Ethics prac SAC responses

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/3

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

4 Terms

1
New cards

Task 1  - Aristotle (10 marks)

"It is from the same causes and by the same means that every virtue is both produced and destroyed. By doing the acts that we do in our dealings with others we become just or unjust, and by facing danger or avoiding it we become brave or cowardly. The same is true of desires and emotions; some become temperate and good-tempered, others self-indulgent and irascible, depending on their behaviour in certain situations. In short, states of character arise from our activities. It makes a great difference whether we form habits one way or another from our very youth — indeed, it makes all the difference."

— Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Book II, Chapter I (adapted)

a.     According to Aristotle, why does the formation of habits from an early age matter so much for the development of virtue?

b.     How might another philosophical account of moral action challenge or qualify Aristotle’s emphasis on habit? You may draw on one of the Journal thinkers or, where useful, another thinker studied in the unit.

c.     Is the cultivation of a virtuous character sufficient to guide action when moral values conflict or when doing the right thing carries a significant personal cost? Defend your position and test it with a relevant example or case.

 

A) Aristotle argues that the formation of habits from an early age is crucial for the development of virtue because children are taught how to find pleasure in good actions and pain in bad actions, so that they can think morally. Aristotle suggests that we are not born moral, instead we become virtuous characters through habitually acting in a balance between excess and defect, ‘made perfect by habit.’ If children have flawed morals from a young age, is important for them to be corrected when they are children as to break the habits so that they create a moral, virtuous character. If they do not have moral guidance, then their experiences will shape their character instead of their character shaping their experiences, making them susceptible to developing immoral states of characters. In contrast, when they consistently practice balanced actions, they are more likely to become second nature and lead to a virtuous character. For example, if a parent notices their child stealing something from a shop when they think the shopkeeper is not looking, it is important for them to correct this behaviour, so it does not become a repeated unjust behaviour that becomes a part of the child’s character. Therefore, Aristotle suggests that it is important to form positive habits at a young age so that children develop virtues.

 

B) Both Kant and Aristotle agree that morality is grounded in reason, but Kant suggests that morality comes from principles and not habit. As a deontological philosopher, Immanuel Kant would critique Aristotle’s emphasis on habit, by suggesting that humans’ moral actions are motivated by a universal internal sense of duty, ‘the moral law within.’ He would reason that rational beings have an innate capacity to recognise these moral duties, so that moral action is not a result of habit but instead is tied to a sense of duty, in accordance with rational moral principles. For example, if someone sees another person drowning at the pool and they have completed lifeguard training, Aristotle may argue that a virtuous character would do the right thing and save the person, acting in a balance of cowardice and recklessness. However, Kant would suggest that this person must question whether they can rationally will the maxim of refusing assistance as a universal law. Overall, Kant focuses more on the rational principles and moral duty of actions, whilst Aristotle focuses on virtuous acts being habituated.

 

C) Possessing a virtuous character is not sufficient to guide moral action when moral values conflict, or when doing the right thing carries a significant personal cost. There can be multiple conflating moral virtues, such as a duty to tell the truth conflating with a duty to not harm innocent people, in which a virtuous character is not enough to remove the conflict of virtues. We can have a strong compulsion to act in a certain way yet act differently because of temporary lapses in judgement; ‘akrasia’. Consider that someone’s house is being invaded and the law enforcement are searching for someone in hiding. You are debating whether to lie to the law enforcement even though you think lying is bad, or to tell them where the person is and risking putting them in danger, being responsible for whatever happens to them. There are two conflating virtues—honesty and responsibility (to protect innocent people from harm). Though Aristotle offers ‘phronesis’ as a resolution to provide people the ability to negotiate difficult circumstances, it still does not settle the conflict between these virtues. Thus, habituation helps guide moral actions, but reasoning and calculations are necessary when conflating values and external factors conflict.

2
New cards

Task 3 – Immanuel Kant (10 marks)

"Humanity itself is an end, and never merely a means. Rational beings have a worth that is not simply a price that can be exchanged for some other benefit. I should therefore act so that I treat humanity, whether in my own person or in the person of another, always at the same time as an end and never merely as a means. When we deceive another person, coerce them, or use them only as an instrument for achieving our own purposes, we fail to respect their capacity to choose rationally for themselves. This requirement does not disappear because using one person might produce a desirable result for many others. Moral action is grounded in respect for rational persons and in principles that every rational agent could accept, rather than in calculating which outcome produces the greatest balance of benefit. A good will acts from duty because the moral law is binding in itself, not because obedience happens to produce favourable consequences."

— Immanuel Kant, Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals (adapted)

a.        Explain Kant’s claim that rational persons must be treated as ends in themselves rather than merely as means. How does this principle shape his account of morally right action?

b.        How might another ethical perspective respond to Kant in a case where using or harming one person could produce a substantial benefit for many others? Explain the philosophical disagreement, using a relevant case or thought experiment if helpful.

c.        Does respect for universal duties and the intrinsic worth of persons provide an adequate guide when duties, consequences or other moral considerations conflict? Defend your position with philosophical reasoning and a relevant example or case.

