1/27
Looks like no tags are added yet.
3 general categories of implied terms
Terms implied by statute
Terms implied by custom and usage
Terms implied by the courts
Terms implied by Statute
In contracts for the sale of goods and supply of services
Certain basic provision are implied by statute in order to provide protection to purchases
Everything you buy is subject to the statutory legislation.
Why are some terms implied by statute?
Done for core issues where it is seen as reasonable that such matters are automatically written into a contract
Sale of goods act 1979
**Sale of goods contracts
Involves the transfer or an agreement to transfer, the property in goods from the seller to the buyer, in exchange for a money consideration.
Implies the seller has a right to sell the goods
Implies a term that the goods will correspond to their description
implies a term that the goods will be of satisfactory quality and fit for the purpose
If there is a breach of implied terms- consumers are eligible to different remedies:
Right to reject
Right to repair or replace
Right to a price reduction
Right to compensation
A term that the goods must correspond to all of their description
S13 SOGA
Implied Term of Correspondence with Description
Sale by Sample and Description
the goods must correspond to the description and the standard set by the sample
Grant v Australian Knitting Mills 1936
Woollen jumper
Point of law- Even if the goods have been seen they still need to match their description
Harlingdon & Leinster v Christopher Hull Fine Art (1990)
Painting
Point of law- There can’t be a sale by description if the buyer has not relied on the seller’s description
If you bring in an expert, no longer rely on description
Ashington Piggeries Ltd v Christopher Hill Ltd (1972)
Mink
Point of law- A term that identifies the very commercial characteristics of unseen goods must be one which the buyer may rely on under these provisions.
Moore v Landauer 1921
peaches came in 24 instead of 30
point of law- the goods must exactly match the description
Arcos v Ronassem (1933)
wood barrells
Point of law- The goods must exactly match the description.
Sale of goods contracts S14 SOGA
•implies a term that the goods will be of satisfactory quality and fit for the purpose
2.14 Geddling v Marsh
Bottle of water broken and caused injuries
Point of law- All goods sold under the contract are covered by law, including packaging
Wilson v Rickett Cockerill (1954)
Point of law- Goods contaminated with another substance are unsatisfactory, even if the contaminant would be satisfactory if it was on its own
Wormell v RHM Agriculture (1986/7)
Weed killer
Point of law- Unclear instructions could render what would otherwise be a satisfactory product, unsatisfactory
Frost v Aylesbury Dairy Co. Ltd (1905)
Germs in Milk
Point of Law:
The liability of the supplier is strict. This means that it is no defence to say that reasonable care had been exercised
Sale of good contracts- Satisfactory quality S.14
• Differing descriptions lead to differing expectations.
Where defects have been brought to the attention of the buyer, a buyer is deemed to have accepted the goods accordingly
Bartlett v Sydney Marcus Ltd (1965)
Satisfactory quality
Point of law- Where defects have been drawn to the buyer’s attention, a buyer is deemed to have accepted the goods accordingly
Defects that should have been discovered after examination
•Can be Patent – discoverable by reasonable inspection.
•Or Latent – cannot be discoverable, e.g. building foundations not discoverable for years afterwards.
Wren v Holt (1903)
Beer contaminated with arsenic
Point of law- A buyer takes goods subject to any patent defect which is or ought to have been discovered where an examination of the goods has taken place
Brown v Craiks (1970)- satisfactory quality- price// Rogers v Parish (Scarborough) Ltd (1987)
Point of law- The more you pay, the better the quality you can expect.
Jackson v Rotax Motor & Cycle Co Ltd [1910]
good purchased for £450 but cost was £35
Point of law- would the defects prevent the goods from being reasonably sold on
Hidden defects 2.14 (2B) d
Safety defects put goods in breach of the condition as to satisfactory quality
Bernstein v Pamson Motors (Golders Green) Ltd 1987- A hidden defect that can cause safety issue is not a minor defect
Godley v Perry (1960)- catapult and 6 year old boy
Sale of goods contracts – Satisfactory Quality - S.14 (2B) e- Durability
•How long do the goods last?
•A warranty which results in damages only (repairs).
•It will not cause a breach of condition (you will be entitled to reject the goods)
•Separate to the SOGA.
•Individual to the store.
•Repair or replace in that period.
•May be different to a court decision.
Mash & Murrell v Emmanuel (1961)
point of law- Goods should be durable and last for a reasonable amount of time.
Fitness for purpose
If the buyer makes it known the purpose for buying the good, then the seller must supply it accordingly
Manchester Liners v Rea (1922)- Pol- If the buyer makes it known the purpose for buying the good, then the seller must supply it accordingly
Priest v Last (1903)- Pol- Where goods are to be used for their normal purpose, it is assumed that the buyer need not say anything.
Fitness for purpose vagueness
•When the buyer indicates a range of (or specific) uses of the product the seller must meet the expectations.
•The vaguer the buyer is, the lower the requirement of compliance
M/S Aswan Engineering Establishment v Lupdine Ltd (1987)
Pol- When the buyer indicates a range of (or specific) uses of the product the seller must meet the expectations.