1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Dispositional meaning.
The tendency to act or think in a certain manner under given circumstances.
Key premise.
Grounded in the idea that individuals differ in their propensity to offend, dispositional theories explore the internal and social conditions that generate or restrain criminal motivation.
Origins of the dispositional theory.
Criminals are different from law-abiding people: Criminals have a lower sense of morality compared to law-abiding people. Criminals have less activation in their prefrontal cortex, which is responsible for self-control (Raine)
Biological inferiority causes criminality, according to Lombroso: He argued that crime is an innate defect rather than an act of free will or moral weakness. He called criminals atavistic (evolutionary throwbacks). He said that those with tattoos are more likely to be criminals.
Biological determinism: Raine et al. found that criminals have less activity in the prefrontal cortex, which is linked to self-control. They found that there was higher activation in the amygdala, which is responsible for fear recognition. Price et al.: XYY chromosome leads to criminality.
Origins: Durkheim’s anomie.
He argues that there are no natural limits, but society places these limits.
The dissolution of social bonds that hold society together = the collapse of social solidarity and social cohesion.
Anomie is a state of normlessness. It occurs when we lack guidance on how to behave.
Strain and emotion: Agnew
Valued goals are not achieved.
Something valued is lost (loss of positive stimuli), such as losing a job or a loved one.
Something bad happens to you (loss of negative stimuli)- Discrimination.
Strain is about emotion.
He said that stressful situations, such as relationships and work, trigger negative emotions, which lead to crime in order to cope.
Merton’s strain theory.
Strain: pressure so strong that it can lead to collapse/harm/damage
• Cultural goals: what we want money
• Institutional means: legal ways of getting it
• Social structures/inequalities limit the possibility of
success.
• Blocked goals can lead to deviance.
Control theories: Why do people break the law?
Social bonds- Hirschi: We have social bonds such as involvement and commitment. If these are absent, we turn to crime.
Attachment: Emotional closeness to adults - Happens during childhood. Need to please them, not anger them.
Commitment: Educational and career goals “stake in conformity”- More likely to commit crime if you have nothing to lose. If you have more to lose, you’re less likely.
Involvement: Participation in conventional, structured activities reduces the opportunity to offend, such as school and work.
Belief: Acceptance of social rules, such as that killing is illegal.
Self-control: Gottfredson and Hirschi
Control does not come from bonds, but it comes from the inside (willpower).
Formed in early childhood- parental control and regulation- you’re always going to give in to temptation or refrain from tempting behaviour.
Self-control remained stable.
What is the significance of the theory?
Strain:
Tackle inequalities- policy-making.
Access to opportunities.
Stress support, so it can lead to preventing crime.
Control:
Early years of intervention
Family support
School engagement.
Critiques for strain, control and both.
Strain:
Shared goals - Not everyone wants the same thing
Control:
Circular argument.
Both:
Who decides what deviance is.