1/42
Exam Term IDs
Mill’s method of agreement
Compares cases that are otherwise different but agree on one dimension producing a similar outcome. Example: four friends go out to eat and all other different meals, but they all experience food poisoning, but they all experience food poisoning. Their meals had only one thing in common, and it was that they all included an omelet. According to Mill’s method of agreement, the omelet gave them food poisoning. Mill's method of agreement is important because it gives us a practical, repeatable way to cut through complexity and identify the most likely cause of an effect.
Mill’s method of difference
Compares cases that are otherwise similar but differ on one dimension, producing variant outcomes. Imagine you and your friends go out to eat. Everyone eats the same foods except for one person getting a different dish, and everyone gets food poisoning, but the person with the different dish. Using Mill’s method of difference, the one dish that everyone had in common, but that one person, is the cause of the food poisoning. Mill’s method of difference matters because it provides a way to identify factors by comparing cases.
Dependent variable
The phenomenon we want to understand or explain. In research question like, does economic development cause democracy, democracy is the dependent variable because it is what we want to explain/understand. A dependent variable is important because it defines the research question.
Independent variable
The factor explaining the dependent variable. In the research question, does economic development cause democracy, the independent variable is economic development. This is important because it establishes casual explanations.
falsifiability
The criterion that a theory, hypothesis, or claim must be structured so that it can be tested and potentially be proved wrong by evidence. Example: Economic development leads to democratization; if a country experiences sustained economic growth but does not transition to a democratic regime, the theory is falsified. Falsifiability is essential in comparative politics because it ensures that theories and claims are testable, evidence-based, and open to scrutiny, which strengthens the credibility and usefulness of political analysis.
Spurious correlation
A statistical relationship between two variables that appear related but have no casual connection, usually due to coincidence or an unobserved third factor such as a confounder. Example: the number of foreign aid dollars a country receives seems to correlate with the level of political stability in that country. At first glance, it might look like more aid causes stability. But in reality, the correlation could be spurious; both variables may be influenced by a third factor, such as the country’s economic crisis or natural disaster. In those cases, governments may seek more foreign aid and experience political instability at the same time, so aid is not the cause of stability. This matters because if analysists mistake spurious correlation for a causal link, they may design policies based on false premises.
Omitted variable
The omitted variable is the variable that may be left out when a researcher finds a positive correlation between two variables. Example: a researcher studies the effect of economic development on democracy and finds a positive link. However, they omit education level from the model. education is correlated with both economic (more educated populations tend to have higher incomes) development and democracy (educated citizens are more likely to support democratic institutions). Because the omitted variable is linked to both the independent and dependent variables, the estimated effect of economic development on democracy is biased upward; the model attributes some of education’s effect to economic development. This is important to note because if not it could lead to biased estimates and may be misleading.
reverse causation
Reverse causation occurs when the presumed outcome actually causes the presumed explanatory factor. Researchers might argue that economic development causes democracy, but democracy could also influence economic development. Comparative politics must address this problem to explain differences between countries accurately rather than mistake correlation for causation.
Weber’s definition of the state
A state is an organization that successfully claims a monopoly over the legitimate use of physical force within a defined territory. The French state authorizes police to enforce laws and prohibits private armed groups from exercising independent political authority. This definition helps comparativists distinguish states from other organizations and evaluate whether governments effectively control their territories
coercive capacity
Coercive capacity is the state’s ability to enforce its decisions and maintain order through institutions such as the police and the military. A government unable to prevent armed groups from controlling provinces has limited coercive capacity. It helps explain cross-country differences in security, political stability, and government’s ability to suppress opposition.
extractive capacity
extractive capacity is the state’s ability to obtain resources from society through taxation, conscription or other means. A government that collects taxes reliably from businesses and households has greater extractive capacity than one dependent on voluntary payments from local elites. It helps explain why some states can finance effected institutions and public services while others cannot.
political centralization
Political centralization concentrates final political authority in central institutions rather than independent local rules. French monarchs strengthened central authority by reducing the independence of regional nobles. It helps explain the development of unified political systems and variation in governments’ ability to enforce common rules.
differentiation of the state from other social organizations
differentiation means that state institutions operate separately from families, religious organizations, clans, or a ruler’s household. A civil service recruits officials through qualifications rather than giving offices exclusively to the ruler’s relatives. It helps comparativists explain differences between impersonal administration and systems in which public authority serves private relationships.
