1/15
Looks like no tags are added yet.
‘A loving God would not send anyone to hell.’ - Agree points
Arguments in support
The Bible insists that God is loving / eg John 3:16: ‘God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son so that those who believe in him should not perish but have everlasting life/ This kind of love would not include hell.
God is a fair judge / a fair judge would not sentence anybody to pain and torment / so God would not send anybody to hell.
Eternal punishment would be pointless and unloving / so God would not do anything that is pointless.
Some Christians are universalists / and argue that everyone will eventually respond to God’s love / repenting and being forgiven for the sins they may have committed, etc.
‘A loving God would not send anyone to hell.’ - Disagree points
Arguments in support of other views
The Bible refers to hell as a real place / a place of fire and torment / In the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats, it says that those who do not look after others will depart into eternal punishment / God’s love therefore includes hell.
Some will understand hell as separation from God / or as a person’s state of mind / where they punish themselves for their own misdeeds / This idea of hell does not mean that God is unloving.
Some will argue that hell is an invention used by Christians (and others) / it is a threat of punishment in order to make sure that people follow Christian teachings / Alternatively, there is no God to send anybody to hell in the first place.
God gives free will / so the choice is for people to make / so God has to accept the choice of some to reject him, etc.
‘God cannot be loving because people suffer.’ - Agree points
Arguments in support
Christians believe that God is all-loving / a loving God would want to stop all suffering, and has the power to stop suffering, so suffering should not exist.
If God is loving God would know that humans are weak, and would end suffering.
This applies to life after death as well – an all-loving and just God would not allow people to suffer after they die / but the Bible teaches that hell is real / eg in the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats.
Most natural disasters are not caused by anything done by humans and animals / so God should take control of disasters such as earthquakes, volcanic eruptions and floods, etc.
God created humans, so why would a loving God create people to suffer?
It is not just that God allows suffering / the extent of suffering is huge, eg those who are victims of crimes such as rape, murder, arson, theft / why would a loving God allow so much suffering? etc.
‘God cannot be loving because people suffer.’ - Disagree points
Arguments in support of other views
Humans are responsible for what they do to others / so a lot of suffering is caused by ourselves, and not by God (references to Genesis – humanity being expelled from Eden for disobeying God).
Having free will means that humanity must have the power and the choice to reject the moral rules in the Bible and cause other people to suffer.
Despite being all-powerful, God himself suffered on the cross, so if God can suffer, so can we /perhaps God is all-loving but is not all-powerful.
By suffering on the cross for human salvation, Jesus atoned for human sins in order to release/redeem humanity from suffering and sin: eg John 3:16: ‘God so loved the world that he gave his only Son so that those who believe in him should not perish …’
One answer to suffering is prayer / as in the Parable of the Unjust Judge (Luke 18:1–8).
Love does not exclude suffering / parents discipline their children through love, to make them better people / doctors can inflict pain on their patients to cure their illnesses.
A world without suffering would be a toy world / we have to learn through suffering, etc.
Some see suffering as a test of faith, following which God will reward them with eternal life.
Suffering is needed as a balance, to appreciate the good / without bad, good cannot be recognised / suffering teaches us to look after the world.
Our response to suffering is important, eg Jesus from the cross: ‘Forgive them, for they know not what they do.’ (Luke 23:34), etc.
‘The resurrection of the dead is the most important Christian belief.’ - Agree points
Arguments in support
For most Christians, suffering, and death are the worst things they have to deal with / so if they believe that the dead are resurrected, then they no longer have to fear suffering or death.
Christians fear separation from their families at death / so belief in resurrection to heaven means that they will be reunited with those they love.
Christians believe that after their resurrection they will live forever in God’s kingdom / in a state of perfect happiness.
Ideas such as these are the central claim of Christianity: that Jesus was God incarnate / crucified, resurrected and ascended / and is the means of salvation from sin, since Jesus’ death and resurrection atone for human sin.
St Paul states clearly that God raised Jesus from the dead / and if he had not done so, then the (human) dead are not raised either / in which case faith is futile, for Christians are still in their sins/ and those who have already died will remain dead (1 Corinthians 15:15-19) / so Paul shows that the resurrection of Jesus and of Christians are the most important Christian beliefs: one follows from the other.
There is so much evidence for the resurrection of Jesus that it must be true / the four Gospels all have an account of the resurrection of Jesus / so the resurrection of Christians must also be true / and must be the most important Christian belief.
St Paul reached this conclusion at his trial described in Acts 24, where he says that he is on trial for his life because of his belief that the dead will be raised to life, etc.
‘The resurrection of the dead is the most important Christian belief.’ - Diagree points
Arguments in support of other views
Some might argue that belief in God as Creator is the most important Christian belief / since for resurrection to be important to believers, people have to be created first.
