Contracts

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/366

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Trust God

367 Terms

1
New cards

Landy exam approach: order of questions for each party pair?

(1) Is there offer and acceptance? (2) Is there any glaring barrier to enforcement? (3) What are the terms? (4) Was there a breach, and what's the remedy? Don't spend much time on offer and acceptance when the facts say the parties agreed. [Landy memo]

2
New cards

Contract: Restatement (Second) definition?

'A promise or set of promises for the breach of which the law gives a remedy, or the performance of which the law in some way recognizes as a duty.'

3
New cards

Contract: four basic elements?

(1) 2+ parties; (2) 1+ promise; (3) an exchange relationship (needn't be equal); (4) enforceable in law.

4
New cards

Contract law: three sources and how they rank?

(1) Common law: default rules (services, land, employment). (2) Statutes: UCC Article 2 for goods and other state law; statutes override common law where they apply. (3) Secondary sources (Restatement, treatises): persuasive only, though courts often adopt them.

5
New cards

Equitable remedies: types, and when are they available?

Specific performance (very rare), injunction (very rare), rescission (less rare). Generally available only when money is inadequate; heavily disfavored for personal services contracts. [Kakaes]

6
New cards

Remedies: if a clause is a promise rather than a pre-agreed remedy, who picks the remedy?

The court, and money wins if it's adequate. [Kakaes]

7
New cards

RS § 344: three interests remedies protect?

(a) Expectation: benefit of the bargain, as good a position as if the contract had been performed. (b) Reliance: as good a position as if the contract had never been made. (c) Restitution: restores any benefit P conferred on D.

8
New cards

Expectation damages: basic measure (Hawkins)?

Value of the promised result minus value of the actual result. [Hawkins v. McGee]

9
New cards

UCC Article 2: scope (§§ 2-102, 2-105, 2-106)?

Article 2 applies to sales of goods. A good is something movable (§ 2-105); a sale is the passing of title (§ 2-106). Transfer of title to a movable item = sale of goods.

10
New cards

Why does UCC vs. common law matter?

Different rules on terms, statute of limitations, and Statute of Frauds.

11
New cards

Hybrid contracts (goods + services): test and factors?

Predominant (primary) purpose test. Look at contract language, price allocation, reason for the contract, and nature of the seller's business. Predominantly goods → Article 2 applies.

12
New cards

UCC § 2-104: three ways to be a merchant?

(1) Deals in goods of the kind; OR (2) by occupation holds itself out as having knowledge or skill peculiar to the practices or goods involved; OR (3) has that knowledge or skill attributed to it through an agent, broker, or other intermediary who holds itself out that way.

13
New cards

UCC: how do you know whether merchant status matters?

Check whether the section uses the word 'merchant.' E.g., § 2-308 (place of delivery): no merchant requirement; § 2-209(2) (no-oral-modification clause): applies 'except as between merchants'; § 2-205 (firm offer): offer by a merchant; § 2-207(2): both merchants.

14
New cards

Merchant: does aesthetic or occupational expertise count?

Yes. A stylist who holds herself out as knowing jewelry is a merchant even if she doesn't deal in gems, and entrusting goods to a merchant lets her pass good title to a good-faith buyer (§ 2-403(2)). [Zaretsky]

15
New cards

Landy trap: is a buyer who has never bought these goods before a merchant?

Likely not, if it also doesn't hold itself out as having expertise. That can decide the § 2-207(2) analysis. [Landy memo]

16
New cards

Mutual assent: objective test?

Based on a party's outward expressions (words, actions), would a reasonable person in the other party's position assume the party intends to agree? Objective is the default, not subjective intent.

17
New cards

Objective test: context factors for reasonableness?

Judged from the perspective of the party the manifestation was made to: (1) that party's attributes (experience, training, sophistication); (2) background information it had; (3) relationship between the parties; (4) nature of the transaction.

18
New cards

Duty to read: does it matter if the offeree didn't read or understand the terms?

