1/244
Looks like no tags are added yet.
CHAPTER 9
Courts and Pretrial Processes
Does the United States have a single court system?
No. The U.S. has a series of court systems that deal with issues related to law.
What are the two types of court systems in the United States?
State courts and Federal courts
Which handles more offenders, state courts or federal courts?
State courts. They handle more than ten times the number of offenders compared to federal courts.
What kinds of crimes do federal courts handle?
A limited range of crimes, such as drug smuggling.
Jurisdiction
The range of a court's authority.
What are the three broad categories of state courts?
1. Courts of "Limited" jurisdiction
2. Courts of "General" jurisdiction
3. Court of Appeals
What are some names for state courts of LIMITED jurisdiction?
Many local names, such as Municipal Courts, County Courts, and District Courts.
What do state courts of LIMITED jurisdiction typically have authority over?
Misdemeanors, and they conduct preliminary investigation of felony charges.
What is the caseload of state courts of limited jurisdiction?
They do the bulk of case work:
- About 65% of cases go into these courts
- About 60 million cases a year
Which model of justice are state courts of limited jurisdiction noted for?
The Crime Control Model
What are some other names for state courts of GENERAL jurisdiction?
Felony courts, superior courts, supreme courts, or circuit courts.
What cases do state courts of GENERAL jurisdiction handle?
The most serious felony cases and civil cases.
What is a state's "Court of Last Resort"?
Each state has one. It is most often called a State Supreme Court. Some states have a separate court of last resort for civil and criminal cases.
Wisconsin Supreme Court: how many justices and how long are their terms?
7 justices
10-year terms
Wisconsin Court of Appeals: how many judges, how many districts, and how long are their terms?
16 judges in 4 districts
6-year terms
Wisconsin Circuit Courts: how many judges and how long are their terms?
249 judges (at least 1 per county)
6-year terms
List Wisconsin's court structure from highest to lowest.
1. Supreme Court
2. Court of Appeals
3. Circuit Courts
4. Municipal Courts
What do federal courts have authority over?
- Violations of federal criminal statutes
- Civil suits between citizens of different states
- Civil suits between a citizen and an agency of the federal government
What is the federal court hierarchy, from lowest to highest?
1. District Courts (lowest)
2. Circuit Appeals Courts
3. Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS)
What is the role of Federal District Courts?
They are the trial courts of the federal system. They hear all trial cases, both civil and criminal.
How many Federal District Courts are there, and how many does each state have?
94 Federal District Courts in total
Each state has between 1 and 4
What do Federal Appeals Courts do?
They review federal and state cases based on appeals. They focus on judicial interpretation of law and procedure of law.
Do federal Appeals Courts hold trials or decide guilt/innocence?
No. They DO NOT hold trials or determine guilt or innocence.
How many federal Courts of Appeals are there?
13 (but there are many judges within those courts)
Which federal circuit is Wisconsin in?
The 7th Circuit
Describe the makeup of SCOTUS (Supreme Court of the United States).
- Highest court in the U.S.
- 9 members
- Appointed to life terms by the president, confirmed by the Senate
- 1 serves as Chief Justice
How does SCOTUS choose its cases?
It gets to choose its cases (almost unlimited jurisdiction).
How many cases does SCOTUS hear, and how many get full briefs?
Hears 300-5000 cases
Only about half (150-2500) get full briefs
What is the most important thing SCOTUS does?
It interprets the Constitution, determining what the "Supreme Law of the Land" says.
Why do SCOTUS cases matter so much?
They have serious ramifications and shape the future of the rights, liberties, and duties of U.S. citizens.
What problems leave the state court systems overburdened?
- Huge caseloads
- Inadequate resources
- Uneven and ineffective judges
- Local political interests often prevent reform
- Diminishing budgets, leading to furloughs and fewer court sessions
Historically, who has become a judge, and what are the job's perks and downsides?
Historically white men with political connections.