In the same way, some might argue that the most important belief is that God is good / this is not obvious from all the evil in the world / but if God is not good then there will be probably be no resurrection.
Equally, some might argue that the most important Christian belief is not just in the resurrection of the dead but in resurrection to judgement / this can be seen in the Parable of the Sheep and Goats (Matthew 25) / which teaches that the dead will be resurrected to God’s kingdom or else to eternal fire / so the most important belief must be to follow the teachings of God/Jesus to avoid being sent to hell.
Some might argue that belief in resurrection of the body is more important than belief in resurrection of the soul / eg because Jesus’ resurrection was bodily / or else that resurrection is a metaphor for being with God in some unknown way.
Some might argue that all Christian beliefs are equally important / and that the incarnation /crucifixion / resurrection / ascension / Pentecost are all equally necessary for Christian belief /belief in human resurrection is just one part of a connected group of beliefs, etc.
‘For Christians, it is impossible to understand the nature of God.’ -Agree points
Arguments in support
This is true because Christians do not agree about God’s nature / so by definition it cannot be understood.
God is beyond human understanding in every respect / this includes understanding God’s nature.
God is believed to exist as a Trinity – as Father, Son and Holy Spirit / Christians describe this as a ‘mystery’, but it is hard to understand how one being can exist in three distinct forms.
The Nicene Creed describes God as ‘the Father Almighty / the one Lord Jesus Christ, the only- begotten Son of God / the Holy Ghost, the Lord and Giver of life’, but many Christians struggle to understand these ideas and how they combine into one God.
As God the Son, Jesus is believed to have been God in human form / but Jesus’ body was crucified by the Romans / some Christians therefore have difficulty in understanding the resurrection narratives.
God is seen as loving / but the amount of evil and suffering in the world makes it difficult for Christians to understand this.
God is seen as omnipotent / all-powerful, eg Matthew 19:26, ‘With God, all things are possible.’ / but if God is all-powerful and all-loving, some Christians cannot understand the nature of a God who allows evil to exist.
God is also seen as a just judge, eg John 5:30, where Jesus says, ‘My judgement is just because I seek not my own will but the will of him who sent me.’ / but some Christians then do not understand why God sends people to hell (Matthew 25:41: ‘Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels’), etc.
‘For Christians, it is impossible to understand the nature of God.’ -Disagree points
Arguments in support of other views
Others might argue that the universe exists / so the nature of whoever or whatever made it can be understood by looking at its complexity, design and beauty.
Some might use the cosmological argument to suggest that the universe shows a creator’s design and power in creating the universe out of nothing.
Some will argue that the oneness of God and the Trinity of Father, Son and Holy Spirit can be understood, but in a limited way / because God has to be incomprehensible in order to be God.
The nature of the Trinity is a spiritual truth, and not one of logic or science / it is not the meaningless joining up of three gods but the idea of three persons within the one nature of God / Christians can relate to the persons of Father, Son and Spirit.
The question of why an all-powerful and all-loving God allows evil to exist can be answered simply / without evil, there is no challenge – nothing to overcome – no reason to try to improve / Jesus spent his life showing his followers how to improve.
God’s nature as a just judge can be understood in a similar way / when Jesus warns his followers about hell (eg Matthew 25:31-46) he may be speaking figuratively – hell is people’s missed opportunities to do what is right.
Some might argue that it does not matter if a created being cannot understand the creator / an ant could hardly be expected to understand physics / equally a human cannot be expected to understand God, etc.
‘For Christians, what the Bible says about creation is true.’ -Agree points
Arguments in support
The Bible is the main source of Christian belief and teaching, so Christians should accept what itsays about creation as true / if they do not, then there would be no reason to accept anything the Bible says about any other belief or teaching.
The story of creation in Genesis 1:1-3 states that in the beginning God created the world formless, empty and dark, and that God then created light / God then made the world fit for life, including humans, who were created in God’s image / for many Christians this is a clear and reasonable account of the order and content of creation, so it is true.
Many Christians believe that God is all-powerful and all-knowing, so only God would be able to create the world. The creation story is therefore true.
Many Christians believe that the New Testament supports the Genesis creation story / John 1:1-3 refers to ‘the Word’, stating that (1) the Word existed in the beginning (2) the Word was with God (3) the Word was God / many Christians believe that the Word refers to Jesus / meaning that the Holy Trinity of Father, Son and Spirit was present at creation / Christians should therefore believe that the Trinity was present and active throughout creation.
Christians believe that the Bible is the inspired word of God / and that God is all-knowing and all-powerful, so cannot be wrong / Christians should therefore accept that what it says about creation is true.
Proof of the truth of what the Bible says about creation comes from 2 Timothy 3:16, which says that, ‘All scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching, reproof, correction, and for training in righteousness’ / meaning that the Bible can solve all arguments and disputes / it can establish the truth about everything it contains, including the creation of the world, etc.