No, so long as there was notice of the terms and some act signaling assent. Signing = assent even if you don't understand the language. [Morales; James; Good v. Uber]

19
New cards

Standard term types: boxtop, shrinkwrap, clickwrap, browsewrap?

Boxtop: printed on the outside of the packaging. Shrinkwrap: inside the packaging, seen only when opened. Clickwrap: an affirmative step is required to proceed. Browsewrap: terms available by link; no affirmative step.

20
New cards

Online terms: rule for enforceability?

Notice + assent. Browsewrap: hyperlink proximity and conspicuousness alone aren't enough [Nguyen v. Barnes & Noble]. Clickwrap: reasonable notice (totality of circumstances) + a clear act of assent binds, even if unread [Good v. Uber].

21
New cards

Posted contest rules that a participant never read: bound?

Yes. The offeror must give notice of the terms, and participating = acceptance; not reading doesn't matter. [James]

22
New cards

Secret jest or hyperbole: is there a contract?

Outward manifestations control; a secret jest is irrelevant [Lucy v. Zehmer]. But no contract if no reasonable person would see the statement as a serious offer, judged by content, circumstances, and conduct [Leonard v. Pepsico; Kolodziej].

23
New cards

Offer: RS § 24 definition?

'A manifestation of willingness to enter into a bargain, so made as to justify another person in understanding that his assent to that bargain is invited and will conclude it.'

24
New cards

Responses to an offer (3) and their effect?

Outright rejection with no counterproposal: no contract. Rejection with a counterproposal: maybe a contract (counteroffer). Acceptance: contract formed.

25
New cards

Offer vs. invitation to negotiate: how do you find the offer?

Ask what created a power of acceptance in the other party. Look at the plain language, the parties' conduct, and whether something looked like an acceptance and what it referred to. [Babcock & Wilcox v. Hitachi]

26
New cards

Is a bid 'for informational purposes only' an offer?

No. A solicitation is an invitation to make offers, and a bid disclaiming being bound isn't an offer. [Fletcher-Harlee]

27
New cards

Ads as offers: general rule and test?

Ads generally aren't offers. An ad is an offer when it is clear, definite, and leaves nothing open for negotiation [Lefkowitz]. Specificity matters: who may accept, disclaimers, restrictions, formalities.

28
New cards

Ads: reward offer exception and factors?

Reward offers (including coupon redemption) can be offers: would a reasonable person assume performing the specific requested act yields a contract? Factors: no disclaimer; specific instructions; formal enrollment; no over-acceptance problem. [Sateriale]

29
New cards

Landy trap: does an ad with vague terms ('wine,' 'cheese platter,' 'Saturday night') pass the Lefkowitz test?

Be careful. Most students called it an offer, but the terms were intentionally unclear, and Landy gave only partial credit for persuasively arguing it was clear. Confront each vague term against 'clear, definite, nothing left open.' [Landy memo]

30
New cards

RS § 30: forms of acceptance an offer may invite?

(1) An affirmative answer in words, performing or refraining from a specified act, or the offeree selecting terms. (2) Unless indicated otherwise, any manner and medium reasonable in the circumstances.

31
New cards

Acceptance: four elements?

(1) Communicated to the offeror (any reasonable manner; mailbox rule for non-instantaneous communications); (2) complies with any instructions in the offer; (3) doesn't vary the terms (otherwise likely a counteroffer); (4) timely (by any stated deadline, otherwise within a reasonable time).

32
New cards

Mailbox rule: rule and scope?

Where mail is a reasonable method, acceptance is effective on deposit of a properly stamped and addressed acceptance. A default rule; applies only to acceptances, not rejections or revocations. [Trinity Homes]

33
New cards

Mailbox rule: instantaneous communications?

Substantially instantaneous two-way communication (e.g., phone) is treated as if the parties were face to face. Instantaneous = transmitted within seconds; two-way = a party can readily tell whether the other is aware. Fax is one-way, so the mailbox rule applies. [Trinity Homes]

34
New cards

Counteroffer vs. acceptance: test?

