1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the core argument of strain theories, and how does Merton (1938) develop this from Durkheim's concept of anomie?
→ Strain theories argue that people engage in deviant behaviour when they are unable to achieve socially approved goals by legitimate means, such as becoming frustrated and resorting to criminal means, lashing out in anger, or turning to drug use for comfort.
→ Merton (1938) developed the first strain theory by adapting Durkheim's concept of anomie to explain deviance.
What two elements does Merton combine in his explanation of deviance, and what strain lies at the heart of his theory?
→ Structural factors: society's unequal opportunity structure.
→ Cultural factors: a strong emphasis on success goals and a weaker emphasis on using legitimate means to achieve them.
→ For Merton, deviance results from a strain between the goals that a culture encourages individuals to achieve and what the institutional structure of society allows them to achieve legitimately.
→ For example, American culture values 'money success' (individual material wealth and the high status that goes with it).
What legitimate means and meritocratic ideology are associated with the 'American Dream', and how does reality differ for disadvantaged groups?
→ Americans are expected to pursue 'money success' through legitimate means such as self-discipline, study, educational qualifications, and hard work in a career.
→ The ideology of the 'American Dream' portrays society as meritocratic, where anyone who puts in the effort can get ahead because opportunities are open to all.
→ In reality, disadvantaged groups face blocked legitimate opportunities, such as poverty, inadequate schools, and discrimination in the job market affecting many minority ethnic groups and the lower classes.
How does Merton explain the 'strain to anomie', and why does he argue the pressure to deviate is intensified?
→ Frustration caused by the strain between the cultural goal of money success and limited legitimate opportunities creates pressure to resort to illegitimate means like crime and deviance, which Merton calls the 'strain to anomie'.
→ This pressure to deviate is intensified because American culture prioritises achieving success at any price over using legitimate means.
→ In summary, cultural goals generate the desire to succeed, blocked opportunities create pressure toward illegitimate means, and weak norms fail to stop some people from giving in to temptation.
How does Merton explain different adaptations to strain, and what are Conformity and Innovation?
→ Merton argues that an individual's position in the social structure shapes how they adapt to the strain to anomie across five adaptations, depending on whether they accept, reject, or replace approved cultural goals and legitimate means.
→ Conformity: individuals accept culturally approved goals and pursue them legitimately (most likely among middle-class people with good opportunities, though Merton views it as typical of most Americans).
→ Innovation: individuals accept the goal of money success but use 'new', illegitimate means such as theft or fraud to achieve it (greatest pressure falls on those at the lower end of the class structure).
What are Ritualism, Retreatism, and Rebellion in Merton's typology of adaptations?
→ Ritualism: individuals give up on achieving the goals but have internalised the legitimate means, following the rules for their own sake (typical of lower-middle class office workers in dead-end, routine jobs).
→ Retreatism: individuals reject both the goals and the legitimate means and become dropouts (Merton lists 'psychotics, outcasts, vagrants, tramps, chronic drunkards and drug addicts' as examples).
→ Rebellion: individuals reject existing society's goals and means and replace them with new ones to bring about revolutionary change and a new kind of society (including political radicals and counter-cultures such as hippies).
What are the key strengths of Merton's strain theory?
→ Merton shows how both normal and deviant behaviour can arise from the same mainstream goals, as both conformists and innovators pursue 'money success' (one legitimately, the other illegitimately).
→ He explains key patterns in official crime statistics: most crime is property crime because American society values material wealth so highly, and lower-class crime rates are higher because they have the least opportunity to obtain wealth legitimately.
What are the main criticisms of Merton's strain theory regarding official statistics, determinism, and ruling-class power?
→ Merton takes official crime statistics at face value, which over-represent working-class crime and lead him to see crime as mainly a working-class phenomenon.
→ The theory is too deterministic: although the working class experience the most strain, they do not all deviate.
→ Marxists argue that Merton ignores the power of the ruling class to make and enforce laws in ways that criminalise the poor while protecting the rich.
What further criticisms challenge Merton's assumptions about value consensus, non-utilitarian crime, and group deviance?
→ Merton assumes there is a value consensus where everyone strives for 'money success', ignoring the possibility that many people may not share this goal.
→ His theory only accounts for utilitarian crime for monetary gain, failing to explain crimes such as violence, vandalism, or state crimes like genocide and torture.
→ He explains deviance as individuals adapting to the strain to anomie, ignoring the role of group deviance such as delinquent subcultures.