1/109
Comprehensive practice flashcards reviewing federal civil procedure, covering jurisdiction, court structure, remedies, procedural due process, pleadings, Rule 12 motions, discovery, dismissals, arbitration, and judgments as a matter of law.
How is Civil Procedure defined, and what parties are typically involved?
Civil Procedure is the process that courts follow in non-criminal, federal cases. It includes private citizens, corporations, governments, and government agencies.
How are the federal courts structured?
Federal courts consist of U.S. District Courts (which primarily hear issues of fact and interpretations of federal law), U.S. Courts of Appeals (primarily hearing issues of law), and the U.S. Supreme Court (which has no obligation to hear cases via writ of certiorari).
What are the specific trial courts in Louisiana?
Louisiana has 3 U.S. District Courts: Western, Central, and Eastern, and is located in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals.
How are state courts structured?
State courts have broad general jurisdiction and hear most civil cases. State trial courts primarily hear issues of fact and interpretations of state law, while state intermediate appellate courts primarily hear issues of state law.
How many state trial courts does Louisiana have?
Louisiana has 42 state trial courts.
What are the three main categories of remedies embodied by court judgments?
Damages, injunctions, and declaratory relief.
What are Damages?
Monetary compensation for what a π has lost because of the defendant’s wrong; most common
What are the four primary types of damages in civil litigation?
Punitive: Intended to punish bad behavior especially reprehensible actions that may not lead to substantial compensatory damages. (e.g., drunk driving, intentional torts).
Compensatory : Compensate for subjective, non-tangible harm (e.g., emotional distress, pain and suffering).
Actual: Objectively calculated based on fair market value (e.g., medical bills, lost wages).
Statutory: Minimum or maximum damages required by legislation, often when other damages are small or hard to prove. (can encompass both actual and compensatory damages)
What happens if state courts get a case whose damages are exactly or over $75,000.01?
Use the Jurisdictional Amount in Controversy Rule
What is the Jurisdictional Amount in Controversy Rule?
If the case involves an issue of state law, then it must have an amount in controversy of exactly $75,000.01 or more. The party seeking removal to federal court bears the burden of proof.
What is an Attachment Provisional Monetary Relief?
Involves seizure of property ((in the case of real property the "seizure" may be accomplished by anything from physical occupation of the land to the symbolic posting of a notice at whatever office keeps track of titles to land)
What is an Garnishment Provisional Monetary Relief?
Involves asking some third party, often ∆ bank or employer not to pay ∆ money due to him because the plaintiff has a claim on it
What is an injunction?
A form of specific relief when a court orders parties to do or not do something.
What are the two types of injunctions?
Provisional (A remedy that occurs before the pre-trial or discovery process) and Permanent (A remedy that occurs after final judgment).
What if both a monetary and injunctive relief are available?
Use the Adequacy of Legal Remedies Rule
What is the Adequacy of Legal Remedies Rule?
Injunctions require that no adequate remedy (monetary damages) is available to Plaintiff
What is an Ejectment Specific Relief?
Removing someone from your property.
What is a Replevin Specific Relief?
Getting your property back from someone.
What is Declaratory Relief?
Parties in circumstances where specific relief or damages are unavailable may seek from the court a declaration of their rights w/o seeking or being in a position to seek any coercive relief such as damages or injunctions.
What does Declaratory Relief do?
Tells parties where they stand legally when a party reasonably believes that he is about to be sued.
What is Temporary Relief?
Remedies pending final judgment
What are the 3 forms of Temporary Relief?
Ex Parte Temporary Restraining Order
Temporary Restraining Order
Preliminary Injunction
What is an Ex Parte Temporary Restraining Order?
A TRO that is served w/o notice to the adverse party.
What is the rule for an Ex Parte TRO?
To be issued w/o notice, either (1) specific facts must show immediate and irreparable harm will result before notifying the adverse party, or (2) efforts have been made to provide notice.
What is a TRO and what does it do?
