1/28
Looks like no tags are added yet.
nature role in language development
developmental language disorder
developmental language disorder
Used to be called Specific Language Impairment (SLI)
Affects childrens ability to acquire lang despite normal cog and emotional development - dont behave or look dif to anyone else
Struggle to use/understand/produce lang - difficulties using vocab and grammar
Impacts are consistent + impact everyday communication, academic settings + social interactions
Identified when children start school - not noticed when infants
Dif from other lang/developmental disorders, eg dyslexia, autism etc
1 out of 15 children has DLD in the UK (Norbury et al., 2016)
Tend to be more prevalent in boys than girls
example of dld
At a young age made lots of sounds but not actual words
Relied on symbols and pictures to communicate
Lang helped by songs and familiar stories
Music and acting helped
Not incurable
Helped by intense speech therapy - need lots of training to achieve fluency in first lang
transmission of dld
suggested to run in families
proband-wise concordance - Statistical measure used in genetics to measure how frequently a particular trait/disorder is shared between two people when one of them has a disorder
Concordance is quite high - suggests a genetic role
Does that mean there is a language gene

KE family
Black shapes represent persons with some forms of DLD.
Circles represent females, and squares represent males
37 members measure across three generations
15 had DLD - suggests DLD is heritable
Initially failed to identify a gene in this family - could be due to having too many genes to look at

genetics and dld
Boy with DLD - not a member of KE family
Had a clear defect on chromosome 7
FOXP2 correlated with DLD
Then looked back at KE family - found to have defective FOXP2 as well
media frenzy
Journalists quickly dubbed FOXP2 “the language gene” or the “grammar gene”.
Suggested if didn’t have this gene, then wouldn't be able to acquire any human languages
Latest DLD development
Reality is much more complex…
No single gene for Developmental Language Disorder - KE family is perhaps an exception, not the case that everyone with DLD has a defective FOXP2
Instead, DLD is polygenic and complex trait associated with many, many genetic variants (each common across the population), each of tiny effect size
Newbury, D. F., & Monaco, A. P. (2010)
summary of nature
DLD has a heritable biological basis. - tends to run in families
Language: has a nature component. - in general complex interaction between genes and environmental factors
However, there isn’t a language gene
Genes obviously matter! - Only humans seem to be able to acquire human languages
So must be something special with human genes that makes human lang acquisition possible
Nurture
Nurture DEFINITELY plays a role in language acquisition.
Otherwise, every child would be speaking the same language!!
Suggests social exposure crucial in shaping lang development
Is there a time period where nurture has to take place?
what does vision tell us about development
Not something we are born fully equipped with
Brain must learn to interpret and understand visual info
Learning occurs most effectively at a specific time in early childhood (critical period)
First few years of life - brain is highly sensitive to visual input. Adequate stimulation strengthens neural pathways
So if deprived of visual input at an early age, brains visual pathways will weaken, leading to lasting difficulties in perceiving shapes and colours
Need to receive lots of visual info so pathways get trained
eye patches
Eye patch - forces weaker eye to work harder and strengthen pathway - missing this critical period would result in one eye being impacted - could lead to long lasting visual impairments
Highlights importance of a visually stimulating environment
Idea of critical period in vision has been extended to lang
Critical period hypothesis
A longstanding debate over the extent to which our ability to master a language is linked to our biological age
If a person does not receive language input during this window, the individual will never achieve a full command of language
Most psycholinguists agree there is an optimal period in lang acquisition, however we are unsure as to how wide this window is
genie
Total isolation since birth, up till 13 years old
Deprived of social and linguistic input since 20 months
Lived in a cage
Has genie lost her chance to learn language forever
Spent over a decade helping genie to acquire lang - trained linguists and psychologists helped with this
Exposed to many training sessions
Government funding eventually cut, returned to mother but couldn't take care of her. Moved from dif foster homes, neglected further
how much language did she manage to learn
Never achieved language proficiency of someone raised in a typical environment
phonology not the sane
semantics
morphosyntax
genie phonology
did not become native-like, voice remained high-pitched and soft.
After training become somewhat louder, lower and clearer (still retained some high + soft pitch).
Ability to articulate words improved but consistently removed/substituted words - made it hard to understand.
Genie seemed to be unaware of her pronunciation issues - couldn't self correct very well. Added another layer of complexity
genie semantics
little difficulty learning hundreds of words. speed at which she learnt words exceeded all expectations -
after 2 years could accurately name most objects she encountered
genie morphosyntax
faced sig challenges when using grammar
Genie full stomach
Father fake piece wood. Hit. Cry.
Want milk.
Genie bad cold live father house.
Suggests inconsistency in ability to apply grammatical rules, grammar very limited and far from being native like
what does this suggest
Critical period for mastering sentence structure etc might have passed before the age of 13
Critical period hypothesis - what does genie tell us
Genie = extreme case - confounding factors
Need to consider language difficulties in the context of severe neglect. isolation at a young age affected lang, intellectual and emotional development. Confounding factors that make it dif to draw firm conclusions that her lang difficulties are solely due to the absence of early linguistic input
Less extreme cases
Deaf children: Newport (1990)
Is there a critical period for first lang acquisition
Native ASL Signers - learned from birth by their deaf signing parents
First exposed to ASL between 4 and 6 - not exposed to sign lang, born to speaking parents
Late learners (12+)
Measure grammatical knowledge of american sign language
results
Basic grammar - eg i love you
Basic grammar was a high level across all groups
Complex grammar
Eg Verb agreement production - eg i wish vs he wishes (need s/dont)
Native speakers able to produce complex grammar very accurately, 4-6 okay but not as good, late learners struggle with all forms of complex grammar measured in study
So critical period for learning complex grammar may end relatively early

