1/6
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Cardiopulmonary criterion for death vs. brain death criterion
Cardiopulmonary criterion: A person is dead when their heart stops beating and blood circulation stops.
Brain death criterion: A person is dead when all brain functions have irreversibly stopped, even if their heart is still beating and a ventilator keeps them breathing.
Singer argues that brain death is not the same as the death of the whole human organism because the body can continue functioning without a brain.
Sanctity of life vs. quality of life
Sanctity of life: All human life has equal value, regardless of a person's consciousness or quality of life.
Quality of life: Whether continued life benefits a person depends partly on their ability to have experiences, be conscious, and enjoy life.
Singer argues that simply being a living human organism is not enough to show that life must always be prolonged.
Motivations for the brain death criterion
The brain death criterion was introduced partly because hospitals had patients with irreversible brain damage occupying beds and because doctors needed organs for transplants. The Harvard committee believed the new definition would reduce burdens on families and hospitals and make more life-saving organs available. Singer argues these were ethical and practical reasons, not simply new scientific discoveries about death.
Problems with the brain death criterion
Some patients declared brain-dead can maintain bodily functions for months or years, including growth, healing, and fighting infections. This shows that the body can still function as an integrated organism without brain activity. The standard tests may also fail to detect some remaining brain activity, meaning a patient could be incorrectly declared brain-dead.
Integrated functioning without brain activity (TK)
TK was a patient who was declared brain-dead at age four but lived for years afterward on a ventilator and feeding tube. His body grew, healed wounds, and fought infections despite having no functioning brain. Singer uses TK's case to argue that the brain is not necessary for the body to maintain integrated functioning, so brain death is not necessarily the death of the whole organism.
Minimally conscious states (Jahi McMath)
Jahi McMath was a teenager declared brain-dead after complications from surgery. Her family kept her on life support, and later evidence suggested she could respond to spoken commands and had some brain activity. Singer argues that this case raises doubts about whether standard brain death tests can reliably distinguish total, irreversible loss of brain function from a minimally conscious state.
Dead donor rule
The dead donor rule says that vital organs should only be removed from a donor who is already dead. Singer argues that if brain death does not mean the death of the whole organism, then removing organs from a brain-dead person with a beating heart conflicts with this rule. He proposes two possible alternatives: define death as the irreversible loss of consciousness, or keep the traditional cardiopulmonary definition but allow organ donation from living organisms who have irreversibly lost consciousness and given informed consent.