Middle East - 2 differences/similarities

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/31

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

32 Terms

1
New cards

Explain TWO ways in which the first Intifada (1987) was different from the second Intifada (2000).

- The second intifada was more violent and brutal than the first. Rocks vs knives, bullets, grenades, rockets and suicide bombings causing more chaos and casualties 5,000 palstians and 1,200 in the first
- The triggers were slightly different : 1987, by a violent flashpoint Israeli market trader stabbed to death, followed by the IDF van killing 4 and injuring 7. In 2000 violence erupted when Sharon visited the site of the Al-Aqsa mosque, seemingly asserting Israeli authority over the holy site. Palestinians protested.

2
New cards

Explain TWO ways in which the first Intifada (1987) was similar from the second Intifada (2000).

- Both caused by Palestinian resentment about the treatment by IDF/Israeli gov. In the occupied territories. Also built up resentment at continued building of Israeli settlements
- After the initial eruption of violence, there was a degree of organisation to both intifadas : the first saw the UNLU take the lead in orchestrating Palestinian resistence. The second was a range of groups organise operations such as Hamas, PFLP and Islamic Jihad

3
New cards

Explain two ways in which Jewish terrorist organisations and David Ben Gurion differed in their approaches to establishing an independent Jewish state [6 marks]

- Jewish terrorist organisations were much more violent in how they established the jewish independant state - bombing of king david hotel which killed 91 , deir yassin irgun / lehi killed 120 compared to David Ben Gurion who was much more focused on politics
- Ben Gurion was patient he waited for the British mandate to end and snatched it immediately; where the irgun and lehi terrorism and were relentless

4
New cards

Explain two differences between the Balfour Declaration and the Hussein McMahon Correspondence [6]

- Balfour didn't consider the views of the Arabs, HMC recognised Arab independence after ww1 as the British wanted to maintain a good relationship with the Arab countries for economic reasons and protection in the war.
- The balfour was intended to establish a homeland for the jews in hopes to thank/ impress the Americans for helping in the final 8 months of the war where HMC was established in return to thank the arabs

5
New cards

Explain two similarities between the Balfour Declaration and the Hussein McMahon Correspondence [6]

- They both promised an independent state for someone
- They were both ambiguous

6
New cards

Explain two ways in which Jewish and Arab organisations differed in the 1920s and 1930s [6 marks]

- The jewish forces were supported by the British, as they helped establish the haganah and supported them in battles, 50,000 british soldiers fought off the arab revolt. In contrast the Arab organisations had to fight against the british
- The jewish organsisations also had a lot more success - 1922 -35 270,000 migrants, zionist settlements expanded, they dominated the Arab Revolt in 26 killing and injury 2500. Where Arab organisations struggled to resist the immigration and were put under curfews after military losses

7
New cards

Explain two ways in which British treatment of the Jews and Arabs differed in the period 1917-37 [6 marks]

- Established balfour declaration which encouraged jewish immigration by 1935 nearly 300,000 jewish migrants had arrived, this compeltely differs to the attitude to the arabs where they ignored their promise of the hussein macmahon agreement and instead established their own British mandate
- They also militarily prepared the jews, establishing the haganah to the point in 1936 where 15,000 trained soldiers stopped the arab revolt, British officers worked in night squads and attacked arab homes, working with the jewish in all battles including the arab revolt in which there were 50,000 british soldiers. This contrasts to where they used brutal torture methods and put suspected arab terrorists in prison camps.

8
New cards

Explain two ways in which the first Arab-Israeli War (1948-9) was different to the Six Day War (1967) [6 marks]

- The Arab Israeli war was caused by the ending of the british mandate and David Ben Gurion's immediate establishment of the state of Israel; where the six day war was caused by Israeli fear from the Cairo conference and developments in terrorism from it and the trigger of Nasser closing the straits of Tiran stopping Israel trade to Asia.
- The Arab Israel war was extremely difficult for Israel initially and they were poorly prepared with only 1 in 5 soldiers carrying guns. With the six day war the Israelis caught the Egyptians off guard destroying 309/340 of the aircrafts and all 19 of the airfields by 11 am on the first morning and managed to force a ceasefire by 10 June.

