1/52
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Central argument
-Practice theory should not be understood as one unified theory or as a fixed set of concepts that researchers can mechanically apply
-Instead, it is best understood as an interconnected package of theory, method, and vocabulary
-Practice theory is less a theory that supplies universal explanations and more a way of asking questions, it encourages researches to explain social phenomena in terms of interconnected pratices
3 elements that cannot be separated
-Theory provides assumptions about what the social world consists of
-Method determines how researchers observe and investigate that world
-Vocabulary provides the concepts used to describe and represent what researchers find
Assumptions in practice theory
-Social life happens through practices
-Practices are collective and material
-Practical knowledge is not fully verbal
-Social order must be continuously produced
-Action remains partly open
Social life happens through practices
-Phenomena such as knowledge, power, institutions, language, culture, science, and social change exist through practices and their interconnections
-An institution is not simply an abstract structure standing above individuals, it is continually produced through activities like organizing meetings and writing documents
-What appears to be a stable organization is the temporary and ongoing result of numerous practices being repeatedly performed
Practices are collective and material
-Practices are not simply individual behaviors or mental intentions, they are organized combinations of actions and speech performed by multiple people and mediated by material arrangements
-These material arrangements can include technologies, buildings, documents, tools, human bodies, natural objects, spatial arrangements, and infrastructures
Practical knowledge is not fully verbal
-Much of what people know is practical and embodied, people are often able to perform an activity without being able to describe every rule they follow
-This includes the learned capacity to recognize what is happening, respond appropriately, use tools competently, coordinate with others, etc.
-Practice theory challenges theories that explain action mainly through explicit beliefs, decisions, or formal rules
Social order must be continuously produced
-Stable social arrangements do not simply exist, they are created and reproduced through repeated work
-Queues, classrooms, markets, organizations, and institutions appear durable, but their durability depends on people continuing to perform the relevant practices
Action remains partly open
-Practices organize and guide conduct, but they do not determine everything in advance
-Every performance contains uncertainty, people reproduce existing practices but they can also modify them, make mistakes, resist expectations, or respond creatively
-Social change is always possible, every new performance can reproduce the practice slightly differently
What is a practice
-Practices are spatially and temporally dispersed collections of doings and sayings (Schatzki)
-These activities are organized by shared understandings, rules, purposes, tasks, and acceptable ways of proceeding
-Practices are entangled with material arrangements
-Definitions can make practices sound too much like fixed entitites, which creates the danger of reification --> therefore practices are regimes of mediated, object-oriented performances composed of organized sayings and doings
Elements of what a practice is
-Practices are performances
-Practices are mediated
-Practices are organized sayings and doings
-Practices have histories
-Practices have social constituencies
-Practices are normative
-Practices are object-oriented
Practices are performances
-A practice only exists when it is performed and reproduced, teaching does not exist as a mysterious entity seperate from performance
-The focus should be on connected performances across time and space
Practices are mediated
-People do not perform practices without resources, their actions are mediated by material and discursive elements
-Material mediators include tools, machines, technologies, buildings, documents, and physical spaces
-Discursive mediators include language, concepts, categories, stories, instructions, and professional terminology
-These mediators are not passive background elements, they make particular performances possible and influence how they are conducted
Practices are organized sayings and doings
-Practices contain recognizable combinations of speech and action
-Cooking, teaching, trading, or diagnosing patients each involves different arrangements of what people say and do
-The organization of these actions distinguishes one practice from another
Practices have histories
-A single action is not automatically a practice
-Practices have duration because performances are repeated and connected across time
Practices have social constituencies
-A practice requires a group that regularly performs and recognizes it
-This community helps sustain the practice and defines what counts as competent or legitimate participation
-When nobody performs a practice any longer, the practice disappears although the documents and memories remain as traces
Practices are normative
-Practices contain ideas about correct and incorrect performance
-Participants recognize that there are better, worse, appropriate, inappropriate, competent, and incompetent ways of proceeding
-These standards are not necessarily fixed, they may be contested and struggles over proper performance can produce new versions of a practice
Practices are object-oriented
-Practices are directed toward something that matters to participants: object/telos
-This purpose is not completely fixed, it is continually negotiated and may change as the practice developes
-The purpose does not originate exclusively in individual intentions --> when indvidiuals join a practice, they encounter existing expectations about what the activity is trying to accomplish
Individuals as carriers of practices
-Practice theory does not claim that individuals are unimportant, it changes how they are understood
-The individual is not necessarily the starting point of the explanation, individuals are treated as carriers of practices --> they learn, perform, reproduce, combine, and modify
-Behavior is shaped by the professional practices in which they participate, including the ways of speaking, standards of competence, technologies, etc.