Objective: the reasonable meaning of the response. An acceptance must immediately form a contract; if the offeror has to 'do something' to tell whether there's a contract, it's a counteroffer. A response labeled a counteroffer is one, even with identical terms. [Roth v. Malson]

35
New cards

Revocation: rule and methods?

Acceptance must come while the offer is in effect; acceptance after revocation = no contract. Revocation can be direct, from the offeror [Hendricks], or indirect, through a reliable third party [Dickinson v. Dodds]. An uncommunicated acceptance doesn't block revocation. [Hendricks]

36
New cards

Must the offeree know of the offer?

Usually yes; manifesting acceptance while unaware an offer exists = no contract [Glover]. Exception: standardized, widely distributed, non-negotiable forms the offeree is generally aware of [Anderson].

37
New cards

Silence as acceptance (RS § 69): default and exceptions?

Default: silence ≠ acceptance. Exception 1 (conduct): offeree voluntarily takes the benefit of services it had a chance to reject [Day v. Caton]. Exception 2 (relationship): the relationship justifies the offeror expecting an explicit rejection; look for a clear offer, reasonable opportunity to opt out, repeated instructions on the consequences of silence, and the nature of the relationship [Gupta].

38
New cards

Unilateral vs. bilateral contract; implied-in-fact contract?

Unilateral: offeree accepts by fully performing; only the offeror has an outstanding promise [Carlill; Wayment]. Bilateral: both parties promise future performance. Implied-in-fact: established by conduct, not words; its meaning can be a jury question [Wayment].

39
New cards

RS § 45 vs. § 62: beginning performance?

§ 45 (offer invites performance only): beginning or tendering performance creates an option contract, so the offer can't be revoked; the offeror's duty is conditional on completion. § 62 (offer invites promise or performance): beginning performance = acceptance and operates as a promise to complete.

40
New cards

RS § 54: notice of acceptance by performance?

No notice needed unless the offer requests it. But if the offeree knows the offeror can't readily learn of the performance, the offeror's duty is discharged unless the offeree uses reasonable diligence to notify, the offeror learns within a reasonable time, or the offer waives notice.

41
New cards

UCC § 2-206: acceptance rules?

Acceptance in any reasonable manner and medium. An order for prompt shipment can be accepted by a prompt promise to ship or by shipping conforming or nonconforming goods. If beginning performance is a reasonable mode of acceptance, an offeror not notified within a reasonable time may treat the offer as lapsed.

42
New cards

Battle of the forms: common law baseline?

Mirror image rule: an acknowledgment with different boilerplate = rejection + counteroffer. No performance → no contract. If the offeree performs and the offeror acquiesces, the counteroffer is accepted (offeree's terms). Last shot rule: the last communication before performance controls.

43
New cards

UCC § 2-207: what two questions does it answer?

(1) Is there a contract? (2) What are the terms? The terms question dominates.

44
New cards

§ 2-207(1): when is there a contract?

A definite and seasonable expression of acceptance, or a written confirmation sent within a reasonable time, operates as an acceptance even if it adds or changes terms. Definite and seasonable = the transaction-specific terms match (price, quantity, payment, delivery).

45
New cards

§ 2-207(1): exception?

No contract under (1) if the acceptance is expressly conditional on assent to the new or different terms ('no contract until you agree to our terms').

46
New cards

§ 2-207(2): new terms when one or no party is a merchant?

New terms are proposals for addition and are excluded unless accepted (separately agreed to).

47
New cards

§ 2-207(2): new terms between merchants?

Included unless: (a) the offer expressly limits acceptance to its own terms; (b) they materially alter the deal (test: unreasonable surprise or hardship); or (c) the offeror objects, already or within a reasonable time.

48
New cards

§ 2-207(2): is a forum selection clause a material alteration?

Courts have treated it as one, so it's excluded. [Ridgelawn; Lively (written confirmation)]

49
New cards

§ 2-207(3): when does it apply, and what are the terms?

