1/417
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the 6 key stages of a civil claim?
1. Pre-Action Stage - pre action considerations and conduct
2. Statements of Case Stage - claim form and particulars of claim, then acknowledgement of service and/or admission/defence and counterclaim
3. Case Management Stage - the court will then allocate the claim to a track and set out directions explaining what is required of the parties on the journey towards trial
4. Evidence Stage - disclosure, witness statements, expert reports
5. Trial Stage - preparations for trial and trial
6. Post-Trial Stage - enforcement, appeal
When does the claimant want to state what remedy / relief they want?
Pre-Action Stage
Why will parties exchange documents and exchange witness statements?
Ensures that the hearing runs as efficiently as possible and also allows either party to consider an out of court settlement
What is the civil court system hierarchy?
1. County Court
2. High Court
3. Court of Appeal
4. Supreme Court
What court / courts can the solicitor advocate for their clients?
ONLY the County Court
What is the criteria for a claim to be held in the High Court?
1. Financial value of the claim has to be more than £100,000 for non-personal injury, and £50,000 for personal injury
2. There is a moderate complexity of facts / legal issues / remedies / procedures
3. It is of moderate importance to the public
4. There is a specific enactment states the claim shall be issued in the High Court
What is the criteria for a claim to be held in the County Court?
1. Financial value of the claim has to be worth less than £100,000 for non-personal injury, and £50,000 for personal injury
2. The claim cannot be justified to be issued in the High Court on the grounds of complexity of facts / legal issues / remedies / procedures
3. The claim cannot be justified to be issued in the High Court on the grounds of importance to the public
Can claims with a financial value of £100,000 + for non-personal injury / £50,000 + for personal injury be issued in the County Court?
Yes - the rule is that claims below £100,000 cannot be in the High Court, there is no rule capping the value of claim that can be in the County Court
How many County Courts are there?
1 national County Court and 170 County Court 'hearing centres' spread across England and Wales.
How many High Courts are there?
There is 1 national High Court of Justice which sits in the Royal Courts of Justice (RCJ) and 130 'district registries' serving various parts of the countries
What are the 3 divisions of the High Court?
1. King's Bench Division
2. Chancery Division
3. Family Division
What major courts / lists are within the King's Bench Division?
1. General KBD List:
Covers broad areas, including claims for damages forpersonal injury, professional negligence, breach of contract other matters not falling within specialist courts / lists
2. Administrative Court:
Appeals / applications relating to planning permission, highways and rights of way
3. Commercial Court:
Cases arising out of business disputes, in particular arbitration, aviation, banking, financial markets, fraud and insurance
What major courts / lists are within the Chancery Division?
1. Insolvency and Companies List:
Cases regarding personal and corporate insolvency, shareholder disputes, director disqualification and application under CA 2006
2. Revenue List:
Claims involving major points of principle relating to taxation where HMRC is a party
3. Property, Trusts and Probate List:
Land including landlord and tenant, administration of estates, execution of trusts, charities, probate.
Can a case transfer from one Hight Court division to another?
Yes, where there is an overlap in subject matter (eg commercial matters, contract claims)
What are the two divisions of the Court of Appeal?
1. Criminal Division
2. Civil Division
When will a case be heard in the Supreme Court?
Where permission to appeal to the Supreme Court is granted (appeal will only be granted if the issue raised is of 'general public importance')
What is the definition of a 'limitation period'?
The period of time within which a party to a contract or a party who has suffered damages as a result of another party's conduct, must bring a claim
What happens if proceedings are not commenced within the relevant limitation period?
The claimant will be barred from recovering damages and on this basis, the defendant will have a full defence
What is the general limitation period for contract / tort disputes?
6 years after the date on which the cause of the action occurred
What is the limitation period for personal injury claims?
The claimant must bring the claim within 3 years at the latest of:
1. The date when the cause of action occurred, or
2. The date of knowledge of the person injured
These dates are commonly the same day
What is the 'date of knowledge' regarding personal injury claims?
The date that the individual is reasonably expected to know that:
1. The injury was significant
2. It was attributable (at least in part) to the wrongful doing
3. The identity of the defendant / the identify of the person other than the defendant if they committed the wrongdoing
What is the limitation period for fatal accident claims?
Where an employee dies at work due to the negligent failure of their employer to provide a safe place to work, the employees family can claim compensation as long as the claim is within 3 years of:
1. The employee's date of death
2. The date of knowledge of the dependent of the employee
Can there be an extension of time to the limitation period of a personal injury or fatal accident claim?
Yes - the court can extend time in consideration of the overriding objective
What is the limitation period for a person liable for damage to claim a contribution from another person?
