1/20
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Riperian System
Operates under reasonable use principle, where anyone who has access to river or stream is entitled to reasonably use it. Each landowner is equally entitled to a reasonable amount of the water from the shared system but must act with due regard to the rights of others and to the public interest
Prior Appropriation System
Water usage system in which the person who got there first has higher claim over those who get there later. It operates under the beneficial use principle, in which water rights do not attach automatically to land ownership but to the use of water for beneficial purposes as defined by law, and if it is not used, the right is forfeited.
Common Law
A system of legal principles and rules that evolve from court decisions, customs, and general principles; a field of law characterized by distinctive remedies such as payment of damages or the recovery of property.”
Tort
An act or omission that causes injury or harm to another and amounts to a civil wrong for which courts impose liability (plaintiff v. defendant)
Injury
The invasion, interference with, or infringement of a legally protected right. Can exist without measurable financial or physical loss.
Harm
Actual loss, damage, or detriment suffered by the person to whom an injury was done. May be physical, emotional, economic, reputational, or property related. Proof of significance is usually required for the award of damages
Liability
A legal finding of responsibility
Damages
monetary settlements
Injunctions
judicial orders that direct a person to do something or to stop doing something
Compensatory Damages
financial losses (costs to restore property, loss of wages or profits, medical expenses) and general harms (emotional distress, pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, harm to relationships)
Punitive Damages
Additional penalties for egregious misbehavior (continued violations or intentional harm
Social Utility
The same action may generate both benefits (jobs, revenue) and harms (pollution); judges may tailor remedies to mitigate harm while allowing operations to continue
Nuisance
that activity which arises from the unreasonable, unwarrantable, or unlawful use by a person of his own property, working an obstruction or injury to the right of another or to the public, and producing such material annoyance, inconvenience, and discomfort that the law will presume resulting damage (odor, dust, light, smoke, airborne pollutants, water pollution, or other emissions of hazardous substances.) Can be public or private. An example being Carmichael v. Texas.
Tresspass
Interference with the exclusive possession of property, not merely its use or enjoyment; an unlawful, forcible entry onto another’s property.
Negligence
“The omission to do something which a reasonable man, guided by those ordinary considerations which ordinarily regulate human affairs, would do, or the doing of something which a reasonable and prudent man would not do. Needs to prove the defendant had a legal duty to exercise “due care” concerning the plaintiffs’ interests (duty of care), his duty was breached either by doing or failing to do something that a reasonable person could have foreseen would cause injury (reasonable person standard), and an injury was caused, resulting in significant harm for which compensation is owed
Personal Injury Cases
extremely difficult to win because of the difficulty of proving causality: Americans are exposed to hundreds of carcinogenic chemicals during a lifetime and have latent and cumulative symptoms
CERCLA
intended to deal with some of the deficiencies of common law environmental litigation by: • Clarifying liability of persons responsible for releases of hazardous wastes at identified sites • Establishing national standards for cleanup of toxic and hazardous wastes • Creating a trust fund to subsidize cleanup when no responsible party could be identified. Under pressure from oil companies--created a “petroleum exception” exempting “crude oil” and all products resulting from “normal refining processes” penalties
Carmichael v. City of Texarkana
Case in which the City of Texarkana’s new sewer system deposited a cesspool onto the farm of the Carmichaels, fouling the land. Court ruled that although it followed Arkansas law, the sewage system was a public nuisance because it deprived those downstream of the ability to use and benefit from their land.
Village of Wilsonville v. SCA Services
Village officials alleged that a local hazardous chemical landfill posed significant risks to the community, including public health threats should the chemicals leak into the groundwater. SCA Services defended themselves by claiming that all necessary permits were obtained, the evidence of the danger posed was up to dispute, and no injuries or losses could be linked to the plant. The court ruled that the nuisance was the severe risk that the plant posed, and ordered suspension of plant operations and to clean/restore the site.
Martin v. Reynolds Metal Co.
Farmers in Oregon claimed their property was being covered in microsopic flouride compounds emitted in vapor form by the Reynolds Metal Plant. Claimed injury to land and cattle: cows were poisoned by grazing on the polluted fields, rendering the pastures unusable. Court found Reynolds liable for trespass, $71,000 for livestock and $20,000 for the deterioration of the land through growth of brush and weeds resulting from the lack of grazing.
Branch v. Western Petrolium
The Branches owned property in Utah and used wells for cullinary and drinking water. Western Petrolium operated nearby oil fields, disposing of wastewater in unlined pits. This water then migrated into the groundwater, contaminating the Branch’s wells. Western Petrolium had a duty to operate its oil wastewater disposal in a way that would not endanger their neighbors. A reasonable person would not place polluted wastewater in unlined disposal pits where it is likely to leak into groundwater. Water pollutants are traced back to WP’s pits. Therefore, the Branches were awarded both compensatory and punitive damages for the pollution of the wells, mental suffering, discomfort, and annoyance.