1/60
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Resources consumed to produce goods and services:
-direct medical
-direct non-medical
-indirect
-intangible
-opportunity
Direct Medical Costs
Costs incurred to provide medical goods and services
Direct Medical Costs examples
-Pharmaceuticals
-Diagnostic tests
-Physician visits
-Pharmacist visits
-Emergency department visits
-Hospitalization
-Patient counseling and consultations
-Home medical visits
-Nursing services
-Medication administration
Direct Nonmedical Costs
To the patient and the family
Direct Nonmedical Costs examples
-Travel costs
-Nonmedical assistance (homecare services)
-Hotel expenses- patients and caregivers-out of town care
-Childcare services
Indirect Cost
-Costs incurred that are due to morbidity or mortality of the disease
-Usually considered in a societal perspective
-Difficult to capture and assign a value
Indirect Cost examples
-lost productivity
-decreased earnings over a lifetime
-lost earnings due to premature death
Intangible Costs
Costs resulting from not so obvious factors
-Usually considered in a societal or patient perspective.
-Difficult to assess and assign avalue
Intangible Costs examples
psychological factors such asstress, pain, fear, suffering, etc
Alternative Methods of Categorization of Cost
-Health care sector costs
-Other sector costs
-Patient and family
-Productivity cost
Incremental costs
Additional costs incurred to obtain an additional unit of benefit compared to an alternative intervention
-Extra cost to purchase an additional effect.
-Different than marginal cost because it looks at additional cost to switch to better therapy
Marginal costs
additional costs for next unit of the same intervention
Two steps in measuring costs:
-Identify all resources used in the activity
-Assignment of the dollar value on the resources (associated costs)
Possible vehicles for resource use data:
-RCTs
-Observational studies
-Literature
-Administrative databases
-Expert opinion
Best source of data depends on:
-Study question
-Research resources
Cost Centers
-Drug costs
-Hospital costs
-Other institutional costs
-Labor costs
-Costs borne by patients and families
Drug Costs
-Usually these are the direct costs of obtaining and administering drugs
-Administration typically is measured using time and motion (TAM) methods
Time and Motion (TAM) methods
-The end product is a flowchart of the process including all drug preparation and administration steps and associated times required for each step
-If overlap with other duties occur (joint production) allocate time spent to both tasks
-Use hourly wage to calculate administration costs
Drug acquisition
-Costs (resource consumption) versus charges (patient bills used as a proxy for costs)
-Average wholesale price (AWP)
-Hospital acquisition costs
-Pharmacy prices
Hospital Costs
-Use of TAM for hospital care (for nurses)
-Per diem
-Disease-specific per diem
-Diagnosis-related group (DRGs)
-Micro-costing
Physician Costs
-Physician fees may be used if they bill separately for services
-Problem with variation in fees based on patient group
-TAM may be used for salaried physicians
Other Medical Costs
-Nursing home or home health care
-Difficult to assess compared to hospitals
-When both private and public sectors are purchasers, often the public sector defines the costs(I.e. DRGs)
Patient and Family Costs
-Transportation
-Time
Valuation
-Market prices (e.g. wage rates) are usedunless strong belief they do not reflect opportunity cost (e.g. volunteers).
-Local currencies vs international currency.
-Adjustments for price inflation.
Calculation
Multiply unit of measurement by unit cost (e.g. 8 hours of time at $ 25 per 200 labor cost).
Discounting
𝑃𝑉 = 𝐹𝐶/(1 + 𝑟)𝑛
Patient Reported Outcomes(PRO)
-a direct subjective assessment by patients about aspects of their health
-Symptoms, emotional well-being, quality of life,and satisfaction with treatment
PROs ask patients to evaluate:
the impact and functional implications of the disease or treatment to reflect their interpretation of the experience,which is influenced by their internal standards, intrinsic values, and expectations.
Patient Satisfaction
-Patient satisfaction is an important and commonly used indicator for measuring the quality of health care.
-Patient satisfaction affects clinical outcomes, patient retention, and medical malpractice claims. It affects the timely, efficient, and patient-centered delivery of quality health care.
