Reason and Argument - Chapter 5: Reconstructing Arguments
Foundations of Argument Reconstruction and the Principle of Charity
Standard Form and Its Purpose:
Putting arguments into standard form makes them substantially clearer and easier to understand by explicitly exposing the underlying assumptions and the inferential connections between ideas.
Standard form enables deeper understanding and simplifies the rigorous evaluation of whether the provided premises genuinely support the proposed conclusion.
The reconstruction method applies to all genres of writing, including brief letters to the editor, newspaper editorials, and extended theoretical essays.
Successful reconstruction requires combining systematic analytical rules with a careful, fair, and sympathetic reading of the source material.
Inquiry and Argument Construction:
When investigating a question of genuine interest—whether in natural science (the behavior of subatomic particles, the causes of earthquakes), biology (the life span of tropical fish), sports economics (the leading money winners in professional golf), or applied ethics (the morality of abortion)—the investigator gathers data, reads literature, conducts empirical tests, or engages in focused reflection.
The collected information functions as a set of premises in an argument whose conclusion is the proposed answer to the target question.
Evaluating the inquiry requires determining whether the inferential step from those premises to the conclusion is logically strong (valid or cogent).
Contrasting Orientations Toward Argumentation:
The Debater / "Person of Contradiction": Views arguments purely as competitive contests aimed at winning. Such individuals tend to dispute everything they encounter and deliberately reconstruct opposing arguments in weak, foolish, or ridiculous ways to refute them easily.
The Dogmatist: Focused exclusively on defending pre-existing beliefs while remaining entirely closed to new information or perspectives. Dogmatists analyze arguments solely to find flaws in conclusions with which they disagree, rather than using argument analysis as an epistemic tool to determine what is true.
The Skeptic: Disposed to misuse argumentative analysis by indiscriminately dismantling any positive claim or rational support.
The Rational Thinker: Views arguments as clear, explicit formulations of reasons for believing propositions whose truth value is of genuine interest. When faced with multiple interpretations of an argument, the rational thinker formulates the most plausible and robust version to assess what is truly reasonable to believe.
The Principle of Charity ():
Formal Definition: When reconstructing an argument, try to formulate a reconstruction that is well-formed, has reasonable premises, and is undefeated. In other words, make the argument as strong as possible.
Epistemic Justification: Adherence to is not motivated by politeness, etiquette, or pity for the arguer. Rather, it ensures that investigators confront the best available versions of arguments, thereby maximizing insight into the issue under consideration.
Rational Strength vs. Rhetorical Effectiveness: The Principle of Charity requires maximizing rational strength (logical validity, cogency, and premise plausibility), not rhetorical or persuasive effectiveness.
Distinguishing Arguments from Nonarguments
Prerequisite for Analysis:
Before reconstructing an argument from prose, it is necessary to determine whether the text contains an argument at all.
The topic of an essay does not determine whether it is an argument; the presence of an argument depends strictly on whether reasons are provided to support a conclusion.
Descriptive Writing:
Definition: Writing in which the author merely describes an event, circumstance, or factual situation without attempting to prove or rationally establish the truth of any specific claim.
Characteristics: Standard news reporting represents descriptive writing. It conveys facts regarding who, what, when, where, and background context without demonstrating that the events took place or defending a thesis about them.
Case Example (Johnny Penry): A report describing prosecutors deciding to retry Johnny Penry (a man with the reported reasoning ability of a 7-year-old whose death sentence for the 1980 murder and rape of Pamela Carpenter was vacated by the Supreme Court due to omitted jury instructions on mental impairment and child abuse) is purely descriptive. Although the topic is widely debated, the passage simply reports facts and court rulings without offering an argument on the merits of executing mentally impaired individuals.
Rhetorical Writing:
Definition: Writing that expresses an opinion, attitude, or viewpoint—often forcefully, passionately, or emotionally—without presenting reasons or evidence designed to establish the truth of that viewpoint.
Linguistic Markers: Relies on emotionally charged, loaded vocabulary (e.g., "leftist," "disgusted," "abhorrent," "ridiculous") that manifests the author's feelings without providing an inferential justification.
