1/47
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Role of judicial branch
Settle disputes
Review constitutionality of legislation
Limitations on judicial branch
Passive
Judiciable disputes
Limited jurisdiction
“Case or controversy”
Standing
Judiciable dispute
Formal, legal conflict able to be decided by court
“Case or controversy”
Courts may only adjudicate real disputes, not abstract questions
Standing
Party must have direct, personal stake in case
Judicial restraint
The judicial ideology that judges should apply the law as written, disregarding their own personal preferences
Judicial activism
The judicial ideology that judges may go beyond a strict, literal reading of the Constitution to address social, political, or rights issues
Originalist
The judicial philosophy that the meaning of the Constitution is fixed to how its words have been interpreted historically
Living document
The judicial philosophy that judges should apply foundational Constitutional principles to contemporary problems/technologies
Nomination process for federal judges/justices
Selection
Vetting
Senate Judiciary Committee
Senate confirmation vote
SCOTUS original jurisdiction
State vs. state
Ambassadors
SCOTUS appellate jurisdiction
Lower federal courts
State Supreme courts
Writ of Certiorari
Cert petition (you should take this case)
Cert pool
Pool of cert petitions for the SCOTUS clerks to read
Rule of 4
4 SCOTUS justices must agree to grant cert
Merit briefs
Petitioner & respondent argue merits of their case
Amicus Curiae briefs (amici)
Non-party opinions/args submitted to Court
Government brief
Solicitor General (10th justice) argues on behalf of U.S. gov
Purpose of oral arguments
To convince other justices
SCOTUS Conference
Chief Justice speaks first → descending order of seniority
Brief synopsis + opinions
Most senior justice in majority assigns opinion
Most senior justice in dissent assigns dissenting opinion
Circulating the opinion(s)
Reading the opinion(s) from the bench
Plurality decision
Justices agree with opinion but disagree on reasoning
Parts a, b, c
Evidence for SCOTUS being insulated
Lifetime tenure
Unelected
Salary may never be diminished
Evidence for SCOTUS not being insulated
Nominated/appointed by President
Could be impeached/removed
People could ignore ruling
Stare decisis
“Let decision stand” — tendency to defer to past SCOTUS precedents
Super precedents
SCOTUS decisions that are so fundamental that they can’t be overturned
E.g. Marbury v. Madison; Miranda v. Arizona
Selective incorporation
SCOTUS selects individual provisions/clauses from the Bill of Rights and incorporates them into the Due Process clause of the 14th Amendment
14th Amendment clauses
Citizenship clause
Privileges & immunities clause
Due process clause
Equal protection clause
Gitlow v. New York (1925)
Seminal selective incorporation case
SCOTUS incorporated certain first amendment free speech protections
However, SCOTUS ruled the first amendment does NOT protect seditious speech
Citizenship clause
(14th amendment) All persons born or naturalized in the U.S. and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the U.S. and of the state wherein they reside
Privileges & immunities clause
(14th amendment) No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the U.S.
Due process clause
(14th amendment) Nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property without due process of law
Equal protection
(14th amendment) Nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws
Why selective incorporation and not total incorporation?
Seems more mild to prevent states from getting upset
Provisions of Bill of Rights that won’t be incorporated
Grand jury → too annoying for states
10th amendment → already grants power to the states
3rd amendment → no one quarters soldiers anymore
First amendment protections (6)
Establishment of religion
Free exercise of religion
Free speech
Free press
Peaceably assemble
Petition for redress of grievances
Establishment clause
Prohibits the federal government from creating an official religion
Free exercise clause
Protects people’s right to practice (or not), as long as it does not break the law
“Wall of Separation” Doctrine
TJ letter advocating “wall of separation” between church and state
Engel v. Vitale
State-sponsored prayer in public schools is unconstitutional
School voucher programs ARE constitutional
Compulsory pledge of allegiance is unconstitutional in some places
Parochial
Religious
Secular
Non-religious
Reynolds v. US
Polygamy is not protected by free exercise clause
Yoder v. Wisconsin
Amish homeschooling is protected by free exercise clause
Unprotected speech
Defamation (slander v. libel)
Fighting words (Chaplinksy)
Clear & present danger (Schenck v. US)
Sedition (Gitlow v. NY)
Obscenity (not profanity)
Burning a draft card
Defamation
Words that harm a person’s reputation
Slander: verbalized
Libel: written
Schenck v. US
SCOTUS established precedent that speech that creates a clear and present danger is unprotected
Quasi-protected speech
Student speech
Tinker v. Des Moines
Morse v. Frederick
Commercial speech
44 Liquormart
Tinker v. Des Moines
Students have free speech unless speech creates material, substantial disruption