plaintiff.21
injurious falsehood
false statements about the plaintiff’s product, services, or property that causes a loss of business
slander of title
a category of injurious falsehood involving false statements about the plaintiff’s property that causes the plaintiff to be unable to sell the property or to receive a lower price on sale
passing off
attempting to benefit from the plaintiff’s goodwill or reputation by selling goods that are confusingly similar to those of the plaintiff
38
To prove an action for passing off, the plaintiff must establish three elements:
The existence of goodwill. Goodwill has been described as the “positive association that attracts customers towards its owner’s wares or services rather than those of its competitors.”22
Deception of the public due to a misrepresentation. This false representation by the defendant may be intentional, negligent, or careless and may involve the use of a logo, a product design, or packaging that is confusingly similar to the plaintiff’s.
Actual or potential damage to the plaintiff.23
Goods sold in this manner are commonly referred to as “knock-offs.” For example, if you sold purses with a logo or pattern similar to that of a well-known brand to confuse the public into believing they were purchasing authentic purses, you would likely be committing the tort of passing off. Local brands, however, may find it difficult to prove goodwill if knock-offs are sold in a different geographical area. For example, a restaurant with a sole Toronto location may not be able to establish that it has goodwill with Vancouver customers if it attempts to sue a similarly named Vancouver restaurant.24
Registering a trademark may thus be of assistance in cases where a business wants to protect its name, slogan, or logo. A registered trademark gives the owner protection across Canada, and unlike in an action for passing off, the plaintiff in a trademark infringement action does not need to prove goodwill. For these reasons, well-known brands will typically register trademarks with respect to logos, patterns, and other distinctive elements of their products, and actions in respect of infringing logos will be for trademark infringement rather than passing off.
TABLE 3.1 A Comparison of Torts Based on False Representations
The Defendant Says/Does:
The Applicable Tort:
The defendant is dishonest in telling the plaintiff that her sales amounted to $100,000 for the year so as to pay less in royalties
Deceit
“Charles committed theft. I saw him do it.”
Defamation
“ZitAway Cream will give you a rash and cause your hair to fall out! Buy our product instead!”
Injurious falsehood
The defendant improperly places a lien on your house
Injurious falsehood (slander of title)
The defendant sells you a knock-off purse that has the well-known logo of a French company on its packaging
Passing off
39
Intimidation
YOU BE THE JUDGE
You have just graduated from college and are planning to satisfy your lifelong dream to open a fast-food restaurant in downtown Toronto. You have chosen a prime location and have started to purchase inventory. Unfortunately, the owner of a nearby restaurant is unhappy at the prospect of competition and threatens to burn down your restaurant if you open as planned. You take the threat seriously and decide that owning a restaurant is not worth the risk. You thus cancel your plans. Has the owner of the nearby restaurant committed a tort?
In this scenario, you may be able to sue for the tort of intimidation. While the competing restaurant owner never actually made good on his threat, the threat itself may be actionable.
To prove intimidation, the plaintiff must establish that:
the defendant intended to injure the plaintiff or a third party;
the defendant made a threat to the plaintiff such that the plaintiff’s non-compliance would result in the defendant committing an unlawful act (including a criminal act, a tort, or breach of contract)25 against the plaintiff;
as a result of the threat, the plaintiff does something they wouldn’t have done otherwise or refrains from doing something they are otherwise entitled to do; and
the plaintiff or a third party suffers damages.26
The tort has been described as “a civil form of extortion.”27 In the scenario above, you would likely be able to establish that intimidation occurred since the restaurant owner’s threat to commit arson and destroy your premises resulted in you cancelling your plans to open your restaurant. You would not be able to make a case for intimidation, however, if the threat had no effect on your plans and you opened the restaurant anyway. Further, it would not be intimidation if someone threatened to do something that was not unlawful. Thus, it would not be intimidation if you threatened to sue a supplier for breach of contract where the supplier refused to deliver the goods you ordered.
Inducing Breach of Contract
YOU BE THE JUDGE
You sign a five-year lease with a landlord known as ABC Corp. You intend to use the space to operate a business. One year into the five-year term, another property owner (let’s call them XYZ Corp) offers to lease you space in their building. XYZ knows that you have an existing contract and wants to make it worth your while to move, so the company offers to charge you half the rent you’re currently paying. The offer is too good to pass up, so you breach your current lease and move your business to XYZ’s premises. Has XYZ committed a tort?
intimidation
a threat that causes the plaintiff to do something they wouldn’t have done otherwise or refrain from doing something they are otherwise entitled to do
40
In the above scenario, ABC will probably want to pursue you for breach of contract (a topic covered later in this textbook). But it may also want to sue XYZ for its role in convincing you to breach your lease agreement. In that respect, the tort of inducing breach of contract may be relevant.
