1/19
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Name | Mastery | Learn | Test | Matching | Spaced |
|---|
No study sessions yet.
McKitty v. Hayani
A case where a woman was declared brain-dead, but her family objected to removing life support.
Legal Definition of Death
Deciding when someone is legally dead is not just a medical question; it's an evaluative judgment by the law.
Jeff McMahan
Supports the Higher Brain View: death happens when consciousness ends, not when the body dies.
Advance Requests for MAID
Should be respected even if the person is no longer conscious, because the wishes of the past self matter most.
Critique of Standard Deprivation Accounts
Death is bad because it deprives us of life, but McMahan critiques standard deprivation accounts.
John Broome
Argues that death is harmful by comparative harm, cutting life short and depriving us of future good experiences.
Lucretius / Epicurus
Death is nothing to us; when alive, death isn't present; when dead, we don't exist to be harmed.
Symmetry Argument
We don't fear the time before we were born, so we shouldn't fear the time after death.
Doomsday Scenario / Scheffler
Imagines Earth destroyed 30 days after your death, showing we care about the collective future of humanity.
Higher Brain View (HBV)
Death occurs at the irreversible loss of consciousness, focusing on the person, not the biological organism.
Whole Brain View
Requires all brain functions to stop for death to be declared.
Robert Truog
Critiques treatment of families when brain death is declared and advocates for honesty about brain death.
Ethics of Organ Donation
Accepts organ donation can be ethical even if the patient isn't strictly 'dead.'
UDDA
Uniform Determination of Death Act, which Truog participated in revising.
Interest-Independent Value / Dignity
Everyone has intrinsic worth, not dependent on personal interests; basis of Kantian ethics.
Lazarus Sign
Involuntary spinal reflex seen in brain-dead patients that can look like life but doesn't indicate consciousness.
Population Ethics
Deals with value across many lives: quality vs. quantity of life.
Afterlife Conjecture
Human projects feel valuable only if humanity continues.
Parfit's Repugnant Conclusion
Summing up lives can lead to counterintuitive conclusions about value.
Broome's Comparative Harm
Decisions weigh the goodness of lives lost vs. lives lived.