Case Example (Flag-Burning Letter Excerpt): A letter expressing outrage at a newspaper editorial supporting a Supreme Court ruling on flag burning contains strong rhetoric and reveals personal disgust, but by itself supplies no premises to justify why the ruling or editorial was erroneous.
Nonargumentative Writing with Substantive Significance:
Descriptive and rhetorical writing are not inherently inferior to argumentative writing; they simply serve different communicative purposes.
The Declaration of Independence: Eloquently asserts that truths are self-evident, that all men are created equal, and that they are endowed by their Creator with unalienable rights (Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness). It powerfully moves readers, but it asserts these foundational rights without arguing for their existence.
Adam Smith on Handgun Statistics (1981): Presents striking statistics—approximately 10,000 handgun deaths in the U.S. compared to 40 in Britain; 18,714 Americans murdered in 1978 with 64% killed by handguns; more handgun homicides committed by American children aged 10 and under than by British killers of all ages; Canadian homicides totaling 579 versus over 20,000 in the U.S. While these facts evoke strong convictions regarding gun control, the passage itself reports data without constructing a formal argument.
Arguments Embedded in Nonargumentative Prose:
Arguments are frequently embedded within paragraphs of rhetorical complaints or descriptive exposition.
Full Flag-Burning Letter Analysis: An extended complaint may include implicit or explicit arguments, such as: flag burning is obscene (analogous to public nudity on Main Street), and obscenity should be legally prohibited; or officeholders have a duty to implement the will of the people, and the overwhelming majority opposes flag burning, so flag burning should be banned.

Identifying Conclusions and Premises
Identifying Conclusions:
Definition: The conclusion is the central claim or main point that the author is attempting to rationally establish.
Core Heuristic: Isolate the overarching takeaway of the passage and condense it into a single, straightforward proposition.
Universality of Propositions: Any statement on any subject matter (scientific, ethical, metaphysical, mundane) can serve as a conclusion; the topic itself never reveals whether a statement is a conclusion.
Structural Outlining: In complex essays containing multiple sub-arguments, authors may defend intermediate conclusions that subsequently serve as premises for further conclusions. Segmenting and boxing distinct claims clarifies the structural progression.
Conclusion Indicators: Linguistic markers signaling that a conclusion follows include: "hence," "therefore," "thus," "I conclude that," "so," "it follows that," "proves that," "implies that," "establishes that," and "shows that."
Preceding Conclusions: Conclusions often precede premises in natural language, connected by terms such as "since," "because," "follows from the fact that," "is established by," and "is implied by."
Implicit Indicator Test: When indicator terms are omitted, inserting "so" or "therefore" before a sentence tests whether it functions coherently as the conclusion without altering the author's meaning.
Explicit vs. Implicit Conclusions: An explicit conclusion is stated verbatim. An implicit conclusion is omitted by the author because they assume it is obvious or leave it to the reader to deduce (e.g., stating that all individuals exposed to a virus contract the illness and that Will was exposed carries the obvious implicit conclusion that Will will contract the illness).
Indirect or Misstated Conclusions: Authors often misstate their actual conclusions. For example, a prosecutor stating "I believe that Gil T. is guilty" is not attempting to prove the sociological or psychological fact of her personal belief (which the jury already takes for granted), but rather the objective factual claim: Gil T. is guilty of the crime.
Substantive Confusion: Arguers frequently conflate distinct issues, such as conflating whether a policy (such as banning abortion) is constitutionally permissible with whether it is morally desirable.
Identifying Premises:
Definition: Premises are the statements of evidence, facts, or reasons intended to establish the truth of the conclusion.
Core Heuristic: Identify the conclusion and ask: "What reasons does the author offer to support the truth of this statement?"
Premise Indicators: Phrases signaling premises include: "My reason is…," "The evidence for this is…," "On the basis of the fact that…," "After all," "Since," and "Because."
Explicit vs. Implicit Premises: Explicit premises are articulated directly in the prose, whereas implicit premises are unstated assumptions required to make the inference well-formed.
Clarification of Obscurity: Poorly phrased, convoluted, or obscure premises should be rewritten in clear, precise language during standard reconstruction.
Elementary Argument Patterns:
Categorical Syllogism Pattern (e.g., Ken B. Bribed):
1. is an .