‘For Christians, what the Bible says about creation is true.’ -Disgree points
Arguments in support of other views
Other Christians understand ‘truth’ in different ways / and some can be inspired by the Bible’s account of creation without believing it to be literally true / for example they might see the creation story as a poetic account of God’s creation of the world.
Some might argue that the creation story is not meant to be a scientific account of how the universe came into being / but is instead a statement of belief in a creator who designed it / it is meant to present spiritual truth rather than scientific facts.
Where 2 Timothy 3:16 says that all scripture is inspired by God / some would argue that ‘inspired’ does not mean ‘true’, but ‘inspirational’ / for example Christians might be inspired to look after God’s creation because Genesis 1:26-29 says that God made humans to be stewards of creation.
The biblical stories of creation might date to somewhere around 500 BCE – a time when knowledge about the universe and its origins was very limited / so some Christians today might argue that God created the universe through science, ie through the physics of the Big Bang / and that the Genesis creation accounts are stories meant to express God’s role as creator.
Some might argue that the Genesis creation accounts are inaccurate but are using well-known ideas and language to express belief in God as creator / the accounts are like Jesus’ parables in the New Testament / which are stories intended to illustrate important moral and religious ideas / so the creation stories contain religious ideas for Christians to think about and act upon / for example by looking after God’s world.
John 1:1-3 is one of the best-known parts of the Bible / some might say that it is ‘true’ religiously in what it says about God / it is using a different kind of language.
Some Christians believe that Genesis 1:1-3 cannot be literally true because it is a copy of parts of the Babylonian creation story / which is much older than Genesis / and includes similar accounts of creation, etc.
‘Belief in Jesus is all that Christians need to be saved from sin.’ -Agree points
Arguments in support
All that Christians need to do to be saved from sin is to believe in/have faith in Jesus / Paul talks about this in Romans 3–5 / everybody is saved who has faith in Jesus (3:20–26) / they are treated as righteous because they believe.
Christians are not justified by works (what they do) / nobody can earn righteousness and be saved / being saved from sin is not a matter of bargain or sale.
The sin of Adam and Eve separated humans from God / so that all humans inherit the original sin of Adam and Eve / Jesus atoned for the sins of humanity by his sacrifice on the cross / but this does not mean that people can earn a place in heaven by doing good works / because they will always fall short of the standard set by Jesus / however, God loves humanity, and salvation is offered as a gift.
Salvation comes through God’s grace and the Spirit / even though humans will always fall short of the standards set by Jesus / but Christians believe that grace is not earned but is given by the presence of the Holy Spirit in their hearts / and by this they will be saved.
Paul concludes that ‘All are justified freely by God’s grace through the redemption that came byJesus’, etc.
‘Belief in Jesus is all that Christians need to be saved from sin.’ -Disagree points
Arguments in support of other views
If belief and grace were everything needed for Christians to be saved from sin, then everybody would be saved / but the Bible makes it clear that this is not the case / the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats, for example, makes it clear that those who do not live by God’s commands will go to hell (Matthew 25:31–46) / to be saved, something more is needed.
Grace and Spirit are not themselves a certain way of being saved / good works are needed /meaning that Christians should obey God’s commands as well as they are able.
Since Christians can never be perfect, God’s grace is what allows them to be saved even when they have sinned / so long as they repent and try to follow God’s commands in the future.
If belief in Jesus were the only requirement for Christians to be saved / then they could break some or all of God’s commands and still go to heaven.
Christians therefore need both faith and works to be saved from sin / this is what the Letter of James says (2:14–26) / if a fellow human being lacks food or clothing and someone says they love them but they do not feed or clothe them, that is useless / faith without works is dead / just as a body without spirit is dead, faith without works is also dead.
Some Christians believe that baptism is needed to be saved from sin, etc.
‘The Resurrection of Jesus is the most important belief in Christianity.’ -Agree points
Arguments in support
Christians celebrate Easter because it celebrates Jesus’ resurrection from the dead / death is perhaps the most feared event for most humans, so if Jesus overcame death through being resurrected by God, then Christians have no need to fear death, making it the most important belief / all Christians therefore are given the hope of resurrection if they accept Jesus.
If Jesus was resurrected, this proves to his followers that he was the son of God / God’s son could survive death, bringing the promise of eternal life.
Resurrection saves Christians from their sins, because as St Paul says: ‘… I handed on to you as of first importance what I in turn had received: that Christ died for our sins in accordance with the scriptures.’ (1 Corinthians 15:3) / Paul goes on to list the reasons why he was sure of this, for example that Jesus’ burial and his being raised on the third day were in accordance with the scriptures / further, he appeared to Cephas and then to the twelve, then to more than 500 at one time, then to Paul himself / Paul is clear that for him, this is a proof of Jesus’ resurrection as the most important part of his own belief / because if there is no resurrection of the dead, then Christ has not been raised and his preaching and their faith are in vain (1 Corinthians 15:13-14).