9
New cards

Explain two ways in which the first Arab-Israeli War (1948-9) was similar to the Six Day War (1967) [6 marks]

- The Israelis made significant gains in terms of land in both. With the first Arab Israeli they gained 79% of the land from the British mandate and in Six Day they gained most of the Sinai desert, the Suez Canal, East Jerusalem, golan heights and the west bank. Israel was 350% bigger than it was before
- The Palestinians were deeply affected by both. After Arab-Israeli 700,000 Palestinians became landless refugees. After Six Day 1 million Palestinainss who lived in the west bank found themselves under Israeli military control with around 300,000 fleeing from the west bank to jordan where they once again became landless refugees

10
New cards

Explain two ways the Suez Crisis was similar from the First Arab-Israeli war [6]

- They both left unresolved issues with 700,000 palestinains becoming landless refugees, and after the Suez Crisis there was lots of unresolved tension between Israel and Egypt as well as well as US and USSR which led to terrorism and continued fighting like the Six Day War
- The UN had to intervene in both wars - they called a 1 month truce in June 1946 which helped the Israelis secure arms from Czech and a 3 month truce in July which allowed the Israelis to push and ultimately win the war. Equally, the UN sent a ceasefire ending the crisis after 8 days saving the egyptians from defeat.

11
New cards

Explain two ways the Suez Crisis was different from the First Arab-Israeli war [6]

- The Czech's provided Israel with weapons during UN truce (30,000 rifles, 4,500 machine guns, 84 planes and 47 million rounds of ammo) vs Czech provided Egypt with weapons in preparation for the Suez criss, in return for $300 million worth of cotton which they used to rearm themselves with over 300 tanks and 250 planes
- Arab Israeli was initiated by Arabs angry with Ben Gurion after the establishing the state of Israel in may 14 1948, the war was about land; where Suez were initiated by Israel because of Nasser - he rejected their offer for the investment of aswan dam, he had organised a secret arms deal with czech and he had nationalised the suez canal - causing the Sevres agreement to be signed

12
New cards

Explain two ways in which Palestinian attacks on Israel in the 1970s were different from those in the 1960s. [6]

- Their ambitions changed as during the 1960s after the six day war they still didn't accept Israel as a state and wanted to completely crush it, targeting economic points in order to cause as much damage as possible. However, during the 1970s they realised that crushing Israel wasn't achievable so they aimed to regain the territories lost by Six Day and increase global sympathy for their cause.
- The methods changed from the 1960s to 70s. In the 60s they used guerilla warfare mainly by the fatah out of Jordan on random targets to cause general disturbance. where in 1970s they moved more globally and targeted such as the munich olympics in 1972, the double aeroplane highjacking conducted by the PFLP and Black Septmeber as they wanted to make their plight more global making there terrorism larger in magnitude

13
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Yom Kippur War was similar to the Six Day War. [6]

- Both were started with surprise attacks - Six Day: Israel launched an attack destroying 309/340 aircrafts in Egypt and all 19 air fields, allowing them to move into the Sinai peninsula reaching the suez. This was similar to the 1973 war because Egypt and Syria decided to launch a surprise attack on Golan Heights and the Bar Lev line on the holy day of Yom Kippur
- A second way was that Israel was victorious and made territorial gains - Six Day war : they gained Sinai, Suez, East Jerusalem, Golan Heights and West Bank, increasing their territory by 350%. In Yom Kippur the Israeli army had gained land in Egypt around the Suez canal and they had made a significant victory especially when being caught off guard.

