“Can God be omnipotent” Discuss

studied byStudied by 0 people
0.0(0)
Get a hint
Hint
  1. Descartes Voluntarism

1 / 3

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Government

4 Terms

1
  1. Descartes Voluntarism

  • Believes that Gods omnipotence involves the power to do anything even the logically impossible- says that God could have made it false that 2X4=8

  • Has the power to changed mathematical, geometric and logical truths- God existed before the laws of logic and created them as is therefore not bound by them

  • Logic=human limitations

  • However:

  • Voluntarism is incoherent and undermines theodicies- if it is logically possible for God to do the logically impossible then it is not logically impossible- self defeating- destroys logical necessity

  • Undermines theodicies- why cant god give us free will and prevent evil?

New cards
2
  1. Aquinas- God can only do the logically possible

  • Gods power is founded in Gods infinite nature which possess the perfection all being- Gods omnipotence Can only bring about things which are consistent with the perfection of being

  • Even though God cannot do the impossible- not limitation of his omnipotence once properly understood as power founded in the perfection of being

  • However: The paradox of the stone- “can god create a stone so heavy he cant lift is”- Aquinas’ definition is therefore too narrow

  • Mavrodes- the stone is logically self contradictory- no such thing as a stone too heavy too lift

New cards
3
  1. Self Imposed Limitation

  • Augustine

  • The only limits on Gods power are limits that God chose- limited by choice- divine self limitation

  • When creating the earth- God made is logically consistent and orderly

  • If God did something logically impossible within the universe- disrupt the logical order of universe and make it chaotic

  • Free will needed to do good/evil

  • However :

  • If God can do logically impossible then no need for divine limitation

  • Reduces the number of things God can do, can’t do what he used to- not all powerful

New cards
4

Conclusion:

  • God cannot be al powerful

  • God being all powerful is incompatible with other attributes or god, for the omnipotence of God to be justified- the definition of Omnipotence needs to be compromised (Anthony Kenny)

New cards

Explore top notes

note Note
studied byStudied by 17 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 20 people
... ago
5.0(2)
note Note
studied byStudied by 4 people
... ago
5.0(2)
note Note
studied byStudied by 33 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 4 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 18 people
... ago
5.0(2)
note Note
studied byStudied by 12 people
... ago
5.0(1)
note Note
studied byStudied by 147 people
... ago
5.0(3)

Explore top flashcards

flashcards Flashcard (50)
studied byStudied by 13 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (300)
studied byStudied by 6 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (30)
studied byStudied by 5 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (46)
studied byStudied by 4 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (171)
studied byStudied by 1 person
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (92)
studied byStudied by 109 people
... ago
5.0(1)
flashcards Flashcard (56)
studied byStudied by 7 people
... ago
5.0(1)
robot