what does this suggest
All the studies discussed thus far are concerned with native language (L1)
The learning of complex grammar in L1 may have a relatively small window. By 3-4 need to be exposed to complex grammar to achieve native like proficiency
Semantics doesn’t seem to be hugely affected by the age of acquisition. Can still learn new words and communicate with people. Dif aspects of lang have dif windows in opportunity

Johnson & Newport (1989) - grammar and critical periods in an L2
Grammaticality judgments
*Every Friday our neighbor wash her car.
*Two mouses ran into the house this morning.
*The horse jumped the fence over this morning.
Judge whether sentences are correct or incorrect
Compared proficiency of 46 adult Korean/Chinese participants who live in the US. arrived as child or adult. Arrived at dif ages
Clear and strong advantage for those who arrived in the us at a younger age - age 3-7 could achieve same proficiency as native speakers
Evident across all kind of grammatical structures
Those who arrived later - lots more variation compared to those who arrived early
Flege et al. (1999) - accent and grammar
240 native speakers of Koreans who moved to the US at different ages. Also native english speakers as control pps
Read aloud some English text.
Rated by native speakers of English (not part of control group)
Accent rating
As age of arrival increases, accent becomes less native like
Need to arrive in us before age of 10 to sound native
Grammaticality judgements
Later they arrived, lower their score
If arrive before 16 can acquire same proficiency of native english speaker
what do these results suggest
Seems to be a critical period of second lang acquisition - how wide that window is likely depends on what aspect of language is being looked at
Hartshorne et al. (2018)
Grammaticality judgements (95 sentences)
669,498 participants!
Monolinguals, simultaneous bilinguals (exposed to two lang from birth or before age 3), late bilinguals, late learners
Immersion vs. non-immersion learners (immersed in lang vs solely taught in the home)
Can a person achieve native-like fluency in an L2 before a certain age? (Werker & Hensch, 2015)
Study looks at whether there are neurobiological basis for critical periods
Linguistic distance
Spanish vs. Portuguese
Danish vs. Swedish vs. Norwegian
Japanese vs. English
Arabic vs. Russian
Easier to learn an L2 with smaller linguistic distance