2 years from the date on which the right to recover the contribution arose (either the date when the judgement was given imposing liability on the first party or the date on which the amount to be paid was first agreed in cases where no judgement was imposed)
What is the definition of 'stare decisis'?
A higher court's precedents binds lower courts + certain courts bind themselves
Is the Court of Appeal bound on its previous decisions?
Yes, unless:
1. Where a previous decision of its own conflicts with a subsequent Supreme Court / House of Lords decision since its past decision
2. If a previous decision of the Court of Appeal is considered to have been given per incuriam then the present Court of Appeal is not bound to follow it (a previous court judgement failed to pay attention to existing precedent or statutory provision)
What is the definition of 'per incuriam'?
A previous court judgement failed to pay attention to existing precedent or statutory provision
Is the Supreme Court bound on its previous decisions?
Yes, although rare, the Supreme Court may depart from a previous decision if it appears right to do so (eg stare decisis)
Is the High Court bound on its previous decisions?
Yes, unless:
1. Where a previous decision of its own conflicts with a subsequent Supreme Court / House of Lords decision since its past decision
2. If a previous decision of the Court of Appeal is considered to have been given per incuriam then the present Court of Appeal is not bound to follow it (a previous court judgement failed to pay attention to existing precedent or statutory provision)
Is the County Court bound on its previous decisions?
No
What is the solicitor's role regarding the client and the funding of the case?
A solicitor is required to conduct a reasonable and proportionate search to establish whether the client has any funding options + try to ensure the client ends up with the most appropriate one
What is 'private funding'?
Where the client funds legal work through their own private resources - many individuals will not have enough money to do this for substantial or long term work, but it is normal for minor work (eg conveyancing, probate)
What is 'professional funding'?
Legal work funded by a trade union or professional organisation - in practice it is most likely to occur in relation to civil or criminal litigation (eg a union might fund the legal work involved in helping an employee bring a claim against their employer)
What is 'before the event insurance (BTE)' funding?
BTE is taken out before the need for legal work arises - the insurance coverage 'pays out' to cover the legal work in the event that it is needed (the coverage is often capped)
How long does the defendant have to respond to proceedings (with either an acknowledgement of service or a defence) when served out of the jurisdiction?
This varies, depending primarily on the country in which service takes place
Is the before the event insurance (BTE) premium included where the unsuccessful party pays their opponent's cost?
No
What is 'community legal service (CLS)' funding? (Legal Aid)
The provision of public funds to assist in the procurement of legal services for those who could not otherwise afford it.
Most eligible types of claim relate to particular types of children / family disputes - if the client's income is too high or the client has too much capital (eg savings) then they will be ineligible
What is 'conditional fee agreement (CFA)' funding?
It is a type of 'no win no fee' agreement, which means that the solicitor will not get paid / get a reduced payment unless the case is successful
If the case is successful, the solicitor will be paid the normal fee (or 'basic fee') plus a success fee (also known as an uplift) of up to 100% on top of the normal fee (eg the success fee might be an extra 25% on top of the normal fee)
What happens if a case funded by a conditional fee agreement (CFA) is successful?
The solicitor will be paid the normal fee (or 'basic fee') plus a success fee (also known as an uplift) of up to 100% / up to 25% for PI claims on top of the normal fee
(eg the success fee might be an extra 25% on top of the normal fee)
When recovering costs from the opponent, can the successful party include a solicitor's success fee from a conditional fee agreement (CFA)?
No - this means that the success fee effectively comes out of the claimant's damages
What is the maximum success fee payable to solicitors under a conditional fee agreement (CFA) in a personal injury case?
25%
Will a solicitor be paid if they lose a case under a conditional fee agreement (CFA)?
Potentially - depending on the terms of the CFA, they may be paid a reduced amount or sometimes be not paid anything
What is a damaged based agreement (DBA)?
It is a type of 'no win no fee' agreement, which means that the solicitor will not get paid unless the case is successful
If the case is successful, the solicitor will be paid a proportion of the damages awarded to their client:
Capped at 25% in Personal Injury cases (excluding damages for future care and loss)
Capped at 35% in Employment Tribunal cases
Capped at 50% in all other cases
What is the difference between a conditional fee agreement (CFA) and a damaged based agreement (DBA)?
If the case is successful, the solicitor's success fee in a CFA is generally at the solicitor's discretion up to 100% whilst a success fee in a DBA is capped at a certain amount depending on the case
What is 'after the event insurance (ATE)' funding ?
An insurance policy taken out in order to help the client cover the costs of litigation once a dispute has already arisen
Whether or not ATE insurance will be available will depend on the merits of the case and the level of cover required
(eg whether a particular insurance company is willing to take on the risk and on what terms)
What costs does 'after the event insurance (ATE)' usually cover?
