1/52
Vocabulary flashcards covering governing rules, procedural rules, and evidence rules for the Georgia High School Mock Trial Competition.
Rule 3 - Witness Bound by Statements
Witness Bound by Statement A witness is bound by their own statement and relevant exhibits. Fair extrapolations (reasonable inferences) are allowed. On direct, a question calling for info NOT in the statement/exhibits AND material to the case is objectionable under Rule 4. On cross, a witness may answer outside the statement only if consistent with it and not advantaging either side. A witness is not bound by other witnesses' statements. The Case Summary/Introduction is background only - not usable as evidence.
Rule 4(a) - Fair vs. Unfair Extrapolation
An extrapolation is a fact introduced at trial that isn't in the case materials. FAIR = gives no advantage to either side. UNFAIR = materially affects testimony or a substantive issue AND gives one side an adversarial advantage.
Rule 4(b)-(c) - Countering Unfair Extrapolation / Questions Outside Case Materials
Unfair extrapolations should be countered via impeachment and closing argument, not just objection. On direct, attorneys cannot ask questions calling for information outside the case materials. On cross, attorneys MAY ask about the absence or omission of evidence from the case materials.
Rule 4(d)-(g) - Unfair Extrapolation Objection and Rulings
The special objection is "unfair extrapolation" or "beyond the scope of case materials." The judge rules: no extrapolation occurred, an unfair extrapolation occurred, or it was fair. The judge's ruling is final. Points may be deducted if the extrapolation was intentional or if the objection was baseless.
Rule 15(i)-(j) - Who May Object
Only the attorney assigned to DIRECT a witness may object during that witness's CROSS. Only the attorney assigned to CROSS a witness may object during that witness's DIRECT.
Rule 47(a) - Argumentative Question
A question that asks the witness to just agree with a conclusion the attorney drew, without eliciting new facts. Limited use may be allowed on cross at the court's discretion.
Rule 47(b) - Ambiguous Question
A question capable of being understood in two or more different ways.
Rule 47(c) - Non-Responsive Answer
A witness's answer that fails to actually respond to the question asked.
Rule 48 - Assuming Facts Not in Evidence
A question that assumes unproven facts. Exception: an expert may be asked a question based on stated assumptions reasonably supported by the evidence.
Rule 49 - Lack of Foundation
An attorney must lay a proper foundation before moving to admit evidence; even after that motion, the exhibit may still be objectionable on other grounds.
Rule 50 - Introducing Exhibits
A 12-step procedure: 1) Show exhibit to opposing counsel, 2) Request to approach witness, 3) Give exhibit to witness, 4) State "I show you what's marked Exhibit ___", 5) Ask witness to identify, 6) Witness identifies only, 7) Lay foundation, 8) Offer exhibit into evidence, 9) Judge asks if objection, 10) Opposing counsel responds, 11) Judge rules, 12) Question on contents if admitted.
Rule 52 - Redirect/Recross
Redirect and recross are permitted but must follow scope restrictions in Rule 611(d) (redirect limited to matters raised on cross; recross limited to matters raised on redirect).
Rule 53(a) - Objections During Openings/Closings
No objections are allowed DURING openings/closings. Instead, after the statement, an attorney may state what they would have objected to. The judge does not rule; evaluators weigh it.
Rule 53(b) - Scope of Closing Arguments
Closing arguments must be based only on evidence and testimony actually presented and admitted at trial.
Rule 53(c) - Filibustering / Deliberate Time Wasting
A witness may not give evasive, non-responsive, or narrative answers on cross specifically to burn time. Raising a filibustering objection may award extra cross time and cause point deductions.
Rule 106 - Rule of Completeness
If a party introduces part of a writing/recorded statement, the adverse party may require the rest or a related part introduced at the same time if fairness requires.
Rule 401 - Relevance
Evidence is relevant if it has ANY tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without it, AND the fact is of consequence to the case.
Rule 402 - General Admissibility of Relevant Evidence
Relevant evidence is admissible unless another rule says otherwise. Irrelevant evidence is NOT admissible.
Rule 403 - Excluding Relevant Evidence (Prejudice, Confusion, Waste of Time)
The court MAY exclude relevant evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by unfair prejudice, confusing issues, misleading the jury, undue delay, wasting time, or needlessly cumulative evidence.
Rule 404(a)(1) - Character Evidence: General Rule
Evidence of someone's character or trait is NOT admissible to prove they acted in conformity with it on a specific occasion.
Rule 404(a)(2) - Character Evidence: Criminal Exceptions
Defendant may offer evidence of pertinent trait (prosecutor may then rebut); may offer victim's pertinent trait (prosecutor may rebut AND offer same trait about defendant); in homicide, prosecutor may offer victim's peacefulness trait to rebut claim victim was first aggressor.
Rule 404(b) - Other Crimes, Wrongs, or Acts
NOT admissible to prove character to show propensity. MAY be admitted for another purpose: motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, or absence of mistake/accident.
Rule 407 - Subsequent Remedial Measures
Fixes made after an injury are NOT admissible to prove negligence, culpable conduct, product defect, or need for warning. MAY be admitted for impeachment or ownership/control/feasibility if disputed.
Rule 411 - Liability Insurance
Evidence that someone was or wasn't insured is NOT admissible to prove negligence or wrongful conduct, but MAY be admitted to show bias, agency, ownership, or control.
Rule 501 - Privileges
Recognized privileges excluding evidence on policy grounds: spousal communications, attorney-client, grand juror communications, state secrets, and medical/mental-health provider-patient communications.
Rule 602 - Personal Knowledge
A witness may only testify to something if there is evidence they actually have personal knowledge of it (does not apply to expert testimony under Rule 703).