2. All s are s.
3. is a .
Standard Form Example:
1. Ken B. Bribed is a politician.
2. All politicians are corrupt.
3. Ken B. Bribed is corrupt.
Modus Ponens Pattern (e.g., Gupp E.'s Aquarium):
1. is an .
2. If is an , then is a .
3. is a .
Standard Form Example:
1. That ten-gallon aquarium contains forty fish.
2. If that ten-gallon aquarium contains forty fish, then that aquarium is too crowded.
3. That ten-gallon aquarium is too crowded.
Reversed Premise Order Syllogism (e.g., Will I. Getit):
1. Everyone who is exposed to the virus gets the disease.
2. Will I. Getit was exposed to the virus.
3. Will I. Getit will get the disease.
General and Specific Premises
Categorization of Premises:
Specific Statements: Assert alleged facts about particular, singular individuals, objects, or events (e.g., "Ken B. Bribed is a politician").
Generalizations: Assert alleged facts about categories, classes, or kinds of individuals (e.g., "All politicians are corrupt").
Standard Forms for General Statements:
To maintain uniformity and simplify deductive and inductive evaluation, generalizations should be rewritten into canonical standard forms using explicit quantifiers.
Universal Generalizations: Statements affirming a condition across the entirety of a class.
Canonical Pattern: .
Linguistic equivalents: "Every is a "; "If something is an , then it is a "; "Anything that is an is a "; "A person is an only if that person is a "; "The only s are s" (which translates to "All s are s" or vice versa depending on syntax).
Conversion Example: The statement "The only people who got an A in that course did it by bribing the professor" converts to the standard form: All people who got an A in that course are people who bribed the professor.
Nonuniversal Generalizations: Statements asserting that a property applies to a subset or statistical portion of a class.
Patterns: ; ; .
These operate analogously to statistical distributions in inductive logic.
Epistemic Legitimacy of Generalizations:
Popular culture often treats "generalizations" as inherently fallacious or biased. In logic, this connotation is mistaken.
Numerous universal generalizations are definitively true, including:
All planets in the solar system revolve around the sun.
All bachelors are unmarried.
All members of the U.S. Senate in 1997 are more than three years old.
Generalizations become defective only when they are empirically false, overreaching, or asserted without adequate evidential justification.
Adding Implicit Premises and Governing Principles
The Function of Implicit Premises:
Real-world prose rarely states every logical step. Reconstructors must supply unstated background assumptions to produce an argument that is well-formed (valid or cogent).
Adding implicit premises is frequently the most critical and challenging phase of argument reconstruction.
Implicit Premises That Are Not Generalizations (Linking Premises):
Linking Premise Definition: An unstated specific statement that connects an explicit general premise directly to a singular subject in the conclusion.
Structural Gap: If an argument states "All people who got an A in that course bribed the professor; therefore, Dan bribed the professor," the general premise does not mention Dan. It is ill-formed on its own.
Correction: Supply the singular linking premise: Dan is a person who got an A in that course.
Formal Deductive Patterns for Singular Completions:
If given and , supply .
If given and , supplying indicates an invalid underlying structure unless completed as Modus Tollens (given and , supply ).
If given and the conclusion , supply the missing singular premise to form a cogent argument.
Implicit Premises That Are Generalizations:
Supplying missing general principles involves complex trade-offs between charity and authorial intent.
Case Example (Tweety flying / Tweety is a bird):
Attempt 1: Add "All things that can fly are birds." Valid, but obviously false because airplanes and bats fly.
Attempt 2: Add "All living things that can fly are birds." Ill-formed without an additional premise stating Tweety is alive.
Attempt 3: Add both "Tweety is a living thing" and "All living things that can fly are birds." Structurally valid (; ; ; therefore, ), but the generalization remains false because insects are living things that fly.
At this stage, the reconstructor must decide whether the speaker made an elementary error or whether complex unstated qualifications should be supplied.
Core Methodological Principles for Adding Implicit Premises:
The Principle of Faithfulness (): Add implicit premises that are consistent with the intentions of the author of the argument. Rely on immediate textual context and relevant background information to reconstruct what the arguer actually had in mind.