Paul goes on to argue that if the resurrection is not true, then Jesus’ other promises are not true /‘If the dead are not raised, then Christ has not been raised / and if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile’ (because they are still in their sins) / moreover those who have died believing in Christ have simply ‘perished’. (1 Corinthians 15:16-18).
Without the resurrection there can be no Church / because the Church would have been founded on false beliefs / for example there can have been no ‘great commission’ before the Ascension, since Jesus would not have been alive to command it / in other words, if belief in Jesus’ resurrection is undermined, then Christianity as a whole is false / so Jesus’ resurrection is true.
If there is no resurrection, the human condition will remain such that there would be no vindication or hope for those who suffer from disease, famine, war or other evils / as the resurrection confirms the all-powerful nature of God / belief in Jesus’ resurrection is therefore justified on many different grounds, etc.
‘The Resurrection of Jesus is the most important belief in Christianity.’ -Disagree points
Arguments in support of other views
To be the most important Christian belief, belief in Jesus’ resurrection needs to be compared with other important beliefs / for example Jesus’ crucifixion / many Christians believe that during the crucifixion, Jesus suffered terrible pain and death / so that humans who suffer can take comfort in knowing that Jesus shared human pain / moreover without Jesus’ crucifixion there could have been no resurrection / Jesus was dead, so belief in the crucifixion as part of Jesus’ passion is as important as belief in the resurrection / they are two aspects of one event.
Some might view the belief that God created the world and how Jesus is sent into the world as the most important / as the Incarnation of God / and view his ongoing interaction with the world as proof of God’s immanence and love for creation as a more powerful belief / including how God sends the Holy Spirit at Pentecost.
Some might argue that Jesus’ miracles of healing and miracles over nature are the most important Christian belief, since they show that Jesus can heal the worst diseases of the body and mind / some might refer to Jesus’ raising from the dead of Jairus’ daughter and of Lazarus, proving his divine authority.
Others might argue that the main value of Christianity is in its moral teachings and not in its beliefs about the resurrection of Jesus / for example Jesus taught the Christian virtues of compassion and agapeic love for others / and these might be illustrated from his parables / for example the parable of the Good Samaritan, which illustrates how people should show love to everyone.
Some might therefore argue that the most important Christian belief is the Christian way of life / as opposed to any basic belief in Jesus’ resurrection / since Christian principles are important whether or not Jesus rose from the dead / faith must be accompanied by works (Paul).
Christians have different beliefs about whether resurrection would be of the body or the soul / such uncertainty might lead some to focus on Christian values and doing good actions than on this Christian belief.
Some might argue that ‘the most important Christian belief cannot be defined / or that Christian beliefs form an interlocking whole / in which the package of beliefs is more important than any single belief, etc.
‘The problem of evil and suffering means that God cannot be loving.’ - Agree points
Arguments in support
The argument from moral evil which suggests that a loving God would not allow moral evil (the evil that humans do to each other) to exist / especially as God is believed to be all-powerful so is able to prevent this type of evil / or could have created humans without the capacity to commit evil to one another.
The argument from natural evil, that evil is not caused by humans but part of the created world / which suggests that the existence of natural disasters, diseases, or other forms of suffering not caused by human action means God cannot be loving / as a loving God would prevent these from occurring or intervene to stop them / because a loving God would not create a world where such things could occur.
Some might argue that evil and suffering are God’s judgement on the world or on humans / due to the choices made by humans against God’s will / and this punishment is an act of God’s power, etc.
‘The problem of evil and suffering means that God cannot be loving.’ - Disagree points
Arguments in support of other views
The argument from free will / which suggests that the existence of evil and suffering is a necessary aspect of God’s loving gift to humankind of free-will / as if humans are truly free to make their own choices then some will inevitably choose to do evil / which therefore shows that the loving creation of free will for humans comes with the consequence of evil and suffering being possible.
Some Christians will believe that the existence of evil and suffering is a mystery / which cannot be fully understood as humans do not have the knowledge of God / and that although the existence of evil and suffering may be difficult for humans to reconcile with God being loving it does not necessarily mean that both cannot be concurrently true, as with God all things are possible.
Some Christians may refer to the account of Adam and Eve from the Book of Genesis / where evil and suffering enter into creation due to the fall of Adam / after Adam and Eve disobeyed God’s commandments to not eat of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil / making evil and suffering due to human sin / and due to the temptations of the Devil / and not due to a lack of God being loving.
Some Christians may refer to the concept of evil and suffering being necessary for spiritual development / also referred to as ‘soul-making’ / as humans need to experience evil and suffering in order to learn and develop / as such growth in goodness is not possible in a perfect world without trials and tribulation, etc.