1/19
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Context
Shift in 1965 away from demographic engineering towards strict equity
Key Themes
Tension between visas and demand for labor, rise of undocumented population, partisan polarization
Thesis
1965 ended discriminatory quotes> strict equity created unintended consequences> 1986 and 1990 failed to resolve> criminalization and legislative gridlock
Hart-Cellar Act of 1965
Abolished the national origins quota, visas no longer discriminated against race/ethnicity
Preference System
Shifted the visa focus to family reunification and professional skills
20k Per-Country Cap
Established a uniform limit of 20,000 visas per country, regardless of demand
20k Unintended Consequences
Treated high-demand countries the same as low-demand countries which created visa backlogs and incentivized unauthorized entry as legal routes closed
Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA)
Legalization if there was proof of continued residence in the U.S. before 1982.
Employer Sanctions
Ended the texas proviso, IRCA made it a crime to hire undocumented workers
Immigration Act of 1990
Increased visa caps, doubled employment visas, diversity visas
Institutional Design Problems
1990 act failed because it did not remove the 20k country cap
HR4437
Represented a shift toward the criminalization of undocumented presence, attempting to turn it into a felony punishable by imprisonment
Broad Enforcment
Bill sought to punish anyone who “assists” or transports an undocumented person
Mass Mobilization
2006 marches, “today we march, tomorrow we vote”, immigrant rights activists
Partisan Polarization
Growing ideological divide between political groups, b/c of HR4437
Determinants of Sentiment
Brader et al. research, elite cues and anxiety
Problem of Innumeracy
People consistently overestimate the size of the immigration population
Demography vs. Destiny
Demographic change has not led to pro-immigrant policy because the population is concentrated unevenly in places
Legislative Broken System
Requirement for 218 house votes and 60 senate votes to overcome a filibuster ensures that partisan polarization remains a barrier
Reflection
The broken system is a result of 1965 framework and the subsequent failure of the 1986 and 1990 acts to adjust for the reality of international migration