Tools to evaluate sustainability from product to system

0.0(0)
Studied by 1 person
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/39

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

40 Terms

1
New cards

What is the environmental food impact?

  • Emission of greenhouse gases

  • Eutrophication

  • Resource consumption (land, energy, water)

  • Loss of biodiversity

  • Toxicity


2
New cards

Emission of GHG → What are the primary greenhouse gases associated with food production?

  • Methane (CH4) from ruminants, manure, and soils;

  • nitrous oxide (N2O) from nitrogen in fertilizers, manure, and soils.

  • CO2 from fossil fuels, deforestation and organic soils


3
New cards

What are the main sources of greenhouse gas emissions from wild-caught seafood?

Fuel and refrigerants (e.g., R22).

4
New cards

Eutrophication → what is eutrophication?

The process in which a body of water becomes overly enriched with minerals and nutrients, primarily nitrogen and phosphorus, leading to excessive growth of algae and aquatic plants

5
New cards

What percentage of eutrophication is contributed by agriculture?

75%.

6
New cards

What is the limiting factor for eutrophication in freshwater versus land and sea?

Phosphates (phosphorus) are typically the limiting factor in freshwater, while nitrogen is often the limiting factor on land and at sea.

7
New cards

What are the main causes and solutions for agricultural and processing eutrophication?

Causes: fertilizers in agriculture and waste-water from processing or net-pen aquaculture

Solutions include more precise fertilization, water treatment and nutrient recirculation, and closed aquaculture.

8
New cards

Resource consumption → What are the main categories of resource consumption evaluated in food environmental impacts?

Land (deforestation, desertification, competition), energy (fertilizer production, field work, fishing, processing, transports), and water.

9
New cards

What are the other critical environmental impact categories beyond climate change, eutrophication, and resource consumption?

Biodiversity (loss of species and ecosystem services) and toxicity (use of pesticides, cadmium, and antifouling paints in the food chain).

10
New cards

What are commonly used quantification methods for environmental performance?

  • Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)

  • Ecological Foot-printing

  • Eco-efficiency

  • Technology assessment

  • Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA).


11
New cards

What is Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)?

A tool that systematically and quantitatively expresses how a product affects the environment from raw material extraction to waste (cradle-to-grave)

12
New cards

LCA helps you map environmental pressures, indentify if they are large or small and understrand in depth and see the system effects so you can…

Communicate and prioritize actions, be safe in debeate and optimize activities

13
New cards

What are the four main steps of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)?

  1. Goal and scope

  2. Life cycle inventory

  3. Impact assessment

  4. Interpretation


14
New cards

Goal and scope → You must define the purpose of LCA, what must you answer? o

You must answer:

  • Why is the LCA being done

  • Who is the commissioner

  • Who is the audience

  • How are the results going to be used

It is a sialogue between the commissioner and practitioner


15
New cards

Goal and scope → what common questions must you respond to know the goal and the scope of the model?

  • How large is the environmental impact of the product?

  • Which part of the life cycle is affecting the most?

  • Is the alternative product A better than B?

  • Whay should in order to make the most improvement?


16
New cards

What is a functional unit in LCA?

A normalisation of data to a common "denominator" that reflects the system's function (e.g., 1 kg of food, 1 liter of beverage, 1 m2 of protected surface for 10 years).

17
New cards

Goal and scope → how to define the systems boundaries?

  • Where is the cradle?

  • Where is the grave?

  • What cut-offs can be done?


18
New cards

What does the Life Cycle Inventory (LCI) step involve?

Collecting specific and generic data on input resources (energy, materials, land, water) and output emissions (to air, water, soil, waste, and by-products) for each step within the system boundaries.

19
New cards

What does the Impact Assessment step do in LCA?

Calculates results by translating inventory data into potential environmental impacts (such as global warming potential in kg CO2 eq, acidification in kg SO2 eq, and eutrophication in kg NO3 eq).

20
New cards

What does the Interpretation step involve in LCA?

Analyzing results, checking completeness, consistency, sensitivity/uncertainty, and revisiting previous steps if needed.

21
New cards

What is the eventual problem with LCA?

The allocation problem: LCA gets complicated when a single process makes multiple products (e.g., a cow produces meat and leather and dairy).

22
New cards

What are the four main methods to handle allocation when multiple products or by-products emerge from a process?

  1. Sub-divide the production process

  2. Use system expansion

  3. Allocate the environmental burden based on physical attributes (e.g., mass, energy content),

  4. Allocate the environmental burden based on economic value.


23
New cards

What is allocation by system expansion?

A method where the system boundary is expanded to include the additional functions of co-products, subtracting the avoided impacts of alternative production systems from the main product system.

