1/14
A set of vocabulary flashcards covering key definitions, principles of statutory interpretation, theories of the Rule of Law, and constitutional concepts from Dr Marinos Diamantides's lecture.
Rule of Law (RoL)
An ideal of political morality referring to the importance and ascendancy of law and legal institutions in a system of governance.
Separation of Powers (SoP)
An ideal pattern of governance where government responsibilities are separated into three different branches—the legislative, the executive, and the judiciary—to stave off the concentration of power, prevent abuse of power, and diversify liabilities.
Constitutional Reform Act 2005
A UK statute that reinforced the separation of powers by reforming the office of the Lord Chancellor, establishing the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom (UKSC), and legally protecting judicial independence.
Literal Rule
A principle of statutory interpretation holding that if the words of an Act are clear, the court must follow them even if they lead to manifest absurdity.
Golden Rule
A principle of statutory interpretation providing that if a literal reading leads to an absurdity, the court should examine the context in which the provision was passed to achieve a more sensible application.
Mischief Rule
A principle of statutory interpretation requiring the court to determine what defect in the old law the statute intended to remove and construe the provision to minimise the possibility of that defect reoccurring.
Purposive Interpretation
An interpretative technique where a judge tries to fill gaps between a statute and the facts by imagining what the framers would have done; common in continental Europe and the USA, but considered an affront to Parliamentary Sovereignty in the UK.
Judicial Activism
A judicial philosophy according to which courts can and should go beyond the applicable law to consider the broader societal implications of their decisions, pejoratively termed 'judicial supremacism' by opponents.
Judicial Restraint (Deference)
The judicial philosophy opposite to activism, where the courts defer to political branches, especially regarding political questions or matters deemed more appropriate for Parliament or the executive.
Formal (or 'Content-Free') Theories of the RoL
Theories of the Rule of Law that focus strictly on the form of the law and the procedures by which it is made rather than its content, equating the Rule of Law with the principle of legality or 'Rule by Law.'
Substantive (or 'Content-Rich') Theories of the RoL
Theories derived from the natural law tradition asserting that laws are only binding if they align with specific moral and political ideals, such as democracy, fairness, human dignity, and social justice.
A.V. Dicey's Definition of the Rule of Law
The classic doctrine stating that no person is punishable or can be lawfully made to suffer in body or goods except for a distinct breach of law established in the ordinary legal manner before the ordinary courts of the land.
Hansard
The official parliamentary record which, following Pepper v Hart (1993), may be introduced in court to show ministerial explanations of what a statutory provision was intended to achieve.
Declaration of Incompatibility
A formal ruling under section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998 issued when primary UK legislation is found to violate European Convention on Human Rights rights, leaving the validity and operation of the statute intact.
Belmarsh 9 Case (A and others v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2004])
A landmark case where the House of Lords held that the indefinite detention of foreign terrorist suspects under the ATCSA 2001 disproportionately discriminated against foreign nationals contrary to Article 14 ECHR, prompting a section 4 declaration of incompatibility.