1. The client's own disbursements and,
2. Their opponent's costs and disbursements in the event of losing their case
Is the after the event insurance (ATE) premium included where the unsuccessful party pays their opponent's cost?
No
Why is after the event insurance (ATE) commonly used alongside a conditional fee agreement (CFA) or a damaged based agreement (DBA)?
The CFA / DBA effectively covers the client's own solicitor's costs, and the ATE covers the disbursements and opponent's costs
What is a 'disbursement'?
An expense that a solicitor pays on behalf of a client, and then adds to the client's final bill
(eg court fees, filing fees, expert evidence fees etc)
What is third party funding?
Occurs when independent litigation funding is provided by a third party to enable parties to bring their cases to court.
In the event that the claim succeeds, the funder receives their money back, plus an uplift.
Name 2 third parties which typically partake in third party funding?
1. Hedge Funds
2. Banks
3. Private Equity Firms
Why might third parties provide litigation funding to enable parties to bring their cases to court?
In the event that the claim succeeds, the funder receives their money back, plus an uplift.
What code of practice regulates third party funders and is it mandatory to adhere to?
1. The Association of Litigation Funders
2. Funders do not have to legally be apart of The Association of Litigation Funders, nor adhere to its code of conduct
What two primary ways does the court set out certain procedures that the court expects the parties to follow before issuing proceedings?
Pre-Action Protocols and Practice Directions
What is the definition of a 'practice direction'?
A supplemental protocol to rules of civil and criminal procedure in the courts that is used to regulate minor procedural matters and act as an official announcement by the court laying down rules as to how it should function
Do practice directions take priority over pre-action protocols?
No - if a specific pre-action protocol applies to the case then, in the event of a conflict with the provisions of the Practice Direction, the provisions of the specific protocol will take priority
Name 5 examples of pre-action protocols:
1. The claimant writing a Letter of Notification to the potential defendant regarding their intention to issue proceedings
2. The defendant acknowledging the Letter of Claim within 21 days
3. The defendant writing a Letter of Response within 'reasonable time' acknowledging the claim, and either accepting the claim or rejecting the claim (in full or part)
4. The parties attempting to negotiate and proposing settlements to the claim
5. Joint selection of a Quantum Expert or Medical Expert
What is a quantum expert?
An expert that provides the tribunal or court with independent valuations that allow them to value the claims depending on the way that they decide on liability
What is the overall purpose of pre-action protocols?
They enable the parties to obtain information they reasonably need to settle the matter at the earliest possible opportunity and, if settlement is not achievable, to lay the foundations for court proceedings
What are the consequences of non-compliance with pre-action protocols?
They are at the court's discretion depending on the extent that the non-compliance impacted the other party / the proceedings as a whole
(eg increasing the amount of court costs to be paid, decreasing the amount to be received etc)
What are pre-action protocols?
A set of guidelines that outline the steps parties should take before starting civil court proceedings
Is there justification for non-compliance with pre-action protocols?
Yes only in very limited circumstances
(eg where the limitation period is about to expire)
What happens if a party issues a claim in the wrong court? (eg issues a personal injury claim of £25,000 in the High Court)
1. The claimant might have to pay a fee for the transfer of the case to the other court
2. Any costs awarded to them in the claim may be reduced by 25% at the court's discretion
Who should the claimant's solicitor send a completed claim form to?
They should send:
1. One copy of the completed claim form to be kept on the court's file
2. One copy of the completed claim form for each defendant
3. One copy of the completed claim form for the claimant to keep on their own file
What is the definition of 'service'?
The process of giving a document to another party in a way which is recognised by the court
What is the definition of a 'claim form'?
The document used to commence proceedings and to set out key elements of the claim
(eg the identity of the parties, remedy being sought)
Who can serve a claim form?
1. The claimant
2. The claimant's solicitor
3. The court
What is the process for the court serving a claim form?
1. Service will be usually via first class post
2. Once the court has the effected service, it will send the claimant a notice of issue stating the deemed date of service
What method of service will the court generally use when serving a claim form?
First Class Post
What happens if the court is unable to serve the claim form for any reason?
The claimant will be sent a notice of non-service - it is then up to the claimant to try to serve the claim form on the defendant
What is the process for the claimant / claimant's solicitor serving a claim form?
1. They must notify the court when issuing the claim form that they do not wish the court to serve it.
2. The court will give or send the claimant / claimant's solicitor the issued claim form with sealed copies for service on the defendant
3. The claimant / claimant's solicitor must then conduct effective service (the 'relevant step') upon the defendant
4. The claimant's solicitor must then file a certificate of service at court within 21 days of service which outlines the method of service and the date is was served
Name 3 methods that constitute as effective service:
1. Personally giving it to the defendant
2. Leaving the document at a permitted address
3. First class post
4. Document Exchange
5. Fax
What is the 'relevant step'?
