Debates on Further Constitutional Reform

Flashcards created based on key concepts and arguments about constitutional reform in the UK.

What is a potential benefit of a codified constitution in the UK?

Entrenchment of rights and protection against governmental interference.

What is one argument against codifying the UK Constitution?

It would limit Parliament's ability to pass legislation that may offend human rights protection.

What does it mean that a codified constitution would be judiciable?

Judges would resolve political issues and protect the constitution.

Why do some argue against further devolution to England?

It could render the Westminster Parliament useless and lead to calls for independence among other regions.

What issue does the West Lothian question address?

The right of MPs from Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland to vote on laws affecting England while English MPs cannot vote on devolved matters.

What is one reason people may oppose devolution in England?

Referendums and opinion polls have shown that people do not want devolution in England.

What would an elected House of Lords provide according to proponents of reform?

More legitimacy and a better check on the government.

What limiting factor currently affects the House of Lords' power?

Recent reforms have taken away most of their power; they cannot veto or delay financial bills.

Why are large majorities in the House of Commons seen as a problem?

They can prevent opposition parties from effectively holding the government accountable.

What is the impact of whipping in the House of Commons?

It forces members to vote along party lines, often at the expense of independent decision-making.