14
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Peel commission was different to the white paper [6}

- The white paper massively favoured the Palestinian cause as it involved 10,000 jews migrating per year where the Peel massively favoured the jews as they were given the most fertile land and 90% of orange groves
- The white paper was rejected by the Israelis but partially accepted by the Arabs; whilst the Peel commission was accepted by the jews but was rejected by the Arabs due to 300,000 arabs living in jewish territory

15
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Peel commission was similar to the white paper [6}

- they were both intended to pacify tensions and establish harmony.
- they both failed which led to increase opposition against the British

16
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Peel was similar to the UN partition plan [6]

- They both aimed to create harmony by separating the jews and arabs.
- They were both accepted by the jews because they were more lenient to the jews - 90% of orange groves in Peel and half the land for 33% of the population from partition

17
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Peel was different to the UN partition plan [6]

- The Peel heavily favoured the jews however, the UN partition was more fair with both groups receiving the same amount and quality of land
- The Peel was simply British so wasn't balanced where the Partition was multinational as it was established by UNSCOP which was made up of 11 countries.

18
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Road Map for Peace and the Oslo Peace Accords were similar [6]

- They both failed for similar reasons - Road Map failed because of the continued violence and the mistrust which it created between Israelis and Palestinians for example in March 2004 an Israeli helicopter missile killed the spiritual leader of Hamas. Similarly with Oslo - Netayahu encouraged further building on the west bank.
- they both set out to achieve peace after so many years of death and destruction - Oslo was introduced after the first intifada and the road map was introduced after the second intifada.

19
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Yom Kippur War was different to the Lebanon War of 1982 [6]

- Aims - In Yom Kippur Sadat wanted to gain Suez and sinai as the war of attrition damaged the economy where with the Lebanon Israel wanted to stop terrorism out of Lebanon from the PLO especially as the PLO received more weapons from USSR
- Results - Yom Kippur ended with willingness from both parties to make peace where Lebanon resulted in further terrorism as the Hezbollah took the place of the PLO

20
New cards

Explain two way in which the Yom Kippur War was similar to the Lebanon War of 1982

- both were triggered by Arab actions - Yom Kippur invaded to get land back and protect refugees and Lebanon, Coastal road massacre and ambassador assassination leading to operation peace of Galilee.
- They both demonstrated the power of the Israelis - even when caught off guard in Yom they managed to overcome the forces and destroy 260 tanks. Lebanon they sent 70,000 troops and killed 12,000 and sent 11,500 PLO to Tunis.

21
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Israeli invasion of Lebanon was different from the Suez Crisis [6]

- Suez was caused by politics where Lebanon was caused by violence - Nasser nationalising the Suez and arms deal caused Suez Crisis where Lebanon was caused by Coastal Road massacre in 1978 killing 38 and Israeli ambassador attempted assassination in London by Palestinian resulting in operation peace for Galilee.
- Israel were a lot more successful in Lebanon achieving what they set out to do which was to get rid of the PLO, 11,500 members including Arafat to Tunisia. Where Suez was stopped abruptly and Israel were only partly successful in what they set out to achieve as terrorism still lived on even though they had destroyed all fedayeen bases

22
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Israeli invasion of Lebanon was similar to the Suez Crisis [6]

- both initiated by Israel in the result from of terrorism - Fedayeen raids and $300 million arms deal for 300 tanks and others. Lebanon caused by Coastal Road massacre general terrorism and Israeli ambassador.
- The Israelis received bad publicity as a result for both because they were extremely brutal in Lebanon committing Shatila massacre killing 2,000. Suez was bad because it was such an unfair battle. Both also resulted in more terrorism Cairo Conference and Hezbollah.

23
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Roadmap for Peace (2003) was different to the Oslo Peace Accords (1993)

- Roadmap for peace was more successful as it ended the 2nd intifada, created ceasefires with in militant groups and Israel agreed to withdraw from towns in Gaza. Where Oslo failed to stop the Israeli building on the west bank and continued violence from Palestinians
- Members were more willing to negotiate in Roadmap - Sharon and Abbas made genuine efforts and made progress with talks where Netanyahu and Hamas weren't interested.