traditional authority
Traditional authority rests on the belief that inherited customs make a ruler’s power legitimate. A hereditary monarch is accepted because the royal family has historically governed. It explains why people may accept political rule without elections and why established institutions remain resilient.
charismatic authority
charismatic authority rests on followers’ belief in a leader’s exceptional personal qualities or mission. Fidel Castro’s revolutionary reputation contributed to his personal authority in Cuba. It helps explain political mobilization around individuals and succession problems when authority is difficult to transfer.
legal-rational authority
legal-rational authority rests on established laws and procedures that grant power to offices rather than particular individuals. A German chancellor exercises authority through constitutional procedures rather than hereditary entitlement. It helps explain institutional continuity and why political systems can remain stable despite changes in leadership.
state, regime, and government
the state consists of enduring governing institutions; the regime consists of rules for accessing and exercising power; the government consists of current political officeholders. A British election can replace the government while leaving the democratic regime and state institutions intact. Comparative politics distinguishes these levels to separate ordinary leadership turnover from democratization, authoritarian takeover, or state collapse.
state death
state death occurs when a political entity ceases to exist as a separate sovereign state. east Germany ceased to exist as a separate state following German reunification in 1990. It helps explain changes in the international map and distinguishes the disappearance of a state from the replacement of its rulers.
state formation
state formation is the historical emergence of centralized political authority over a territory and population. European kingdoms formed through consolidation of territories previously controlled by competing nobles. it explains where contemporary political institutions came from and why countries inherited different governing structures
state building
state building is the development and strengthening of institutions that implement political decision. establishing a national tax agency or professional civil service strengthens an existing state. It helps explain why countries with formal sovereignty differ in their practical ability to govern.
state scope
refers to the range of activities and responsibilities undertaken by the state. a state providing healthcare, pensions, education, and industrial planning has broader scope than one providing mainly defense and policing. it allows comparativists to distinguish the size of a government’s agenda from its ability to accomplish that agenda.
state capacity
state capacity is the ability to implement policies and achieve governing objectives. two countries may adopt universal education, but only one successfully staffs and supplies schools throughout its territory. it explains why similar policies can produce different outcomes across countries.
common measures of state strength
state strength is commonly assessed through tax collection, bureaucratic professionalism, and effective provision of public goods and welfare. Reliable taxation merit-based recruitment, maintained roads, and accurate pension payments indicate administrative strength. These measures allow comparisons beyond military power; high spending alone does not establish that a state governs effectively.
state reach/infrastructural power
infrastructural power is the state’s ability to implement decisions throughout society and across its territory. A government maintains functioning registries, schools, and courts in remote communities as well as major cities. It explains why national policies and citizenship rights may operate unevenly within the same country.
brown areas
brown areas are places where state authority and legal protections operate weakly or unevenly, often allowing local power holders to dominate. a district holds national elections, but a local boss controls policing and prevents residents from exercising their rights. the concept shows why a country classified as democratic may contain areas where citizens experience authoritarian rule.
failed state
a failed state experiences severe breakdown in core governing functions, particularly security, administration, and territorial control. Somalia following the collapse of its central government in 1991 is a common example of a failed state. It helps analyze extreme institutional weak ess, although the label can hide substantial differences between regions and institutions.
Tilly’s bellicist model of state building
Tilly argues that warfare encouraged rulers to build taxation, administration and armies, which then enabled further warfare. Competition among European powers pushed rulers to develop permanent revenue systems and military organizations. It explains state formation through military competition and raises the comparative question of whether states elsewhere faced similar pressures.
geography and weak states
geographic explanations argue that terrain, population distribution, and transportation costs can make state control difficult. Mountains can shelter insurgents and make government access to remote communities expensive. Geography helps explain differences in territorial reach, while comparisons show how infrastructure and institutions can reduce these constraints.
slavery and weak states
this explanation links slavery and slave trading to institutional weakness through predation, depopulation, insecurity, and the empowerment of coercive elites. Slave raids disrupted communities and encouraged violent extraction in parts of Africa. It connects historical exploitation to later differences in political trust and institutions; effects varied, and some slave-trading states gained short-term military power.
