1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Framing Effects
Imagine that the country is preparing for the outbreak of an unusual disease, which is expected to kill 600 people.
Two alternative programs to combat the disease have been proposed, which will have the following consequences:
Program A - 200 people will be saved
Program B - 1/3 chance that 600 people will be saved, 2/3 chance that no people will be saved
Program C - 400 people will die
Program D - 1/3 chance that no one will die, 2/3 chance that 600 people will die
define framing effects
Framing effect: tendency to change your decision depending on how choices are framed, even when the different frames are logically identical
People tend to avoid risks when dealing with possible gains, but to seek risks when they are dealing with possible losses
What questions would you ask somebody to find out if they are extraverted?
framing effects study
People did “getting to know you” interview in pairs
Told their partner was introverted or extroverted
Researchers were interested in questions
Introverted: Have you ever felt left out of social group
Extroverted: How do you liven up a party?
(Snyder & Swann, 1978)
Participants were given a frame: their partner was either introverted or extroverted.
This frame influenced what they expected from their partner.
Their expectations influenced the questions they asked.
Those questions encouraged answers that confirmed their original expectations.
confirmation biases
Once first impression formed, people have tendency to look for information to CONFIRM that impression (rather than to disconfirm)
Results in attending to confirming info, and disregarding disconfirming
•Hannah (Darley & Gross, 1983)
Half participants told Hannah was from rich family, half poor family
All the participants watched video in which Hannah answered academic questions, she did ok (Some hard questions right, some easy wrong)
those who thought she was rich had higher expectations of her academic abilities, and focused on the hard q’s she got right, rating her academic potential as higher
those who thought she was poor had lower expectations, and focused on the easy q’s she got wrong, rating her lower
confirmation bias: the ppl only focus on the info that supports what they already believe and use that to judge Hannah
self-fulfilling prophecy
Do teachers’ expectations influence student performance in classroom?
Teachers told some students were “bloomers”, on the verge of intellectual potential
In fact, “bloomers” were randomly selected
8 months later, “Bloomers” were performing better in the classroom (Rosenthal & Jacobson, 1968)
How? High expectations lead to more challenging homework, attention, praise, feedback, which positively impact student (Rosenthal, 2002)
Impressions
Impressions form very quickly (as we saw in social perception unit)
Once impressions are formed, they are harder to update due to factors like:
Confirmation biases
Confirmatory hypothesis testing
Self-fulfilling prophecies
other biases in controlled thinking
Overconfidence: tendency to have too much confidence in the accuracy of your own judgments
E.g., gave people information about targets (descriptions, interviews, video clips, base rates, etc)
Ask them to predict what the targets are going to do
People consistently respond with high confidence that far exceeds their actual accuracy
other biases in controlled thinking
Planning fallacy: tendency to be overly optimistic about how soon they will complete a project
•E.g., 1994 study asked psychology students how long it would take to finish their thesis
Average estimate: 33.9 days
Estimate if everything went as well as possible: 27.4 days
Estimate if everything went as poorly as possible: 48.6 days
Actual average completion time: 55.5 days
planing fallacy
Often occurs even if you know that similar tasks in the past have taken longer
Only for your own tasks; when predicting for others, sometimes even show opposite bias (pessimism bias
These are all errors we can make even when we are doing our very best to be accurate
But sometimes, without even realizing it, other goals might come in the way of our goal to be accurate
motivated reasoning - look at the 2 graphs in the slides
Our motivations can affect the way we reason about the world
Here, motivation = any wish, goal, preference, or desire concerning the outcome of a given reasoning task
“Is the weather going to get worse before tomorrow?”
Multiple types of goals when reasoning
Accuracy goals: want to reach the most correct conclusion (ex: want to find out the true impacts of smoking on health)
Directional goals: want to reach a particular conclusion (ex: wants to find out that smoking is fine for your health)
motivated reasoning
When reasoning is driven primarily by accuracy goals, we process information more carefully and attend to what’s relevant
motivated reasoning
But when directional goals dominate, we instead process information in a way that supports our goal
We can’t just completely make something up
Still want to maintain the “illusion of objectivity”
So instead, we attempt to rationally construct a justification for our desired conclusion
example of motivated reasoning
Participants who were for or against capital punishment
Read two studies: one supported the idea that capital punishment deters crime, the other opposed this idea
Participants were more critical of the methods used in the study that disconfirmed their beliefs than the study that confirmed their beliefs
All potentially valid criticisms! But people applied them differently depending on their motivations
Attitudes became even more polarized after being exposed to the mixed evidence
outcome dependency and motivated reasoning
Outcome dependency: when you are connected to another person and your outcomes are dependent on them
outcome dependency and motivated reasoning
Neuberg & Fiske, 1987
Participants believed they would be partnered with someone being treated at a psychiatric facility
If they believed their outcomes are linked together (e.g., need to work on a task together), they saw him more positively
outcome dependency and motivated reasoning
Berscheid et al., 1976
Participants believed they were in a study on dating partners
Watched discussion and told one of the people would be their dating partner
More positive views of the person they thought they would go on a date with
summary
So even thinking that is slower and more “controlled” can have biases
We make errors in reasoning like…
Shifting our judgments depending on framing in terms of losses/gains
Looking for confirmation at the expense of disconfirmation
Which can create self-fulfilling prophecies
And sometimes we have goals that override our desire for accuracy