1/53
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Three reasons a party may need to amend its statement of case
To add a party, to correct an error, or because its knowledge of the case has changed.
CPR Parts governing amendments to statements of case and changing parties
CPR Part 17 governs general amendments, and CPR Part 19 governs adding, removing, or substituting parties.
Rule requiring amendments to be verified by a statement of truth
CPR Part 22 requires amendments to be verified by a statement of truth unless the court orders otherwise.
Rule on amending a statement of case before it has been served (CPR 17.1(1))
A party may amend at any time without permission, subject to the rules on changing parties and the court's power to disallow under CPR 17.2.
Requirements for amending a statement of case after service (CPR 17.1(2))
The amendment requires either the written consent of all other parties or permission from the court.
Requirement of court permission to add, remove, or substitute a party (CPR 19.4(1))
Permission is required once the claim form has been served; no permission is needed before service.
Time limit and procedure to apply to disallow an amendment made without permission (CPR 17.2)
Any other party may apply to have the amendment disallowed within 14 days of service of the amended statement of case.
Procedure and documents required when applying for permission to amend (PD 17 para 1)
File an application notice accompanied by a copy of the statement of case showing the proposed amendments.
Deadline for filing and serving an amended statement of case after permission is granted
Within 14 days of the order (or as directed by the court), served with the order on every party.
General rule on who bears the costs of an amendment (PD 17)
The party applying to amend usually bears the costs of and arising from the amendment.
Required endorsement on a statement of case amended without permission (PD 17 para 2.1)
'Amended [Particulars of Claim / Defence] under CPR [17.1(1) or 17.1(2)(a)] dated [date]'.
Required endorsement on a statement of case amended with court permission (PD 17 para 2.1)
'Amended [Particulars of Claim] by order of [Master/District Judge/Judge] dated [date]'.
PD 17 requirements regarding text display and formatting of amendments
Original text need not be shown unless directed; if shown, amendments are marked by coloured text or numerical code, endorsed, and verified by a statement of truth.
Colour sequence for successive amendments to a statement of case (PD 17)
Red, then green, then violet, then yellow.
Balancing test applied by the court when deciding whether to allow an amendment
The court balances the injustice to the applicant if refused against injustice to the other party and other litigants if allowed, guided by the overriding objective.
Merit threshold required for any proposed amendment to be permitted
The proposed amendment must have a real prospect of success.
Examples of amendments the court is likely to refuse
Versions of facts that are inherently implausible, self-contradictory, or unsupported by evidence, or amendments sought close to trial causing unfairness.
Primary procedural risk and consequence of a late amendment application
It puts the trial date at risk and may cause the trial to be postponed or adjourned.
Significance of Swain-Mason v Mills & Reeve [2011] EWCA Civ 14
Key Court of Appeal authority establishing that courts should be less willing to allow very late amendments, placing a heavy onus on the applicant to justify delay with evidence.
Swain-Mason principle regarding defective formulations in late amendments
The proposed amendment must be properly formulated; the applicant cannot rely on curing deficiencies later by further information or evidence.
Significance of Quah Su-Ling v Goldman Sachs [2015] EWHC 759 (Comm)
Commercial Court authority reinforcing the heavy burden on an applicant seeking a late amendment and the strict approach to late applications putting trial dates at risk.
Usual consequence when a court allows a late amendment causing unfairness or extra burden to the opponent
Heavy costs consequences are ordered against the applicant.
Limit on the number of claimants or defendants joined to a claim under CPR 19.1
Any number of claimants or defendants may be joined to a single claim.
Governing rule containing the general test for adding, removing, or substituting a party
CPR 19.2 (or CPR 19.6 after the limitation period has expired).
Test under CPR 19.2(2) for adding a party to proceedings
Whether it is desirable to add the party so the court can resolve all matters in dispute, or an issue connected to the dispute involving the new party and an existing party.
Test under CPR 19.2(3) for removing a party from proceedings
Whether it is no longer desirable for that person to remain a party to the proceedings.
Test under CPR 19.2(4) for substituting a party in proceedings
Whether the existing party's interest or liability has passed to the new party, or substitution is desirable to resolve the matters in dispute.
Factors considered by the court when applying CPR 19.2 discretion
The parties' rights, who will be affected, the overriding objective, and the added complexity and case management burdens.
Factor considered by the court when deciding whether to allow an additional Part 20 claim
The status of the main claim, because allegations in the additional claim may affect main claim issues and leave a party exposed.