  1. Identify the main product you are studying (e.g., Product A).

  2. Identify the co-product (e.g., Product B).

  3. Determine what Product B replaces. Imagine Product B is a bio-based plastic. If we didn't make it here, the world would have to make that plastic out of fossil fuels.

  4. Expand the system. You expand your study to include the production of that avoided fossil-fuel plastic.

  5. Subtract the avoided impact (The Credit). Because your process created Product B (which saved the world from making fossil-fuel plastic), you give your main product (Product A) an "environmental credit." You subtract the impact of the avoided fossil-fuel plastic from the total impact of your system.


<p>A method where the system boundary is expanded to include the additional functions of co-products, subtracting the avoided impacts of alternative production systems from the main product system.</p><ol><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Identify the main product</strong> you are studying (e.g., Product A).</p></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Identify the co-product</strong> (e.g., Product B).</p></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Determine what Product B replaces.</strong> Imagine Product B is a bio-based plastic. If we didn't make it here, the world would have to make that plastic out of fossil fuels.</p></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Expand the system.</strong> You expand your study to include the production of that avoided fossil-fuel plastic.</p></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Subtract the avoided impact (The Credit).</strong> Because your process created Product B (which saved the world from making fossil-fuel plastic), you give your main product (Product A) an "environmental credit." You subtract the impact of the avoided fossil-fuel plastic from the total impact of your system.</p></li></ol><p></p>
24
New cards

ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY OF COMPANIES → How is the overall "environmental performance" of a company organized and calculated?

  1. Product Life Cycle Performances:

    • The impacts of the products the company makes, from cradle to grave (raw materials, manufacturing, consumer use, disposal).

    • Influenced by: Product development, sourcing, packaging, and transport.

  2. Environmental Performances of Selected Technology:

    • The impacts of the specific machinery, equipment, and production lines the company chooses to use.

    • Influenced by: Engineering choices, factory design, and equipment efficiency.

  3. Environmental Performances of Operations:

    • The daily, ongoing impacts of running the business (e.g., heating the factory, lighting the office, company vehicle fleets, business travel).


<ol><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Product Life Cycle Performances:</strong></p><ul><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph">The impacts of the products the company makes, from cradle to grave (raw materials, manufacturing, consumer use, disposal).</p></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><em>Influenced by:</em> Product development, sourcing, packaging, and transport.</p></li></ul></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Environmental Performances of Selected Technology:</strong></p><ul><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph">The impacts of the specific machinery, equipment, and production lines the company chooses to use.</p></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><em>Influenced by:</em> Engineering choices, factory design, and equipment efficiency.</p></li></ul></li><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph"><strong>Environmental Performances of Operations:</strong></p><ul><li><p class="ds-markdown-paragraph">The daily, ongoing impacts of running the business (e.g., heating the factory, lighting the office, company vehicle fleets, business travel).</p></li></ul></li></ol><p></p>
25
New cards

What does the "Degrees of freedom to make changes" graph illustrate in the context of product/company development?

  • It illustrates a core rule of sustainable design: The earlier you make changes, the easier and cheaper it is.

  • Degrees of freedom are highest at the idea and lab scale stages and decrease significantly as a process moves to pilot and full scale.

  • If you want to make a product more sustainable, you must do it at the "Idea" stage. If a company waits until the product is already in full production, they have locked themselves into whatever environmental footprint that design has


<ul><li><p><span>It illustrates a core rule of sustainable design: </span><strong>The earlier you make changes, the easier and cheaper it is.</strong></p></li></ul><ul><li><p>Degrees of freedom are highest at the idea and lab scale stages and decrease significantly as a process moves to pilot and full scale.</p></li><li><p>I<span>f you want to make a product more sustainable, you must do it at the </span><strong>"Idea" stage</strong><span>. If a company waits until the product is already in full production, they have locked themselves into whatever environmental footprint that design has</span></p></li></ul><p></p>
26
New cards

What is the average greenhouse gas impact of present food consumption in Sweden per person per year compared to the sustainable level?

Present food consumption is around 2 tonnes (CO2 eq) per person and year, whereas the global sustainable level is below 1.5 tonnes (consistent with limiting warming to <1.5 °C).

27
New cards

ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY CONSUMPTION → How is total environmental impact calculated in food consumption?

Total environmental impact = amount of product * (impact / amount of product).

<p>Total environmental impact = amount of product * (impact / amount of product).</p>
28
New cards

How do different diets compare in terms of reduced climate impact per person and year?

From highest to lowest impact: increased meat consumption, today's diet (~2 tonnes), no-waste diet, season-adjusted diet, dietary guidelines (1.4–1.7 tonnes), climate-smart median diet (0.9–1.3 tonnes), ovo-lacto vegetarian diet, and vegan diet.