When there's no contract under (1) but the parties act as if there's a deal. Terms: keep the terms the writings agree on; toss conflicting terms; fill gaps with UCC gap fillers (e.g., § 2-308), then common law defaults. [Niagara]

50
New cards

§ 2-207: sequence?

Contract under (1) → go to (2), then stop; don't go to (3). No contract under (1) → go to (3).

51
New cards

Landy trap: you found a contract under § 2-207(1). Where next?

§ 2-207(2), not (3). Many students wrongly went to (3). The turning point is usually whether both parties are merchants. [Landy memo]

52
New cards

Rolling contract: definition?

A contract concluded after the buyer has seen the terms, had a reasonable opportunity to reject, and didn't. It forms once the buyer takes no action to reject within the allowed period. Generally enforceable. [Dye v. Tamko]

53
New cards

Terms inside the box (shrinkwrap)?

Bind if the buyer had notice and a chance to reject and kept or used the product (courts accept the seller's view). [ProCD]

54
New cards

Terms printed on the outside of the box (boxtop)?

Opening and keeping the product after conspicuous notice = acceptance. An agent's acceptance binds the owner. [Dye v. Tamko]

55
New cards

Unilateral post-contract amendments: when is the non-drafter bound?

Through continued use, if there was (1) notice of the drafter's right to amend, given at the original contract, and (2) notice of the changes when made.

56
New cards

Preliminary agreements: three types?

Type I: fully binding to the ultimate contractual objective. Type II: binding obligation to negotiate open terms in good faith within the agreed framework. Type III: not binding at all.

57
New cards

Type I preliminary agreement: four factors?

(1) What the words say; (2) partial performance; (3) open terms; (4) whether this kind of deal is usually reduced to a full writing.

58
New cards

Type II preliminary agreement: five factors?

(1) What the words say; (2) context of negotiations; (3) open terms (may make sense to leave some for later); (4) partial performance (would a party suffer significant loss without it?); (5) necessity of putting the agreement in final form.

59
New cards

Two-page MOU to 'work together' on a development, with open terms?

Not Type I (open terms; such deals are usually fully written), but Type II: the parties must negotiate in good faith. [Brown v. Cara]

60
New cards

Agreement to agree: when enforceable?

If terms are sufficiently definite (not every detail). Price needs at least a formula. The court must be able to determine with reasonable certainty what the parties intended, and gap-filling must be consistent with their intent. [Alaska Fur]

61
New cards

Agreement to negotiate: requirements?

(1) Sufficiently definite terms; (2) a specific way to resolve differences; (3) a means to determine breach and provide a remedy. The word 'negotiate' alone isn't enough. [Alaska Fur]

62
New cards

Indefiniteness: what's the minimum at common law?

Terms definite enough to determine with reasonable certainty whether a breach occurred: price (a number or a means to get one), duration, and any other limiting terms (e.g., what counts as 'success'). Courts flesh out terms from the writings and commercial practice. [Baer v. Chase]

63
New cards

Promise to pay 'commensurate to true value' if a show succeeds?

Too indefinite: no agreed price or duration, and 'success' undefined. [Baer v. Chase]

64
New cards

Statute of Frauds: covered contracts?

(1) Answering for the debt of another; (2) duties of decedents (executors); (3) in consideration of marriage; (4) sale of land or an interest in land; (5) can't be performed within one year; (6) sale of goods for $500+ (UCC § 2-201; leases of goods $1,000+).

65
New cards

SOF: what counts as a writing?

Tangible or electronic; need not be formal (it's evidence of a contract). Informal writings, texts, or a series of connected texts/attachments are OK; can be pieced together from multiple documents.

66
New cards

SOF: signature requirement?

Signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought: wet ink, electronic, or other indicia of intent to authenticate. Can be an agent's signature. Need appear on only one document.

67
New cards

SOF: essential terms requirement?

Identifies the subject matter and material unperformed terms, directly or implicitly, with specificity and intent to bind. Under the UCC, must include quantity.