Effective service upon the defendant
How long does the claimant have to file a certificate of service at court?
Within 21 days from the date of service
(eg if the date of service is 2 November, the last day to file a certificate of service is 23 November)
Is second class post a method of effective service?
No - service by post HAS to be via first class
What are the conditions of effective service via fax / another electronic method?
It is only permissible if the defendant has indicated that they will accept service via this method
What happens if the defendant provides their solicitor's address for service?
Service MUST be served there
What is the rule if an individual for whatever reason cannot be served at their usual residence?
They can be served at their last known residence
How long does the claimant have to serve the claim form?
Within 4 months of the date of issue
(eg if the claim form was issued 2 January, the last day to file a certificate of service is 2 May)
Can the claimant apply for an extension of time to serve the claim form?
Yes, with a good reason
What is the purpose of the 'particulars of claim'?
It sets out the claimant's case in full detail, and is the claimant's main statement of case and will be referred to by the court and all parties as such
How can the claimant serve the defendant the particulars of claim?
1. Within the claim form or,
2. In a separate document served with the claim form or at a later date
What must be included if the particulars of claim are served WITHIN the claim form?
A response pack (contains a form for admission, form for defending and a form for acknowledging the service)
What is contained within a response pack?
1. A form for admission
2. A form for defending
3. A form for acknowledging the service
If the particulars of claim are not contained in or served with the claim form, how long does the claimant have to serve it?
Within 14 days of service of the claim form (and within 4 months from the date of issue of the claim form)
(eg if the claim form was served 2 February, the last day to serve the particulars of claim is 16 February)
How long does the claimant have to file a copy of the particulars of claim at court?
Within 7 days of service of service of the particulars of claim
(eg if the particulars of claim where served on 6 March, the last day to file a copy to court is 13 March)
What is the deemed date of service of a claim form?
The second business day after completion of effective service (the 'relevant step') upon the defendant
(eg if a claim form is served by email on Wednesday 5 September, the second business day after this step is Friday 7 September, which is therefore when the claim form will be deemed served)
What is the definition of a 'business day'?
Any day except Saturdays, Sundays, Bank Holidays, Good Friday or Christmas Day
If the defendant receives and read the claim form the business day after service, is it classed as being deemed served?
No - it is irrelevant when the defendant reads the claim form as it will still be deemed served on the second business day after completion of effective service
What is the deemed date of service of a the particulars of claim?
If the particulars of claim are served WITHIN the claim form - the rules on deemed service of a claim form apply
If the particulars of claim are NOT served within the claim form - the deemed date of service is dependent on the service method:
1. Instant Methods (eg personal service, email) - if done before 4:30 pm on a business day, it is deemed to be served on that same day
If done after 4:30 pm on a business day or anytime on a non-business day, the deemed date of service is the next business day
2. Non-Instant Methods (eg post) - if done on a business day, it is deemed served the second DAY after the service method is conducted (if the second day is not a business day, the service will be effective upon the next business day after the hypothetical deemed date of service)
What is the deemed date of service of a the particulars of claim sent via an instant method?
If done before 4:30 pm on a business day, it is deemed to be served on that same day
If done after 4:30 pm on a business day or anytime on a non-business day, the deemed date of service is the next business day
What is the deemed date of service of a the particulars of claim sent via a non-instant method?
If done on a business day, it is deemed served the SECOND business day after the service method is conducted (if the second day is not a business day, the service will be effective upon the next business day after the hypothetical deemed date of service)
What would the deemed date of service be for particulars of claim served on its own via email on Friday 1 November at 4:05 PM?
Friday 1 November - deemed date of service is the same day as it is served before 4:30 pm on a business day
What would the deemed date of service be for particulars of claim served on its own via email on Friday 1 November at 4:38 PM?
Monday 4 November - because it was served after 4:30 PM on a business day, the deemed date of service is the next business day
What would the deemed date of service be for particulars of claim served on its own via post on Friday 1 November?
Monday 4 November - because it was served on a business day, the deemed date of service is the SECOND business day after the service method is conducted
However, because the second day is not a business day, the service will be effective upon the next business day available which is Monday 4 November
What would the deemed date of service be for particulars of claim served on its own via post on Saturday 1 November?
Monday 3 November - the Second Business Day after service
What is the statements of case?
The documents by which a claimant sets out the factual basis of its claim and the relief sought, and the defendant gives its own position in relation to the alleged facts and the alleged entitlement to relief
(eg claim form, particulars of claim)
What is a statement of truth?
A formal way of a person signing confirming that they believe that the document is true (required for every statement of case)
What does every statement of case require to validate it?
A statement of truth
What happens if someone falsely signs a statement of truth without believing that the document is true?
They may be held in contempt of court