<p>From highest to lowest impact: increased meat consumption, today's diet (~2 tonnes), no-waste diet, season-adjusted diet, dietary guidelines (1.4–1.7 tonnes), climate-smart median diet (0.9–1.3 tonnes), ovo-lacto vegetarian diet, and vegan diet.</p>
29
New cards

What is the effect of changing the functional unit (FU) from mass to nutritional metrics like protein or iron?

Changing the FU changes the comparative environmental impact metrics (e.g., GWP per gram of protein is 1.4 times higher than kg, and per mg of iron is 6 times higher).

<p>Changing the FU changes the comparative environmental impact metrics (e.g., GWP per gram of protein is 1.4 times higher than kg, and per mg of iron is 6 times higher).</p>
30
New cards

What are the main challenges and solutions regarding the "Environmental Sustainability of Consumption"?

1. The Overshoot: In countries like Sweden, the emissions from just food consumption (1.5–2 tonnes CO₂/person) already exceed the total sustainable limit for an individual (1.5 tonnes).
2. The Biggest Lever: Shifting diets away from meat and animal products toward plant-based foods (a vegetarian/vegan diet) drastically reduces the climate footprint.
3. The Measurement Problem: Comparing food by weight (1 kg vs 1 kg) is unfair. We must use "Nutrient Density" as a functional unit to compare foods based on their health value per unit of environmental impact.
4. The Behavioral Challenge: Changing consumption requires guiding consumers through thousands of daily "micro-decisions" using tools and better information.

31
New cards

What is the Nutrient Rich Food 9.3 (NRF9.3) index used for in sustainable consumption?

As a starting point for dietary quality scores to assess nutrient density in combination with environmental assessments.

32
New cards

What are the main takeaways regarding food and the environment?

Food contributes substantially to global/local impacts, greenhouse gas increases will affect global production, indicators are not always aligned, and we need to address both what we eat and how we produce food.

33
New cards

What is social sustainability?

assessing the impacts on all stakeholders involved in the value chain. This includes:

  • Workers (e.g., Are they paid fairly? Are there unsafe conditions?)

  • Local Communities (e.g., Does the factory pollute their water? Does it support local jobs?)

  • Consumers (e.g., Is the product safe? Does it respect cultural heritage?)

  • Society (e.g., Does the business pay taxes? Is it involved in political conflict?)

  • Value Chain Actors (e.g., Are suppliers treated fairly?)


34
New cards

What is Social Life Cycle Assessment (S-LCA)?

S-LCA is a tool used to measure the social and human impacts of a product across its entire life cycle (from raw materials to disposal).

How it works: It focuses on stakeholders (workers, local communities, consumers, society) and measures impact categories like human rights, working conditions, and health/safety.

35
New cards

Difference between social and environmental sustainibility:

  • Environmental (E-LCA): Has a very solid scientific basis. A gram of CO₂ is a gram of CO₂ everywhere in the world.

  • Social (S-LCA): There is no general scientific basis. It is highly stakeholder-based and study-specific. What is considered "fair pay" or "acceptable working hours" changes depending on the country, culture, and the specific companies involved.


36
New cards

How is Social Life Cycle Assessment (SLCA) structured?

  • Stakeholder Categories: Who is affected? (Workers, Local Community, Society, etc.)

  • Impact Categories: What is the broad issue? (Human rights, Working conditions, Health and safety, Governance).

  • Subcategories & Indicators: How do we measure it? For example, under the stakeholder "Workers" and category "Human Rights," the subcategory might be "Child Labor." The indicator would be the percentage of child labor in the workforce.


37
New cards

What are the main steps in Social Life Cycle Assessment (SLCA)?

  1. Goal and scope definition

  2. Life cycle inventory (data collection across unit processes)

  3. Impact assessment (using referencing scales from ideal performance +2 to starkly below compliance -2, or risk levels)

  4. Interpretation (completeness, consistency, sensitivity checks, and materiality assessment).


38
New cards

How is the data in social LCA?

Like the environmental version, the Social LCA requires collecting data on every step of the process. However, instead of looking at inputs like water and energy, it looks at things like:

  • Number of accidents

  • Wages paid compared to the living wage

  • Hours of training provided

  • Occurrence of child labor


39
New cards

How is the impact assessment done in SLCA?

Because social data is often qualitative (hard to put into a strict number), the S-LCA uses a Reference Scale (shown on page 68). It scores the performance of a company on a scale from -2 to +2:

  • +2: Ideal performance (Best in class)

  • +1: Beyond compliance (Doing more than the law requires)

  • 0: Compliance (Following local laws and basic societal expectations)

  • -1: Slightly below compliance

  • -2: Starkly below compliance (e.g., using illegal child labor)


40
New cards

How to check if SLCA strudy is valid:

  • Completeness check: Did we cover all the important steps?

  • Consistency check: Did we apply the same rules to all parts of the supply chain?

  • Sensitivity check: What happens if our data is slightly wrong?