2 extremes
-Methodological individualism, which explains society primarily through individual choices
-Structural determinism, which explains behavior through large structures that appear to control people from above
From local practices to larger social phenomena
-One of practice theory's main ambitions is to connect small-scale activities with large-scale phenomena
-Organizations, institutions, markets, and societies are not located at a separate, higher level of reality --> they are composed of interconnected practices and material arrangements
-Practices become connected when, for example, one practices produces resources used by another, different practices depend on the same space, several practices share a goal
Flat ontology
-Rejects the assumption that society is naturally divided into levels such as the individual, organization, institution, and society
-Researchers should instead investigate how apparently large phenomena are practically assembled from connected activities
-This does not mean that large structures are imaginary, it means that researchers must explain how their apparent size, stability, and power are produced
Weak program
-Recognizes that researchers should pay more attention to everyday activities, however does little more than describe and list what people do
-A weak study might identify activities such as holdings meetings, producing reports, or speaking with clients without explaining why the activities take their form, how they became established, how they connect with other practices, etc.
-Such research can result in a so what problem, it uses language of practices but does not generate a new explanation
Strong program
-Uses practices to explain social phenomena
-Asks how social arrangements emerge, become stable, change, disappear, connect with other arrangements, and produce particular consequences
-The strong version goes beyond documenting local activity, it reconstructs organizations and institutions as networks, assemblages, nexuses, or textures of practices
Danger of localism
-Practice research often involves close observation of particular situations, which is useful but it can produce localism
-Localism occurs when researchers explain everything through what happens in one immediate situation while ignoring the broader historical and spatial connections that made that situation possible
-A practice only becomes fully intelligible when its wider context, history, and connections are investigated
Conventional scientific sense
-Formulate universal laws
-Identify fixed causal relationships
-Develop variables that predict behavior
-Construct a complete model of society
What does practice theory supply
-A vocabulary, such as practices, performances, mediation, material arrangements, and nexuses
-A grammar explaining how these concepts can be connected
-A methodology for investigating social activity
-A style for representing social phenomena in research texts
Theory must remain open
-Nicolini warns against constructing an all-encompassing practice vocabulary that tries to classify everything in advance
-A productive ontology should remain incomplete, it should provide researchers with conceptual resources while allowing empirical phenomena to challenge and modify those concepts
-Researchers should not first construct an ideal definition of practice and then measure reality against it
Machinery for asking questions
-Practice theory should be treated as a method of generating questions rather than as a collection of predetermined answers
-Its purpose is not simply to study practice as an abstract topic
-Researchers use practice theory to investigate substantive phenome such as organizations, education, healthcare, consumption, etc.
4 research orientations
-Situational
-Genealogical
-Configurational
-Conflict-sensitive
Situational orientation
-The situational orientation begins with close observation of how participants produce an orderly scene of action
-The research asks what people are doing and saying, how they coordinate their actions, what objects and technologies are involved, what counts as a resource, etc.