It offers high status but low pay (compared to what lawyers can make).
What are the demographics of state judges today?
- Women: 30 to 35 percent of many state judges
- African American: only 7 percent of state trial judges
- Latino: 4 percent
What are the three additional major roles of a judge (beyond presiding over trials)?
1. Adjudicator
2. Negotiator
3. Administrator
Judge's role: Adjudicator
Acts as an unbiased referee between the prosecution and the defense.
Judge's role: Negotiator
Oversees arguments between prosecutors and defense attorneys about plea bargains, sentencing, and bail.
Judge's role: Administrator
Manages the courthouse, such as its records, schedules, and even budgets.
What are the four ways to select judges?
1. Election
2. Gubernatorial appointment
3. Legislative selection
4. Merit selection
Judge selection by Election: partisan vs. non-partisan
Partisan: candidates share a political party
Non-partisan: they do not
Judge selection: Gubernatorial appointment
The governor selects someone from a list.
Judge selection: Legislative selection
A governing body is responsible for selecting the judge.
Judge selection: Merit selection
People are picked based on their experience.
Which amendments require due process for all accused?
The 5th and 14th Amendments
Do most cases go to trial?
No. Only a small percentage of cases go to trial. States are meant to move defendants through or filter them out.
What is bail's purpose, and what is the bail system based on?
Bail is pretrial release. It is based on:
- the seriousness of the crime
- the defendant's record
- the recommendations of the prosecutor
Is there a right to bail?
No, there is no right to bail.
When does pretrial detention happen?
If bail cannot be met or if the judge denies bail.
How many people are in American jails on most days, and what share has not been convicted?
About 700,000 people
About 69% are not convicted and are awaiting bond/trial. The remainder are serving a period of incarceration.
What are the experiences of individuals in jail?
- Can be a traumatic experience
- Conditions are often worse than prison conditions
- Can last a significant time (some felony defendants wait more than a year for trial)
Jurisdiction
The geographic territory or legal boundaries within which control may be exercised; the range of a court’s authority.
Trial courts of limited jurisdiction
Criminal courts with trial jurisdiction over misdemeanor cases and preliminary matters in felony cases. Sometimes these court hold felony trials that may result in penalties below a specified limit
Trial courts of general jurisdiction
Criminal courts with jurisdiction over all offenses, including felonies. In some states, these courts also hear appeals
Appellate (appeals) courts
Courts that do not try criminal cases but hear appeals of decisions of lower courts
Drug courts
Specialized courts that impose drug testing and counseling requirements on substance abusers and monitor their progress instead of sending them immediately to jail or prison
Nonpartisan election
An election in which candidates’ party affiliations are not listed on the ballot
Partisan election
An election in which candidates openly endorsed by political parties are presented to voters for selection
Adversarial system
Basis of the American legal system in which a passive judge and jury seek to find the truth by listening to opposing attorneys who vigorously advocate on behalf if the respective sides
Inquisitorial system
Basis of legal system in Europe in which the judge takes an active role in investigating the case and asking questions of witnesses in court
Merit selection
A reform plan by which judges are nominated by a commission and appointed by the govenor for a given period.
When the term expires, the voters are asked to approve or disapprove the judge for a succeeding term. If the judge is disapproved, the committee nominates a successor for the governor’s appointment
Arraignment
The court appearance of an accused person in which the charges are read and the accused, advised by a lawyer, pleads guilty or not guilty
Motion
An application to a court requesting that an order be issued to bring about a specified action
Bail
An amount of money specified by a judge to be paid as a condition of pretrial release to ensure that the accused will appear in court as required
Citation
A written order or summons, issued by a law enforcement officer, often directing an alleged offender to appear in court at a specified time to answer a criminal charge
Release on Recognizance (ROR)
Pretrial release granted on the defendant’s promise to appear in court, because the judge believes that the defendant’s ties in the community grantee that he or she will appear
Preventive detention
Holding a defendant for trial, based on a judge’s finding that, if the defendant were released on bail, he or she would flee or would endanger another person or the community
United States v. Salerno and Cafero (1987)
The preventive detention provisions of the Bail Reform Act of 1984 and are upheld as a legitimate use of government power designed to prevent people from committing crimes while on bail
CHAPTER 10
Prosecution and Defense
How long are prosecutors' terms in most states?