The Principle of Charity for Implicit Premises (): Add implicit premises that are reasonable to accept rather than implicit premises that are obviously false.
The Tension Between and : Maximizing premise plausibility under can result in formulating complex arguments that diverge significantly from the author's actual thoughts, thereby violating . Conversely, strictly adhering to an author's simplistic phrasing can saddle them with indefensible claims. Resolution depends on the reconstructor's objective: stay close to the text when evaluating an author's specific performance; permit more generous reconstructions when investigating the substantive truth of the issue.
Width of Generalizations and the Generalization Principle ():
Definitions of Scope:
A wide generalization covers a broader class of entities.
A narrow generalization restricts the class by adding qualifications or conditions.
Example: "All people who are smart, articulate, and like to argue will be successful lawyers" () is wide. "All lawyers who are smart, articulate, and like to argue will be successful lawyers" () is narrow because it restricts the scope to individuals who are already lawyers.
The Generalization Principle (): When adding a generalization as an implicit premise in an argument, add a true wide generalization rather than a true narrow one, and add a true narrow generalization rather than a false wide one.
Rule of Qualification: Do not add arbitrary restrictions (e.g., restricting a generalization about lawyers strictly to "women lawyers" when the text mentions a female candidate) unless the context provides a clear rationale for that restriction.
Deductive Validity vs. Inductive Cogency in Reconstruction:
Reconstructing arguments as deductively valid often forces the inclusion of universal generalizations (using "all") that are clearly false upon reflection (e.g., claiming that every single smart, articulate, argument-loving lawyer will succeed ignores factors like lack of motivation, poor work ethic, or poor courtroom demeanor).
When the evidence supports a claim with high likelihood rather than absolute certainty, reconstruct the argument as inductively cogent by supplying a nonuniversal generalization (using quantifiers like "most" or "nearly all").
Case Example (Bar X. Am):
1. Bar is smart.
2. Bar is articulate.
3. Bar likes to argue.
4. Bar is a lawyer.
5. Most lawyers who are smart and articulate and who like to argue will be successful lawyers.
6. Bar will be a successful lawyer.
This reconstruction is cogent, avoids indefensible universal generalizations, and complies with both and .
Two Common Analytical Pitfalls:
Omitting Linking Generalizations Entirely: Presenting a list of specific premises and jumping directly to the conclusion without supplying the linking principle renders the reconstruction ill-formed.
Omitting Quantifiers: Writing generic generalizations devoid of quantifiers (e.g., "Professional basketball players are tall") leaves the inferential structure undefined. The reconstructor must supply the appropriate quantifier (e.g., "Nearly all professional basketball players are tall") to enable proper evaluation.
Cheap Validity
Mechanics of Cheap Validity:
Any argument consisting of arbitrary premises () and an unrelated conclusion () can be made deductively valid by adding a conditional linking premise that takes the conjunction of the premises as its antecedent and the conclusion as its consequent:
.
The Boston Red Sox Case Example:
Explicit Premise: It rained yesterday.
Conclusion: The Boston Red Sox will win the World Series in 2005.
Cheap Validity Addition: If it rained yesterday, then the Boston Red Sox will win the World Series in 2005.
Logical Consequence:
Cheap validity does not turn a bad argument into a good one. It merely shifts the defect from formal invalidity to an absurd, entirely unjustified conditional premise.
Analytical Value: Formulating the conditional premise explicitly highlights the underlying gap in the reasoning, making the flaw straightforward to identify and critique.

Step-by-Step Procedure for Argument Analysis
Step 1: Decide If There Is an Argument:
Read the text carefully to determine its primary objective.
Determine whether the author provides rational support (reasons/evidence) for a claim.
If rational support is provided, proceed to Step 2. If the text is purely descriptive or rhetorical, stop; there is no argument to reconstruct.
Step 2: Reconstruct the Argument:
2a. Identify the conclusion: Search for conclusion indicators and isolate the central thesis the author intends to establish.
2b. Identify explicit premises: Search for premise indicators and isolate all stated reasons offered in support of the conclusion.
2c. Check if the argument is well-formed: Evaluate whether the explicit premises deductively entail or inductively support the conclusion.