An injunction that lasts for 14 days, unless the court or adverse party chooses to extend it; A TRO preserves the status quo until a preliminary injunction hearing.
What is a Preliminary Injunction, and what does it do?
An injunction issued before or during trial to prevent irreparable injury; not prescriptive, but can be used as a tool to indicate the verdict of litigation.
What four elements must a plaintiff prove to obtain temporary relief?
Plaintiff must prove that
They are likely to succeed on the merits (tends to be the most important factor).
Whether it is reasonable that the π requesting the injunction could win the case. (the meat & potatoes of the case)
They are likely to experience irreparable injury w/out the injunction.
An irreparable harm cannot only be possible; it must be likely for a π to receive temporary relief.
The balance of equities favors the plaintiff.
The injunction is in the public interest.
What if the court uses the same reasoning from prelim injunction on perm injunction?
If a court issues a permanent injunction w/ the same reasoning as a preliminary injunction and w/o any additional evidence, the court abused its discretion.
What type of case tends to satisfy all 4 elements of a TRO?
Constitutional rights violations as long as a party proves a likelihood of success on the merits.
What must every order granting a TRO or preliminary injunction state pursuant to FRCP 65?
Order must state: (1) the reasons why it was issued, (2) its terms specifically, and (3) in reasonable detail—without referring to the complaint or other document—the act or acts restrained or required.
What are the two types of Due Process?
Procedural and Substantive
What are the two threshold questions required to establish a Procedural Due Process violation?
Has someone been deprived of life, liberty, or property by state action?
If so, have they received due process through constitutional procedures (including notice and the right to be heard)?
Fuentes v Shevin
The ∆ filed a writ of replevin, demanding the return of the π’s stove and stenograph. On the same day, the sheriff seized the π’s property. Under the Florida replevin statute, the π did not receive notice or have the opportunity to be heard. SCOTUS found that the π had a property interest, and she did not receive due process through constitutional procedures.
What is Due Process?
Per the Fifth & Fourteenth Amendments, the government cannot “deprive a person of life, liberty or property without due process of law.” Due process includes the right to be heard and the right to notice; only applicable when the state acts.
What are the three factors of the Eldridge Test for Procedural Due Process’ second element?
The private interest that will be affected by the official action.
The risk of erroneous deprivation of such interest through the procedures used, and the probable value, if any, of additional or substitute procedural safeguards.
The government's interest, including the function involved and the fiscal and administrative burdens that the additional or substitute procedural requirements would entail.
O’donnell v. Harris County:
The π sought a preliminary injunction claiming that Harris County’s process for determining secured bonds was unconstitutional. First, the court found that the liberty interest was the right to individualized bail assessment under TX law. The court weighed the factors of the Eldridge Test: (1) private interest in an individualized bail assessment, (2) high risk of erroneous deprivation of individualized bail assessment, and the value of safeguards such as pre-trial services, affidavits, and longer hearings, and (3) government interest in efficiency and the burden of these new safeguards. The court narrowed the injunction.
What is the American Rule regarding the payment of litigation legal fees?
Each party pays their own legal fees; leads to nuisance-value settlements (people will pay more to settle lawsuit faster) and accommodates constitutional reform; discourages negative value claims (cost outweigh recovery)
What is the English Rule regarding the payment of litigation legal fees?
The losing party pays the opposing party's legal fees.
What is a Contingency Fee?
If you do not win or settle your case, you owe no attorney fees. On the other hand, an attorney may take up to 25-40%. Attorneys must weigh recovery v. expenses v. likelihood to succeed on the merits
What are Third Party Lenders?
Lender takes on the financial risk instead of the π’s firm. Pro bono: Legal services, impact litigation, movement lawyering
What are Fee Shifting Statutes?
Help plaintiffs seeking smaller damages awards or injunctive relief for claims covered by those statutes.
What if a prevailing party wants to waive the fees under fee shifting statutes?