The tort of inducing a breach of contract involves four elements:
The plaintiff had a valid and enforceable contract with a third party.
The defendant was aware of the existence of this contract.
The defendant intended to and did procure the breach of the contract. This element is established if the defendant acts with a desire to cause the breach or “with the substantial certainty that a breach of contract would result”28 from its conduct.
The plaintiff suffered damages as a result.29
Thus, a prospective employer who offered you a job would not be inducing a breach of contract if they had no idea that you were already employed. Further, it would not be inducing a breach of contract if the prospective employer simply gave you information about their company or offered to hire you after you complied with the termination provisions in your current employment contract by providing your current employer the required amount of notice. Presumably, in neither of these cases would the prospective employer be acting with an intention of procuring a breach of contract.
Where the elements above have been met, the defendant may have the defence of justification. While it is not justification to serve one’s own business interests, justification may apply in cases of public interest30 or where the defendant is acting “with a right conferred by contract or a duty imposed … by competent authority.”31 For example, the defence of justification may protect a doctor who encouraged a patient to breach a contract for health-related reasons.32
FACT SCENARIO
You make $120,000 per year working as a software engineer for a social media company called InstaPic. Under your contract of employment, you agree to give the company 30 days’ notice before leaving the company.
You are, however, unhappy with your job and begin to look for opportunities elsewhere. After interviewing with rival social media companies, one called Flitter offers you $200,000 per year to work for them. While they know that you are currently employed by InstaPic, Flitter make it clear that your employment will only begin after your notice period with InstaPic has passed. So you give InstaPic notice and work your last 30 days at the company before starting to work at Flitter.
When InstaPic finds out you were induced to quit with an offer of a higher salary, they threaten to sue Flitter for inducing breach of contract. Do they have a case?
inducing breach of contract
intentional incitement to breach a contract
41
Unlawful Means Tort
YOU BE THE JUDGE
You’ve just opened a bakery. A popular local restaurant, Wanda’s Sandwiches, regularly buys bread from you. While there is no contract between you and Wanda’s, the restaurant is an important customer and buys many of the loaves you bake every day. One day, however, Wanda’s stops purchasing from you entirely, resulting in a drastic drop in your revenue. It turns out that a competing bakery called Belinda’s Baked Goods, wanting to put you out of business, burned down Wanda’s. Deprived of your biggest customer, your business struggles, and Belinda’s expands in your area.
You can’t sue Belinda’s for inducing a breach of contract since there was no contract between you and Wanda’s. However, Belinda’s has deprived you of a customer, not through fair competition, but by doing something unlawful. Can you sue Belinda’s?
In the above scenario, you may be able to bring an action against Belinda’s. The unlawful means tort, sometimes known as “intentional interference with economic relations,” occurs where the following two conditions are met:
The defendant uses unlawful means against a third party. This means that the defendant’s conduct was an actionable civil wrong that would give rise to a cause of action by the third party (even if the third party suffered no loss).33 Criminal offences and breaches of a statute would thus not qualify.34
The defendant intended to harm the plaintiff through the use of the unlawful means. In considering intention, it is not enough that “the harm to the plaintiff be an incidental consequence of the defendant’s conduct, even where the defendant realizes that it is extremely likely that harm to the plaintiff may result.”35
FIGURE 3.1 The “Parasitic” Nature of the Unlawful Means Tort
Illustrating the parasitic nature of the unlawful means tort. In the fact scenario described above, Belinda’s tort against Wanda’s, committed with the intention of harming you, allows you to sue Belinda’s.
unlawful means tort
using unlawful means against a third party to harm the plaintiff
42
In the case above, Belinda’s conduct included trespassing and conversion against a third party (Wanda’s), both of which are civil causes of action. Further, Belinda’s committed these unlawful acts with the intention of causing you economic damages. As such, you likely have an action against Belinda’s for the unlawful means tort, even though Belinda’s didn’t directly commit an act against your property. In this sense, the unlawful means tort is “parasitic” in that your claim against Belinda’s is dependent on Wanda’s having a civil claim against Belinda’s.
Conspiracy
Conspiracy is a tort designed to provide for liability where a group of people act together to injure the plaintiff. Specifically, conspiracy occurs where the defendants, working in combination (either by agreement or with a “common design”), engage in lawful or unlawful conduct with the predominant purpose of injuring the plaintiff, and as a result, the plaintiff suffers a loss. Notably, the tort of conspiracy may occur even where the defendants’ conduct is otherwise lawful.36 On the other hand, where the defendants engage in unlawful conduct, the predominant purpose need not have been to injure the plaintiff. The defendants will be held liable where they engaged in conduct directed at the plaintiff and they knew (or should have known) that injury was likely to result.37
Thus, there are two distinct types of conspiracy: predominant purpose conspiracy and unlawful means conspiracy.