68
New cards

SOF: can texts or emails satisfy it?

Yes, they can be a signed writing. But 'work through my broker' ≠ authority for the broker to bind. [St. John's Holdings] An email exchange can satisfy the SOF. [Landy memo]

69
New cards

SOF one-year rule: how measured, and test?

Measure from formation to the end of performance (not the start). Test: in light of the terms, would it be a breach to finish in under a year? Was early performance contemplated and permitted? If the terms require more than a year with no early payoff option → SOF applies. [Holloway v. Bucher]

70
New cards

SOF: partial performance exception?

Applies when the only reasonable explanation for the parties' actions is a contract. Usually limited to sale or lease of real estate where possession has transferred.

71
New cards

UCC § 2-201(1)?

A writing sufficient to show a contract was made, signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought (or its agent/broker). Not insufficient because it omits or misstates a term, but not enforceable beyond the quantity shown.

72
New cards

UCC § 2-201(2): merchant's confirmation?

Between merchants, a confirming writing sufficient against the sender satisfies (1) against the recipient if the recipient has reason to know its contents and makes no written objection within 10 days of receipt.

73
New cards

UCC § 2-201(3): exceptions (regardless of merchant status)?

(a) Specially manufactured goods: not suitable for sale to others, and the seller made a substantial beginning or procurement commitments before notice of repudiation. (c) Partial performance: goods paid for and payment accepted, or received and accepted (only to that extent).

74
New cards

SOF: is an end-user a merchant? Are fungible goods specially manufactured?

No to both. [Vanguard]

75
New cards

Landy trap: oral agreement to sell land, with no signature by the party being sued. Enforceable?

No. Sale of land must satisfy the SOF; even with other elements met, there's no signature by the party against whom enforcement is sought. Next argument: promissory estoppel. [Landy memo]

76
New cards

Consideration: definition (Hamer)?

Some right, interest, profit, or benefit to one party, or some forbearance, detriment, loss, or responsibility given, suffered, or undertaken by the other, given in exchange for the return promise. No actual benefit to the promisor or harm to the promisee is required. [Hamer v. Sidway]

77
New cards

RS § 71: bargain theory?

(1) Performance or return promise must be bargained for. (2) Bargained for = sought by the promisor in exchange for its promise and given by the promisee in exchange for that promise. (3) Performance may be an act, a forbearance, or creating/modifying/destroying a legal relation. (4) May be given to or by someone other than the promisor or promisee.

78
New cards

Consideration: three elements?

(1) Nature: a promise, forbearance, or performance (incl. giving up a legal right); can be implied. (2) Mutuality: on both sides, not illusory on either end. (3) Inducement: must induce the return promise on both sides.

79
New cards

Consideration: can reliance or a general motive supply inducement?

No. Actions taken after the promise can't have induced it, and a general positive motive (e.g., a desire to help) isn't enough. [Kadimah; Carlisle]

80
New cards

Condition to a gift vs. consideration: test?

Does the condition benefit the promisor, and did that benefit induce the promise? Yes to both → consideration [Pennsy v. American Ash]. If the condition merely enables the promisee to receive the gift → gift [Carlisle; Kirksey]. Consideration can be implicit.

81
New cards

Adequacy of consideration?

Courts won't inquire unless it shocks the conscience or is a sham. Unfairness or inadequate compensation doesn't matter. [Kessler v. Nat'l Presto]

82
New cards

Landy trap: can you argue a royalty rate (the price term) is unconscionable?

Likely a failing argument. The royalty is the consideration, and courts rarely inquire into its sufficiency unless it's token; 10% isn't token. [Landy memo]

83
New cards

Past consideration?

Not consideration. Consideration must be new to this contract. [Carlisle]

84
New cards

Pre-existing duty rule (RS § 73)?

Performing a legal duty already owed (by contract, statute, etc.) that isn't doubtful or honestly disputed isn't consideration. Exception: doing something different that reflects more than a pretense of bargain. [White v. Homewood]

85
New cards

Common law modifications: rule?