Rule: A statute like the Civil Rights Act that allows a prevailing party to recover attorney fees does not prevent a prevailing party from waiving the fees.
Evans v. Jeff D
The ∆ offered a settlement with a provision waiving attorney fees. Although the π’s lawyer knew he would not be compensated, he counseled the π to agree to the settlement. The Court held that constitutional right statutes do not outright prevent fee waivers.
What is required for a plaintiff to be considered a 'prevailing party' to recover statutory attorney's fees under Buckhannon v. W.V. Health?
The plaintiff must receive a judgment on the record, either through a court-ordered consent decree or a judicial judgment. Legislative change rendering the contested policy void during litigation does not suffice.
What FRCP Rule governs Pleadings?
Rule 7(a): Only these pleadings are allowed: (1) a complaint, (2) an answer, (3) an answer to a counterclaim, (4) an answer to a cross-claim, (5) a third-party complaint, (6) an answer to a third-party complaint, (7) a court-ordered reply to any answer.
What is a Complaint?
The document the π files to initiate the lawsuit. Filing a complaint does not mean the claim is viable. After a party submits a complaint, the party must serve a summons and complaint (90-day requirement).
What are the 3 functions of a Complaint?
The complaint (1) identifies factual disputes of the parties by allowing the π to present their version of the facts & (2) lets courts determine whether the π’ s story entitles them to relief.
A complaint should tell a compelling story based on its most important facts. A successful complaint is persuasive, detailed, and precise.
Most important function of a complaint—survive a motion to dismiss. If the complaint does not survive a 12 (b) (6) motion, the π may request to amend the complaint.
What rule governs the requirements of a complaint?
FRCP 8(a); A pleading that states a claim for relief must contain: (1) a short & plain statement of the court’s jurisdiction, (2) a short & plain statement showing that the π is entitled to relief, (creates “notice” pleading standard so π must plead facts) (3) a demand for the relief sought.
What are the 4 types of ∆ respones?
Default -> The ∆ does nothing & a judgment is entered against the ∆.
Settlements -> The parties agree.
Pre-Answer Motions —-> Fall under Rule 12
Answer —> The ∆ either admits, denies, or makes a disclaimer about every allegation
What FRCP rule governs a Default?
FRCP 12(a) and 55
What is FRCP 12(a)?
…
What is FRCP 55?
…
What rule governs jurisdiction?
Not in federal court: FRCP 12(b)(1)
Not in state court: FRCP 12(b)(2)
What is FRCP 12(b)(1)?
…
What is FRCP 12(b)(2)?
…
“Even if all of your non conclusory, factual allegations are true, you still lose” is based in what rule?
FRCP 12(b)(6)
What is FRCP 12(b)(6)?
…
What if the ∆ claims the story isnt true?
Denial (in answer) FRCP 8(b)
What is FRCP 8(b)?
…
What rule is based in “even if your story is true, I can tell another that’ll show that I win anyway”
Affirmative defense (in answer) FRCP 8(c)
What is FRCP 8(c)?
…
What rule is based in “Now that you mention it, I want something from you”?
Counterclaim or crossclaim (in answer) FRCP 8(a) and 13
What is FRCP 8(a)?
…
What is FRCP 13?
…
What are the time limits for a defendant to answer a complaint under Rule 12(a)(1)(A)?
A defendant must answer: (i) within 21 days after formal service, (ii) within 60 days if formal service is waived, or (iii) within 90 days if the defendant is outside U.S. jurisdiction.
What happens if the defendant doesn’t comply with FRCP 12(a)(1)(A)?
When left unresolved, clerk enters default judgment
What is a settlement?
The parties can settle a case before the π even files the complaint. Here, the ∆s are not admitting the allegations. Instead, they avoid the cost and time of litigation. This sometimes includes NDA’s which prevent the plaintiffs from speaking about certain information
What is a pre answer motion?
Pre-answer motions under Rule 12(c), 12(e), & 12(f) ask the court to resolve an element of the complaint.