Colonialism and weak states
colonial explanations argue that institutions designed for extraction and limited territorial control often left weak foundations for broad public administration. Colonial governments frequently ruled through local intermediaries while concentrating investment in export-producing areas. They explain why postcolonial states inherited unequal territorial reach and institutions poorly suited to providing universal services.
cultural theory of development: weber
cultural theories argue that beliefs and values influence behaviors that support or inhibit economic development. weber emphasized religious ideas encouraging disciplined work and accumulation. treating work as a moral calling can encourage saving and reinvestment. in comparative politics, the theory offers a cultural explanation for economic differences that can be evaluated against institutional and geographic explanations.
protestant ethic
the protestant ethic describes values emphasizing disciplined work, restraint, and vocational duty that Weber associated with modern capitalism. A business owner reinvests profits while avoiding luxurious consumption. It illustrates a proposed mechanism through which religious beliefs can influence economic organization and long-term development.
ascetic work/Calvinist predestination
ascetic work combines disciplined labor with restrained consumption. Calvinist predestination holds that God has already determined salvation; weber argued that believers sought reassurance through disciplined conduct. a merchant works diligently and lives modestly as expressions of religious commitment. the argument shows how beliefs about salvation could unintentionally encourage behaviors associated with capitalist development.
geography theory of development: sachs
geographic theories explain development partly through climate, disease, agricultural productivity, and access to markets. landlocked countries may face high transportation costs, while tropical diseases can reduce productivity. the theory identifies constraints that may influence national development regardless of leader’s policy preferences.
institutional theory of development
institutional theories argue that rules and power arrangements shape incentives to invest, innovate, and engage in productive activity. Reliable contract enforcement encourages businesses to make long-term investments. they connect political organization to economic outcomes and help explain why countries with similar resources develop differently.
inclusive vs extractive institutions
inclusive institutions provide broad access to economic opportunity and political participation; extractive institutions concentrate power and benefits among elites. open businesses entry contrasts with a system reserving profitable industries for politically connected families. the distinction explains how political power can encourage broad development or allow elites to block changes threatening their advantages.
modernization theory: traditional vs modern man
modernization theory describes development as movement toward industrial urban socierty, accompanied by changing attitudes. its ideal types contrast attachment to inherited roles with orientations toward innovation, achievement, and planning. Employment increasingly depends on education and qualifications rather than family status. It connects economic and social transformation, but comparativists criticize its tendency to treat Western experience as a universal path.
rostow’s stages of economic growth
Rostow argues that countries develop through five stages: traditional society dominated by low productivity agriculture; preconditions for take-off involving infrastructure and investment; take-off into sustained industrial growth; drive to maturity as technology spreads across industries; and high mass consumption, when rising incomes support widespread purchases beyond basic necessities. Britain illustrates the proposed sequence: it moved from an agricultural economy toward expanding trade and investment, experienced rapid industrial growth through mechanized textiles, diversified into other industries, and eventually developed widespread consumption of cars appliances and services. Why it matters: in comparative politics, the model provides a framework for comparing economic development and identifying potential priorities for government investment. however, its assumption of a common development path is criticized for overlooking colonialism, global inequalities, and the different conditions facing late-developing countries.
Gerashchenko’s theory of relative backwardness
Gerashchenko argues that late developers follow different paths because they need substitutes for missing capital markets or institutions. greater backwardness can encourage stronger roles for banks and the state. German banks and the Russian state played major roles in financing industrialization. it explains why successful development institutions vary across countries and historical periods.
dependency theory
dependency theory argues that unequal relationships between wealthy core economies and peripheral economies can reproduce underdevelopment. a country exports raw materials while depending on foreign manufactured goods, investment, and technology. it shifts comparative analysis toward international economic power and the domestic elites benefiting from dependent relationships.
developmental state
a developmental state uses capable institutions and strategic intervention to promote industrialization and economic transformation. south Korea supported selected industries and tied assistance to performance, including export success. it helps explain why state intervention encourages development in some countries but produces inefficiency or patronage in others.
embedded autonomy
peter evans concept combines bureaucratic independence from narrow interests with strong, organized connections to economic actors. officials consult businesses about production problems while retaining the ability to withdraw subsidies. it identifies institutional conditions under which cooperation between government and business can support development.
Import-substituting industrialization
ISI
ISI encourages domestic production of previously imported goods through protection subsidies and public investment. Brazil protected domestic manufacturing industries from foreign competition during much of the twentieth century. it helps explain industrial growth and later economic difficulties associated with protected markets and foreign-exchange constraints.