FIGURE 3.2 Predominate Purpose vs Unlawful Means Conspiracies
conspiracy
a tort that is committed by defendants acting in concert to injure the plaintiff
predominant purpose conspiracy
a type of conspiracy where the defendants’ actions, whether lawful or unlawful, are done for the predominant purpose of injuring the plaintiff
unlawful means conspiracy
a type of conspiracy whereby the defendants, acting in concert, engage in unlawful conduct directed at the plaintiff with knowledge that their acts would likely result in injury to the plaintiff; “unlawful” conduct may be criminal conduct or a private wrong
43
As an illustration, imagine that Charlie and Elaine, angry that a department store carries fur, decide to break into the store in the middle of the night and spill red paint on merchandise. On the chosen night, Charlie breaks the store’s window and waits outside as Elaine climbs in to spill red paint around the store. Since trespassing, breaking windows, and destroying merchandise are unlawful acts, this would be an unlawful means conspiracy. The test for the tort would be met if Charlie and Elaine knew their acts would likely result in injury to the store, even if their predominant purpose was not to injure the store but to instead gain publicity for animal welfare.
On the other hand, assume that Charlie and Elaine decide to organize a boycott of the store and spread the message on social media. There is nothing unlawful about encouraging others to stop shopping at a store, but the elements of the tort of conspiracy may be made out if their predominate purpose was to injure the store.
In reality, however, courts are hesitant to find liability in actions that are otherwise lawful, and they may instead find that the predominate purpose of such a boycott was to focus public attention on the cause of animal welfare rather than injuring the department store.38 If, however, a boycott were conducted by spreading defamatory falsehoods about the store or by inducing people to breach contracts with the store, Charlie and Elaine would certainly be committing torts, including an unlawful means conspiracy.39
CASE in POINT
PARTIES IN AN UNLAWFUL MEANS CONSPIRACY MUST ALL ACT UNLAWFULLY
Agribrands Purina Canada Inc v Kasamekas, 2011 ONCA 460, on appeal from 2010 ONSC 166
Walter Kasamekas and Raymond Jackson set up a company known as Raywalt Feed Sales and entered into a contract with Purina to become a Purina livestock feed dealer for a specific geographic territory. Despite the fact that the dealership agreement gave Raywalt exclusive rights to sell Purina feed in its territory, Purina continued to sell feed to Ren’s Feed Supplies, a former Purina dealer. After Purina stopped selling to Ren, Ren started buying feed from McGrath, a Purina dealer in a neighbouring territory. This allowed Ren to continue to resell feed in Raywalt’s territory. Raywalt ended up ceasing operations after less than a year in business and subsequently initiated a lawsuit that claimed, among other things, that Purina, Ren, and McGrath had engaged in a conspiracy.
At trial, the Superior Court found Purina liable for breaching its contract with Raywalt. In addition, the Court found that Purina, Ren, and McGrath had engaged in an unlawful means conspiracy. In doing so, the Court interpreted “unlawful means” to include not just a crime or tort, but conduct that a “defendant ‘is not at liberty’ or ‘not authorized’ to engage in.”40 While Ren and McGrath had not otherwise committed a tort, the Court found that they had engaged in unlawful and unauthorized conduct due to the fact that Ren was not authorized to purchase Purina feed for resale and McGrath was not entitled to resell feed to Ren.
On appeal, however, the Court of Appeal found that “unlawful” conduct for the purposes of such a conspiracy is limited to conduct that is “wrong in law.”41 Thus, while private acts like a breach of contract or tort would qualify, it would not include conduct that was simply “unauthorized.” As Ren and McGrath had not engaged in any unlawful conduct, the Court of Appeal set aside the trial court’s finding of conspiracy.
44
Establishing the tort of conspiracy in addition to other potential torts like trespass to land or trespass to chattels would be useful to the plaintiff in the scenario above, as it would allow the store to pursue both participants for the extent of the damages, even though only one of them was directly responsible for causing most of the losses. As such, Charlie could be held liable for the full extent of the damage to the store’s merchandise even though it was Elaine that actually damaged the goods.