Rule 607 - Who May Impeach a Witness
ANY party may attack a witness's credibility—even the party who originally called that witness.
Rule 608(a) - Reputation/Opinion of Truthfulness
A witness's credibility can be attacked or supported through reputation or opinion testimony about truthful character. Truthful character evidence is allowed only after truthfulness has been attacked.
Rule 608(b) - Specific Instances of Conduct
Except for criminal convictions under Rule 609, specific instances of conduct cannot be proven with extrinsic evidence to attack/support truthfulness, though cross-examination questions may be allowed if relevant.
Rule 609(a) - Impeachment by Conviction: Felonies and Dishonesty Crimes
A felony conviction (death/1+ year sentence) must generally be admitted subject to Rule 403; for defendant-witnesses, only if probative value outweighs prejudice. ANY crime involving dishonesty or false statement must be admitted regardless of punishment level.
Rule 609(b)-(e) - Impeachment by Conviction: Limits
If 10+ years have passed since conviction/release, admissible only if probative value substantially outweighs prejudice. Pardoned/annulled convictions generally inadmissible. Convictions remain usable while on appeal.
Rule 611(a) - Court Control of Examination
The court controls the mode and order of witness examination to make truth-finding effective, avoid wasting time, and protect witnesses from harassment.
Rule 611(b) - Scope of Cross-Examination
Cross-examination is NOT limited to the scope of direct examination; an attorney may ask about any relevant matter in the witness's statement/exhibits, reasonable inferences, and material omissions.
Rule 611(c) - Leading Questions
Leading questions are NOT allowed on direct examination (except to develop testimony); they are allowed on cross and when a witness is hostile, an adverse party, or identified with an adverse party.
Rule 611(d) - Redirect/Recross Scope
Redirect examination is limited to matters raised on cross. Recross examination is limited to matters raised on redirect. Repetition should be avoided.
Rule 613(b) - Extrinsic Evidence of Prior Inconsistent Statement
Outside evidence of a prior inconsistent statement is admissible only if the witness gets a chance to explain/deny it and opposing party gets a chance to question about it.
Rule 701 - Lay Opinion
A non-expert's opinion is only allowed if rationally based on perception, helpful to understanding testimony/fact, and NOT based on scientific, technical, or specialized knowledge.
Rule 702 - Expert Testimony
A witness qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may testify if specialized knowledge helps the jury understand evidence/fact, based on sufficient facts or data.
Rule 704(a) - Ultimate Issue Opinion
An opinion is not automatically objectionable just because it addresses an ultimate issue in the case.
Rule 704(b) - Expert Mental State Limit (Criminal)
In a CRIMINAL case, an expert may NOT give an opinion on whether the defendant had the mental state/condition that is an element of the crime or defense; that decision belongs to the jury alone.
Rule 801(c) & 802 - Hearsay Definition and Rule
Hearsay is a statement the declarant does not make while testifying at current trial, offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted. Hearsay is NOT admissible unless a specific rule allows it.
Rule 801(d)(1) - Not Hearsay: Declarant-Witness's Prior Statements
If declarant testifies and is subject to cross: prior inconsistent statement under oath at earlier proceeding is not hearsay; prior consistent statement to rebut fabrication/improper motive is not hearsay; identification statement is not hearsay.
Rule 801(d)(2) - Not Hearsay: Opposing Party's Statements
A statement is not hearsay if made by opposing party, adopted, authorized, made by agent/employee within role, or made by coconspirator during/in furtherance of conspiracy.
Rule 803(1)-(2) - Hearsay Exceptions: Present Sense Impression and Excited Utterance
Present Sense Impression: statement describing event made while/immediately after perceiving. Excited Utterance: statement about startling event made while under stress of excitement.
Rule 803(3) - Hearsay Exception: Then-Existing Mental/Emotional/Physical Condition
Statement about declarant's then-existing state of mind (motive, intent, plan) or physical condition, but NOT memory/belief to prove remembered fact (unless regarding a will).
Rule 803(4) - Hearsay Exception: Medical Diagnosis or Treatment
Statement made for and relevant to medical diagnosis or treatment, describing symptoms, history, or cause.
Rule 803(5) - Hearsay Exception: Recorded Recollection
Record about something witness once knew but cannot fully recall, made/adopted when memory fresh and shown accurate. May be READ into evidence, but becomes exhibit only if offered by adverse party.
Rule 803(6)-(7) - Hearsay Exception: Business Records
Regularly-kept business record made near event by someone with knowledge is admissible if custodian/certification confirms trustworthiness. Absence of record can prove event didn't happen.
Rule 803(8)-(10) - Hearsay Exception: Public Records
Records of public office activities or required observations (excluding law enforcement in criminal cases) are admissible unless untrustworthy. Diligent search finding no public record proves nonexistence.
Rule 804(a) - Declarant Unavailable
Declarant unavailable if: exempted by privilege, refuses to testify under court order, testifies to no memory, dead/ill, or absent and unprocureable by reasonable means.
Rule 804(b)(1)-(2) - Hearsay Exceptions: Former Testimony and Dying Declaration
Former Testimony: testimony given at earlier trial/hearing/deposition offered against party with prior opportunity/similar motive. Dying Declaration: statement in homicide/civil case regarding cause of believed imminent death.
Rule 804(b)(3) - Hearsay Exception: Statement Against Interest
Statement so contrary to financial/legal interest or exposure to liability that reasonable person wouldn't say unless true. In criminal cases, needs corroborating circumstances showing trustworthiness.
Rule 805 - Hearsay Within Hearsay
A statement containing hearsay within hearsay is admissible only if EACH layer of the statement independently qualifies for a hearsay exception.