1/177
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Aim of the stress and physical activity practical
To investigate how high school students manage stress and physical activity and explore how they perceive the relationship between their stress levels and physical activity
Research design used in the stress and physical activity practical
A qualitative research design using semi structured interviews to collect detailed information about participants experiences and perspectives
Semi structured interview
An interview that uses predetermined questions while allowing the researcher to ask follow up questions and explore responses in greater depth
Why a semi structured interview was selected
It provided a consistent set of questions while allowing participants to expand on their experiences and researchers to explore relevant responses
Number of questions in the interview
Fifteen predetermined questions were constructed to investigate stress physical activity and their possible relationship
Why interviews were conducted individually
Each participant was interviewed separately rather than participating in a focus group so they could feel more comfortable sharing their answers
Interview setting
Face to face interviews were conducted with individual participants in a gym equipment room at Cypress Creek High School
Duration of each interview
Each participant was interviewed for approximately five to six minutes depending on how much they expanded on their responses and how much the interviewer deviated from the predetermined questions
Sample size in the stress and physical activity practical
Six high school students from one gym class at Cypress Creek High School
Time and class from which participants were recruited
Participants were recruited from the last period of the school day which was seventh period gym
Sampling method used in the practical
Convenience sampling because researchers selected students who were easily accessible to them
Convenience sampling
A sampling technique in which participants are selected because they are readily available and accessible to the researcher
Volunteer sampling in the practical
Students who willingly agreed to participate were included in the interview sample
How interview questions were developed
Researchers considered relevant aspects of stress and physical activity and constructed questions exploring each topic and their possible relationship
Example of a physical health question
Participants were asked what they did to take care of their physical health including activities such as exercising meditating and playing sports
Purpose of asking about physical health habits
To establish what participants did to maintain their physical health before exploring whether their activity levels affected their stress
Example of a question about the relationship between stress and physical activity
Participants were asked whether they felt their stress levels were affected by how physically active they maintained their lifestyles
Example of a question about stress triggers
Participants were asked what types of situations if any caused them stress
Example of a question about stress management
Participants were asked what strategies they found helpful and unhelpful for managing stress
Why open ended interview questions were useful
They allowed participants to explain their experiences in their own words and provided detailed qualitative responses
Roles of the three researchers during data collection
Samantha conducted the interview the researcher managing time provided time warnings and recorded videos and Isabella recorded written notes
Role of the interviewer
Samantha verbally asked the predetermined questions and conducted the face to face interview with each participant
Role of the timekeeper and recording researcher
The researcher managed the interview timing provided time warnings and recorded the interviews
Role of the note taker
Isabella recorded written notes about the participants responses during each interview
Why both written notes and audio recordings were used
Using both forms of documentation helped researchers capture participants responses more completely for later analysis
How audio recordings supported data collection
Recordings preserved participants spoken responses so researchers could revisit what was said during analysis
How written notes supported data collection
Notes provided an additional record of responses and helped researchers document important information during the interviews
Thematic analysis in the practical
A qualitative data analysis method in which researchers identify and organize recurring themes or patterns across participants responses
How thematic analysis was used
Researchers examined the answers of all six participants and identified common themes relating to how students manage stress and physical activity
Purpose of thematic analysis
To identify patterns across interview responses and use those patterns to develop findings and conclusions about the sample
Type of data collected in the practical
Qualitative textual data consisting of participants spoken interview responses documented through recordings and written notes
Informed consent in the stress and physical activity practical
Participants were informed about the interview and consent was obtained before they took part
How consent forms were distributed
Consent forms were forwarded to the gym teacher who distributed them to the participants
Parental consent for participants aged fifteen or younger
Participants aged fifteen or younger received consent forms for their parents or guardians to sign and return before the interview
Verbal consent before the interview
Researchers verbally obtained consent from each participant before beginning the interview
Information provided before verbal consent
Participants were told that the interview would involve questions about stress and physical activity so they understood what participation involved
Right to skip questions
Participants were told that they did not have to answer any question that made them uncomfortable
Right to withdraw in the practical
Participants were informed that they could stop participating at any point if they no longer wanted to continue
Consent for audio recording
Before asking the first question researchers specifically asked participants for permission to voice record the interview
Why permission to record was important
Participants needed to know that their spoken responses would be recorded and agree to this before recording began
Confidentiality in the practical
Researchers reassured participants that identifying information such as names teacher and gender would not be released
How confidentiality was communicated
After the interviews researchers thanked participants and reaffirmed that no identifying information would be published
Protection from harm in the practical
Researchers avoided questions considered sufficiently socially sensitive to cause psychological distress during the interviews
Debriefing and closure in the practical
Researchers thanked participants for their cooperation and reassured them that their identifying information would remain protected
Reflexivity in qualitative research
The process through which researchers examine and acknowledge how their personal backgrounds beliefs values and research decisions may influence data collection and interpretation
Why reflexivity is important
Researchers are part of the research process and their assumptions or experiences may influence the questions they ask and how they interpret participants responses
Two types of reflexivity
Personal reflexivity and epistemological reflexivity
Personal reflexivity
The process of examining how a researcher's personal background experiences beliefs and values may influence the research
Personal reflexivity in the stress and physical activity practical
Researchers were high school students studying their peers so their own experiences with school stress schedules and health habits could influence how they interpreted participants responses
How shared student identity could introduce personal bias
Researchers may interpret participants answers through their own experiences of high school stress and physical activity rather than considering each response independently
How acknowledging personal background supports reflexivity
Recognizing researchers own experiences and values makes it easier to identify where subjective interpretations could influence conclusions
Positive effect of shared identity in the practical
Being students at the same school helped researchers establish rapport with participants quickly and easily
