juror cards

J1: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) Foreman
2) ?
3) voted NG at the 3-9 vote that happens after J7 votes not guilty b/c of being “fed up” (around psychiatrist discussion)

J2: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) shy nerd guy
2) woman’s testimony (saw killing)
- thought it was obvious
3) helps w/ debunking old man’s walking to bedroom and seeing killing testimony

J3: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) bias against kids
2) old man’s testimony
- he illustrates the facts behind the old man’s testimony

3) finally separates the two boys, final not guilty vote

J4: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) stockbroker
2) alibi → story flimsy
knife → states the facts behind the boy’s whereabouts before the murder & the testimony of knife being one of a kind
3) he “now has a reasonable doubt" after J8 debunks the woman’s testimony

J5: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) night nurse; grew up poor like kid
2) pass
3) old man’s testimony, likely couldn’t have heard the killing happen

J6: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) none
2) testimony across hall
3) same to J2 - couldn’t have taken less than 42 seconds for old man to walk to door despite the killing happening in around ~10 seconds

J7: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) baseball game, impatient dude

2) 0-5 crim record
3) after psychiatry discussion, acts like he doesn’t care anymore and votes NG (J11 flames him and he admits he believes the boy is not guilty)

J8: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) architect / father
2 ) never
3 ) everything

J9: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) old man
2) none
3) believed boy was guilty, but wanted to hear what J8 had to say

J10: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) bias against “those people”
2) ?
3) outnumbered at the 9-3, so votes NG (before J4, after J12)

J11: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) watchmaker
2) blind trust for all case evidence, no significant reliance
3) votes NG after old man being able to hear is debunked; along with J5 (8-4)

J12: job/alias, evidence relied on, why voted NG

1) advertisement doodler
2) never fully engages, just follows majority
3) believes it's possible that the woman could have made a mistake → NG