If the argument is already well-formed, proceed directly to evaluation.
If the argument is ill-formed, proceed to Step 2d.
2d. Add implicit premises: Formulate unstated assumptions to make the argument well-formed, ensuring that added premises are:
Reasonable to accept, satisfying .
Appropriately general, satisfying .
Faithful to the author's intent, satisfying .
2e. Resolve conflicts between principles: When , , and pull in competing directions, use the overarching purpose of the analysis to guide the reconstruction, or provide alternative reconstructions and analyze the merits and defects of each.
Key Technical Terms Checklist
Descriptive Writing: Writing that describes an event, state of affairs, or situation without attempting to prove any specific claim.
Argumentative Writing: Writing that provides reasons and evidence intended to establish the truth of a claim.
Rhetorical Writing: Writing that expresses a viewpoint or emotional attitude forcefully without providing rational justification.
Conclusion Indicator: Words or phrases signaling that a conclusion follows (e.g., "therefore," "thus," "hence").
Explicit Conclusion: A conclusion directly stated in the text.
Implicit Conclusion: An unstated conclusion that the author intends the audience to infer from the context.
Premise Indicator: Words or phrases signaling that a premise is being presented (e.g., "because," "since," "after all").
Explicit Premise: A premise directly articulated in the text.
Implicit Premise: An unstated premise supplied during reconstruction to make the inference well-formed.
Specific Statement: A statement asserting a fact about a specific, singular entity or individual.
Generalization: A statement asserting a characteristic about a class, kind, or category of entities.
Quantifier: Words specifying the numerical scope of a generalization (e.g., "all," "most," "many," "some").
Universal Generalization: A generalization asserting that every member of a category possesses a given attribute ().
Nonuniversal Generalization: A generalization asserting that a portion of a category possesses an attribute ().
Linking Premise: A premise connecting other premises to the conclusion to produce a well-formed structure.
Narrow Generalization: A generalization whose scope is restricted by specific qualifications.
Wide Generalization: A generalization covering a broader class of entities.
Missing Quantifier: A defect occurring when a generalization is stated without a quantifying term, leaving its logical scope ambiguous.
Cheap Validity: The practice of making an argument deductively valid by mechanically adding a conditional premise stating that if the premises are true, the conclusion is true.
Comprehensive Case Studies, Exercises, and Worked Solutions
Classification of Real-World Editorial Texts (Flag-Burning Debate):
The Elite Have Spoken (Paul R. Neuriter): Primarily descriptive regarding the Supreme Court's ruling and potential implications for tax protestation, with an embedded argument suggesting the ruling is flawed because it implies violating a law is protected speech.
Can't Shout Fire, Either (A. W. Bruce): Rhetorical question referencing Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes's famous dictum that free speech does not permit shouting "fire" in a crowded theater, functioning as an enthymeme for the conclusion that free speech has limits.
Save Both Flag, Freedom (Arthur S. Beckhofer): Descriptive/prescriptive proposal suggesting Congress declare the flag national property under eminent domain, copyright its design, and treat flag burning as vandalism of federal property comparable to defacing the Lincoln Memorial.
Get Down to Business (Jon K. Edwards): Rhetorical diversion urging politicians to stop squabbling over flag desecration and instead address the national debt and trade deficit.
There Are Worse Crimes (Robert L. Holmes): Genuinely argumentative. Contends that government should not criminalize offensiveness (analogous to rock music or punk hairstyles) or personal wrongs (infidelity, lying); that burning one's own cloth harms nobody; and refutes Chief Justice Rehnquist's claim that alternative means of expression remain by noting that locking someone in a room compromises their freedom even if they retain access to a telephone.
Who Cares More? (Scott Henry): Rhetorical passage asking whether a protester who flags issues like nuclear leaks, defense spending, and inequality cares more for the nation than passive citizens sitting in Lazyboys.
Classification of Commentary on Televised Executions (Cass Canon):
Passage a (KQED Lawsuit): Descriptive reporting that San Francisco public television station KQED sued to broadcast California executions as part of a late-night death penalty forum.
