1/14
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Emad 2019
Ethnography of medical students taking their dissection anatomy course
Classic rite of passage in medical training
Looks at studentsā shifting perceptions of themselves and the cadavers over time
Article is also a self-ethnography as Emad considers her own reactions
also interested in how the students were learning
Specifically the process of reflection on their emotions, responses & actions while learning
In education, reflective practice means a process in which trainees or working professionals reflect on our actions and the ideas behind them, learning from these and growing as practitioners
Corpses, cadavers and teaching
In contrast the cadaver is a medicalized corpse, considered as a source of medical/forensic information or a teaching tool
This recontextualization invites us to consider the corpse differently
Corpses, body parts and teaching
Conversations about the cadaver and the use of the corpse in teaching include:
Perceptions of the cadaver in medicine
Discussions like Emad 2019
Foucaultās ideas on power and control (see Lecture 6)
The corpse as āedutainmentā ā audience responses to displays like BodyWorks
Structural inequities in anatomy & osteology
Kristeva argues that things that threaten our sense of primal identity trigger abjection: a sense of horror/nausea/dislocation
Since infancy weāve relied on a set of mental divisions (e.g. person vs. thing), so seeing these divisions violated/questioned disturbs us
The corpse menaces us by being both person and object and by visibly crossing the boundary into dead matter (decay)
Emad refers to the resulting feeling as āfinding oneself suddenly and radically embodied and disembodied at the same timeā ā encountering the cadaver makes students conscious of their own bodies and what they have in common with the cadavers (mortality, an existence as mere matter)
Abjection as a concept in Emad 2019
Emad explains that abjection isnāt just revulsion, it can be experienced as a deep sense of shock
She points out that this abjection is likely heightened by the fact that people in this society rarely come into contact with the dead
The idea of abjection helps Emad to understand the studentsā initial responses to the cadavers as well as her own
Itās also important for Emadās discussion of how students learn in the lab ā she argues that this shock jolts students out of their old mental habits and is thus an important part of their learning
Observing a rite of passage
Students observed during 2008 dissection anatomy course
Followed up with interviews and focus groups
Emad argues (as others have done before her) that this course is an important rite of passage for medical students
Passage into special identity of physician in training
Achieved through dissecting a cadaver ā not only becoming intimately familiar with death, but treating the corpse in a way that is unacceptable for most other members of society
Dissection anatomy lab can be seen as a liminal space for transition where death is seen differently and decay is suspended
Incorporation - students validated as ātrueā physicians in training
Observing a rite of passage: We actually see multiple elements of rites of passage
Each day: initial separation through passage into a separate preliminary space (classroom), wearing of special identifiable clothing
Also literal separation through the āfirst cutā which can be seen as a rite of separation or even its own small rite of passage ā cutting into corpse is unacceptable in almost any other situation ā an important boundary to cross
Observing students and cadavers
Students experience abjection, especially early in the course
Disquiet at seeing/handling cadaver and at cutting into it, disquiet when they are reminded of their common humanity
Part of their experience is dealing with this reaction
They distance themselves enough to allow learning, in part by reinterpreting the corpse as a learning object or gift from dead
They try not to dehumanize the body, showing care/compassion
They stress their ultimate goal of treating the living
Observing herself
Emad also notes her own reactions and abjection
Reflexivity (considering oneās own position, perspective and reactions) is an important aspect of anthropological research
She passes through the course in her own different way
As an observer ā visibly different, not as welcomed by some
As a social scientist (maybe not experienced in any dissection at all)
She suggests that her different role and lack of support structure (classmates) may help to explain strong abjection she experienced
A āpassageā from, and back to, humanity
Specialized embalming āredefinesā the corpse as a cadaver
During its time in the anatomy lab the cadaver exists in a liminal space, is not named, is treated differently than a usual corpse
After dissection is over, bodies are cremated and returned to kin; medical schools hold memorials where the bodies are remembered as selfless, named donors and teachers ā theyāre ārehumanizedā
The cadaver, humanity and identity: Emad study gives us an example of
Abjection and how the corpse can be seen to inspire disgust, fear or revulsion as well as fascination, interest or compassion
Changing identity and self-perception of the living as the result of contact with/handling of the dead
The very different ways that death and the dead may be seen when we move from mortuary/ritual to medical/scientific context
Corpses, dissection and power
Modern anatomical gifts programs rely on voluntary donation, but exist against a long history of very different behaviour
Poor communities and racial minorities were less able to protect their dead, less likely to be listened to when victimized
Measures taken to protect the dead included cemetery guards and mortsafes ā both were expensive, so graves of the poor were more likely to be robbed
This declined after laws allowing dissection of unclaimed bodies and destitute passed in 1830s (UK) and 1850s onward (USA)
Earlier inequities persisted ā most cadavers from marginalized groups (more likely to be unclaimed)
Dissection and consent today
In the latter 20th c., policies of medical schools shifted
Reliance on donated cadavers, emphasis on respectful treatment
Reflects institutional and cultural changes including:
Growth of formalized medical ethics
Increased emphasis on consent in medical procedures
Changing public attitudes toward body donation
However some dependence on unclaimed bodies persists
This varies by nation, and by school within nations ā see Osterholtz reading. The UofA medical school uses only donated bodies.
Corpses, curation and power
Older practices created a modern dilemma:
Some early 20th c autopsies of unclaimed remains ended with the preparation of skeletons for study and curation
This created large skeletal anatomy collections still used in research today
These have been vital to research in forensics (e.g. methods for estimating age/sex), but represent marginalized people who did not willingly donate their remains
Corpses, dissection and power (Back then)
Dissection traditionally forbidden by most faiths
Considered a violation of deceased ā body should remain intact
Practiced in Europe starting in 1300s
Corpses of condemned criminals dissected
In 1700s and 1800s number of dissections and demand for cadavers increased
Result was rise of body snatching ā theft of bodies from recent burials for sale to medical schools
Illegal, but authorities often looked the other way