No new duties → no new consideration → modification unenforceable. [Alaska Packers]

86
New cards

Supervening difficulties exception to the pre-existing duty rule (5)?

Modification upheld without consideration if: (1) substantial, burdensome, unanticipated difficulty after formation; (2) burdened party didn't assume the risk; (3) difficulty didn't result from its own error or misjudgment; (4) other party's agreement is genuine, fair, and equitable; (5) the party seeking modification dealt honestly and fairly, not coercively.

87
New cards

Landy trap: party demands more money mid-contract to do work it already promised. Analysis?

Pre-existing duty rule bars the modification. Don't use the parol evidence rule (it doesn't reach post-formation promises), and duress needs an objective threat. [Landy memo]

88
New cards

Forbearance to sue: when is it consideration?

Only with a bona fide dispute: the outcome is in good-faith, genuine doubt, and there's an objectively reasonable basis for the claim, even if it would ultimately fail. [Holt v. Holt]

89
New cards

Illusory promise?

Lacks any real promise because all obligations can be avoided; entirely discretionary performance = no consideration. E.g., a unilateral right to change, modify, or cancel any terms at any time. [NFB v. Container Store]

90
New cards

Illusory promise: how can an implied promise save the contract?

Look at context and other terms. E.g., exclusivity + revenue share + accounting duties → implied obligation to use reasonable efforts. [Wood v. Lucy]

91
New cards

Oral pledge to a charity, with only budgeting and naming plans afterward?

No consideration: those plans didn't induce the promise. The court declined RS § 90(2). [Kadimah v. DeLeo] Compare Morton Shoe (budgeting, borrowing, hiring = reliance → enforceable).

92
New cards

RS § 90(1): promissory estoppel?

A promise the promisor should reasonably expect to induce action or forbearance, which does induce it, is binding if injustice can be avoided only by enforcement. The remedy may be limited as justice requires.

93
New cards

RS § 90(2)?

A charitable subscription or marriage settlement is binding without proof that it induced action or forbearance.

94
New cards

Promissory estoppel: four elements?

(1) A promise: explicit, needn't be as definite as a contract promise, but more than optimism. (2) Reasonable expectation of inducement (foreseeable reliance). (3) Actual, reasonable, detrimental reliance; look for a substantial change in position. (4) Enforcement necessary to avoid injustice.

95
New cards

PE: must the promise be definite enough for a contract?

No. [Hoffman v. Red Owl] But optimism isn't a promise, and the promisee's sophistication matters [Garwood]. In a commercial context, reliance can be evidence a promise was made.

96
New cards

Landy trap: is 'we expect' (or 'I think I can get you…') a promise for PE?

No. 'We expect' is not a promise. Also check reasonable reliance and whether there's any injustice to remedy (e.g., merely shopping around isn't reliance). [Landy memo]

97
New cards

Landy trap: PE to change the terms of a signed, enforceable contract?

Atypical. PE usually fills in where there's no enforceable agreement; it must be balanced against the duty to read, and you need a true promise and actual reliance on it. [Landy memo]

98
New cards

RS § 139(1): PE and the Statute of Frauds?

A promise meeting § 90 is enforceable notwithstanding the SOF if injustice can be avoided only by enforcement; remedy limited as justice requires.

99
New cards

RS § 139(2): factors for whether injustice requires enforcement despite the SOF?

(a) Availability and adequacy of other remedies (esp. cancellation and restitution); (b) definite and substantial character of the reliance relative to the remedy; (c) how much the reliance corroborates the promise, or clear and convincing evidence; (d) reasonableness of the reliance; (e) foreseeability to the promisor.

100
New cards

Can PE overcome the SOF? (split)

No: the SOF is legislative [DK Arena]. Yes: PE softens a blunt instrument [Tour Costa Rica]. Maybe: if there was also a promise to put it in writing. Maybe: if a party showed intent not to assert the SOF. PE remedy can include expectation when reliance/restitution wouldn't make P whole [Tour Costa Rica].