1/65
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Logic
the science that evaluates arguments.
argument
A group of statements, one or more provide support for one of the others.
statement
Is a sentence that is either true or false.
premise
The statements that set forth the reasons or evidence.
conclusion
the statements that the evidence is claimed to support or imply.
inference
the reasoning process expressed by an argument
proposition
the meaning or information content of a statement
truth value
the truth and falsity of a statement
principle of charity
We should treat the argument the way the author intended it to be.
loosely associated statements (not an argument)
may be about the same general subject, but they lack claim that one of them is proved by the others.
expository passage (not an argument)
develops the topic sentence
Illustrations (not an argument)
A statement about a certain subject combined with a reference to one or more specific instances intended to exemplify.
explanations (not an argument)
a group of statements that’s purpose is to shed light on an event.
conditional statements (not an argument)
If, then statements
sufficiency (example)
being a dog is all you need to be an animal
nessesity (example)
You can’t be a dog without being an animal
deductive argument
premises are claimed to support the conclusion in such a way that it is IMPOSSIBLE for the premises to be true and the conclusion false.
inductive argument
premises are claimed to support the conclusion in such a way that it is IMPROBABLE that the premises are true and the conclusion false.
argument based on mathematics
an argument in which the conclusion depends on some purely arithmetic or geometric computation or measurement.
argument from definition
the conclusion is claimed to depend merely upon the definition of some word or phrase used in the premise or conclusion.
syllogism
an argument with 2 premises and 1 conclusion
categorical syllogism
a syllogism in which each statement begins with one of the words ALL, NO, or SOME
hypothetical syllogism
a syllogism having a conditional statement for one or both of its premises.
disjunctive syllogism
A syllogism having a disjunctive statement (either or) for it’s premises.
argument from analogy
an argument that depends on the existence of an analogy or similarity between two things or state of affairs.
inductive generalization
an argument that proceeds from the knowledge of a selected sample to some claim about the whole group.
prediction
premises deal with some known event in the past or present and the conclusion moves beyond this event to some event in the relative future
argument from authority
an argument in which the conclusion rests upon a statement made by some presumed authority or witness.
argument based on signs
an argument that proceeds from the knowledge of a certain sign to a knowledge of the thing or situation that the sign symbolizes.
casual inference
proceed from knowledge pf a cause to knowledge of an effect or conversely, from knowledge of effect to knowledge of a cause.
particular statement
makes a claim about one or more particular members of a class
general statement
makes a claim about all members of a class.
valid argument
an argument such that it is impossible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false. (deductive)
invalid argument
it is possible for the premises to be true and the conclusion false.
sound argument
A deductive argument that is valid and has all true premises
unsound argument
a deductive argument that is invalid, has one or more false premises or more false premises or both.
strong argument
It is improbable that the premises be true and the conclusion false. (inductive)
weak argument
the conclusion does not follow the probability from the premises even though it is claimed too.
cogent argument
an inductive argument that is strong and has all true premises.
incogent argument
an inductive argument that is weak, has one or more false premises, or both.
fallacy
a defect argument that consists of in something other than merely false premises
formal fallacy
may be identified through mere inspection of the argument
informal fallacy
can be detected only through analysis of the content of the argument
fallacies of relevance
premises are logically irrelevant to the conclusion but use psychology to manipulate how it is perceived.
appeal to force
uses threats
appeal to pity
uses pity
appeal to the people
(direct and indirect) Uses human desires to get people to accept the conclusion.
direct approach
arguer addresses a large group of people
indirect approach (3 ways)
not at a crowd, but at one or more individuals separately.
bandwagon argument
the idea that you will be left behind or left out of you don’t use this product.
appeal to vanity
associates the product with someone who is admired with the idea that you will be like them.
appeal to snobbery
only a select few can be a part of it
Argument against the person (3 options)
Two arguers, one attacks the other in some way.
ad hominem abusive
responds by verbally abusing the other
ad hominem circumstantial
the responder discredits the argument by alluding to circumstances
tu quoque
tries to make the arguer look hypocritical
accident
committed when a general rule is applied to a specific case it was not intended to cover
straw man
arguer distorts an opponent’s argument for the purpose of more easily attacking it
missing the point
illustrates a special for of irrelevance
red herring
diverts the attention of the reader to a subtly related topic
the ethics of belief
(Clifford) One should only believe something if there is clear evidence.
Dunning-Kruger effect
people believe they know more or less than they actually know based on howe educated they are about the topic.
baloney detection kit
gets to the truth value using critical thinking values
reason to believe (Clifford)
Is it knowledge a human can possess? Has the person acquired knowledge.
James
agrees with Clifford.
Criteria for James
Is it living or dead?
Forced or avoidable?
momentous or trivial?
For James it must be living (realish), forced, momentous.