1/21
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Week 10, Conspiracy Theories
How prevalent are conspiracy theories?
A lot of people believe – in Australia and overseas.
What are the consequences of conspiracy theories?
Higher support for violence Lower support this pro-climate policies Cybersecurity threats Risky health behaviours.
What are the differences between misinformation and disinformation?
Misinformation – incorrect or misleading info, unintentional errors communicated by unsuspecting persons Disinformation – deliberatively deceptive info.
What is the definition of conspiracy theory?
Actors typically attempt to usurp political or economic power, violate rights, infringe upon established agreements, withhold vital secrets, or alter bedrock institutions Beyond simple criminal conspiracies to rob a shop Not all are irrational
What are the critical ingredients to a conspiracy theory?
(1) Patterns – assume folks, object, or events are causally connected (2) Agency – conspirators are deliberate actors (3) Coalitions – group of actors working together (4) Threats – goals of conspirators are harmful or deceptive (5) Secrecy – conspiracy theories are hidden and difficult to disprove.
What are general vs. specific conspiracy theories?
General mindset → The government is involved in the murder of innocent citizens and/or well-known public figures, and keeps this a secret • New and advanced technology which would harm current industry is being suppressed
Specific beliefs → Global warming is a hoax. Senior federal government officials knew about the September 11th attacks before they happened.
What is the competing evolutionary hypothesis?
Conspiracy beliefs are by-product of other psychological processes that evolved for different reasons
What is the by-product hypothesis?
Epiphenomenon – due to our brains’ capacities for thinking, reasoning, and gossiping A by-product of various psychological mechanisms (e.g., pattern recognition, agency detection) working together, which originally evolved for different purposes.
What are some psychological processes associated with the by-products hypothesis?
Patterns Perception Agency detection Threat Management Alliance Detection.
Critique the by-product hypothesis
Given that according to this hypothesis, conspiracy beliefs by-products for these mechanisms with no functional or adaptive importance However, this is a contradiction, for the by-product hypothesis to be correct we have to assume that these conspiracies do not exist OR that they did not have significant selection pressure on our “evolutionary” ancestors But these conspiracies do exist and evidence from anthropology suggests that they have had significant selection pressure.
What is the adaptive-conspiracism hypothesis?
States that conspiracy theories is an adaptive mechanism of the human mind, as it allows for navigation of the social world for anticipates and overcome dangers. We are often biased toward making false positives when the cost of false negatives is high.
Error management theory?
What is error-management theory?
Over recognizing conspiracies is less costly when the dangers of the conspiracies are greater Actual conspiracies secretly plan to harm individuals, therefore failure to recognize or believe may lead to costs/death and folks err on the side of caution and believe May be an adaptive mechanism as early humans who were suspicious of conspiracies were more likely to reproduce
What are the assumptions of the model?
Like other evolutionary hypotheses, model does not posit that conspiracy theories are adaptive in modern day Conspiracy beliefs were adaptive in our ancestors, but may no longer be adaptive, and may even be maladaptive.
What are some underlying motivations behind conspiracy beliefs?
Epistemic needs → Conspiracy theories provide explanations that help folks in the face of uncertainty, Uncertainty increases CBs, CBs are correlated with perceiving patterns in randomness, need for cognitive closure, and seeking meaning
Existential → Conspiracy theories can help folks deal with threats to existential needs When we lack control, we may feel more in control if we believe conspiracy theories that offer better “accounts” than official narratives.
Social → Conspiracy theories may help folks maintain a positive self-image. Possess rare, important info that others do not have
What is the relationship between certain personality traits and conspiracy beliefs?
Research has presented mixed results for the relationships between general personality variables and belief in conspiracy theories Narcissism, Paranoia , schizotypy and pseudoscientific beliefs - increased Cognitive ability - protective factor
What are other correlates of believes in conspiracy theories?
Belief in one conspiracy theory relates to belief in others Political orientation correlations are mixed and depends on issue IQ not strongly correlated with believing in conspiracies
What is the relationship between conspiracy theories and entertainment? Describe the initial entertainment study?
van Prooijen et al. 2022 looked at the relationship between conspiracy theories and entertainment. In the first study - individuals read a text that is described as an election event that was manipulated to be neutral or entertaining. They rated entertainment value and emotions as well as conspiracy theory belief. They found that conspiracy theories were more entertaining
Describe the Jeffery Epstein entertainment study?
In the second study, individuals read about the reasons for Jeffrey Epstein death - he was murdered by powerful folks OR he committed suicide. They found that - Conspiracy text was rated as more entertaining in conspiracy (murder) than control (suicide) condition Participants felt more positive affect after conspiracy than control condition Participants felt more intense emotions after conspiracy than control condition Conspiracy beliefs were higher in conspiracy than control condition
What is the relationship between EVIL perceptions and conspiracy theories?
Harmon-Jones, Szymaniak, & Edgeworth, 2022 used the jeffery epstein study, with the addition of an evil perceptions measure (of the guards) to judge if the belief that individuals were evil increased the possiblity of believing in a conspiracy theory.
They found that evil perception influenced belief more than entertainment or conditions, suggesting a strong link.
How could you nudge individuals to share more accurate beliefs about conspiracy theories?
Pennycook et al. compared the effect of reminding individuals about the importance of accuracy before asking individuals to share news articles.
They found that —>
Participants were more likely to share true headlines relative to false headlines after they rated the accuracy of a single non-COVID-related headline
Nudging persons to think about accuracy improves choices about what to share.