Prosecutors are elected to a four-year term in most states.
How does politics affect prosecutors?
Political influence can affect elections, and prosecutors act politically because of their discretionary power.
Who do prosecutors interact with, and are their decisions public?
They interact with all players in the system. Decisions are made out of public view, but public opinion can influence them. No laws govern their decisions.
What determines the burden of proof?
It depends on the court you are in (criminal vs. civil).
Burden of proof in CRIMINAL court
Beyond a reasonable doubt
Burden of proof in CIVIL court
Preponderance of evidence
What are the prosecutor's four roles?
1. Trial counsel for the police
2. House counsel for the police
3. Representative of the court
4. Elected official
How does a prosecutor influence the system?
- Chooses the cases to be prosecuted
- Selects the charges to be brought
- Recommends the bail amount
- Influences the judge's decisions
What are examples of prosecutorial discretion?
- Many arrests do not result in formal charges
- Multiple charges
- Charge reduction
- Nolle prosequi
- Discovery
Nolle prosequi
A prosecutor's decision to drop the charges and not pursue the case.
Discovery
A prosecutor's pretrial disclosure, to the defense, of facts and evidence to be introduced at trial.
What factors go into the decision to prosecute?
- Seriousness of the offense
- Strength of the case
- Witnesses and victims
- Community values
- Sentencing history of the judge
- Workload of the system
What is the key concern in the decision to prosecute?
Convictability. Prosecutors want cases they can win.
What do prosecutors depend on the police for?
1. Suspects
2. Evidence
Why do the police control the first step of a case?
Prosecutors do not investigate. Police may have various reasons for pursuing a case or not, including protecting their clearance rate. There has been a call for greater police/prosecution cooperation.
Who decides to press charges, and why do victims and witnesses matter?
The prosecutor decides. But it is difficult to do so without support from victims/witnesses, and there are many reasons someone might not cooperate.
What do prosecutors know about judges?
They know which judges are harsh and who is likely to accept a plea deal.
How does the community relate to the prosecutor?
The public pays relatively little attention to the criminal justice system, and crimes vary depending on location. Example: a community might not see gambling as that severe.
What do prosecutors' decision-making policies cover?
How they evaluate evidence and decide what to charge someone with.
What are the three policy models for prosecutorial case management?
1. Legal sufficiency
2. System sufficiency
3. Trial sufficiency
Legal sufficiency
Is there enough evidence to prosecute?
System sufficiency
Can the case be quickly and efficiently disposed of?
Trial sufficiency
Is there enough evidence to ensure conviction?
What is the defense attorney's duty?
To protect constitutional rights, not to "save criminals."
What is the reality of defense attorney work?
- Preparing clients for the likelihood of conviction
- Serving as advocates for the accused
- Challenging points made by the prosecution and advising the client
Why is the defense attorney's relationship with the client important?
It is crucial. Both defendants and the public may not understand the defense attorney's role.
Which case gave poor people facing jail the right to an attorney, and what problem remains?
Gideon v. Wainwright (right to an attorney since the 1960s)
Excessive caseloads are a significant problem.
What are the three types of counsel for indigents?
1. Assigned counsel
2. Contract counsel
3. Public defender
Assigned counsel
A private-practice attorney represents the indigent (paid by the state).
Contract counsel
A private attorney contracts with the government to represent indigents for a period of time.
Public defender
The government hires a full-time, salaried attorney to represent indigents.
United States attorneys
Officials responsible for the prosecution of crimes that violate the law of the United States; appointed by the president and assigned to a U.S. district court jurisdiction