Rapport in qualitative interviews
A comfortable and trusting relationship between the interviewer and participant that can encourage participants to share their experiences
How shared identity could improve interviews
Participants may feel more comfortable speaking with researchers who understand their school environment and experiences
Epistemological reflexivity
The process of examining how research methods research assumptions and the way knowledge is produced influence the data collected and the conclusions reached
Epistemological reflexivity in the practical
Researchers considered how conducting interviews in a cramped gym equipment room under strict time limits could restrict the depth and richness of participants responses
Physical constraints affecting the practical
Interviews were conducted while standing in a cramped gym equipment room which may have affected participants comfort and the quality of their responses
Time constraints affecting the practical
Each interview lasted approximately five minutes and participants received a thirty second warning which may have restricted how much detail they could provide
How the rushed environment affected data collection
Participants may have shortened their answers because of the limited interview time which could have reduced the richness of the qualitative data
Why researchers considered the physical interview setting
The cramped environment and standing arrangement may have influenced how comfortable participants felt and how fully they expressed their experiences
Credibility in qualitative research
The extent to which researchers interpretations and conclusions can be trusted to accurately reflect participants experiences and the collected data
Why credibility matters in qualitative research
Qualitative findings involve interpretation so researchers must demonstrate that their conclusions are grounded in participants actual responses
Triangulation
The use of multiple perspectives methods researchers or data sources to examine a research question and strengthen confidence in findings
Why triangulation improves credibility
Comparing different forms of evidence or observations can help identify inconsistencies and reduce dependence on one researcher or one source of information
Types of triangulation relevant to the practical
Researcher triangulation method triangulation and data triangulation
Researcher triangulation
The use of multiple researchers to collect observe record or interpret data about the same research topic
Researcher triangulation in the practical
Three researchers contributed to data collection through interviewing managing timing and recording and writing notes
How researcher triangulation improved credibility
Multiple researchers documented the interviews which helped confirm observations and reduce the likelihood of individual recording errors
Limitation of researcher triangulation in the practical
Although three researchers participated in data collection the study did not necessarily establish whether their interpretations of the responses were independently consistent
Method triangulation
The use of multiple research methods to investigate the same phenomenon
Example of method triangulation for the practical
Researchers could combine semi structured interviews with direct observations or participant stress logs
Absence of method triangulation in the practical
The study relied on interviews rather than combining them with other methods such as direct observation or stress logs
How the absence of method triangulation affected credibility
Researchers could not compare interview findings with evidence collected through different methods which limited their ability to confirm the findings
Data triangulation
The use of different data sources such as different participant groups settings or time periods to investigate the same research question
Example of data triangulation for the practical
Researchers could interview students from different class periods rather than relying exclusively on one seventh period gym class
Absence of data triangulation in the practical
All six participants came from the same gym class during the last period of the day
How the absence of data triangulation affected credibility
Findings could reflect the experiences of one particular classroom rather than patterns that would also appear in other groups of students
Overall credibility strength of the practical
Researcher triangulation through three different data collection roles helped reduce individual recording errors and provided multiple records of participants responses
Overall credibility limitation of the practical
Reliance on one short interview method and one classroom group prevented researchers from confirming findings through alternative methods or participant sources
Bias in qualitative research
The extent to which data collection and analysis may be influenced by participant behaviour or researcher assumptions rather than fairly representing participants experiences
Participant bias
Distortion of research responses caused by participants expectations motivations or desire to present themselves in a particular way
Researcher bias
Distortion of data collection or interpretation caused by researchers expectations assumptions or personal viewpoints
Social desirability bias
The tendency for participants to provide answers they believe will make them appear socially acceptable or favorable
Social desirability bias in the practical
Participants may have exaggerated their exercise or healthy habits or presented their stress management strategies more positively to make themselves look good to researchers
Why face to face interviews may increase social desirability bias
Participants may feel pressure to give socially acceptable answers when speaking directly with other students
How peer relationships could influence responses
Participants may change their answers because they want to impress researchers who attend the same school
Acquiescence bias
The tendency to agree with statements or provide agreeable responses regardless of one's genuine beliefs or experiences
Acquiescence bias in the practical
Participants may have given positive or agreeable answers about managing stress and maintaining physical health even when those answers did not accurately represent their daily habits
Demand characteristics
Cues or information that allow participants to guess the purpose of a study and change their behaviour or responses accordingly
Demand characteristics in the practical
A participant who learned about the interview questions before their own interview may have guessed the research aim and prepared answers they believed researchers expected
How the interview schedule change created possible demand characteristics
Johnathan interview was moved to the following day in Mr Dunlop office because an active assailant drill delayed the original schedule
Why Johnathan may have experienced demand characteristics
Because his interview occurred later he may have heard about earlier interviews and had additional time to guess the research aim or rehearse responses
How demand characteristics could affect the findings
A participant who guesses the research aim may provide answers that fit their assumptions about what researchers want rather than their genuine experiences
Confirmation bias
The tendency to favor information that supports existing beliefs while overlooking or discounting information that challenges those beliefs
Confirmation bias in the practical
Researchers may have focused more on participants statements that supported their existing viewpoints about student stress while overlooking responses that contradicted those viewpoints
How confirmation bias affects qualitative analysis
Researchers may interpret ambiguous responses in ways that reinforce their expectations rather than allowing themes to emerge fairly from the data
Leading question bias
Bias introduced when question wording suggests a particular response or directs participants toward a specific topic or interpretation
Leading question bias in the practical
Questions specifically focused on stress triggers and stress management may have encouraged participants to emphasize stressful experiences rather than discussing their experiences more broadly
How leading questions affect interview responses
Participants may be guided toward particular topics or answers which can limit the range and neutrality of the information collected
Volunteer bias
A form of sampling bias that occurs when people who willingly participate differ from those who do not volunteer