What are the three specific pre-answer motions available under Rule 12(c), Rule 12(e), and Rule 12(f)?
Rule 12(e): Motion for a more definite statement (when a pleading is so vague that a party cannot reasonably prepare a response).
Rule 12(c): Motion for judgment on the pleadings (filed when ∆ submits answer, but early enough not to delay trial, raising issues of law rather than material facts); ∆ admitted enough info in its answer and based on this, either party can move on the motion.
Rule 12(f): Motion to strike (removes an insufficient defense or any redundant, immaterial, impertinent, or scandalous matter). Used to strip complain of claims and remove prejudicial or irrelevant allegations
What type of motion is a Motion to Dismiss 12(b)(6)?
Pre Answer motion
What is an answer?
It addresses each paragraph of the complaint, addressing each of the π’s factual allegations.
What are the type of answers?
Admission, denial, or denial due to lack of knowledge or information
What are the functions of an answer?
Identify factual disputes between the parties and raise affirmative defenses
What are the elements of an answer?
Affirmative defenses; counter and cross claims
What is a counter and cross claim
When the ∆ sues the Plaintiff back; when the plaintiff sues 2 ∆’s and one ∆ sues another ∆
What are the seven defenses available under Rule 12(b)?
Rule 12(b)(1): Lack of subject-matter jurisdiction
Rule 12(b)(2): Lack of personal jurisdiction
Rule 12(b)(3): Improper venue
Rule 12(b)(4): Insufficient process
Rule 12(b)(5): Insufficient service of process
Rule 12(b)(6): Failure to state a claim
Rule 12(b)(7): Failure to join a party
How many 12(b) motions can a party file in either its responsive pleading or motion?
One
How many 12(b) motions can a party file in one pleading?
Multiple combined
What is FRCP 12(h)(1)?
States which 12b motions are easiest to wave
What does FRCP 12(h)(1) state?
A party waives any of the defenses listed in 12(b)(2-5) if the party: (A) omits it from a motion or (B)(i) fails to either make it by a motion under this rule or (ii) include it in a responsive pleading or an amendment.
What specific motions apply to FRCP 12(h)(1)?
Rule 12 (b) (2): lack of personal jurisdiction
Rule 12 (b) (3): improper venue
Rule 12 (b) (4): insufficient process, meaning a defect in the complaint.
Rule 12 (b) (5): insufficient service of process
What is FRCP 12(h)(2)?
States which motions are harder to Waive: These motions can appear in the ∆’s responsive pleading following a motion, a 12 (c) motion, or at trial.
What does FRCP 12(h)(2) state?
A party may raise 12(b)(6-7) or failure to state a legal defense: (A) in any pleading allowed or ordered, (B) by a motion under Rule 12(c), or (C) at trial.
What specific motions does FRCP 12(h)(2) include?
Rule 12 (b) (6): failure to state a claim
Rule 12 (b) (7): failure to join a required party
What is FRCP 12(h)(3)?
States which motions are not Waivable: This motion is never waived & always within the court' s purview, even on appeal.
What does FRCP 12(h)(3) state?
If a court determines at any moment that it lacks subject-matter jurisdiction, the court must dismiss the action.
What specific motions does FRCP 12(h)(3) include?
Rule 12 (b) (1): lack of subject-matter jurisdiction
What is FRCP 12(b)(6)?
Failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted. First, the motion admits the facts alleged in the complaint. 2. Second, the motion argues that even if the alleged facts are true, the law grants the plaintiff no legal remedy. A 12(b)(6) motion requires the court to interpret both the substantive law and the pleading standard outlined in Rule 8(a).
How did the pleading standard evolve from Conley v. Gibson through Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly and Ashcroft v. Iqbal?