TABLE 3.2 Summary of Business Torts
Business Torts
Definition
Example
Deceit
A false representation that the defendant knows or believes is false and that the defendant intends the plaintiff to act on
Lying to a wholesaler so you can get a discount to which you are not entitled
Defamation
A false statement about a person that tends to lower the person’s reputation in the eyes of a reasonable person
Falsely accusing someone of assaulting you
Injurious falsehood
A false statement made maliciously about a person’s product or services
Posting an online review of a competitor’s product that contains lies so that customers choose your product instead
Slander of title
A false statement about a person’s real property
Improperly registering a lien on a customer’s house so that they will be unable to sell
Passing off
Bringing to market goods that are confusingly similar to those of a reputable company
Selling purses that contain a logo similar to that of a well-known brand
Intimidation
A threat that causes the plaintiff to do something they wouldn’t have done otherwise or to refrain from doing something they are otherwise entitled to do
Telling the restaurant across the street that you will vandalize their property if they open for brunch on Sundays
Inducing breach of contract
Intentionally inciting someone to breach a contract
Encouraging someone to immediately leave their job to come work for you despite a work contract that requires them to provide notice
Unlawful means tort
Using unlawful means against a third party with the intention of harming the plaintiff
Burning down your competitor’s supplier so that your business improves
Predominant purpose conspiracy
Two or more people jointly engage in lawful or unlawful conduct with the predominant purpose of injuring the plaintiff and, as a result, the plaintiff suffers a loss
Organizing a boycott of a store for the purpose of reducing its business
Unlawful means conspiracy
Two or more people jointly engage in unlawful conduct directed at the plaintiff that they knew (or should have known) would likely cause injury
Acting with others to break into and vandalize a store
45
CHAPTER SUMMARY
This chapter introduced torts that generally involve an interference with business or contracts. Intentional torts that commonly arise in the context of business include deceit, defamation, slander of goods and title, passing off, intimidation, inducing breach of contract, the unlawful means tort, and conspiracy.
Deceit generally involves a false representation that the defendant knows or believes is false and that the defendant intends the plaintiff to act on. Deceit may involve half-truths or statements that are true when made but that later become false due to a change in circumstances.
Defamation is a false statement about a person that tends to lower the person’s reputation in the eyes of a reasonable person. Defamation has two forms: libel and slander. Slander is defamation through an oral statement; libel requires broadcast or “publication,” which is loosely defined. In both cases, the statement must be untrue and likely to lower the plaintiff in the estimation of right-thinking members of society to constitute defamation.
Injurious falsehood, slander of title, and passing off are torts designed to compensate plaintiffs whose commercial interests have been interfered with by some kind of false representation. Injurious falsehood is typically committed by a competing merchant attempting to gain market share. Slander of title involves statements designed to discourage potential buyers or lessors from contracting to buy or lease the plaintiff’s real estate. Passing off occurs when one vendor attempts to take advantage of another’s good business reputation or the reputation of their products by convincing the public that its own goods (commonly called “knock-offs”) are those of the plaintiff.
Intimidation involves threatening to commit an unlawful act as a way of coercing a person into either doing something they might not otherwise have done or into not doing something they were otherwise entitled to do.
Inducing breach of contract is a tort alleged by a party to a contract against a third party in circumstances where the third party has deliberately caused the other party to the contract to breach the contract. This tort occurs where the defendant is aware that the plaintiff has a contract with a third party and intentionally acts so as to cause the breach of the contract.
The unlawful means tort involves the defendant committing a civil wrong against a third party with the intention of harming the plaintiff. It can be described as parasitic in nature, as the plaintiff’s claim is dependent on the third party having a civil claim against the defendant.
Conspiracy occurs where the defendants, acting together, engage in lawful or unlawful conduct with the predominant purpose of injuring the plaintiff (a predominate purpose conspiracy) or unlawful conduct where the defendants knew or should have known that injury was likely to result (an unlawful means conspiracy). Conspiracy is designed to cast a net of liability broad enough to catch defendants who participated in acts that injured the plaintiff, even if they only played a small part in a larger series of acts.
KEY TERMS
conspiracy, 42
deceit, 34
defamation, 35
inducing breach of contract, 40
injurious falsehood, 37
intimidation, 39
libel, 36
passing off, 37
predominant purpose conspiracy, 42
slander, 36
slander of title, 37
special damages, 36
unlawful means conspiracy, 42
unlawful means tort, 41
REVIEW QUESTIONS
Why might someone sue for deceit even though the defendant has been charged criminally with fraud?
In what circumstances would someone sue for intimidation resulting from, for example, a threat of violence where the defendant didn’t actually go through with the violence?
Assume that a company has induced an employee of yours to breach her employment contract. Assume you have an ironclad contract and can sue your employee for breaching the contract. How does the tort of inducing breach of contract provide you with a benefit?
What does it mean to say that the unlawful means tort is “parasitic”?
Compare and contrast the torts of injurious falsehood and passing off.
46
Compare and contrast the tort of injurious falsehood with the tort of defamation, specifically with respect to the element of truth.
Explain the elements that must be proved to make a claim of defamation. Why does the plaintiff not have to prove that the statement was untrue?
What is the difference between a predominant purpose conspiracy and an unlawful means conspiracy?