1/5
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the primary sociological diagnosis of post-apartheid inequality in South Africa?
Core Concept: Colonial/apartheid inequality is a structural disease, not just a historical memory.
Key Symbol: Rhodes Must Fall—demanding removal of systemic structures, not just statues.
Key Stats for PEEL Evidence:
White income = 5x Black income on average.
Gini Coefficient = ~63% (world's most unequal)
Distinguish between Sufficientarianism and Limitarianism.
Sufficientarianism: Focuses on a poverty floor. Everyone needs "enough" to flourish; gaps above that don't matter morally.
Limitarianism (Ingrid Robeyns): Focuses on a wealth ceiling ("riches line"). It is morally wrong to hold excess resources.
Key Term: Surplus Money = Any wealth held above the flourishing threshold
What is Robeyns' "Unmet Urgent Needs" argument for Limitarianism?
The Idea: Surplus money has zero moral value to the ultra-rich, but huge value to society.
3 Problems Surplus Money Should Fund:
Extreme poverty.
Deprivations of flourishing.
Collective action crises (e.g., climate change).
How does extreme wealth destroy democracy? (Christiano's 4 Mechanisms
Core Idea: Concentrated wealth turns political equality into oligarchy.
4 Mechanisms to Memorize:
Money for Votes: Funding political parties/campaigns.
Gatekeeping: Setting the political agenda.
Opinion Shaping: Controlling media & lobbying.
Independent Power: Threatening capital flight to stop regulations
What are the main objections to Strong Limitarianism, and how are they resolved?
Strong Limitarianism: 100% tax above riches line.
The Problem: Kills work incentives and philanthropy.
The Solution (Volacu & Dumitru): Weak Limitarianism—use an optimal ~70% tax rate to maximize revenue without destroying the economy.
How does Frank A. Abumere critique Robeyns and expand Limitarianism?
The Flaw: Robeyns bases her argument on protecting democracy. Non-democratic regimes (like Apartheid SA) can claim it doesn't apply to them.
Abumere's Asymmetric Argument: Surplus money causes structural and systemic injustice in any regime, democratic or not.
Takeaway: Limitarianism is a universal tool to fix colonial/apartheid legacy disparities.