24
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Suez Crisis was similar the Yom Kippur War [6]

- US intervention was crucial in determining the result of the two wars. $2.2 billion saved Israel in Yom and US saved Egypt from defeat when they persuaded the UN to call a truce
- Both caused by Super power involvement - Yom was caused by intensified super power interest for example US 1.15 m investment and USSR weapons. Suez was instigated by Israel after Nasser weapons deal with USSR and Czech for 300 million was revealed

25
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Suez Crisis was different to the Yom Kippur War [6]

- Yom was initiated by the Arabs due to the 1 million Palestinians living under Israeli control in the west bank and to claim back the land lost in SDW where Suez was initiated by the British, French and Israelis against Nasser
- Yom resulted in peace between the Nations where Suez resulted in tension and the Cairo conference in which the Arabs stated more intent for violence against Israel (PLO and PLA)

26
New cards

Explain two ways in which the first Arab-Israeli War (1948-9) was different to the Yom Kippur War (1967) [6 marks]

- Arab Israeli resulted in terrorism and a stream of violence in Fedayeen raids 153 Israelis dead between 50-53. Where Yom Kippur resulted in the foudations of Peace Process between Egypt and Israel
- Arab-Israeli was caused by the violence of Deir Yassin killing 120 and Ben Gurion's foundation of Israel. Where Yom Kippur was caused by the 1 million Palestinians who lived in the West Bank under Israeli military control and to win back the territories lost in the Six Day.

27
New cards

Explain two ways in which the first Arab-Israeli War (1948-9) was similar to the Yom Kippur War (1967) [6 marks]

- they both had very similar structures where the Arabs started stronger but help from superpowers got Israel the victory - US organised Czech arms deal with 30,000 rifles and 47 million rounds of ammo and US sent 2.2 billion worth of war resources in Yom.
- The Arabs failed to succeed in what they set out to get - 700,000 Palestinians were removed from the land they were trying to win in Arab-Israeli and Israel managed to maintain nearly all the land in Yom, so they had to settle for peace instead.

28
New cards

Explain two ways in which the War in Lebanon was different to the Six Day War

- Lebanon was caused by constant violence carried out by the PLO and triggered by the Israeli ambassador; where SDW was Israel's way of stopping the pressure formed by the Cairo Conference and the complications that it brought including the head water diversion plan and Nasser closing the Straits of Tiran
-

29
New cards

Explain two ways in which the War in Lebanon was similar to the Six Day War

- They were both initiated by the Israelis in order to cut down on terrorism. Lebanon had coastal road massacre killing 38 and SDW was the PLO and Fatah with Samu Incident and Dogfight, the Israelis wanted to cut this out.
- The Israelis absolutely dominated both, finishing the war in 6 days at SDW with 309/340 planes destroyed as well as killing 20,000 arabs. Lebanon was very similar in that they sent 70,000 troops and killed 12,000 and sent 11,500 PLO members to Tunis.

30
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Suez Crisis was different to the Six Day War [6]

- Six day was a lot more successful than Suez as they gained 350% more land and had crushed their opponents where Suez they destroyed some fadayeen bases and opens the straits of tiran but there were many negatives.
-USA

31
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Suez Crisis was similar to the Six Day War [6]

- both caused by frustrations with Nasser - Suez was because he nationalised the Suez and brought in new weapons such as 300 tanks. Similarly, Nasser closed the Straits of Tiran acting as the trigger Israel to attack
- Both resulted in what the Israelis set out to achieve - they wanted to crush the powers on the surrounding countries with SDW which they did and they were able to reopen the straits of tiran and destroy fedayeen bases in Suez.

32
New cards

Explain two ways in which the Framework for an Egyptian-Israeli Peace was different from the Framework for peace in the Middle East. [6]

- the Framework for an Egyptian-Israeli Peace was wanted and willed by the parties involved with Sadat and Begin both wanting peace, exchanging visits and agreeing on the Treaty of Washington. In contrast with the Framework for peace in the middle east contained Netanyahu who was actively against Oslo and was a pro-settler. Equally, Arab groups such as Hamas as Islamic Jihad continued violence.
- the Framework for an Egyptian-Israeli Peace was also successful with the treaty of washington being signed, where in the middle east both Oslo accords and the roadmap for peace failed.
- the framework for peace in Egyptian-Israeli was a lot fairer with both sides having lots to gain - recognition and withdrawal from Sinai. Where the Oslo accords were very harsh on Palestinians only being given 3% of the west bank just for themselves with Area B being under Israeli control.