General Patient Satisfaction Dimensions
-Access to care
-Interpersonal skills of provider and staff
-Physical environment
-Technical quality
Quality of life (QoL)
-Broad concept with many aspects
-Measures people's overall perceptionof their life
-Includes both health-related and non-health-related aspects of people's lives
-Economical, political, cultural
Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQoL)
-Part of a person's overall QoL
-"Represents the functional effect of an illness and its consequent therapy upon a patient, as perceived by the patient"
-QoL and HRQoL are used in health-related research and articles interchangeably
The FDA guidance on PRO instrument development steps:
-Identify the concepts and develop conceptual framework
-Create an instrument
-Assess the measurement properties
-Modify the instrument
Identify the concepts and develop conceptual framework:
-Target population and research question
-Hypothesize expected relationships among concepts
Create an instrument:
-Administration method, recall period, and response scales
-Instructions
-Format instrument
-Procedures for scoring and administration
-Pilot test and refine instrument
Assess the measurement properties:
-Evaluate administrative respondent burden
-Revise items
-Identify meaningful differences in score
-Finalize instrument formats
Modify the instrument:
Change concepts measured, populations studied, research application, instruction or method of administration
Health Status Measures
Measures a patient's own view of their health (self-reported)
Health Status Measures (HRQoL)
-Multidimensional concept that focuses on the impact of disease and its treatment on the well-being of an individual
-Measures a patient's own view of their health (self-reported)
Generic/general instruments for HRQoL
-These instruments can be used with any population.They generally cover perceptions on overallhealth and also questions on social, emotional,physical functioning, pain, and self-care.
-Measures general health status
-SF-36 is a commonly used instrument
-SF-12
Disease-specific instruments for HRQoL
Focuses on specific problems encountered in a particular disease
-Functional assessment of cancer therapy (FACT)
-Asthma Quality of Life Questionnaire (AQLQ)
Domains of HRQoL
-Physical functioning (ADLs)
-Psychological functioning
-Social and role functioning
-General health perceptions
Utility Measures
-Multiple dimensions
-Economic evaluation of health
-Numbers representing the strength of individual preferences for particular outcomes when faced with uncertainty
-Based on rational decision-making theory by von Neumann & Morgenstern in 1944
Ordinal measures
rank from most preferred to least preferred
Cardinal measures
number must be attached to the outcome
Three sources of utility values
-Literature
-Judgement values (experts or Delphi method)
-Direct measurement from patients
Time Trade-off
-Subject is offered two alternatives
-Like standard gamble except duration of a health state is selected instead of probability
Reliability
-Consistency and repeatability of measurements
-Reliability is expressed between 0 and 1.
Validity
The extent to which differences in test scores reflect the true differences in the individuals understudy
Test-retest reliability
-Same tools on different occasions with the same study population
-No recall of the original response
-No changes in the attributes
-No change in the respondent (no change in health)
-Health and disease are dynamic processes
Internal consistency
Agreement level between responses to questions within the same domain
Interrater reliability
Agreement between two respondents when assessing the health status of the same patient
Content (face) validity
-How well the health concept is captured by the items in the measure
-All aspects of the concept being addressed
-The item must measure the concept
Criterion (predictive) validity
-Higher HRQoL → good health → low use of medical resources
-Low HRQoL → poor health → High mortality rate
Construct validity (theoretically sound)
To which the instrument relates to other measures of theoretical concepts (constructs) in the way that it should
Convergent validity
predicts strong correlations with similar or related measures of the same health concept. Physical activity, mobility, and physical function
Discriminant validity
redicts weaker correlations with less closely related measures. Mental health
Responsiveness
Ability to detect changes in health status over time
Three general perspectives
-Patients
-Societal (or General Public) and health care system are recommended by US Cost-Effectiveness Panel (2018)
-Physicians or expert panel
Quality of life (Q )
-Quality level of health states perceived by an individual or the individual preferences of health states
-Often on a scale from 0 (death) to 1.0 (healthy)
-In some cases, Q has been expressed as a negative value for health states considered worse than death
QALY
Y * V(Q)
Y: numbers of life years
Q: health state
V(Q): the value of health state Q