Passages b & c (Abolitionist & Retentionist Expectations): Descriptive accounts of the beliefs of death penalty opponents (who think broadcasts will turn the public against capital punishment) and supporters (who hope broadcasts will deter violent crime).
Passage d (Joseph Savino): Descriptive report noting death row inmate Joseph Savino requested his execution be televised as a deterrent.
Passage e (Late-Night Viewing Skepticism): Argumentative. Concludes that broadcasting executions on PBS will not achieve its intended moral or deterrent effects because potential murderers do not watch PBS for moral instruction and opponents will not subject themselves to the broadcast.
Standard Form Canonical Conversions of Generalizations:
Statement: "If something is a baseball, then it is round."
Standard Form: All baseballs are round.
Statement: "A person is a student only if the person is registered in some school."
Standard Form: All people who are students are people registered in some school.
Statement: "You can never predict who will win a baseball game."
Standard Form: All baseball games are things whose winner cannot be predicted.
Statement: "Sometimes you can predict who will win a baseball game."
Standard Form: Some baseball games are things whose winner can be predicted.
Statement: "If you are a genius, then you can predict the winner of all baseball games."
Standard Form: All geniuses are people who can predict the winner of all baseball games.
Elementary Argument Reconstructions with Indicator Words:
Gas Prices Case:
1. If gas prices go up, then people will drive less.
2. Gas prices will go up.
3. People will drive less.
Pattern: 1. If then ; 2. ; 3. . (Modus Ponens, Valid).
Jones's Grade Case:
1. Jones worked hard in that course.
2. Everyone who worked hard in that course should get an A in that course.
3. Jones should get an A in that course.
Pattern: 1. is an ; 2. All s are s; 3. is a . (Categorical Syllogism, Valid).
Study Hard Fallacy Case:
1. If you study hard, then you will get an A.
2. You won't study hard.
3. You won't get an A.
Pattern: 1. If then ; 2. ; 3. . (Denying the Antecedent, Ill-formed/Invalid).
Arguments Requiring Premise Clarification and Extraneous Elimination:
Capital Punishment Case:
Passage: "I oppose capital punishment because it might lead to the death of innocent people, and we shouldn’t do anything that might lead to the death of innocent people."
Reconstruction:
1. Capital punishment is an action that might lead to the death of innocent people.
2. All actions that might lead to the death of innocent people are actions that we should not do.
3. Capital punishment is an action that we should not do.
Pattern: 1. is an ; 2. All s are s; 3. is a . (Valid).
Analytical Caveat: The conclusion is We should not perform/use capital punishment, not the subjective autobiographical report I oppose capital punishment.
Telephone Book Case:
1. Most books are things that have some pictures.
2. The telephone book is a book.
3. The telephone book is a thing that has some pictures.
Pattern: 1. Most s are s; 2. is an ; 3. is a . (Cogent).
Smith's Valid Argument Case:
1. Smith's argument is a valid argument.
2. All valid arguments are arguments that have true conclusions.
3. Smith's argument has a true conclusion.
Pattern: 1. is an ; 2. All s are s; 3. is a . (Valid, though Premise 2 is factually false).
Reconstructions Supplying Implicit Generalizations:
College Professor Degree Case:
1. She is a college professor.
2. Almost all college professors are college graduates.
3. She is a college graduate.
Evaluation: Inductively cogent (avoids an absolute universal generalization since rare honorary or self-taught appointments exist).
Olympic Decathlon Case:
1. He won the Olympic decathlon.
2. All winners of the Olympic decathlon are individuals in good physical shape.
3. He is in good physical shape.
Evaluation: Deductively valid (the physical demands of the decathlon make the universal generalization plausible).
Bachelor Case:
1. He is a bachelor.
2. All bachelors are men who are not married.
3. He is not married.
Evaluation: Deductively valid (true by definition).
Weber Cartoon Analysis (Staying Indoors):
Cartoon Dialogue: "My parents taught me that life is full of surprises, so I've always preferred to stay indoors."
Reconstruction of Implicit Premises:
1. Life is full of surprises.
2. Surprises occur primarily outdoors rather than indoors.
3. Surprises are undesirable experiences that should be avoided.
4. Staying indoors effectively prevents exposure to surprises.
5. Therefore, it is preferable to stay indoors.