 

A) Kant’s Humanity Formula, as part of the ‘categorical imperative’, posits that rational beings must be treated as intrinsically valuable in their own rights and not as means to an end. This suggests that actions are morally right when they respect individuals’ rights. Suppose that someone asks their friend to go shopping with them but does not bring any money because they know that their friend is generous. They also know they will not pay their friend back.  Kant would argue that this is exploiting the friend and treating them as a tool in achieving their own desires, thereby making their act immoral. Overall, Kant argues that moral actions should not be exploitative and we should respect people’s autonomy— this matters, as rational people possess intrinsic worth and the capacity to choose ends for themselves.

 

B) Whilst both Kant and John Stuart Mill’s philosophy acknowledge that harming someone can produce substantial benefit for many others, Mill suggests that the consequences of actions determine their morality, rather than principle. Mill would argue that harming one person for the benefit of many others is ultimately justifiable when acting in the pursuit of maximising utility. The Trolley Problem thought experiment suggests that there is a person driving a trolley which is about to divert into one of two tracks, and there are five people on one track and one person on the other. Either way someone will be killed, and the person with the lever must determine which track the train will go on. Mill would argue that it is best to kill one person as to save five, to create the maximum utility, which challenges Kant’s Humanity Formula. Thus, Mill would argue that a person was going to die regardless, and so by allowing five people to live, the consequence of the action is more significant than the intent behind it, creating tension with how Kant believes that people should not be used as a means.

 

C) I do not think that respect for universal duties and intrinsic worth of people provides an adequate guide when external factors conflict, as it is difficult to create universal duties which everyone can agree with. Universal duties such as ‘one should not kill’ cannot truly guide all actions when these duties do conflate, creating significant issues. For example, consider how Batman had the opportunity to kill the Joker countless times as to stop him from killing more people, but instead chose to let him live, to abide by his moral values. Though Kant would argue that this principle of not killing others is a moral duty, it is difficult to justify how Batman could choose to allow the Joker to continue causing significant harm. His moral principle, that killing people is wrong, directly conflicts with how he allows the Joker to kill others, despite having the ability to stop him. Perhaps a more reasonable approach would be W.D. Ross’s critique, with ‘prima facie duties’, suggesting that a duty is binding unless it conflicts with stronger moral duties, thus resolving the conflating duties within Kant’s ethical dilemma.

3
New cards

Task 4 – John Stuart Mill (10 marks)

“Of two pleasures, if there be one to which all or almost all who have experience of both give a decided preference, irrespective of any feeling of moral obligation to prefer it, that is the more desirable pleasure. If one of the two is, by those who are competently acquainted with both, placed so far above the other that they prefer it, even though knowing it to be attended with a greater amount of discontent, we are justified in ascribing to the preferred enjoyment a superiority in quality.”

- John Stuart Mill, Utilitarianism, Chapter II

a.     According to Mill, how can we determine that one pleasure is more valuable than another?

b.     How might another philosophical perspective challenge or complicate Mill’s account of what makes something morally valuable?

c.     Is happiness an adequate basis for determining what is morally right? Defend your position, using a relevant example, case study or thought experiment to test your view.

A)    As a hedonistic utilitarianist, Mill suggests that to determine that one pleasure is more valuable than another, it requires ‘competent judges’, who are people who have experienced both kinds of pleasures prefer the higher ones, even when they bring greater dissatisfaction. This means that their informed preference establishes qualitative superiority. He supports this by explaining ‘it is better to be a man dissatisfied, than a pig satisfied’, further illustrating his belief that intellectual pleasures are more significant and satisfying than lower pleasures. He creates a distinction between lower, sensual pleasures which are those that satisfy basic human needs and instincts such as eating and drinking, and higher, intellectual pleasures which are more significant to human flourishing and lead to more profound happiness, such as wisdom and intellect. Thus, Mill suggests that ‘competent’ judges determine whether a pleasure is more valuable than another.

 

B)    Though both Mill and G.E. Moore hold utilitarian views, Moore argues that pleasure and happiness are not the only things which are intrinsically valuable and suggests that morality encompasses a broader range of intrinsic values that contribute to human wellbeing instead. This perspective challenges Mill’s belief that pleasure/ happiness is the good instead of accepting that there is a plurality of intrinsic goods, for its overly simplistic and reductive nature. Moore also argues against ethical naturalism and hedonism, instead suggesting that there is a plurality of intrinsic goods, other than simply pleasure and happiness, thus challenging Mill’s account of what makes things morally valuable.

 

C)    I believe that happiness is not an adequate basis for determining what is morally right, as other qualities are also important in ethical evaluation. Karl Popper argued that minimising harm must take precedence over maximising happiness, as suffering has a more immediate and severe impact on wellbeing. That is not to say that happiness is not important, but simply, it may not be the only factor that should be taken into consideration when determining what is morally right. Consider Amartya Sen’s colosseum thought experiment, in which the fights that occurred in the arena were watched as entertainment for many. This creates tension with the hedonic calculus used in classical utilitarianism, because if only a few numbers of gladiators were hurt and the happiness of the masses in the crowds was enormous, then it would be calculated as morally justifiable for these practices to occur. Mill may respond by arguing that this sadistic entertainment would be lower pleasure, meaning that their happiness does not excuse the pain caused. However, ultimately, I still believe that aggregate happiness alone is not enough to determine moral action, as it cannot always capture intrinsic worth and can violate human rights.

4
New cards

skip