Conley established that a complaint should not be dismissed unless it appears beyond doubt that the plaintiff can prove 'no set of facts' supporting their claim. Twombly retired this standard, requiring facts sufficient to make the claim 'plausible on its face' rather than merely possible. Iqbal affirmed this heightened standard for all civil actions, ruling that non conclusory factual allegations that, if presumed true, make a claim plausible based on judicial experience and common sense
What is the three-step post-Twiqbal judicial framework for surviving a Rule 12(b)(6) motion?
Identify and ignore bare conclusory legal allegations.
Evaluate the plausibility of the claim based on the remaining non-conclusory factual allegations using judicial experience and common sense.
Consider potential innocent explanations for the defendant's actions.
What does Rule 9(b) require when pleading fraud or mistake?
Rule 9(b) requires a party to state with particularity the circumstances constituting fraud or mistake, including: (1) time, (2) place, (3) contents of representation, (4) identity of the person, and (5) what the person obtained (i.e., clearly identifying the lie).
What does Rule 11(b) require, and what is its safe harbor provision?
Rule 11(b) requires that any pleading, written motion, or paper filed with the court be formed after an inquiry reasonable under the circumstances. Under the safe harbor provision, a motion for sanctions cannot be filed with the court if the challenged paper, claim, or contention is withdrawn or appropriately corrected within 21 days after service.
What is the timeframe for amending a pleading as a matter of course under Rule 15(a)(1)?
A party may amend once as a matter of course no later than: (A) 21 days after serving it, or (B) if a responsive pleading is required, 21 days after service of a responsive pleading or 21 days after service of a motion under Rule 12(b), (e), or (f), whichever is earlier.
Under what standard do courts grant leave to amend under Rule 15(a)(2)?
In all other cases, leave should be freely given 'when justice so requires' in the absence of bad faith (no good reason for not getting it right the first time) or undue prejudice to the opposing party (Beeck v. Aquaslide).
When does an amended pleading relate back to the original filing date under Rule 15(c)?
An amendment relates back if: (1) permitted by the applicable statute of limitations statute, (2) the claim or defense arose out of the conduct, transaction, or occurrence set out in the original pleading, or (3) it changes a party/name, provided the new party received timely notice so as not to be prejudiced and knew or should have known the action was brought against them.
What is spoliation, and what must counsel do to preserve evidence upon reasonable anticipation of litigation?
Spoliation is the intentional, reckless, or negligent destruction, alteration, concealment, or failure to preserve evidence relevant to a pending or reasonably foreseeable lawsuit. Counsel must: (1) issue and reiterate a 'litigation hold', (2) communicate with 'key players' identified in initial disclosures, and (3) instruct employees to produce electronic copies and safeguard backup media.
What sanctions may a court impose under Rule 37(e) for failure to preserve electronically stored information (ESI)?
Upon finding prejudice from the loss of information, the court may order measures no greater than necessary to cure prejudice. Only upon finding an intent to deprive another party of the information's use may the court presume the lost information was unfavorable, instruct the jury to presume it was unfavorable, or dismiss the action or enter a default judgment.
What four mandatory items must be disclosed under Rule 26(a)(1)(A) initial disclosures?
Names, addresses, and phone numbers of individuals likely to have discoverable information the disclosing party may use.
A copy or description of all documents, ESI, and tangible things used to support claims/defenses.
A computation of each category of damages claimed and supporting documents.
Any relevant insurance agreement.
What numerical and time limitations govern interrogatories and depositions in federal discovery?
Interrogatories (Rule 33) are capped at 25 questions including all discrete subparts and cannot be served on non-parties. Depositions (Rule 30) are limited to 10 depositions per side, each lasting a maximum of 7 hours in a single day.
What is the Work Product Doctrine established by Hickman v. Taylor and codified in Rule 26(b)(3)?
It conditionally protects documents and tangible things prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial by or for another party or its representative. Such materials can only be discovered if the requesting party shows substantial need and that it cannot obtain the substantial equivalent without undue hardship. Mental impressions, conclusions, and legal opinions are virtually never discoverable.