Risk to a claimant when an alleged wrongdoer is only a Part 20 defendant
The court can only give judgment for the claimant against defendants to the main claim; the claimant cannot recover directly from a Part 20 defendant.
Action a claimant must take to avoid non-recovery against a Part 20 defendant
Apply to the court under CPR 19.2(2)(b) to add the third party as a defendant to the main claim.
Rule regarding adding a person as a claimant without their consent (CPR 19.4(4))
No person may be added as a claimant without their signed written consent filed at court with the amended claim form.
Procedure when a person jointly entitled to a remedy refuses to be joined as a claimant (CPR 19.3(2))
The person must be made a defendant to the proceedings instead.
Court's general stance on adding new claims or parties after limitation has expired
The court is very strict; post-limitation additions are generally prohibited except under the limited exceptions in s 35 Limitation Act 1980, CPR 17.4, and CPR 19.6.
Statutory date of commencement for a new claim added by amendment (s 35(1) Limitation Act 1980)
It is treated as a separate action commenced on the same date as the original action.
Practical date when a newly added party becomes a party to proceedings
When the amended claim form is served on them, unless the court orders otherwise.
General prohibition in s 35(3) Limitation Act 1980 regarding post-limitation claims
The court will not allow a new claim to be made after the expiry of the limitation period, unless an express statutory or rule exception applies.
Three exceptions to the s 35 Limitation Act 1980 rule against post-limitation claims
Section 33 Limitation Act 1980 (personal injury claims), CPR 17.4 (amendments generally), and CPR 19.6 (adding or substituting parties).
Three circumstances where a new cause of action may be added after limitation has expired
Court direction under s 33 Limitation Act 1980, an original set-off or counterclaim, or where it arises out of the same or substantially the same facts under CPR 17.4(2).
Basis for court discretion to disapply limitation under s 33 Limitation Act 1980
The court has discretion to disapply the 3-year time limit where it is equitable to do so in personal injury or fatal accident claims.
Test under CPR 17.4(2) for allowing a new claim after the limitation period
The new claim must arise out of the same facts or substantially the same facts as a claim for which a remedy has already been claimed in the proceedings.
Party bearing the burden of proof under CPR 17.4(2)
The burden is on the applicant to establish that the new claim arises out of the same or substantially the same facts.
Distinction between adding a new duty versus clarifying an existing duty in post-limitation amendments
Adding a new duty or obligation usually constitutes a new cause of action, whereas adding facts to clarify an existing duty does not.
Procedural consequence of introducing a new distinct allegation after limitation expires
It amounts to a new cause of action (a new claim) and must be justified under CPR 17.4 and s 35 Limitation Act 1980.
Effect of an amendment pleading a further instance of an already alleged breach or a new remedy
It does not usually raise a new cause of action.
Scope of CPR 17.4(3) regarding post-limitation amendments
Correcting a genuine mistake in the name of a party, provided the mistake would not cause reasonable doubt as to the party's identity.
Scope of CPR 17.4(4) regarding post-limitation amendments
Altering the capacity in which a party claims, provided the new capacity was held when proceedings started or has since been acquired.
Civil Procedure Rule governing addition or substitution of a party after limitation
CPR 19.6 (previously CPR 19.5).
Conditions under CPR 19.6(2) for adding or substituting a party after limitation
The limitation period must have been current when proceedings started, and the addition or substitution must be necessary.
Circumstances where addition or substitution is 'necessary' under CPR 19.6(3)
The new party is substituted for a party named by mistake, the claim cannot properly proceed without them, or interest/liability passed on death or bankruptcy.
Distinction between mistake under CPR 17.4(3) and mistake under CPR 19.6(3)(a)
CPR 17.4(3) covers a mistake in name only (right entity, misnamed), whereas CPR 19.6(3)(a) covers a mistake in identity (an entirely different entity was named).
Practical example of a mistake falling under CPR 17.4(3)
A genuine misnaming causing no reasonable doubt, such as serving the correct intended defendant whose company name was slightly inaccurate.
Practical example of a mistake falling under CPR 19.6(3)(a)
Knowing the attributes of the intended defendant (e.g. employer or seller) but suing the wrong corporate entity within a group due to misinformation.
Test in The Sardinia Sulcis [1991] 1 Lloyd's Rep 201 for mistake as to identity
Whether the intended party was identified in the statement of case by a description specific to the case (e.g. 'the owner of the vessel'); if so, CPR 19.6(3)(a) applies.