Reason and Argument - Chapter 5: Reconstructing Arguments

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
Card Sorting

1/22

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Vocabulary flashcards covering the core concepts, principles, writing styles, and reconstruction guidelines from Chapter 5 of Richard Feldman's Reason and Argument.

23 Terms

1
New cards

Descriptive writing

Writing in which the author merely describes an event or situation without attempting to prove or establish the truth of any particular claim.

2
New cards

Argumentative writing

Writing in which the author provides reasons in support of a conclusion or makes an effort to establish the truth of a claim.

3
New cards

Rhetorical writing

Writing that expresses or forcefully asserts an author's point of view on a topic, but provides no reasons designed to establish the truth of that view.

4
New cards

Principle of Charity (PC)

The fundamental principle of argument analysis stating that when reconstructing an argument, one should try to formulate a reconstruction that is well-formed, has reasonable premises, and is undefeated (making the argument as strong as possible).

5
New cards

Conclusion indicator

A word or phrase used to tell readers that a conclusion has just been, or is about to be, stated (such as 'therefore,' 'thus,' 'hence,' or 'so').

6
New cards

Premise indicator

A word or phrase marking the occurrence of a premise or introducing the reasons given in support of a conclusion (such as 'since,' 'because,' or 'after all').

7
New cards

Explicit conclusion

A conclusion of an argument that is stated directly and clearly in the text.

8
New cards

Implicit conclusion

A conclusion that is omitted from direct statement by the author, leaving readers to infer the intended claim from the context.

9
New cards

Explicit premise

A premise that is stated directly and clearly within the argumentative text.

10
New cards

Implicit premise

An unstated premise or assumption that an author has left out but which must be added to make the argument well-formed.

11
New cards

Specific statement

A premise that states a fact, or alleged fact, about a single individual rather than a general category.

12
New cards

Generalization

A statement or premise that asserts a fact about general categories or kinds of individuals.

13
New cards

Quantifier

A word in a generalization that specifies how many members of a category possess a certain attribute (such as 'all,' 'most,' 'many,' or 'some').

14
New cards

Universal generalization

A generalization containing the quantifier 'all' (or an equivalent formulation) that asserts that every member of a category has a certain characteristic.

15
New cards

Nonuniversal generalization

A generalization containing quantifiers such as 'most,' 'many,' or 'some' that applies to a subset rather than all members of a category, functioning similarly to a statistical statement.

16
New cards

Linking premise

An implicit premise that connects a stated premise to the conclusion, showing that a generalization applies to a particular case to make the argument well-formed.

17
New cards

Principle of Faithfulness (PF)

The principle governing argument reconstruction requiring the addition of implicit premises that are consistent with the intentions of the author of the argument.

18
New cards

Principle of Charity for Implicit Premises (PCI)

The principle stating that one should add implicit premises that are reasonable to accept rather than implicit premises that are obviously false.

19
New cards

Generalization Principle (PG)

The principle stating that when adding a generalization as an implicit premise, one should add a true wide generalization rather than a true narrow one, and a true narrow generalization rather than a false wide one.

20
New cards

Wide generalization

A generalization that applies to a broader category of things, encompassing everything a narrower generalization applies to as well as additional cases.

21
New cards

Narrow generalization

A generalization that includes additional restrictions, qualifications, or limitations, thereby applying to a smaller subcategory of items than a wider generalization.

22
New cards

Missing quantifier

A defect in an ordinary English generalization where the quantifier is omitted, leaving it ambiguous whether the statement is universal or nonuniversal and preventing evaluation until supplied.

23
New cards

Cheap validity

The practice of making an invalid argument deductively valid simply by appending a conditional premise stating that if the stated premises are true, then the conclusion is true (e.g., adding 'If P1P_1 and P2P_2, then CC').