theories and objections

quant hedonism

haydn and the oyster philosophy of the swine

haydn and the oyster

qualitative hedonism, lexical priorities, higher lower pleasures

qualitative hedonism

further values, heterogeneity, immoral pleasures, experience machine

further values

these are still pleasures, just higher kinds

heterogeneity

a plus not a con, competent judges, you know whats best for you

immoral pleasures

lower kinds of pleasures a fully informed person whouldn’t have idft

experience machine

our intuition not to plug in is our bias

dft

dead sea apple, drug addict, adaptive preferences

dead sea apple

you did not want a dead sea apple you desired a good apple

drug addict

aggregate desires, ideal dft

adaptive preferences

theory of well-being not justice, idft

idft

alienation, scope prob, direction of explanation

alienation

idealized version of you, opera and baseball wouldn’t be on your list

scope problem

bite the bullet, enhance life negligibly

direction of explanation

whatever you want will be good for you if you get it

objective list

ad hoc, alienation 2

ad hoc

lots of consensus

alienation 2

doesn’t matter if you want it?

pluralism

ad hoc?

consequentialism

calculation, motives irrelevant, demands too much, permits too much

calculation

like bible, rule of thumb

motives irrelevant

who gaf, not theory of virtue simply right action

demands too much c

morality is demanding

permits too much

intuition not to kill in surgeon case is ultimately better for you to have

deontology (commonsense?)

slippery slope, trolley problem

trolley problem

positive and negative duties, negative more stringent

rule consequentialism

impartial compliance, rule worship, incoherence, objection from maintenance costs

impartial compliance

maintenance costs, include internalization and impartial compliance as embedding conditions, include natural biases and limitations

rule worship

disaster escape clause, may lead back to act consequentialism, thresholds

incoherence

factorially deontological, foundationally consequentialist