1/24
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Duress
If a party’s manifestation of assent is induced by an improper threat by another party and leaves no reasonable alternative, the contract is voidable by the recipient
Minor Incapacity
A minor’s contracts are voidable by the minor at any time before reaching the age of majority or within a reasonable time after becoming an adult.
Minors, upon reaching the age of majority, may ratify contracts by words or conduct.
A minor who disaffirms a contract is entitled to recover all of the consideration he has conferred and, in return, the minor is expected to restore as much of the
The minor cannot disaffirm contracts of necessity, contracts where the minor misrepresents their age, contracts where the minor willfully harms the product that is the subject of the contract, or contracts about student loans, insurance, or employment contracts.
Mental Incapacity
The presence of mental illness alone does not establish capacity.
Cognitive test: Tests whether a person can reasonably understand the nature and transaction of the contract (comprehension and cause-and-effect reasoning)
Volitional test: Tests whether a person can act reasonably
Undue influence
(1) The unfair persuasion of a party who is under the domination of the person exercising the persuasion or who, by virtue of the relation between them, is justified in assuming that that person will not act in a manner inconsistent with his welfare.
(2) If a party's manifestation of assent is induced by undue influence by the other party, the contract is voidable by the victim.
Misrepresentation
If a party's manifestation of assent is induced by either a fraudulent or a material misrepresentationby the other party upon which the recipient is justified in relying, the contract is voidable by the recipient. A fraudulent misrepresentation is intentional, but a material one is innocent yet still likely to induce a party’s manifestation of assent
Nondisclosure
Generally, there is no requirement for full disclosure of all relevant facts in every business relationship.
Rule: An uninformed party may seek recission of a contract if there are non-disclosed facts that: have a material effect on the transaction, are not readily observable, and are not known by the uninformed party in the following circumstances:
-Where disclosure is required by the statute
-Where one party intentionally conceals the non-disclosed facts from the earlier,
-Where one party is entitled to know of the facts because of a relationship of trust and confidence between the parties, or
-To prevent or correct a mistake of the uninformed party when the nondisclosure is a breach of the duty of good faith
Mutual mistake
(1) Both parties, at contract formation
(2( Make a mistake
(3) About a basic assumption on which the contract was made,
(4) And that mistake has a material effect on the agreed exchange of performances
Exception: Mutual mistake is not available for a party who beats the risk of the mistake.
Unilateral Mistake
A contract is voidable under unilateral mistake if:
(1) One party, at contract formation,
(2) Made a mistake
(3) About a basic assumption on which the contract was made,
(4) And that mistake had a material effect on the agreed exchange of performances
AND EITHER:
(1) The effect of the mistake is such that enforcement would be unconscionable, OR
(2) The other party had reason to know of the mistake of his fault caused the mistake
Unconscionability
Courts that find contracts to be unconscionable may refuse to enforce the contract or limit the unconscionable clause.
Unconscionability requires both (1) procedural and (2) substantive unconscionability.
There is a sliding scale used in application that allows for a greater degree of one element and a lesser degree of the other to result in a finding of unconscionability.
Procedural Unconscionability
May be demonstrated by gross inequality in bargaining power or unfair surprise.
Gross inequality occurs when a party lacks a meaningful choice, such as with an adhesion contract.
Unfair surprise occurs when a party’s reasonable expectations are disappointed, typically because of lack of actual knowledge of terms, sharp bargaining practices, and complex and hidden terms in a complicated document.
Substantive Unconscionability
Refers to the unfairness of the terms. It may be shown by:
(1) Overly harsh allocation of risks not justified by the circumstances, or
(2) Great price disparity (like gross inadequacy of consideration)
Public Policy and Illegality
A contract (or provision of a contract) may be void or voidable if the subject matter or consideration of the contract is either illegal or against an established public policy at the time of the contract formation
Balancing Test (Public Policy)
In deciding whether to void a contract based on public policy, the court should balance the importance of enforcing the contract against the importance of the public policy.
Partial Enforcement through Severance (Public Policy/Illegality)
If enforcing part of the contract would not violate public policy, then a court may delete the offending term and enforce that part of the contract that is not against public policy.
In determining whether to enforce part of the contract, the court considers whether the party whom enforcement benefits acted in good faith.
If a contract is voided by public policy, does a party generally have a claim in restitution for the performance he rendered.
Generally, restitution is not available, but there are exceptions.
Restitution is available if:
(1) a disproportionate forfeiture would occur absent restitution,
(2) one party is excusably ignorant of the public policy,
(3) one party was not equally in the wrong as the other party, or
(4) one party withdrew from performance before the improper purpose was achieved.
In parĂ delicto
The court leaves parties without a restitutionary remedy for illegal contracts
Types of Contracts Against Public Policy
1. Contracts involving illegality, such as torts or crimes. (See Section B.)
2. Contracts that restrain trade. (See Section C.)
3. 4. Contracts that impair family relations. (See Section D.)
Contracts that violate licensing laws. (See Section E.)
To determine whether a restraint on trade is reasonable, the court consider which factors?
Legitimate interest of the promisee
Hardship to the promisor
Injury to the public
Changed Circumstances
Impossibility
(1) After contract formation,
(2( A supervening event occurs without fault of the party seeking relief
(3) The event causes a party’s performance to become impossible.
(4) The nonoccurrence of the event was a basic assumption on which the contract was made
(5) The party’s duties are discharged unless the contract language or circumstances indicate risk should be allocated to one party
Impracticability
(1) After contract formation,
(2( A supervening event occurs without fault of the party seeking relief
(3) The event causes a party’s performance to become impracticable.
(4) The nonoccurrence of the event was a basic assumption on which the contract was made
(5) The party’s duties are discharged unless the contract language or circumstances indicate risk should be allocated to one party
Frustration of Purpose
1) After contract formation,
(2( A supervening event occurs without fault of the party seeking relief
(3) The event causes a party’s principal purpose to become substantially frustrated.
(4) The nonoccurrence of the event was a basic assumption on which the contract was made
(5) The party’s duties are discharged unless the contract language or circumstances indicate risk should be allocated to one party
Parol Evidence Rule
When the parties to a written contract have agreed that the writing is a total integration, a court shall not admit extrinsic evidence of agreements that contradict or supplement writing.
If the writing is a partial integration (final but incomplete), the writing cannot be contradicted but can be supported by evidence of consistent and additional terms.
If the writing is not integrated, a party may introduce but contradictory and supplemental evidence.