-It treats action as open, the meaning of an action becomes clear through what happens before and after it
Why observation matters in situational orientation
-Familiar activities often become invisble to the people performing them, participants may omit important details because those details seem obvious
-Researchers should observe practices as directly as possible
-Interviews alone are insufficient because interviews provide accounts of practices rather than direct access to their performance
Multiple practices in situational orientation
-Researchers rarely encounter one isolated practice
-The researcher must decide which practices are relevant without assuming the answer beforehand
Main limitation of situational orientation
-Close observation can produce a detailed account of one situation without explaining its history or connections
-The scene of action should therefore be the begining and ideally also the endpoint of the investigation, but not its complete scope
Genealogical orientation
-It follows a practice through time, where it asks how a practice emerges, becomes established, recruits practitioners, travels to new locations, changes, lsoes participants and eventually disappears
-Nicolini discusses an approach in which practices emerge through connections among meanings, skills, and material tools
-A practice can change when one of these elements changes or when they are combined differently
Main affordance in genealogical orientation
-This approach makes social change easier to investigate
-Researchers can examine how a practice is reproduced and how variations gradually become established
-It is also more manageable to study a relatively specific practice than an enormous category
Limitations of genealogical orientation
-Reliance on interviews and retrospective accounts, where practioners can explain how they understand their work, but may overlook embodied or taken-for-granted aspects
-Reification, where researchers may begin treating the practice as an object with fixed boundaries
-Researchers are studying repeated performances, not a stable thing
Configurational orientation
-Examines how practices become connected into larger bundles, nexuses, and constellations --> zooming out
-Researchers follow the mediators that connect different sites, such as people, technologies, financial resources, reports, and measurements
-Instead of assuming that an abstract structure connects activities, researchers investigate the practical work through which connections are made
Main affordance of configurational orientation
Allows practice theory to explain organizations, institutions, and other large phenomena without treating them as abstract forces situated above local activity
Limitations of configurational orientation
-Researchers may begin with a ready-made model and simply search for examples that confirm it
-Practice architecturism: drawing elaborate maps of interconnected practices without explaining how practitioners actually produce those connections
Conflict-sensitive orientation
-Studies the co-evolution, competition, contradiction, and interference of practices
-This orientation is especially important because questions of power can otherwise disappear from practice theory
-Power is not understood exclusively as something possessed by an individual or institution, it is produced through the arrangement of practices
-Conflicts can also be productive, where contradictions may expose problems and create opportunities for learning, innovation, or transformation
What questions does the conflict-sensitive orientation ask
-What happens when practices compete for participants or resources?
-How does one practice become dominant?
-How do practices obstruct one another?
-What contradictions exist inside a practice?
-How do these tensions generate change?
-Who gains or loses power from a particular configuration?
Main affordances of practice theory
-It overcomes traditional dualisms
-It makes invisible work visible
-It explains stability without assuming fixed structures
-It preserves the possibility of change
-It connects local activity with larger phenomena
Traditional dualisms
-Individual and society
-Agency and structure
-Mind and body
-Social and material
-Theory and action
-Local and global
What invisible work does practice research reveal
-Informal coordination
-Improvisation
-Maintenance
-Embodied competence
-Material dependencies
-Small adjustments
-Background labor
Stability without assuming fixed structures
-Practices become durable because they are repeatedly performed, embedded in bodies, supported by objects and texts, and connected with other practices
-Stability is an achievement, not an automatic condition
What changes can occur
-New technologies
-Altered meanings
-New skills
-Conflicts between practices
-Changes in membership
-Shifts in standards
-Modifications in material arrangements
Connecting local activity with larger phenomena
By following connections between practices, researchers can move from a particular scene to broader organizations and institutions without assuming separate levels of social reality
Main limitations and risks
-Merely listing practices
-Reifying practices
-Becoming trapped in local situations
-Overbuilding theory
-Mechanical application of concepts
-Neglecting power
-Methodological difficulties
Overbuilding theory
Endless debates about the exact definition of practice can become detached from empirical research
Mechanical application of concepts
If researchers use predetermined categories as a checklist, they may find only what the theory told them to expect
Neglecting power
Researchers must ask what effects practices produce, which groups benefit, who is excluded, and how some practices become dominant
What decisions need to be made about methodological difficulties
-Where a practice begins and ends
-How long it should be followed
-Which connections matter
-Whether interviews can substitute for observation
-How historical evidence should be interpreted
-Which practices should be compared
Nicolini's unresolved questions
-Practices versus practice-based studies: Is studying one particular practice the same as using practice theory to study a broader phenomenon?
-Proximity and ethnograpgy: Must researchers directly enter the setting? Can practice be studied adequately from interviews, documents, archives, or large datasets?
-Historical scope: How much history is necessary?
-Comparison: Should practice-based studies compare different settings or practices?